r/anime • u/BreaksFull • May 07 '15
[WT!] Baccano! Perfect Storytelling Incarnate
Hello there /r/anime. As you may know from the results of the various '/r/Anime's favorite X' contests, this sub has really SHIT TASTE. I am here to alleviate everyone from this shit taste. Are you all ready kids? Well you better, because I'm about to tell you why you should watch BACCANO!
What is Baccano?
Well I'm glad you asked. Baccano! (Italian for 'Ruckus') is a non-linear 2007 anime by Brains Base, telling a non-linear story through thirteen episodes and 6 follow-up OVAs. It is based off of the award-winning light novel series by Ryohgo Narita, author of Durarara!! It tells the stories of multiple characters and how seemingly unrelated characters and their actions can affect each other in drastic ways.
What's the story?
The story? Well pal the story is all over the place! Baccano means ruckus and ruckus is a beautiful word for this tale of immortals, mafia, train robberies, mad killers, and crazy crooks. The show follows three main storylines across 1930, 1931, and 1932 with a few detours including a notable one back to 1711. The story is very non-linear and reminiscent of Pulp Fiction in how it portrays unrelated characters performing unrelated deeds, setting into action chains of events that snake wildly around to effect each other and send their paths colliding together. It's impossible to talk much about the stories going on without spoilers so I'll briefly touch on what I can.
- The setting is 1930's America during prohibition and depression. One story follows a brewing Mafia war in New York while a young girl searches for her missing brother. Another centers on missing bottles of immortality elixir and the various characters and gangs that get caught up in it. And another features a three-way train robbery between terrorists, mafia, and a group of bootleggers. Any more than this would start giving things away though so I shall be silent.
What about the characters?
Like Pulp Fiction Baccano has no main characters and no main story, which all ties into some delightfully meta-commentary by two reporter characters who spend the first episode discussing the nature of storytelling and how each character is their own main character and the star of their own story, with there being as many stories as there are characters to tell them. The show has a remarkably large cast for such a short show, with around eighteen characters of significance although none of them can be called the main characters.
Screen time is distributed equally between the crew and no one gets too much or too little screentime. And despite the swiftly shifting focus each character is fleshed out beautifully in their limited time and quickly establish who they are, what they want, and what they're like. They are all masterfully handled and the diverse and varied cast of colorful figures means you'll love at least some of them through the show's course.
What about the soundtrack and animation?*
This show's soundtrack can be somewhat reminiscent of Cowboy Bebop with an emphasis on jazzy tunes that move from smooth and slow background music to fiery and energetic action music, and because it kicks all the ass all the places all the time.
And also the dub. Oh the dub. Oh my sweet baby Jesus the dub. Listening to the sub on this is simply wrong, it's just wrong. While the sub is very good this is a very western-ish show taking place in a very distinctly American era (dirty thirties) and watching it subbed is like watching an Edo-period drama done in Texan accents.
So, watch the dub. Just do it. Though I am not responsible for any post-show compulsions to put on a Boston or New Yorker accent and begin talking about broads and the bulls while chomping on a thick cigah.
Animation is flawless. Great lighting, great character design, great fights, great everything. Nothing more to be said there.
So it sounds pretty damn amazing, but why do you think it's perfect storytelling incarnate?
Well my dear friend it's because of just how beautifully well everything fits together. The show is juggling three main story lines with almost twenty main characters with only 13 twenty-minute episodes to fit everything together, which it does flawlessly. I fully recommend the three touch-up OVA's which tie the ending in a nicer bow but even the original thirteen tie everything together amazingly. All the loose threads are tied up nicely together and brought back down to earth, everything makes sense, everything is good.
But the final episode of the OVA's just take the cake, ending with the same two reporters from the first episode talking about how the story ends. Without saying much it perfectly ties everything up and puts a golden cherry on the show's meta-theme about storytelling and characters, and how stories never really end.
So?
