r/anime • u/7TeenWriters :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/7TeenWriters • Jul 08 '15
[WT!] Why You Should (or shouldn't) Watch Kara no Kyoukai
So this is an old /r/animesuggest thread that I made back when I frequented that sub, since WT threads became a thing I've wanted to post this but people have posted a couple of KnK WTs already and each time I decided to wait again. Now I'm posting it because of the new soundtrack rule (I know people are going to go crazy with it, but hey). This post will is from 9 months ago, but rather than edit it I decided to add footnotes at the end because I actually find it kind of interesting just in terms of how I used to write and some of the stuff I added to please the average frequenter of /r/animesuggest... obviously I'm also editing it to add in soundtracks.
So Kara no Kyoukai is one of my absolute favorite shows of all time. It is also probably the least well known out of my favorite shows. I find myself suggesting it on this sub a lot because of this fact, it's a great show that a lot of people are unlikely to have seen. It also falls under a lot of the categories that I see requested. With that in mind I decided to write this, both to get you guys to take a look at the show and also so I can link to this post when people want more information after I suggest it1 . Without further ado, here are the general bullet points about what is good and bad about the show:
- The characters: The male and female leads are both incredibly strong (though the male lead does have a section where he makes some rather stupid decisions, it makes sense to both the characters and the story). The female lead is the one who really takes the show in this, she's a complete badass with great characterization. This can be a more controversial section of the show, as some people find it hard to care about these characters. What I'd have to say is that the show values subtlety. Not everything is too explicitly stated and the female lead especially is rather reserved. There is a lot of emotion present, but it's less obvious than in other shows. This doesn't suit a lot of people, so if it doesn't sound like your kind of thing this is a legitimate reason not to watch it.2
- The story: Depending on who you ask it's either fantastic, confusing, or eh. I obviously loved it but I'll try to give you guys the most objective view I can without divulging any spoilers. Basically, the biggest issue that people have with the plot is that it is told out of order, and not in the most easy to follow fashion. This is a legitimate criticism and one of the major reasons that I feel this show is not for everyone. If you didn't like Baccano! for it's disjointedness or have a hard time understanding linear plots, this show probably isn't for you. I tend to like complex plots and this one took me a second watchthrough to get everything. Other people say it's largely uninteresting (aside from movie 5). That's where expectations come in. If you want an epic world shaking story you're out of luck, this show tells a fantastic story on a much smaller scale than other similar works. The only real thing at stake in any given3 episode is the main characters and maybe a few other lives as well.
- The world: The show is set in the Type-Moon universe, but is very different from the Fate series (and IMO much4 better). The powers and logic of the world are always interesting and make for good supernatural mysteries. Not a giant standout in this regard but solid.
- The animation: The animation in general is frankly glorious. The characters and backdrops are just beautiful.
- The music: one of my top two anime soundtracks of all time. I listen to it on its own like a lot. It's done by Yuki Kajiura if that sells anyone.
Given the new rules, here are my top 10 songs from the show (in no particular order):
Spiral Note that this isn't the actual track from the show but instead an edited version of an awesome piece towards the end that I made for my exercise playlist, if you want to listen to the full 13 minute track (which I do actually recommend) here it is.
M01 (from the 7th movie) (starts about 20 seconds in)
Sprinter (couldn't find a video of the original song, probably copyright reasons)
Paradigm (again, no video for this except for this spoiler filled clip from movie 5)
Satsujin Kousatsu (Go) II - into the light
Oblivious (again, no good video)
- The action: Dear god is it fantastic. When I say that it's good I don't feel like I do it justice. It's hard to explain but it's not your everyday shounen "I'm awesome and I hit things" action. The action in this show is a work of art, the music and the visuals combine perfectly with the tone of the scene to make something more than the fight scenes from any other show I have ever seen. Here, just watch the first two minutes of this video if you're not convinced (that much pretty spoiler free and will give you a taste for what you're getting into. Not the best action in the show but my favorite that isn't spoilerific5 ).
- The romance: Like most other things in this show, it's very much on point. Like I said above under characters it's very subtle. It is always present but doesn't really make itself enough of an issue to distract form the plot (until it becomes a major part of the plot later on).
