r/anime • u/FateSteelTaylor :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/FateSteelTaylor • Sep 29 '15
[WT!] - Gakkou Gurashi: A True Slice of Life
MAL | Crunchyroll | OP
“So promise me, no matter what, you’ll always keep smiling.”
Hey all! /u/FateSteelTaylor here with another [WT!] thread! You might know me from my previous editions on why you should watch Cardcaptor Sakura and Tamako Market/Love Story. Well, with all the fun I this past season, I figured I should complete the moe/feel good trifecta with Gakkou Gurashi! :)
Perhaps you were overwhelmed by the number of comments that the weekly threads were getting. Maybe you didn’t see the appeal of another Slice of Life moefest about a bunch of girls in a school club. And then there’s always the possibility that you were too busy with, wait for it, real life, and so you put this past season on hold?
Okay, the last one might be pushing it. (Fu fu fu…)
Still, if you were at all wondering what the hype was about and were on the fence about picking up this wonderful show, put on your cat-eared hats, grab some canned beef, and hold on tight to your totally-not-Stephen-King novels, because we genki desu in here!
Twitter Pitch (TL;DR)
Gakkou Gurashi is about four girls (and a dog and teacher!) going about their everyday school lives, but with something more weighing heavy on their minds.
More than Moe
We see a lot of words thrown around when talking about anime these days: moe, slice of life, deconstruction, “a slipshod advertisement for the source material,” to list a few. These labels and others have been bandied about and affixed to shows so often that the meaning behind them has almost disappeared, becoming a sort of “one size fits all” category to bring on lazy analysis. But what does it mean to be moe? What is a Slice of Life? And why is the crown guilty, anyway?
All great questions, but since we only have so much time, let’s get to the important one. Slice of Life is a very broad term, but I think the heart of the genre is this: if you took a peek into the pages of someone’s life story, any person at all, what would you see? How would they react to the everyday ups and downs? It’s in how Gakkou Gurashi has these girls handle the things that come their way that sets it apart from the rest of the pack.
Like many of its predecessors, Gakkou Gurashi takes place in a high school setting, something we’re all rather familiar with. We are introduced to four girls (Takeya Yuki, Ebisuzawa Kurumi, Wakasa Yuri aka Rii-san/-chan, and Naoki Miki aka Mii-kun), all of whom are pretty ordinary… well, for anime anyway. Yet what makes Gakkou Gurashi special is the way it places them in certain situations and allows us to see just how these girls (and perhaps, the viewer) would respond. There is a moment when the group is out at the mall shopping and trying out clothes, and Kurumi asks Rii-chan why they’re doing this. It might feel somewhat directed at the viewers and the production team as well; shopping episodes are a staple in the genre, why should Gakkou Gurashi indulge in one as well? Rii-chan simply smiles and says, “We are girls, after all.”
These girls aren’t flying around, they don’t have esper abilities, and they surely aren’t exceptionally good at anything except being exceptionally normal. They handle situations that come in ways that seem real, whether it’s with a tear and a hug or a toothy grin. It’s about them, and what they decide to do. This is their life, this is their story.
Character Study
With any show that’s considered Slice of Life, the characters are the lifeblood and what really make or break it. And for Gakkou Gurashi, this is exactly what it does so well. Each one of the main girls is different in their own way, and even the side characters have meaningful arcs and unforgettable.
Yuki is the star of the show. She’s a third-year in high school, but even with graduation on the horizon, all she can think about is how much she loves everything as it is. And to be fair, what’s not to like about it? Sure she struggles a little bit in school (and needs to stop dozing off in class!), but she is on great terms with her teachers and her classmates are so friendly and close with her. But the biggest joy in her life has to come from the School Living Club, the organization that she and the other three girls are a part of. They’re students who have pledged to be active citizens in the community, who take care of the functions and keep the school going. Of course, this also means they’re allowed to have their own little adventures, from tests of courage at night to camping trips! Yuki is always the one brainstorming for more fun activities for everyone, to lift their spirits and keep them from the everyday grind of school.
