r/anime • u/CheesewithWhine :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cheesewithwhine • Aug 29 '15
[WT!] Shigatsu wa Kimi no Uso / Your Lie in April
Accidentally deleted my post FailFish. Reddit needs a better iphone version. Thankfully I saved a copy.
Do you like drama? Then check out this show.
Do you like romance? Then check out this show.
Do you like music? Then check out this show.
Do you like classical music? You can't miss this show!
MAL: Your Lie in April
Genre: Genres: Drama, Music, Romance, School, Shounen
Number of Episodes: 22
Year: 2014-15
Story: Your Lie in April is about a famous young piano genius, Arima Kousei (CV: Natsuki Hanae), who after the tragic death of his mother, suffers a nervous breakdown and is no longer able to hear his own playing. He quits the piano, seeing the world as monotone, until he meets the pretty, free-spirited young violinist Kaori (CV: Risa Taneda), who drags him back into the world of music. With her accompaniment, as well as his childhood friends Tsubaki (CV: Ayane Sakura) and Watari (CV: Ryota Osaka), Kousei tells a beautiful, touching coming-of-age story not through the explicitness of words, but through the implicitness of music.
This is a show about a bunch of teenagers at a crossroad in their lives, each wearing their hearts on their sleeves, each with their own struggles and fears, and each with their own inner conflicts. Though classified as a drama series, the all too common "it's forced drama" criticism does not apply here; the experiences and conflicts that our characters go through are so realistic, and so resonating, that even though their actions are not always rational, we can't help but empathize, identify with, and ultimately cheer on these kids. Through masterful storytelling and writing, including the highly effective use of foreshadowing, parallel, symbolism, we get to immerse ourselves in the world of Your Lie in April as our cast of characters grow up, grow apart, and grow together.
Your Lie in April boasts a set of lifelike, relatable main characters, as well as a well-rounded, no less important group of support characters, from Kousei's two music rivals Emi (CV: Saori Hayami) and Takeshi (CV: Yuuki Kaji), to his mentor Hiroko (CV: Mie Sonozaki), to his young student Nagi (CV: Ai Kayano), working together to paint a big picture. Notably, each supporting character have their own stories to tell, and each plays his or her part in Kousei's growth and maturation, along with their own variable levels of development; no character is left out. One of Your Lie in April's strengths is that it does not have a single breakout character that makes the show, and instead relies on a team effort of many characters that each do their own part in making the show memorable.
The visuals are absolutely gorgeous. No CG! From each piano and violin, to the hand movements of performer, to the outdoor scene, to a starry night sky, the show's visuals are impeccable. The producers have taken great care in the accuracy of its musical presentations, which most certainly means a heavy budget. For comedic scenes, the show employs a chibi-like slapstick animation, which not only provides good visual contrast with more serious scenes, but also saves budget for where it counts.
If there is one thing more beautiful than the visuals of Your Lie in April, it must surely be the sound. Being a music-centered show, one would have high expectations sound-wise; the show easily meets and surpasses any of those expectations. Through two OPs, two EDs, numerous in-show performances, and various background music, your ears will surely enjoy this feast of a show. Not only is Your Lie in April able to heavily communicate emotion through its music, but it has taken the care to specifically arrange some of Chopin's piano pieces into piano-violin duets to excellent effect. The producers spared no dedication into putting out an aural feast worthy of a top level music title.
This is truly one of the shows that can be watched and re-watched. Whether it's some deep hidden foreshadowing that you missed the first time, or it's a captivating song that you want to listen to again, you'll find many reasons to watch Your Lie in April a second or third time.
Final Score: 9.5/10
56
u/giny33 Aug 29 '15
You mean *Your Feels in April
22
u/Apocalypse_Fudgeball https://myanimelist.net/profile/ApocFudge Aug 29 '15
I think Shigatsu is a solid show and I certainly had a great time watching it, but in spite of that I have few less rosy remarks about the show I'd like to add.
