r/anime • u/kaverik :Ef::Eh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kaverik • Aug 27 '15
[WT!] White Album 2
Often enough people new to anime (and rather experienced, too) ask for recommendations. One of the most common requests is to watch "realistic" romance. Now, with the amount of "romantic comedies" (or simply "romcoms" as we know them) it's really easy to underlook this type of shows, though some of them are really good and worthy of one's attention. One of these works is White Album 2.
- MAL: White Album 2
- Genres: Drama, Music, Romance, Slice of Life
- Number of Episodes: 13
- Year: 2013
- Studio: Satelight
Of course it's really hard to call something "realistic" in the world of anime, but White Album 2 approaches this notion with maximum care and attention. This work is an adaptation of the visual novel of the same name. Since it's a kinetic novel (which means it doesn't have branches and different endings), it was easier to adapt than its counterparts - the narrative is straight and steady. And before we dwell into more details - no, you don't need to watch/read first part of White Album. These stories work fairly well as stand-alone pieces.
Haruki Kitahara is a very good student, a person who's always willing to help and coincidentally rather well-looking human being. Tough luck though - all the people recruited to play music on school festival have left. Suddenly he stumbles across Setsuna Ogiso, a beuatiful girl who likes to sing karaoke. He's reluctant to tell her his troubles at first, but soon enough becomes good friends with her. And who's that mysterious person who plays piano in the locked classroom and inspires Haruki to play guitar himself?..
All in all, White Album 2 excels in the most important part of any romance anime - its characters. We can't say that anyone of our trio of main characters have outstanding features, unreal talent or unhuman power with insane luck. However, they have distincitve personalities, their habits, their fears and desires. They act like human beings - something that we don't usually see in anime, eh? Even the protagonist is not a self-insert character as it often happens in anime like this - he has line of thoughts and behaviour that you may agree or disagree with. They may be not the most memorable characters of all time, but they suit for this anime well enough that you don't ask for more. To make this kind of characters is a very hard task too - step behind, and they look boring and uninspiring, step ahead - and they are unrealistic and caricature. White Album 2 found the balance and presents cast of truly great characters and with their help tells a solid story.
Speaking of story, it's also a very good one. Don't expect many plot twists and turnarounds - there is no hidden thing in this anime other than human logic and emotions. Because of this it's easy to feel the story from inside - everyone who was in the situation (a very common one) that this anime decribes can probably relate to it. Development is slow and steady with certain climax (or even two) and satisfying resolution. Yes, in comparison with many other romance anime out there White Album 2 has definitive and undisputable ending, which is yet another strong point of this work. Moreover, it's a great one which certainly suits the whole atmosphere and idea of anime - while it's a high school, and it's a perfect time to tough some things out while you still can, some events are just too bitter to endure and even think of, and even the binar choice can be the hardest one.
One of the other big aspects of White Album 2 is its music. While you won't hear classic like in Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso or jazz of Sakamichi no Apollon in this anime, it still features very nice music to listen to - OP is simply amazing, and the title song is on top level of quality. It also features no less than 6 (!) different EDs, which is also quite great on its own (/r/AnimeThemes have just uploaded all of them, enjoy!). I can assure you that some of the melodies might sound in your mind for a long time after completing the anime, and you won't feel bad about it. White Album 2 knows how to work well with music and how it matters in creating the special mood.
So I've been describing for quite a while how good this anime is, and what about some drawbacks? Well, White Album 2 doesn't have serious flaws, but some things that one should be aware of. Being a visual novel adaptation, it sticks to the certain canonic character designs. No, they are quite good, but with the recent trend of quirky and bright character designs White Album 2's seem to be a bit bland. Also, don't forget - it's not a "romcom", so the more "serious" tone of character designs is kind of understandable. Another point of complaints could be found in "cringey romance" and "stupid characters", but that could be applied to any romance out there - if you don't believe in what's happening on your screen, everything becomes a target of facepalms and nitpicking. White Album 2 tries its hard to make romance as realistic and relatable as possible, and if you ask me, it works rather well. Yes, you would doubt characters' intentions, motivations and actions, but people are not ideal and can't always act as robots, and White Album 2 perfects this very notion.