Lastly, here are a few major points of the show that might make it or break it depending on who you are. It's dark, there's no getting around that. If you want something lighthearted, this is not the show for you. That's not to say it's the most fucked up thing of all time, but it's a largely humorless show and isn't afraid to show some gore. There is no badass male hero, Mikiya is cool and all, but there is no powerful male MC (which I know is a turnoff for some)6 . The last thing is that it's very dialogue heavy. Most of any given movie is going to be a lot of talking, with small amounts of action interspersed and usually with a glorious final fight scene towards the end. This leads it to feel slower, and some who are watching it for the action might find it boring (though I really like the structure, it is as I keep saying, not for everyone).
If, for the most part, the difficulties with this show don't seem to apply to you, WATCH IT NOW. It is a really great show, and though not everyone enjoys it equally if you are the type of person to enjoy it it will be more worth it than you could believe.
FOOTNOTES
1. There was a time before I frequented /r/anime where I would hunt for threads on /r/animesuggest where Kara no Kyoukai or Baccano! fit, those being the least popular of my favorite shows.
2. The more I think about this this actually becomes one of the great strengths of the show in my mind. Subtlety means more nuance which adds heavily to rewatch value.
3. That's not quite true, there's quite a bit at stake in the 5th movie.
4. At the time I had only seen Fate/Zero and read the Fate arc of the F/SN VN. After watching UBW (which I thoroughly enjoyed) my preference is still unchanged. We'll see after HF though.
5. If you don't care about spoilerific the video that I added for the track Paradigm is fucking awesome.
6. Oh, /r/animesuggest. That line was included because every other thread back when I frequented it wanted an overpowered male protagonist... A bit saddening for me because I actually prefer female leads a lot of the time...
Also, sorry for not putting out more reviews like I said I would in the FTF. I really am trying, but I also have a job and given the fact that I now want my reviews to conform to academic standards I really don't have the time. I'm currently working on (you guessed it) some more specific Kara no Kyoukai analysis focusing on how the show portrays romance with specific attention to the 5th movie, but progress is pretty slow since after working on a bunch of academic stuff writing an academic paper for fun is never really at the top of my list. The moment I get some time to myself I'll probably churn out a few reviews or essays that I'll space out so it seems like I'm being more productive than I am.
Edit: thanks to /u/master_axe all of the songs now have videos.
17
u/tayoku0 Jul 08 '15
Ahh I heard good things about this series a couple years ago when Fate/Zero was airing and finally decided to give it a shot recently. Unfortunately all I remembered of the title was a "no" and two k's, one of which was "kyoukai". So I ended up watching Kyoukai no Kanata by mistake and was left wondering why people had told me that it was pretty dark when all I saw was a bunch of moe KyoAni characters. Thanks for clearing up my confusion with this post!
37
u/h_YsK Jul 08 '15
Kara no Kyoukai, and especially the fifth movie still remains ufotable's magnum opus IMO.
Fun Fact: Hideo Kojima has a nasu/takeuchi signed copy of the Kara no Kyoukai novel
7
u/master_axe Jul 08 '15
These three songs the ones you couldn't find?
sprinter
oblivious
paradigm
5
u/SunlitVoid https://anilist.co/user/SunlitVoid Jul 08 '15
I'm surprised there wasn't a KnK thread already.
On the action, I liked KnK Major Spoilers the most.
For the story I didn't really find it confusing, sure there were terms , but its not overwhelming.
9
u/OutZoned :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/OutZoned Jul 08 '15
I always recommend KnK to just about everyone. It's legitimately incredible, and has one of the greatest soundtracks I've ever heard.
Every anime fan should at least try to watch it, IMO.
4
u/Mega_Nerd :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Mega_Nerd Jul 08 '15
This seems interesting. I heard stuff about orders, Which order do I see them in? I still can't believe how much I keep confusing this for the one made by Kyoani with a similar name.
3
u/ssj58trunks :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/CrimzonTiger Jul 09 '15
I remember you recommended this to me so long ago and I STILL haven't watched idk wtf is wrong with me I will promptly go watch this after I finish up Shirobako.
8
u/ernietwinkle :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ernietinkle Jul 08 '15
I would've enjoyed it if I wasn't required to know a fuckton of Nasu vocab in order to make any sense of the story. Just a warning for people who want to watch it: be familiar with the Nasuverse before trying this.
2
u/kaverik :Ef::Eh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kaverik Jul 08 '15
Good job, 7Teen. I hope I'll get on KnK this summer, after completing UBW and returning to Nasuverse. These movies do sound like something I would definitely enjoy. Thanks for WT thread!