So go watch the goddamn show already. And then once you have done so you can feel bad about not voting for it in the Best Anime Contest.
I rate this show a final score of 10 amazing dub voices out of 10.
25
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
I dunno why I never thought to watch it dubbed seeing as it's set in America.
If people prefer subs though, the original voice acting was pretty reasonable, if a little eccentric.
7
u/kashabash May 07 '15
Not going to say you're completely wrong, but you don't have to be an asshole about it.
34
u/OhMilla May 08 '15
Plus you meet one of the most badass characters ever!
3
u/GUGUGUNGI May 07 '15
Whoa I thought the series was around 70 or so episodes. Is it just 10 + the 3 OVAs or is there a second season or something?
Thanks for the good post :)
85
u/[deleted] May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
Baccano is the best form of storytelling I've ever seen/read. Definitely recommend it.
Also, Baccano > Durarara. I never knew this wasn't common knowledge until some poor misguided folks brought it up in another thread.
6
u/__U_WOT_M8__ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/iThoughtSheWas16 May 07 '15 edited May 07 '15
OSTs fall under this, so you need to remove the full OP and OST links. Otherwise, nazi mods will remove this post.EDIT: ok maybe cdsboy isn't that nazi of a mod
9
u/Kassaapparat :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kassaapparat May 07 '15
Agree with OP, awesome show. However a bit off a warning from my personal experience. The 1st couple of episodes might seem slow and complicated, but stick with it anyway.
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '15
If you guys liked the show, you'll love the light novels. The author's writing translates well and there's a host of delectable plot twists and characters to enjoy. Almost everything's been translated, so you'll have a fairly seamless reading experience.
The 13-episode series covers volumes 1-4. The OVAs cover volume 14.
1
u/princeofbrit May 08 '15
Too bad, I will never get to experience a second season because the first season was not a commercial success. The anime only covered 20% of the baccano storylines. I want more.
1
u/Sevchino May 08 '15
Was that by any chance a reference to the English dub of Peacemaker Kurogane?
19
u/thetrooper007 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/thetrooper007 May 07 '15
I actually think Baccano is really unfocused. The different plots don't rely on each other very much at all which calls into question why they decided to tell the story this way in the first place. (By which I mean that the events of any one arc didn't influence how I viewed the events or characters of any other arc)
None of the plotlines are particularly impressive on their own, and the storytelling style doesn't add much either since it's essentially just three separate stories told simultaneously for no real reason.
0
u/LinnaYamazaki https://myanimelist.net/profile/linnayamazaki May 08 '15
I didn't dislike it, but Baccano! is pretty overrated.
5
u/MeteoraGB May 07 '15
Just finished it yesterday. I found myself enjoying Bacanno more than Durarara. Can't say I particularly love this style of storytelling, but Bacanno is definitely worth a watch and seems to have a sense of direction than Durarara (at least personally).
It helps if you actually pay attention to the timeline otherwise the story might feel all over the place.
1
u/Vsect_ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/vsect May 08 '15 edited May 08 '15
I actually finished Baccano! yesterday by recommendation of a friend who praised it forever. I understand that it manages to tell 3 stories at the same time and still tie them all up into a satisfying ending but it just doesn't feel like a 10/10 to me.
I mean...I still liked it though, i just don't feel like it's the masterpiece people make it out to be. Then again, I'm not really into this kind of setting/era (If you are, totally watch this!).
Oh and the opening, though, is a real masterpiece indeed! One of the best openings I've seen.
6
u/The_Useless_IT_Guy May 08 '15
Baccano! isn't overrated but not an masterpiece either as everyone portrayed. I can understand why it get this praise, and it is simply because of so-called "non-linear" story telling. To be frank, I liked Pulp Fiction movie, and have seen a hell a lot of "non-linear" movies. But somehow Baccano! doesn't impress me as much as some other movies did. After first 2 episodes, things looked kick-ass and I kinda fell for it, but then comes characters after characters, serving no purpose or be there just for the sake of it.