I have bad news for you guys who are looking for "realistic romance" out there - they are rare beasts nowadays, and it's a good thing if there is one such beast appears per year. In 2013, this beast was White Album 2 - hunt it down immediately... or cage it and wait for the mood to strike - it's up to you.
TL;DR White Album 2 is a great and fairly realistic romance anime without "comedy" part in it which excels in characters, story and music departments.
Thanks for reading! Feel free to share your thoughts in comments, any sort of feedback is always appreciated.
19
u/EzioSC5 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Jukain Aug 27 '15
I personally found that White Album 2 was much too clean, too perfect, too ideal. Things just fell into place too easily. It's more 'anime-real' than 'actual-real'. I felt that the original White Album was more real, as it was gritty, chaotic, and a mess. I knew what was going to happen in White Album 2 before it happened, like always. White Album 2, on the other hand, caught me off guard a few times.
Also, I personally don't think you get the titular song "White Album" if you don't know its origins, which are unraveled in the original White Album. In White Album 2, it's just referred to as some amazing song from the past, but they don't really go into the why. You only get that if you watch the original.
3
u/demeyezz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sangu40k Aug 27 '15
I may sound stupid but do I need to watch White Album before this one?
3
u/FoleyX90 Aug 27 '15
I'd like to point out a really good writeup for those who have finished the series and may be left with questions; or you just want a deeper understanding of what the characters were thinking.
24
u/DasTales :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TalesOhneNamen Aug 27 '15
I'm surprised there wasn't already one. Good job on the writeup.
There is one thing that I have to say is not good about WA2 however:
Spoilers:
65
u/misoramensenpai Aug 27 '15
The best thing about White Album 2 is the fact that all the characters are dicks, just like real teenagers. It doesn't have nice, sugarcoated characters or ones with whom you want to empathize; it just shoves in your face that all these characters are dicks, but you'll still care about what happens to them because they're believable, understandable teenagers who cause their own problems, rather than being grouped as "good" or "bad" characters as some series or films do.
18
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '15
Preach it, WA2 is incredible
1
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15
Enjoyed the show. Have any more recommendations similar to this one?
1
u/Tiongki Aug 28 '15
I search for some recommendations for romance genre and this is where I initially landed. The moment I saw the ending of the first episode, I know that I will be hooked. I definitely love the songs and I can still hear it playing in my mind.
Definitely a 10/10 for me. I can't stress enough how realistic this is and the feelings that I felt, it's too real man. I need to find other animes similar to this, but it seems that I'm out of luck?
1
u/Skydanzer :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Skydanzer Aug 27 '15
Speaking as someone who absolutely adored this show and related to characters - It's amazing.
There is no hidden message, like OP says, it hits you right in the face with the most realistic and relatable characters anime has ever (my opinion) seen. It doesn't bush around with the concept of love triangle. It executes it way better than other shows. That's why people like it, and that's precisely why people either love it or hate it. Because they either love the realistic portrayal of characters, or hate that they are too realistic for this medium.
And don't even get me started on the soundtrack of this show. As a metal-genre fanatic, I loved every single bit of it. Meh, after that show I couldn't get into any romance series for quite a while, as they all lacked something called realism..
4
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15
White Album 2 is the perfect blend between cheesy anime tropes and realistic outcomes. I disagree with people though when they say that no one is really at fault there ... Everyone is at fault, but who gets the short end of the stick is plenty obvious in my opinion.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '15
I'm curious. Why are you labeling White Album 2 as a "slice of life?" Is it because it's set in a High School or does it have "slice of life" storytelling elements?
2
u/buttered_popcorn :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/buttered_popcorn Aug 27 '15
Haven't seen it yet, but its been on my PTW list forever. I just have one question: Is there a happy ending?
I tend to stay away from romance animes that end badly, as weird as that sounds. I need to see a cliche happy ending that doesn't rip my heart out from the angst.
