r/anime • u/Hibernica • Jul 14 '15
Shimoneta; or my first attempt at overthinking anime in public. (Also, probably)[WT!]
So in the description I just kind of assumed it was going to be a standard ecchi show with uncomfortable fanservice and alarming amounts of panties. I had no desire to watch it until one of my friends convinced me to give it a shot. There will be spoilers throughout and a little plot synopsis for reference. I will tag major things, but be warned.
It was (mostly) not what I expected. Instead you have a version of Japan where censorship has gone to an insane extreme to the point where taking about anything sexual will get you arrested and sentenced to hard labor based on the severity and quantity of words. Adult magazines and websites are illegal (The tech here is a little hand-wavey, but any time you're censoring the internet you're bound run into hand waving) and the Public Morals group has basically created a Panopticon. The words and movements of every member of the public is observed at all times. For some reason from this they drew the conclusion that people would stop understanding basic things like how to reproduce. This is where I start viewing this tale as an allegory about censorship in education. Obviously I'm viewing this from the perspective of an American, and I can't say for sure that Japan faces any of the same things wee do. I'd be surprised if they don't.
Anyway, the main character gets accepted into the best public morals school in Japan, which he works toward because he idolizes the student council president, Anna. Anna's parents . She's COMPLETELY oblivious to everything which is generally played for comedic affect. The second member of the student council is a guy who knows more than he lets on, but is still pretty out of it. Stylistically he reminds me a bit of Gamagoori and is initially portrayed as being somewhat ape-like. The third member is Anna's best friend and our female MC, and the fourth is our male MC. Our female MC is a "terrorist" who takes off her clothes and puts on a towel and disguises her face with panties (I said mostly earlier) and throws cards with scantily clad people and swears and says rude words. Episode 1 Episode 2
I take the series, as I said, to be an allegory about censoring education and revisionist views of history. It's entirely possible that it is simply a commentary on sex education and the weird censorship laws Japan has on the books, but I don't think so. That penis festival makes me somewhat doubt it. The level of ignorance, to me, stands to be more about freedom of information than anything else. The laws are focused on sex specifically, but Japan would completely lose any connection to biology and history, because you can't really discuss a great deal in either of those fields without an understanding of sex. This would, in turn, cause problems for the society's chemistry research and pharmaceuticals in the long run as well. It's clear that there's a ripple affect building out from the banning or revising of a single field.
It's NOTHING like the shallow stupidity I'd expected. Although the dirty jokes ARE stupid and juvenile.
Really stupid and juvenile.
But I think that's part of the point too since it shows a direct stunting of the development of one of the characters who DOES have the forbidden knowledge.
Ultimately what we're looking at here is an example of information control not dissimilar to 1984 and Orwell's version of the Panopticon. While the information being suppressed is clearly different we see somewhat similar results in a population that is lacking in critical experiences and the knowledge required to make informed decisions. We see this in the reaction the students have to Episode 1. It's a short leap from that idea to kids experimenting on their own and you get unplanned pregnancies from kids who didn't even know what they were doing.
Episode 2 shows a significant drop in critical thinking skills from the affected population. Episode 2. I think this ties into the idea that censoring information has greater harms than just the loss of that specific information. Information is interconnected, a web if you will, and cutting away pieces of the web affects the whole.
There are other themes worth examining such thrill in disobedience and shame, sex education and school students, and the importance of allowing a safe exploration of said sexuality, but my primary interest lies in the censorship.
I was very pleasantly surprised. I might be overthinking it too, but I love overthinking things and I'll gladly take anything I'm allowed to overthink
7
u/ASK_ABOT_DEE_QLUB Jul 14 '15
I'm kind of confused, are you just summarizing the first 2 episodes for us?
And yes, I was pleasantly surprised as well. Probably in my top 10 of the season.
2
u/razzy1818 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rasputin18 Jul 14 '15
I want to say that I saw something about the author actually going for a mildly political undertone when he was writing the storyline for this anime. I think it was supposed to be a satire about the current censorship situation that is happening with China. (Feel free to correct me, but I thought I read this somewhere)
Overall, I think you have some good views on this anime in terms of the social aspects, and I'm glad to see you draw the 1984 comparison for this because that's pretty much exactly the style of the story.