2
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '15
Can we get a rewatching going? I need to rewatch
3
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '15
This series manages to be both overrated and underrated at the same time. Its a good watch regardless, if only for the soundtrack and animation alone. As others have noted, get versed in nasuverse. This series is incredibly hard to understand, and the non-chronological order makes following it even harder.
2
u/ReggaeManMurphy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TJMurphy17 Jul 08 '15 edited Jul 08 '15
Question, will having watched the fate series alleviate any of the confusion Ernie was talking about?
5
u/Plake_Z01 Jul 09 '15 edited Jul 09 '15
I think the characters are the ones that suffer the most from the way it is presented.
Given that the story is told in a non-linear way I think we could have used a bit less subtelty. Don't get me wrong they are well written and complex characters but it's bogged down because some things are more confusing that they need to be.
The presentation and direction does not always account for the fact that the viewer is constantly trying to put the plot together while engaging with the story and can fail to make the characters compelling. Lots of lingo that make no sense if you are not familiar with the setting makes this an even bigger problem.
It's filled with lots of great ideas but ultimately a very unrefined work.
The best example is the "flying vs floating" ordeal in the first movie. There's no reason to present the conflict like that; "fake vs original", Shiki as the "real deal" and the other girls as "imitations" would get the job done just as well but easier to swallow. Which is what you need for a climactic conflict.
I can only assume the idea is that flying and floating fits the antagonists who is literally floating on top of a building and, as good as it sounds to have an idea represented figuratively as a philosophy and literaly "on screen", sometimes authors need to know when is best to restrain themselves. UBW benefited from a straight foward approach and managed to be more exiting, which is what I think both works where aiming to do.
It's easy to read this as KnK actually being pretentious and is why many people call it that, I don't agree because there's more than enough substance to justify everything in here but I can totally see why some think that way and sadly it's not entirely their fault, Kara no Kyoukai could use some tweaks that would go a long way towards making it more approachable.
If you want to enjoy it you have to put in the work, thankfully it does have a lot of hooks that make the viewer interested and incorporating mystery elements into the story are it's saving grace. I do think it's a masterpiece but a flawed unapproachable one.
Edit: This is much longer thatn I wanted it to be. Oops.
4
u/Deathmeister https://myanimelist.net/profile/dbzakj Jul 08 '15
I'm watching this one movie per year, it just feels like one of those things I don't want to end and just ends the year with something so full of quality. Will be movie 5 or 6 this year.
1
u/chocolatechoux Jul 08 '15
Isn't the soundtrack by hikaru nanase, not Yuki Kajiura?
1
u/DogzOnFire Jul 09 '15
My favourite piece of music from the entire series is still the bit that plays during the opening credit sequence of the first film. It's pretty much perfect in setting up the entire atmosphere and setting of the series in one two minute segment. I don't even now how to describe how I think it does that, but it just seems like it fits the series perfectly. It's actually what convinced me to watch the films.
4
u/master_axe Jul 08 '15
Screw the slightly confusing story. This movie series is simply one of anime's greats, if even only for the OST and art. It's slightly melancholic, but what great show isn't...
2
u/PostOnlyOpinions Jul 09 '15
I really like Kara no Kyoukai and I wish there was more to watch. Good stuff! Always think of it when I see haeagen dazs at the store.
1
u/bakuhatsuda Jul 08 '15
Have they made any BDs that are affordable in the west? Are they ever going to?
1
u/[deleted] Jul 09 '15
Hello TeenWriters!
I remember wanting to get into KnK a year ago (maybe a bit longer) and I watched the first movie. I found it intriguing, but I felt like I was thrown into the middle of the story, or like I was thrown in-knowing nothing, expecting to understand something.
Outstanding animation and sound though.
I guess what I am asking, is how much better is the storytelling in the future movies? I got somewhat bored of the story in the first movie because of this lack of understanding. I know I will enjoy this series if I put the effort in, yknow? It's just the block I have from the first movie. (And also, I dislike movie format).
Great write-up.
N.B. Sorry for the way this comment was written, I was kind of rambling.
-11
u/Shadehaluz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Shadu-senpai Jul 08 '15
it's extremely boring
-5
u/kristallnachte :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kristallnachte Jul 08 '15
I see no clarification of the difference between Kara no Kyoukai and Kyoukai no Kanata.