I mean... I agree with much of what you wrote, and good on you for taking the time to write it, but is this really a series that needs a [WT!] post? NGE isn't exactly underexposed, nor underappreciated around here...
I want to make this sheet an universal tool of reference for newcomers/people who want recommendations. And here comes the problem - this list misses some big and famous titles, such as Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann or Hyouka. Now I understand that these anime don't need unnecessary fuss and hype because they are quite popular already. But if the ultimate goal is to use this sheet as a tool of help and the work of the whole /r/anime at the same time, we need these recommendations for historical and referencial purposes. Example: K-On! thread holds #1 spot. As you probably know, K-On! is insanely popular anime and doesn't really need further recommendation. However, the quality of the post is so high that it was an enjoyable read regardless of the show popularity. So, what does it all mean? It means that we need high quality recommendations for popular shows that will later on go into the archive of /r/anime with this spreadsheet. Really like the show and it's famous/popular? Write about it, but make the post so good that even the cynics of /r/anime would agree that your thread is worthy of upvote.
Example: K-On! thread holds #1 spot. As you probably know, K-On! is insanely popular anime and doesn't really need further recommendation.
That's pretty much my point, though. Personally, I'd rather see [WT!] posts for underwatched / underrated series than ones that perpetuate this subreddit's circlejerk of popular titles.
I'm glad someone else said it...that K-On WT didn't convince me to watch it, it just convinced me that the guy who wrote it really really likes K-On. I mean, no offense to the guy, it was well-written and I'm glad he could write so much about something he loves, but it wasn't particularly good at convincing me to watch it because I just felt like he was overselling the anime the entire time.
But if I haven't watched K-On!, stumbled across this post and read it, I would at least become interested what is that show that is worthy of 20k letters. So the post technically would sell me the anime and achieve its goal.
That said, I can't say that this thread about NGE is "worthy of upvotes" as I dreamed of in my post. Sad, but true. That's not what I was aiming for.
As any Eva hater would argue, much to the denial of a fanboy, NGE's plot is both simple, formulaic and to a point, unoriginal. The monster-of-the-week formula exercised in NGE feels shaky as it does in any mecha, and exists solely to provide action, with little reasoning or plot other than some fanciful 'Dead Sea Scrolls = this many angels' bullhonky.
Wow. Not only is this blatantly false, but what the hell is it doing in a WT thread? You're supposed to be recommending the show, not critiquing it. If you think the "monster of the week elements" served no purpose other than mindless action, you have no place discussing this show.
Picking apart the brains of characters, who from the start are flawed and unrealistic is entertaining to say the least, but really bloody interesting coming from a mecha.
You have GOT to be kidding me. Is this a troll post? Evangelion was specifically written to have realistic characters and even its critics agree that it succeeded.
A pussy with a responsibility he (never) wanted.
Taking a meme seriously. Great sign, considering there is nothing actually wimpy about Shinji
This post has no business getting upvoted. NGE doesn't need a WT thread, but if it's going to have one, this is one horrible excuse of a "recommendation" to have. Can the mods delete a WT thread if it blatantly mischaracterizes the show?
I'm just gonna copy paste what I wrote in the Free Talk Friday thread.
That [WT!] thread seemed like a low effort post in general. It read like some guy at a bus station blathering on about some bullshit, when in should have been written with more poise and fluidity. A quality [WT!] thread relies on the strength of the writer, not random ideas splashed across the page.
Mistakes were made, NGE was far from perfect, though that was to be expected from that which was testing the waters, but damn if it wasn't entertaining. 8/10
So many things are wrong with this. How does "far from perfect, but entertaining" give us any reason to watch the show? What does it even mean? It's a useless, vague statement that adds no value to the conversation.
It also bothered me that the OP didn't even mention End of Evangelion, which is essential to the viewing experience of the original series.
NGE deserves better than a hamfisted series of bullet points. Sorry OP, but I just can't get behind this thread, even if NGE is my favorite series.
Here's my problem with even having a WT for Evangelion in the first place.
It's almost universally considered one of the few true "must watch" titles in the medium, because of its sheer influence and notoriety and openness to interpretation. It's a series that doesn't need a hook to lure viewers into watching it. Eva is on the shortlist of titles that you can tell an anime fan to "just watch" because it is so different from what the medium offers (well, save for a few faithful imitations), and it is so important.
It doesn't need a WT. Every anime fan has heard of and probably looked up Eva and its synopsis, and the ones who haven't will hear about it shortly into their fanhood. Even if it was okay to WT Eva, this isn't a very good one. It doesn't tell me anything that I haven't or wouldn't find on a random anime site, which again, is where 99% of anime fans will find out about Eva first.
Also this WT wasn't even a WT, it's just a mediocre review. It doesn't convince me to watch the show, it just critiques aspects of the show and even scores it at the end. And the critique isn't very good, either...