2
u/AmbiguousGravity Aug 27 '15 edited Aug 27 '15
I really enjoyed White Album 2. I refuse to read a summary of the material following White Album 2 though; I'm still holding out for either a full adaptation (unlikely) or a translation of the original VN (also unlikely, but the VN market has been doing pretty well recently so who knows).
If all else fails, the fan translation should be done in about 20 years, so I could read that. Or just learn Japanese. Eh.
Edit: formatting.
2
u/gnauhZ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/gnauhZ Aug 27 '15 edited Aug 27 '15
Great writeup.
Just a heads up but if you enjoyed the music/singing in White Album I highly recommend you guys check out the White Album 2 Vocal Collection. A lot of original and VN songs are covered and they're criminally underrated (here's my favourite).
It's probably my favourite soundtrack in anime and it helps that it's recorded and mastered well unlike 99% of what I come across.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15
White Album 2 is the perfect blend between cheesy anime tropes and realistic outcomes. I disagree with people though when they say that no one is really at fault there ... Everyone is at fault, but who gets the short end of the stick is plenty obvious in my opinion.
1
u/OrangeDragonite Aug 28 '15
I have a Question is this a second season? I am confused because there is a white album and then a white album 2? can someone explain to me if there is a chronological order? Thanks
1
u/BlindPiratez :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BlindPiratez Aug 28 '15
Wow, I was actually about to start this tonight. Thanks for giving me even more motivation to do so!
1
u/royaldocks Aug 28 '15
This series has given me so much different range of emotions. Never a single episode where I was bored.
Hell I thought they would end up slicing and stabbing with each other with a knife in the end like some infamous anime out there.
The things I would do for a season 2....
1
u/GuyWithSausageFinger Aug 28 '15
Guess I should finally watch it
1
u/Lyriq Aug 28 '15
I really want to watch this, but I really want to play the visual novel first. Do I finally accept that an acceptable translation will never happen and just watch the anime?
1
u/DelayedLag Aug 28 '15
Very good watch. Binged the whole thing, and it was amazing.
1
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15
I really don't know how i feel about the anime's plot i guess because it did make me feel emotions, not sad or happy just kind of angry (which is perfectly fine in story telling). Sure Spoiler
I felt like The character i most understood was Haruki's Friend in the endSpoiler
1
u/Gurip Aug 28 '15
certain climax (or even two)
you sneaky bastard, peole that saw this show will know.
1
u/DroppedPJK Aug 28 '15
Take this with a grain of salt but WA2 will make you feel something you wouldn't have necessarily thought you would feel watching it.
It's a roller coaster that only goes up, and it goes up real fast.
1
u/EatDrinkBoogie Aug 28 '15
Watching this now. I'm 5 episodes in and I love the subtlety of the love triangle and the way the characters are depicted. Thanks for the great write up!
1
u/Cptn_Jib :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Space_Cowboy38 Oct 07 '15
Just finished it and absolutely love it, I don't think I've seen a better romance in a TV show thank you for posting this OP. If anyone has suggestions on what I should watch next I will probably take them up on it
0
u/Sakki54 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Brekcel Aug 27 '15
Heads up, contains HEAVY amounts of POSSIBLE spoilers.
0
u/NoMercyOracle :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NoMercy Aug 28 '15
I Started White Album 2 Yesterday, thanks to a week of lurking on /r/anime and /r/animesuggest and it constantly cropping up as a romance anime I never even heard of previously.
3 episodes in I definitely wouldn't say it is anything revolutionary, however the I'm really enjoying the normalcy of the character's situation and the soundtrack (both the in story and background music is gorgeous). It is also good so see so far that the MC actually has some charismatic & physical appeal, so that although the MC is clearly still oblivious that he is being crushed on hard, it seems justified.
-11
u/Deathsodas :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Desusoda Aug 27 '15
/r/anime gives WA2 more praise than it's worth
-3
u/phil3570 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/phil3570 Aug 27 '15
Dropped this recently after 3 episodes, it just felt too formulaic. Feel free to convince me otherwise.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 28 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Aug 27 '15
[removed] — view removed comment