Shigatsu is a show that demands a significant amount of emotional commitment from the watcher and a lot of its effectiveness is entirely reliant upon it. /u/CheesewithWhine clearly managed to commit, but if you can't manage to give yourself to the show in the same way your reaction might fall more along the lines of /u/Revriley1, and you'll feel emotionally manipulated rather than emotionally moved. Therefore my principal advice is: don't watch this show if you're not feeling ready to let it lead you emotionally.
Aside from that, Shigatsu at times suffers from issues of odd comedic timing. While many of the funnier scenes are quite enjoyable the transition between drama and comedy can often be jarring and leave you confused with regards to the mood being developed.
Depending on how story-savvy you are, you might see the ending coming from a mile away. Whether that is a problem will depend entirely on you, and it partly links back to my initial remark: if you are willing to let the show lead you emotionally then knowing what is coming will not be a problem at all. Everyone knows how Oedipus Rex ends, yet we can all still enjoy it in spite of that. If you can see the end of Shigatsu coming, I suggest you try to go into the same sort of mindset you'd use for a classical tragedy, where knowing how it ends doesn't matter as much as seeing how it gets there.
All things considered, I'd Shigatsu is a good show and well worth your time. The protagonist undergoes an admirable amount of growth and the ending is nicely bittersweet, the kind that will have you crying over losses while simultaneously being happy about the obstacles overcome.
5
u/iswinterstillcoming Aug 29 '15
We're doing a WT for a popular series that just ended this year now? Pretty sure you guys are not getting this whole WT thing.
41
u/Revriley1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gallimaufry Aug 29 '15 edited Aug 29 '15
I mean, I disagree with a lot of things in your post, but since a lot of people genuinely loved this show and were emotionally moved by it
despite the pretty unbelievable and archetypal characters and obvious deathflags and more, I won't try and dissuade people from watching it.That being said:
By "deep hidden foreshadowing," did you mean "multiple deathflags so blatantly obvious they remove whatever emotional impact the ending might have had?"
By "well-rounded characters," did you mean "a cast that ranges from pretty okay characters (like Emi and Takeshi) to cringeworthy archetypes (Arima's childhood friends, but especially Watari, who almost experiences character growth but his last main scene destroys what little there was) to unbelievably infuriating (Kaori, who fits the MPDG trope perfectly and only really gains autonomy towards the second half)?"
By "masterful storytelling" did you mean "overdependence on poorly timed and overly long flashbacks that overstayed their welcome by episode four?" (Dare I mention the deathflags again?) or "incredibly unsubtle emotional manipulation?"
Where I shan't disagree with you is the visuals and the music. The rotoscope used for the performances was a bit obvious but prettily done. As for the music, the entire reason I decided to pick up the show while it was airing was for the classical music, since I really like classical music. So I'll vouch for that.
Again, if you're the type who wants to be swept up in a flurry of emotional sob stories and therefore willing to suspend your disbelief and/or willingly ignore that an anime is emotionally manipulating you with hundreds of scenes designed to scream at you "look! these are FEELS. This is emotionally SAD. Be SAD damn you" -- then sure, go ahead.
Ahem. To put it more gently, if you just want a pretty romance story and want to take it by its cover rather than thinking too deeply about it, go ahead. Lots of people loved this one, so chances are you might too. If you want classical music, sure, check it out. That's why I stuck with it, for the most part anyway--the music.
11
u/TR3BAstra :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AstralMUD Aug 29 '15
Whenever anyone mentions that this show is good there's typically a backlash documenting just how shitty this show actually is. I agree with everything and +1 for bravery
6
u/BueKojiro Aug 29 '15
Like others have said before, I'm not trying to be a Debbie Downer here, but I had a question or two I wanted to ask. People call this show a feel train, but to feel sadness at an unfortunate (putting it lightly) event that happens to a fictional character, one must feel connected to this character on a personal level. How does one connect personally to a character when said character does not act like a person?
