r/anime • • Apr 21 '15
[WT!] Nagi No Asukara - A 10/10 for me, and hopefully for you!
So, as the title suggests, this is about the unexpectedly wonderful anime known as Nagi no Asukara.
I went into this show with fairly low expectations. I mean, it was pretty, it had a catchy OP i have now come to adore, but the synopsis sounded so generic... Except for the whole 'under the sea' spiel. Speaking of synopsis, here it is courtesy of MAL:
Long ago, all humans lived in the ocean. But some who longed for the land abandoned the ocean, casting off the special raiments granted to them by the sea god to adapt them to life under the sea... Though mankind was divided into sea dwellers and land dwellers, each with different ways of thinking, they were all still fellow humans, and they continued to maintain contact as time went on. Sakishima Hikari, Mukaido Manaka, Hiradaira Chisaki, and Isaki Kaname live in an undersea village, while Kihara Tsumugu lives on land.When these middle school second-year land and sea dwellers meet for the first time, their hearts begin to undulate like the tides.The youthful fantasy tale of these young people's lives unfolds in a strange and beautiful world.
Now, let me explain spoiler free why I think this show is worth a go.
- The Characters- The characters in this show are what you would come to expect from this sort of anime. Your protagonist can be a bit dense and hot-headed. Who he likes is a ditzy girl. You have the mature male friend and the mature female friend. Their overall core personality is nothing special at all.
But what is special is the amazing character development that this show excels in. Every single damn character in the show gets it. You really see the characters develop and flourish in a truly believable way once you put yourselves in their shoes. Which brings me to...
- The Plot- The plot in this show was phenomenal. Now I will say that, to truly appreciate what is happening and what has happened, it's almost necessary to go in for a second watch once you finish it initially. There are so many nuances you won't catch, so many cleverly inserted things here and there that will make your head spin when you watch it the second time. I know that some people complain about the seemingly repetitive nature of the first conflict in the show, but I have arguments for that. Just soldier through it, it's not like an "endless eight" kind of thing. You get more development in the midst of it all.
- The Art- This show is nothing but scenery porn. I mean really. Some of the shots are just utterly breathtaking. The amount of care and dedication that went into some of them is just awe inspiring.
- The music- I thoroughly enjoyed the themes in this show, as well as the OST. It perfectly accompanies the mood of the show and really helps drive some scenes home, just as a good OST should. All of this is really true in the second part of the show. I feel they stepped up their game for it.
I won't lie. I had trouble the first few episodes. I just couldn't get hooked. But, it was so pretty. So i kept going. And man, I was not disappointed. I know I sound repetitive, but it's all true. This show is only 1 of 5 anime that I have ever rated a 10 to. It's one that I think earned it, even if it took 2 watches to earn it. It's the depth of the writing that really did me in.
Now, I also have a little present to those of you who are interested. I went through and reviewed this show episode by episode. Now, this was my first go at anything like this, and it took me some time to find my feet so to say, so give me some slack. I suggest watching an episode then reading that corresponding post.
I hope i'm not wasting your time, and I hope you love this show as much as I did. Have a nice day r/anime!
10
u/needforkh Apr 21 '15
I feel like a show really got to me when I can't listen to the OP again because its reminds me of the sad moments in the anime. Not saying that the song is bad, on the contrary, the songs are really good but I feel sad when I hear it. This show had really good OP but I just can't listen to it without feeling sad. Same goes for Clannad OP.
7
u/ukainaoto :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ukainaoto Apr 21 '15
I've tried but couldn't get through after the first episode, and coincidentally today finished the third watching of episode 01.
The episode itself was beautiful, cute, but felt somewhat rushed and childish. At the same time it certainly has been indicating to become good watch with that nice world-building and atmosphere. Maybe being too complete for the first episode, I somehow got satisfied and drained and didn't feel an urge to proceed the next episode immediately. Then I escaped to more lighthearted appetizer of Kiniro Mosaic (guilty) with my head emptied while feeling "I have to watch NagiAsu someday" at the back of my mind. Twice, for almost a year now.
If it is the same for the OP I might be able to proceed this time finally. Thank you for WT topic!
Question: Does the episode-by-episode review contain spoiler for the future episode and/or whole plot? Meaning I can read 01 review safely before watching Ep02?
26
u/opasnimiki :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/opasnimiki Apr 21 '15
So this is probably one of the show that had me split the most. In the end it's good but not even close to perfect and not even in my favorite list.
I'd say if you like "love triangles" you will probably like this show. If not you will probably find most of the show annoying.
22
u/Vintrix Apr 21 '15
OH and the Soundtrack is BOMB!
32
u/cscott024 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cscott024 Apr 21 '15
Yeah, it is.
6
u/thetrooper007 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/thetrooper007 Apr 21 '15 edited Apr 21 '15
Seconding this. I wouldn't call it "best anime ever" but it's well worth the watch if you are a fan of drama anime. Don't let the strange setting turn anybody off because it's used really well and is probably the strongest point of the anime imo.