I wanted to finish Baccano! badly, but I couldn't. If I must say, I dragged myself from 11th episode onwards. Till then it was okay-ish but then it got too boring, I literally had to drag myself to watch it for closure(for my OCD kinda thing! I need to finish if I am already half way even if story is crappy! sigh) and to understand why it get such praise! I understand this is my personal opinion, but then, why people suggest Baccano! for everyone?
My problem with Baccano! is, it is literally stuffed with too many characters. Don't say that's the beauty. I am not talking about Jacuzzi, Claire etc. I am talking about other characters who is just there in the screen and serve nothing to story! And by story, I meant closure! Too many of anything spoils its value and that becomes true with this otherwise good anime. Yes, I would have liked the show if not for last 3 episodes where only thing happening is blood splatting all over the place and people talk, talk and those talks not contributing for story or their goal!
The setting is good, I agree. Some action sequences are good. The way characters come across with each is good. But as an complete package, it fails to deliver what other non-linear story telling movies/shows does. I rated it an 7/10, just because of Isaac & Miria and for episodes 2-10. Nothing else.
5
u/The-Sublimer-One :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/The-Sublimer-One May 07 '15
Isaac and Miria are best couple. Your shit-taste argument is invalid.
3
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
Definitely one of the best examples of the dub fitting a show better because of it's setting .
3
u/damiroor May 07 '15
I watched all of Baccano! in one sitting and it is number 2 on my top anime list of everything I've seen.
1
u/PopVuIture :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PopVulture May 08 '15 edited May 08 '15
To those who think the sub is better than the dub, all I have to say to you is "SAMANSA!!"
1
u/Lepony :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/dinglegrip May 08 '15
So the people that don't like Baccano due to the hectic storytelling or whatever, what's your opinion on Pulp Fiction?
1
u/[deleted] May 08 '15
literally the most suspenseful and engaging storyline ive ever encountered in an anime, as someone whos watched every anime they can get their hands on.
1
u/atlantislifeguard May 08 '15
I went in expecting the anime version of Lock stock and two smoking barrels, but it left me a bit... unsatisfied.
For me, the narrative choice was what drew me in, but I didn't think the individual story lines were that interesting. I was simply waiting for when shit would hit the fan, and the moments leading up to them were quite lackluster, and even the payoffs were not that great.
I never got that feeling of frenetic energy like when I watched Guy Ritchie's films. On the plus side though, the music's fantastic.
1
u/tjl73 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/tjl1973 May 09 '15
Is it only available as a DVD in English? I can't find a Blu-Ray version.
1
u/Yggdrazzil https://myanimelist.net/profile/Yggdrazzil May 09 '15
Whelp I watched it in one go! Watched the first episode sub and dub, continued with the dub, that was so incredibly well done! Great show! Not a moment of boredom, great mix of serious and hilarious moments. Awesome! Thanks for the recommendation!!
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
The dubs for this show are amazing. ithink iv seen baccano like five times its that great.
1
u/Yggdrazzil https://myanimelist.net/profile/Yggdrazzil May 07 '15
Great! This sounds like it has a combination of elements in it I don't usually see together in an anime! Got 3 more episodes of Sora No Woto to go (hoped for a lot more depth in this show...) and then I'll go check it out! Excited! Thanks for sharing!!
1
u/[deleted] May 07 '15
Nice job! You pretty much nailed what makes Baccano so awesome!
1
u/bubbla_ https://anilist.co/user/irrocau May 08 '15
I disagree. I watched in sub and in no way did it feel like your example. I have no problem with people watching it dubbed, but you simply can't know what everyone will prefer, so telling people they MUST watch it dubbed is really one sided. I tried dub later. It wasn't for me. Yes they did a better job than most dubs, but I still think original VAs fit much better. So please can dub fans stop INSISTING that everyone watched it the way you liked it? At least let people give subs a chance and choose by themselves.