My biggest issue here is with Kaori and Arima. Kaori doesn't do anything in this show. She gets angry at Arima, which somehow is supposed to translate into humor every single time no matter what the context or content, and she gets sad and thus makes us feel sad. But she has no personality, nothing to individuate as a singular entity in the show. She is a plot device that drives Arima to get in touch with his own love of music. And then there's the obvious spoiler alert toward the end of the show. Why do people become sad when something unfortunate happens to this character, when the type of person she is would never exist in real life? Rather, whoever she really is within the context of the show is not known to us, the viewer, because it was very obvious to me by the end of the show that I knew absolutely nothing about her. What makes her tick? What was her childhood like? Any difficult relationships in her past? What really really annoys her for no reason? What are her favorite things? What is she afraid of? Are there things in life she's uncertain about? Quite simple, we know next to nothing about the answers to those questions. That being said, why are we expected to cry over her as if it was our best friend or lover even, when the extent that we know about her is akin to a friend you met at a party and have seen at another 4 or 5 parties?
Secondly, Arima has a lot of interesting character development, but that's because we get to see a lot of what he's thinking due to his near perpetual monologues. That's my issue with it though. We are supposed to feel connected to him as the protagonist of the show and we are supposed to root for him and be sad when bad things happens to him. But again, I would argue that we know him about as well as we know Kaori by the content shown to us in the course of the show. Imagine if you met someone who barely ever talks and is really shy, but every single day they let you read a page out of their diary, in which most of the entries use mostly identical language as in the last one, often repeating phrases and entire concepts, and rife with meaningless and vague metaphors that are repeated often as well. Aside from the fact that one might be incredibly frustrated at the abysmal ability of self-expression and reflection this person has, what would you really learn about this person after 22 days of reading their diary and exchanging a few glances and a handful of conversations? Would you cry yourself to sleep if you found out that his mother used to beat him when he was a child or that something tragic happened to a girl he had a crush on? Because let's face it, these two did not love each other, they were in love with each other in a very limited way that relied only on vague romantic attraction that was based on love at first sight for both of them. Either way, what are we supposed to feel connected to, when again, we don't even know this person?
My point at the end of the day is that the crux of the show relies on the tragedy and beauty experienced through these two characters and their relationship, but nothing that happens to or between these characters is remotely accurate of either real-life people or a real-life relationship between any two people. So my question for those who felt so deeply moved by this show is, what is it about these characters' unrealistic and redundant behavior that causes you to feel as though they are real enough to cry over them?
Again, I know I'm coming off as a hater, but I really don't hate this show. I enjoyed some of it, but I just really don't understand when people talk about it as if it's the next Clannad.
2
u/blastcat4 :AP:https://www.anime-planet.com/users/uncaringbear Aug 29 '15
This show has been on my PTW list for ages, but as this thread shows, it seems to be very polarizing. I hesitate to watch it for this reason because viewer reactions remind me of those for Sakurasou, which was a major disappointment for me.
I enjoy dramas and romance as much as anyone else, so my question for those who are critical of this show: what shows in this genre do you think are great examples of drama/romance that's well-done and presented?
1
u/aKwin Aug 29 '15
I'm saving this for when I need to make recommendation for this show.
1
u/silkansatin Aug 29 '15 edited Aug 29 '15
Which examples of foreshadowing were masterful? I found the foreshadowing really obvious and didn't feel like foreshadowing at all.
[Spoiler] (/s "Can you please tell me how you related to a boy who was abused by his mom and a girl with a fatal disease?" ) Not trying to be mean or anything, but I didn't find anything about those kids relatable.
I found those quite annoying and unfunny, actually. I don't think the chibi comedy was a good thing.
0
u/Sokonomi Aug 29 '15
I almost got over it, OP.. now you ripped the wound again.. god dammit!
-4
u/[deleted] Aug 29 '15
[removed] — view removed comment