But even with all of this, I have really just been taking it at face value rather than really looking into it and will probably continue to do that.
2
u/Mega_Nerd :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Mega_Nerd Jul 26 '15
What do you think of the recent revelations regarding the latest episode. Like Anna going crazy.
3
u/RDOoM Jul 14 '15
If you think that dirty jokes are stupid and juvenile, you might be missing a point about the show. Specifically, that dirty jokes are a natural part of human behavior, and you shouldn't punish, judge or brand people using them as perverts or juvenile.
It is that kind of "I know better" attitude that allows for the situation where certain things are banned for moral or ideological reasons.
1
u/hahahahastayingalive Jul 14 '15
That's a nice analysis.
When focusing only on the sex aspect, I found previous series like Kenzen robo daimidala more interesting. Daimidara was more dealing with how we see sex and erotism in our current society, and not an hypothetical future, and it allowed a more nuanced approach I think.
Focusing purely on the censorship aspect, it's intersting to see how it's a recurring thing in the current anime landscape, with Toshokan sensou a while before, Psychopass taking more of a minority report angle, and the very stupid Mahouka no koukosei set in a future where morality is inforced to a stricter level than now.
Japan has very much of a censorship problem, especially when people auto-censor and keep controversial ideas to themselves, thus depriving the society of otherwise important insight. Since Fukushima more spotlight went on the Press clubs and the control done on political/government information, but it was done mainly on the net, in discussion boards and blogs, and not on anything officially produced. You won't have a John Oliver show in Japan, not now, not next year.
It seems the caricatural, and sex focused approach taken by Shimoneta to iu gainen ga [...] is as much as we can have for now. I'd really like to see the same kind of anime squarely centered on press or politics.
2
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '15
Not much to say, here. I think the themes are quite in-your-face in this show. Especially after the conversation they had discussing . The context, however, might be more distant for western viewers. If you want to tie this to Japan and revisionism you will probably be interested in Japan's ugly WWII history. Maybe look into the censorship laws and the currently social and political landscape around them.
1
u/rancame Jul 14 '15 edited Jul 14 '15
I think the show would be infinitely better if it was a focused metaphor for sexual exploration at the same time-For example, the main character is trying to censor out his "dirty" thoughts from his mind, and holding Anna in such high esteem is an example of trying to hold onto childhood innocence free from these thoughts. His relationship with dad likewise could represent how he grew more and more disdainful of dirty jokes the more he understood the meaning behind them.
My problem with all this theorizing about underlying themes, though, is that the show doesn't seem to really try to focus on them enough to make thinking about them seem like something done intentionally. It definitely has some kind of statement about Japan's censorship laws beneath it, but it doesn't feel like it's saying anything other than just "this censorship is bad". If the show went on to explore what is wrong with nanny-state censorship and what is wrong with the other extreme (namely, the way the female MC tries to bring about her ideals by forcing them on our male MC) and came to a conclusion somewhere in the middle, I think that would make it so much better.
All of the tools to drive home this theme are there-our MC's disdain for Blue Snow's jokes feels like it almost could make a point that dirty jokes are juvenile but ultimately harmless, especially as he's caught between the two extremes of Anna and Blue Snow, but there isn't enough focus on this in the show for me to think that any deeper meaning that comes from it can be legitimate or intentional. As another example, in my mind, it's also so close to saying something about the declining national birthrate, but I can't prove one way or the other that the show actually knows it's doing this.
Of course, though, we're only two episodes in, and as I said, the show has all the tools it needs for driving home any themes about censorship and sex, so I wouldn't be surprised if it does go this route eventually (actually, I think in the case of this show, it would be harder to miss that you could go down this route with all the natural setup it has). Even if it doesn't, however, it'll still be a good show with some hilariously absurd lines in it ("Protect the urine!" had me in stitches), and that already makes it worthwhile enough for me. :)
1
u/Proctor_J_Semhouse :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Proctor_Semhouse Jul 14 '15
Of course, I could just read the manga or whatever, but only time will tell if this show is actually trying to say anything at all. So far, the bad effects of the censorship have only been used for jokes. There's really not much to it. In fact, I can't even be certain how the author feels about all censorship, only about this kind, which is so obviously bad.
I think it is as stupid as it seems.