1
u/Zeri4Life Apr 21 '15
Sorry if i'm late for this.
I tried this show 1 month ago, and i really hated the main character attitude, he made the anime so hard to watch that i had to drop it at the 2nd/3rd episode.
Will [his] (http://myanimelist.net/character/73067/Hikari_Sakishima) personality get better?
I really liked the rest of the show, the music, the quality and the story seemed interesting as well.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '15
I tried watching this but the forced drama got annoying so I dropped it.
--
Before you ask, I watched all the way up to episode 11.
2
u/watashi-akashi Apr 21 '15
NagiAsu is the only anime I've ever given a full score for both soundtrack and animation. It's so beautiful and the OST is so good, that in itself should be enough to at least warrant a peak.
It's also not as if these elements go in vain, they really create a fantastic world and atmosphere with the two that further adds to the bonus.
However, to provide some fair counterweight to the positive stream of comments that are inherent to these threads, I did not think it was perfect.
I feel it did pretty much everything right up until and slightly beyond a certain event halfway the show. However, the second half and finish of the show was not as good.
My biggest disappointment is that they dropped a certain amount of themes and interactions that gave the show variety, which made the show look more and more like a simple romance. And while most characters had undergone a certain amount of growth up until the big event, at a certain point in the second half it began to feel more and more like a reiteration of moves, with the same conflicts and trouble being dealt with again, which effectively stagnated the development of some characters.
Still a very good show and very well worth your time, but not nearly flawless. It could have done better, but it's great nonetheless.
2
u/Kassaapparat :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kassaapparat Apr 21 '15
Great show by PA Works, not their best, since Hanasaku Iroha is beyond awesome. However this is a definitive watch. Lots of drama and a really interesting world.
4
u/_vogonpoetry_ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThisWasATriumph Apr 21 '15 edited Apr 21 '15
Nagi-Asu is the only perfect anime I've seen. It's the only one where there is literally nothing I would change. Everything was flawless. (Edit: wow guys. How dare I say something so audacious... Obviously whether or not you would change something is your opinion I'm just saying personally I wouldn't change anything. No need for down votes. Why is this sub so immature?)
You are completely right about watching it a second time though. First time I watched it, I of course really liked it, but the second time... It blew me away. So much foreshadowing and little details you miss the first time, as you said.
The soundtrack... I could go on for paragraphs about how amazing it is. If we were allowed to link to them, I'd link to about 15 of my favorite tracks... But I'll cheat the system and just link to this incredible Ebb and Flow Remix.
Animation. Holy shiiiiieeeettttt. Eyegasms. This is another thing you appreciate more on the second viewing because you can afford to pause and stare at it. So many wallpaper worthy scenes. I really love boating and the water (I live in michigan, naturally) so the scenery just hits close to home for me. Love every part of it. Want some wallpapers? BAM: Giant Nagi-Asu Wallpaper Dump.. Theres hundreds of them you can just stare at for hours.
As for the plot, man I loved it so much. So many things about it I loved, from the setting to the characters... I'm totally going to read your episode-by-episode review when I get the chance. Maybe I'll get experience it for the first-time again vicariously through you :D
Anyway I could go on but I dont want to steal your thunder haha. I just wish everyone was able to see and appreciate just how beautiful this series was.
3
u/Cherisle :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/mmmichaeltran Apr 21 '15
MY FAVORITE ANIME EVER :))
2
u/Zynos Apr 21 '15
I dropped it because of all the forced drama and shitty love triangles, I absolutely HATE love triangles.
1
u/lamoragirl :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/aocchan Apr 21 '15
A nice anime indeed, with some peculiar qualities but also with many flaws and cliché that could have been avoided.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '15
Same as what I commented on the previous WT! for Kokoro Connect, NagiAsu and Kokoro Connect are in my top 5, and I got so pumped to see this anime mentioned.
Im jus here to say its brilliant and I fuckin love it
1
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '15
I enjoyed the show while watching it, but the mishandled romance hurts it so much that I can't call it a favorite.
1
u/Terranwaterbender https://myanimelist.net/profile/Teranwaterbender Apr 21 '15
This anime was an interesting one to me.
While I really enjoyed the art and music, I could just not get into the characters...goodness gracious middle schoolers and romance? Talking about pure love as middle schoolers what?
The 1st half of the show to me was rather tiresome and boring being filled with forced romantic drama. The 2nd half of the show though was well done I enjoyed the characters a bit more.
0
u/kristallnachte :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kristallnachte Apr 21 '15
The mid season flip was pretty much the best execution I've ever seen.
It was meaningful, and wasn't just a means of ignoring things.
-5
u/Vintrix Apr 21 '15
in my top 5. its a must buy for me. gotta get those blu-rays! get 10/10 i cried. personal rule if it can get me to cry it gets a 10/10.
Ef- tale of memories/melodies 10/10 Clannad/Aftersstory 10/10
-6
u/Snoresville Apr 21 '15
no
0
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment