r/anime • u/nap682 • Apr 21 '15
[WT!] 5 Centimeters per Second: A Story of Longing.
Let's start this off by saying this is my first WT post so bare with me.
Watch This: 5 Centimeters per Second
Type: Film (3 Episodes)
Year: 2007
My personal rating: 10/10 (masterpiece)
What is 5 Centimeters per Second? Makoto Shinkai’s 60 minute film 5 Centimeters(Wallpapers) per Second follows the life of Takaki Tohno, his relationship with his first love Akari Shinohara, and the effect it has on his life. The film is separated into three distinctive parts; Shinkai begins by introducing Takaki and Akari and the bond they formed as kids, continues by displaying Takaki’s lack of development as he remains reclusive through high school, and culminating all this as Takaki struggles to find his place in the adult world.
Why should you watch it? Although already widely known and regarded as Makoto Shinkai's best work, the simplicity surrounding the film brings along a human-realism to the film. Ignoring Hollywood's idea of love conquering all, 5 Centimeters per Second creates a feeling of passive regret over the past and, much like Shinkai's other works, questions whether it is better to move on or stay rooted in the past.
Shinkai's visuals are outstanding as expected from his work, mixing warming and cold color palettes to match the feeling of the characters in the film as the viewer follows their lives. Music is written by Tenmon, as is common by Shinkai, with a focus on piano matching the stark romance elements of the film.
One of the largest elements of this film is its use of symbolism as a driving force in its "show don't tell" style that Shinkai has become famous for. Very Minor Spoilers
Summing up. To anyone who hasn't watched this film, it is only slightly long than a single game of League and shows some of Shinkai's greatest work. To anyone who has seen it and either disliked it or liked it, I recommend watching it with a Quadrant grid set up. Shinkai begins the film with balanced shots but unbalanced them the more the film goes on to display a form of symbolism that I find remarkable (feel free to message me on a spoiler ridden explanation on the matter)
I leave you with a minor spoiler ridden "Making of".
Personal Reasons Later today I'm giving a presentation on this film to an Intro to Film class as a, "What film should be watched when discussing film?" Since anime hasn't been touched in any sense, I want to attempt to bring it to the table with my personally favorite anime film. (I toyed with Paprika but chose my favorite over it)
22
u/nap682 Apr 22 '15 edited Apr 22 '15
I failed to convinced my group in my film class to analyse an animated film, we're doing the Wolf of Wall-street. So I'm going to pour my thoughts out to anyone else who is inclined to listen.
Super Wall of Text on my thoughts surrounding just the filmography aspects of 5 Centimeters per Second that most people don't think about or don't mention.
Major spoilers to all of them.
The Quadrant System
Symbolism (title)
Symbolism (environment)
Symbolism (Cherry Tree/blossoms)
The Montage
I will probably add more or edit them as I think about it more.
23
u/_vogonpoetry_ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThisWasATriumph Apr 21 '15
Ah thanks for that "making of" album. I love stuff like that. So many gorgeous shots in this movie. Definitely had some issues with the storyline, but nobody can deny this is a beautiful film.
Have you seen the short it's based on? Voices of a Distant Star? It was Shinkai's earlier work and has a very similar feel to it. You can probably think of 5CM/s as a feature length non-sci-fi remake of it.
10
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '15
Does it end with depressing feels or happy feels? I don't wanna get even more depressed than I am rn but I definitely will watch it later it looks good
106
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '15
Alright. I've seen a lot of people tell me to watch this movie, but you've done it. I give up. I will watch the damn movie tonight when I get home from work. Happy now?
5
u/ChumChumz Apr 21 '15
I own the movie. I own the manga (must read if youre a fan of the movie for the extra chapter which tidies up the 2nd episode) I have the movie on my computer in 3 formats and i have the manga on my computer and the soundtrack.
By far my favourite series or movie or whatever you call it.
I know almost every line. Plz watch.
5
u/MayhemHavoc Apr 22 '15
This movie hit me really hard. Like right in the soft spot. I saw it a couple of weeks ago and I'm still wrecked by the bittersweet ending. I guess it's because I'm used to these typical Hollywood happy endings. It's an amazing film and definitely one of my favorites but not a film I'd watch again anytime soon.
4
u/Hunte16 Apr 22 '15
I would watch this.. but I don't want my heart to die. I still haven't healed after Your Lie in April.
3
u/[deleted] Apr 21 '15
What exactly is a Quadrant grid? I'm curious.
2
u/RiceIsBliss Apr 22 '15
Still trying to find a somewhat affordable Blu-Ray copy of this damn movie...
2
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
IT made me cry like a bitch.
2
u/Cptn_Jib :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Space_Cowboy38 Oct 08 '15
Fuck this made me tear up thank you for the WT i absolutely loved it
3
u/Starayo Apr 22 '15
Didn't like it. Put me to sleep.
The art was beautiful and I get what they were going for but it's not my cup of tea.
8
u/gajaczek :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/gaiacheck Apr 21 '15
I dont see a reason not to watch it, for god sake, 60 minutes is not that much and it really is worth it.
7
u/invalidinvalidinvali Apr 22 '15
I hated trains after watching this movie.
5
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '15
I can't even think about this movie without tearing up
5
u/[deleted] Apr 22 '15
5 feels per second
4
u/Syia Apr 21 '15
As you mentioned, one thing I like about Makoto Shinkai is that he doesn't rely on excessive exposition. However, if you're not in the right mood, it can be hard to watch ANY of his works. If you start watching one of his films and something feels "off"/"wrong" I would definitely suggest trying to watch it later.