I can only imagine how utterly shit you must be feeling (especially after writing that edit), what with all these people still going out of their way to bring you flak for writing this. I can tell because I've been there too. All I can do is to plead for you not to hold it against anyone - sure, a lot of them may be pointlessly nasty and apprehensive, but I still firmly believe it's a result of Reddit's majority-empowering system itself, and not because they're particularly bad people or because they have anything to hold against you. It's a storm I think will pass in maybe a week from now, but I certainly won't deny how crap it must be to sit through it. So I just wanted you to know that you have my full support, and that I'm certain this will blow over in due time.
I only hope you're not greeted with stuff like this after an even more terrible day.
Not only is this the last show in the world that needs a WT thread, but you appear to be critiquing it more than recommending it, and you don't appear to have the best grasp on what its main idea is either.
What I warn people who are just starting NGE is that if they expect mech vs. alien action galore, they will not have a great time. If you go in taking more of an interest in the characters and how they develop, the action sequences provide an interesting vehicle in their character development.
I'm not really interested in mech vs. alien action galore, so I guess that's good. My point was that "monster-of-the-week" makes it sound repetitive and dry, even if it does do character development well.
Some of the episodes follow a monster of the week format. These episodes are still important because the majority of most of them is still dedicated to character development. About halfway through the monster format is pretty much entirely abandoned in favor of dark psychological thriller.
I think the show excelled at character introspection and showing how fucked up a world like NGE would actually be but from a storytelling aspect it just falls short. The first 13 or so episodes nothing particularly exciting happens in the overarching mythos of the show and then when interesting things are introduced you get almost no pay off until the movie...kind of. Because the show spent its first half dicking around, the second half is rushed particularly in a scene where we're supposed to feel some emotion to a character just introduced that episode(or maybe the previous one I don't remember). All that being said I did get some enjoyment out of NGE and think that it's worth it for the way characters react to the world crumbling around them even if the story itself leaves much to be desired. Also Rei is the most disappointing character ever created. She had such potential that ultimately led nowhere
The first 13 or so episodes nothing particularly exciting happens
That's very debatable; there were lots of intense action scenes that were much darker in tone than an average mecha. Plus it focusses on fleshing out the characters. It's not an action show; it's character centric.
Because the show spent its first half dicking around
No, it didn't. Every episode in the show is vital to the characterization.
the second half is rushed particularly in a scene where we're supposed to feel some emotion to a character just introduced that episode
You weren't supposed to care about Nagisa. You weren't even supposed to look at him as a character. He was a symbol and a plot device for Shinji's development.
Also Rei is the most disappointing character ever created. She had such potential that ultimately led nowhere
This is just blatantly ridiculous considering her development and the role she plays in the plot
The show had major budget issues. That particular scene was bad, but to discount the entire first half of the show on that basis is ridiculous. Plus, some of the still frame scenes later on are some of the most expressive and unique scenes in anime history
Is not watching it going to stop that from happening somehow? No. Also, it's not like the fan base sexualizing high schoolers is exclusive to Evangelion by any means whatsoever
While it is true that the budget ran out and the latter episodes, specifically the last few, were soddy to say the least, I thought the transition from a narrative driven story to a thematically driven story was done rather well. Was it perfect? No. But I'll be damned if people dismiss it simply because it was too edgy. It has some of the most interesting and realistic character introspection of anything I've seen.
Doing a Watch This! for Evangelion is bold and I applaud you for it. People have written short novels behind the psychology and symbolism in the show, which I am glad you brought up in your post. It is very important to the show and its direction. I also think you should mention End of Evangelion also as required watching after finishing the series. End of Evangelion is my favorite anime movie and a fantastic conclusion to the series, which should be watched after the final episode of the series.
6
u/-Ziro Apr 23 '15
What's next WT! FMA:Brotherhood?
26
u/einherjar81 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Einherjar81 Apr 23 '15
I mean... I agree with much of what you wrote, and good on you for taking the time to write it, but is this really a series that needs a [WT!] post? NGE isn't exactly underexposed, nor underappreciated around here...
36
u/daddy1fatsack Apr 23 '15 edited Apr 23 '15
Wow. Not only is this blatantly false, but what the hell is it doing in a WT thread? You're supposed to be recommending the show, not critiquing it. If you think the "monster of the week elements" served no purpose other than mindless action, you have no place discussing this show.
You have GOT to be kidding me. Is this a troll post? Evangelion was specifically written to have realistic characters and even its critics agree that it succeeded.
Taking a meme seriously. Great sign, considering there is nothing actually wimpy about Shinji
This post has no business getting upvoted. NGE doesn't need a WT thread, but if it's going to have one, this is one horrible excuse of a "recommendation" to have. Can the mods delete a WT thread if it blatantly mischaracterizes the show?