Rii-san is the girl in charge. She cooks for the group, and makes sure everyone’s in line and doesn’t skip their duties (by the way, whose turn was it today to feed Taroumaru, the club’s dog?). Kind and caring, she helps out mostly with the agriculture club but is always willing to recruit others and bring them into their small but loving community. Kurumi is the go-getter of the group, running around and most likely to be caught up in Yuki’s antics. But despite her tough exterior, she’s very vulnerable, and her feelings for a senpai are one of the most emotionally packed moments of the show. As for Mii-kun… well, she has her reservations for the other members of the group, and she’d rather have her nose stuck in a book, but she really does care for Yuki and Taroumaru and the others.
As for Taroumaru: He’s a very loyal (and smart!) puppy! Almost too smart sometimes. How many dogs do you know that can open a classroom door?? Silly Taroumaru. But he’s the mascot of the School-Living club, and a real joy to have!
Extra Ex
Um, /u/FateSteelTaylor?
Yes?
You, uh, you forgot someone…
Yes you did! You know, the teacher…?
Who?
That’s not a nice thing to say!!
Haha, just kidding!! <3
Megu-nee Sakura-sensei the lovable and wonderful teacher for Yuki and the advisor of the School-Living club. And although she has a small presence and gets overlooked at times (gomin!!), Megu-nee really champions what the club stands for.
Extra Extra!
For me, a show reaches “masterpiece” status once it demonstrates it takes full advantage of everything anime has to offer. From cinematography to music to writing and character dynamics, it has to hit all of the right notes and really bring out all of the potential within.
Gakkou Gurashi does just that. The OP is catchy as hell, and gives us a great glimpse of what the show is really about: just how happy everyone is to be at the school, to be surrounded by friends. The camerawork, especially for a Slice of Life series, is exquisite. They do a great job of showing, not telling, allowing the audience to understand bit by bit the struggle that each of these girls holds internally. From slow pans to off-beat angles, the viewer is allowed to process the information at their own pace, but also makes a rewatch almost necessary to get back and pick up on all the little details that pop up. And the music… it really is the crowning feature, with insert songs coming in at the right times not to manipulate the viewer into feeling something, but to enhance their response to the material.
And combined with the writing, the show really takes full advantage of the visual medium and everything it entrails. You can see the steps that the characters take in their development bit by bit, so that by the end, they have come so far and yet you hardly notice it week to week. Nothing is ever wasted; every little moment that is brought up gets some sort of play later on, with no detail left unused. And when you have so many different characters, writers need to make sure that the relationships work out. Character A won’t act the same around Character B as they do Character C, nor would it be the same when Character B and Character C are there. This is a flaw that many shows tend to have, but Gakkou Gurashi avoids this, and it lends itself to a very credible and consistent storyline. With a slice of life, you really have to be able to trust that the characters are, well, staying in character. That’s never a concern with Gakkou Gurashi, as everything goes at its own pace, at its own time.
The Final Points
Watch Gakkou Gurashi if you wonder what drives humans to come together, to push each other away. Watch Gakkou Gurashi if you ever ask yourself, “You know, how would I actually react in that situation?” Because this show challenges the viewers, the characters, the writers, everyone to answer the question of what it really means to be human, what it really means to be alive.
68
u/Lewdist_Beach Sep 29 '15
I cannot tell if this is a typo or intentional...
Great [WT!] though!
79
u/MisterFleur :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MisterFleur Sep 29 '15
High quality
baitpost27
u/LordTakuro :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/LordTakuro Sep 29 '15
I've been waiting for this WT, I think you mentioned it in the last episode discussion thread, and it's exactly as I would have expected. GG Spoilers I salute you
88
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
Can you not
8
u/CakeBoss16 Sep 30 '15
Just want to comment on how fantastically written this is. It's hilarious for those who get the references (if you don't watch it). Also this is a WT thread not a review one so sharing your opinion on its quality seems unnecessary.