The first time I tried to get through 5 cm/s I was unable to appreciate the dreadful feeling Tohno was going through with the train delays. I'm glad I came back to it later, as that feeling of discomfort I had was critical to relating to Tohno. Shinkai's characterization is done mostly visually, for me (personally) to relate I had to envision myself in that situation.
There have been some conversations about Shinkai's characters feeling underdeveloped. In those conversations a common theme is that his works resonate more clearly with people "who have been in a similar situation before". I think that anyone can appreciate his works, but it will have a more profound effect on you if you relate the story symbolically to something in your life.
TL;DR: Give this film a shot. If it isn't "clicking" with you, try again later. It truly is a brilliant film.
1
u/NamiSakamoto Apr 21 '15 edited Apr 21 '15
I fell asleep watching this movie and I typically enjoy all types of anime. I just wish they would of went a little more into it but hey it was a "short film".
-Edit: there that's better.
1
u/DoBearsDreamofHoney Apr 21 '15
Which subs are the best for this movie?
1
u/Slifer13xx https://myanimelist.net/profile/SliferXIII Apr 21 '15
The first time I watched this I didn't get any feels and didn't quite understand the film honestly.. but if I were to rewatch this now, I'm afraid I might break. Because I've gone though a long distance relationship(which started out as a normal relationship) and a break up since that time.. Just thinking about how I might feel almost make me wanna cry..
1
u/Rover16 Apr 25 '15
It's not bad if you manage to stop watching before the ending which I absolutely hated. Ending kind of ruined the overall feel I had for movie so don't consider it anything special or a must watch.
6
u/DHKany :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DHKany Apr 21 '15
Even if some parts of the story leave something to be desired the artwork in this movie is unreal
17
u/fgsfds11234 Apr 21 '15
I thought 5cm/s was kind of "meh" compared to some of the other makoto shinkai movies/shorts, those should be checked out if this interests you at all.
3
u/gst4158 Apr 21 '15
The only anime I refuse to watch. I just don't think I can handle the feels (though they feel so good)
3
u/xStarburstStreamx Apr 22 '15
The realistic setting of the story makes it refreshing. The symbolism gave depth to a very well told story.
I thought that it was amazing, but some of my friends thought that the story was a bit too slow, which is kind of true. Right in the kokoro for me.
Good luck on your presentation!/Good job! That would surely be something new and exciting for the class
2
u/encoreAC :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/enc0re Apr 21 '15 edited Apr 21 '15
My favorite movie of all-time! This movie really hit the mark for me.
2
u/I_Came_For_Cats Apr 21 '15
Wow we have the same taste. 5 Centimeters and Paprika are my two favorites!
2
u/Selnight Apr 21 '15
Since a lot of people praise this show to the skies I got to the point where I am waiting for a perfect time for myself to watch it.
I want to prevent myself from the saying "If I could only watch it again like it was my first time" like it was with Steins;Gate or other great series.
2
u/gfmart93 Apr 22 '15
Wow, that was amazing. 10/10, all I can say is thank you for making me aware of this; I've never really been exposed to short films like this and I think I'm going to have to explore some related or similar works.
2
u/XDingoX83 Apr 22 '15
One of my favorite films of all time. This analysis gives me a whole new way to look at it.
2
u/Pageking123 Apr 22 '15
Man I saw this film a week after ending a long-distance relationship. It's one of my favorite films but some parts hit way too close too home especially with the letters.
2
u/GuyWithSausageFinger Apr 22 '15
Ah this one. I recently watched it. I didn't think it was as emotional as everyone made it out to be. I will say this: It was surprisingly tense!
The whole first part was agonizing. It was brilliantly done.
Over all, when I finished it, I thought the ending was refreshing in the context of the majority of stories dealing with those themes. However, I felt like it wasn't anything special. I just thought, "well, pretty much everyone will have that experience"
Then a little bit later, I got it. I understood. That was the point.
For me, the ending wasn't very emotional, just realistic
It was logical to me, and relatable. It didn't have much of an impact on me, but it made me think about situations like that, and go through the feeling through another person's eyes. That is why I think this movie is great.
It may not have a huge impact (contrary to what many comments about it may lead you to think), but it is a very well done ride that gets you to feel what the characters do, and that is something that leads to some thought, and winds up being very memorable.
Highly recommend.
1
u/GeneraleRusso :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/GeneraleRus Apr 21 '15
I watched this movie briefily some time ago.
Being an italian i know the struggle of commuting by train, and all the problems the main character encountered in the first section of the movie made me think that for a day Japanese Railways were owned by RFI/Trenitalia.
1
u/Tom555 Apr 22 '15
I watched this film and for the most part I enjoyed it, I didn't like the plot and I don't really think it achieved all that it set out to but at the same time I think its something everyone should see. For perspective Garden of Words is my favourite movie.
1
u/zeroryoko1974 https://anime-planet.com/users/wwwzeroryoko1974 Apr 22 '15
I can not love this movie enough, or praise it enough. Truly one of the great films of anime.
1
u/Kaffarov Apr 22 '15
I gotta watch this sooner than later
1
u/RamenRobot Apr 22 '15
5cm/s is wonderful. Takaki's desire to see Akari again was very touching. Made me wonder what I would do in a similar situation. Makoto Shinkai really built on Voices of a Distant Star's premise, and made this into a masterpiece.
1
u/toguro_rebirth :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/vexelpops Apr 22 '15
watch the first 20 minutes and turn it off, it is a lot better that way
1
u/0mfgroflmao :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/0mfgroflmao Apr 21 '15
God damn this movie is beautiful, one of my favorite anime movies. However I think Garden of Words is Shinkai’s best (out of what I've seen so far).