9
u/blindfremen :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/blindfremen Apr 24 '15 edited Apr 24 '15
I'm just gonna copy paste what I wrote in the Free Talk Friday thread.
That [WT!] thread seemed like a low effort post in general. It read like some guy at a bus station blathering on about some bullshit, when in should have been written with more poise and fluidity. A quality [WT!] thread relies on the strength of the writer, not random ideas splashed across the page.
So many things are wrong with this. How does "far from perfect, but entertaining" give us any reason to watch the show? What does it even mean? It's a useless, vague statement that adds no value to the conversation.
It also bothered me that the OP didn't even mention End of Evangelion, which is essential to the viewing experience of the original series.
NGE deserves better than a hamfisted series of bullet points. Sorry OP, but I just can't get behind this thread, even if NGE is my favorite series.
10
u/Mamimisamejimamimi Apr 23 '15
Here's my problem with even having a WT for Evangelion in the first place.
It's almost universally considered one of the few true "must watch" titles in the medium, because of its sheer influence and notoriety and openness to interpretation. It's a series that doesn't need a hook to lure viewers into watching it. Eva is on the shortlist of titles that you can tell an anime fan to "just watch" because it is so different from what the medium offers (well, save for a few faithful imitations), and it is so important.
It doesn't need a WT. Every anime fan has heard of and probably looked up Eva and its synopsis, and the ones who haven't will hear about it shortly into their fanhood. Even if it was okay to WT Eva, this isn't a very good one. It doesn't tell me anything that I haven't or wouldn't find on a random anime site, which again, is where 99% of anime fans will find out about Eva first.
Also this WT wasn't even a WT, it's just a mediocre review. It doesn't convince me to watch the show, it just critiques aspects of the show and even scores it at the end. And the critique isn't very good, either...
So yeah.
3
u/MisterImouto :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MisterImouto Apr 27 '15
I can only imagine how utterly shit you must be feeling (especially after writing that edit), what with all these people still going out of their way to bring you flak for writing this. I can tell because I've been there too. All I can do is to plead for you not to hold it against anyone - sure, a lot of them may be pointlessly nasty and apprehensive, but I still firmly believe it's a result of Reddit's majority-empowering system itself, and not because they're particularly bad people or because they have anything to hold against you. It's a storm I think will pass in maybe a week from now, but I certainly won't deny how crap it must be to sit through it. So I just wanted you to know that you have my full support, and that I'm certain this will blow over in due time.
I only hope you're not greeted with stuff like this after an even more terrible day.
13
u/daddy1fatsack Apr 23 '15
Not only is this the last show in the world that needs a WT thread, but you appear to be critiquing it more than recommending it, and you don't appear to have the best grasp on what its main idea is either.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15
I was debating it before, but I think you actually just convinced me to not watch NGE.
3
u/Elhokar Apr 24 '15 edited Apr 24 '15
Chinpo is kill
Edit: Smart guy, not commenting so you don't get downvoted.
3
u/legnase https://anilist.co/user/Legnase Apr 23 '15 edited Apr 23 '15
I think the show excelled at character introspection and showing how fucked up a world like NGE would actually be but from a storytelling aspect it just falls short. The first 13 or so episodes nothing particularly exciting happens in the overarching mythos of the show and then when interesting things are introduced you get almost no pay off until the movie...kind of. Because the show spent its first half dicking around, the second half is rushed particularly in a scene where we're supposed to feel some emotion to a character just introduced that episode(or maybe the previous one I don't remember). All that being said I did get some enjoyment out of NGE and think that it's worth it for the way characters react to the world crumbling around them even if the story itself leaves much to be desired. Also Rei is the most disappointing character ever created. She had such potential that ultimately led nowhere
2
u/RogueKnight777 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/RogueKnight777 Apr 23 '15
Watch out or the circlejerk that is NGE will get you...
-2
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '15 edited Apr 23 '15
Dont watch it all the otaku freaks on reddit sexualise the girls even though they are only 13 years old its super creepy.
EDIT: 14 years. Not like thats any better.
0
u/BBallHunter :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/IdolHunter Apr 23 '15
Great to read an analysis of NGE from someone who is not a total pompous fanboy or a complete hater.
-4
u/biglisy Apr 23 '15
Most overrated and edgy series of all times.
Budget ends toward the end of the show so they decide to go on an entry level psychological, existential bullshit. Reaction: "OMG SO DEEP!"
0
u/Remington_NA https://anilist.co/user/Remington Apr 23 '15
Doing a Watch This! for Evangelion is bold and I applaud you for it. People have written short novels behind the psychology and symbolism in the show, which I am glad you brought up in your post. It is very important to the show and its direction. I also think you should mention End of Evangelion also as required watching after finishing the series. End of Evangelion is my favorite anime movie and a fantastic conclusion to the series, which should be watched after the final episode of the series.