-5
u/BigBlackPenis May 08 '15
Too ambitious without the writing to match. A boring, confusing mess of a story with a huge cast of one-dimensional characters.
I just do not understand the praise this show gets. As of right now, it stands at 8.62/10 and ranked #58. That’s pretty impressive—at least that’s what I thought—but this was the show that made me question anything on MyAnimeList. An 8/10 is meaningless when Dragon Ball Z is rated 8.28/10. Are you guys even trying to be objective? I think you’d better off with having a “Shit/Not Shit” rating system.
I’m beginning to think the people who like Baccano! do so because it makes them feel smart. They “get” the story. They can follow it and appreciate all delicious complexities. They can keep up with its “non-linear” storytelling. Anyone who doesn’t understand this must be goddam peasant with the IQ of a vegetable.
Baccano! is shit, and you should feel bad for ever recommending this garbage to someone. It’s just gimmick after gimmick that tricks you into thinking it’s better than actually is. If you break it down to the fundamentals of good story telling it fails.
I’ll admit that it’s ambitious—just like another certain show I’ve reviewed (hint: the first word is “Sword” and ends in “Shit”). Baccano! juggles a huge cast, multiple intersecting plotlines, different time periods, and attempts it in 16 episodes. It’s admirable, but when your ambition is that big you better fucking bring your A-game.
And Baccano! fails miserably. It’s so obvious that the writers’ goals could not be met by their abilities. It’s all gimmicks and flash to cover up poor writing. I can forgive boring characters if the story and plotting were good. I can forgive a shit story if the characters are charming enough. But Baccano! has neither. The show 24 has some terribly shallow characters, but, goddamn, you cannot say it doesn’t keep your ass glued to the seat.
There are so many characters, and almost all of them are forgettable. I get it. You’ve got a big cast, and you don’t have time to give everyone an episode to tell their sad, childhood story. Then cut or combine some characters. I couldn’t tell one gangster from another, and there were too many characters I didn’t understand what purpose they served to the story other than just existing. Worse, the shows tries for this authentic, Prohibition era America setting only to have the tone ruined by some lame, “anime”-styled characters. There’s a lot of dialogue that is just embarrassingly cheesy.
The story is told in a “non-linear” way which is just another way of saying, “Fuck you if you can’t keep track of every little detail, you mongoloid.” The plotting skips around so much you can’t tell if you’re watching a flashback. One moment you’re trying to understand what’s happening and it’ll cut to different characters in the past without any indication. This isn’t innovative or bold. It’s confusing. I’m not asking to be spoon-fed a story. Nobody is, but it’s up to you as the writer to balance between telling the story in an engaging way and making sure it’s understood.
Most of the “story” takes place on a train. I cannot stress the quotes around the word “story” enough because there is none. Now I thought it was gonna be one of those coincidence stories where everyone is going after the same thing on the same day in the same place, and the fun comes from them figuring out how to deal with each other. You’ve got gangsters dealing with thieves and an urban legend monster lurking on the train. That would’ve been 100x more exciting than what I actually got which was none of that. They’re literally just on the train for no reason. They run into each and stuff happens. There’s no ultimate goal or something to accomplish, and when you don’t have that why the fuck should I care?
"Blending sci-fi and pulp fiction to create an entertaining saga unlike any other, this action-packed anime series revolves around the exploits of a group of immortal 18th-century alchemists currently living as Prohibition-era gangsters."
The Netflix description is as exciting as the show gets.
It doesn’t even explore or do anything with its immortality gimmick—which was what got me interested in the first place. When they finally talk about it doesn’t have any effect on the rest of the story. You could’ve taken it out, and it’d still be the same boring shit.
And after all this you’re left asking, “What was Baccano! even about?” It’s sad when the only thing I liked was the opening.
-2
u/OkabeKurisu May 08 '15
Your opinion is worthless.
-6
u/Zadujj May 07 '15
Just remember to skip the first episode, and if you want see it after you finish the series.