4
u/Ozbal42 Sep 30 '15
ive bit the bait.
30
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
I'm going to offer a counter opinion, hopefully it doesn't get downvoted because people disagree so it might actually spark an interesting discussion, but I know this might be expecting too much.
The show sucked, real bad. I ended up rating it 4/10.
To start things off, the overly cutesy\moe style is obnoxious as all hell, I get they really wanted to show this huge difference between the characters and the outside world but it came off as annoying.
The characters themselves had literally no depth whatsoever, after 12 episodes I couldn't give a damn about any of them nor can I see why anyone who isn't obsessed with the moe part would.
They don't ever experience any sort of development except towards the very end, and their personalities are just boring walking moe blobs.
What was the point of the show? it seemed like its focus was to capture the moe loving audience and people who love "shock" value with really lame and predictable twists.
The premise of the show is basically "Moe & Shocking", and honestly I would only recommend it to people who care little for depth, can suffer through the obnoxious characters, and are actually into this moe crap cause this is 80% of what the show is about, the rest is just insanely boring and shallow.
I would go into further detail, but seeing as this is a [WT] thread, I wouldn't spoil too much (the plot is as thin as a toothpick, so even saying little might as well reveal everything except for the terrible twists).
tl;dr - its a fairly bad show, I fell for the hype and stuck with it hoping it'll get better, my god it didn't.
16
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
Fuck this ridiculous circlejerk. I understand that people want to keep the true nature of Gakkou Gurashi as a surprise for the people who haven't watched it yet, a bit like we want to keep spoiler in The Tatami Galaxy a secret, but making a WT thread that tiptoes around what you actually want to say is just daft. The things that you're saying might be true, but lying by omission to such a huge extent isn't going to attract any of the people who actually want to watch the kind of show that Gakkou Gurashi is. Not to mention your post is filled with in-jokes for the people who have seen the anime that clearly are not going to be remotely beneficial to your supposed target audience.
For anyone who wants an actual idea of what Gakkou Gurashi is like, it's a not a spoiler slice of life anime. All I'm gonna say. If you're interested, you're interested. It's not like Gakkou Gurashi is the first anime to do what it did anyway.
2
u/Anime-Summit :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kristallnachte Sep 30 '15
"Gomin"? You mean "Gomen"?
72
u/Vaxivop https://anilist.co/user/vaxivop Sep 29 '15
He's finally lost it. O7, may you rest in piece.
30
u/JuanDomingoPeron :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/locomania21 Sep 30 '15
:))) Great read
20
u/Ozbal42 Sep 30 '15
ok, ill binge the whole thing tomorrow and come back with my thoughts i-know-of-the-bait...kinda
19
u/Jakinzify Sep 29 '15
yea cute girls doing cute things I love that
14
u/lytelovespie :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Janux7 Sep 30 '15
You forgot Shovel-kun
7
u/DdraigtheKid :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/justincause Sep 30 '15
Hm. I think I can agree with this [WT!] and it is (as always) very well written. I'm always left wondering how you get all the Creativity to punch out such Quality Content.
10
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
Man, you are hella dedicated. I've been following you for all of GG and it's been wild.
8
u/randCN Sep 29 '15
I like it.
2
u/Awisemanoncsaid Sep 30 '15
I finished this just this afternoon, and it gets my vote to watch.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '15
I was hoping that this post would get darker and creepier as it went on
2
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '15
im reading this while listening to cowboy bebop looped opening. life is great
-7
u/freakazoidspartan257 Sep 30 '15
Can we ban [WT!]'s until 3 months after the show airs? I think these shows would be best to watch in that 2-3 week gap before the next season starts. It's more likely to get watched after sometime has passed since circlejerks on shows linger well after it just airs.
-3
u/FemmaMemetale Sep 30 '15
Or just read the manga, because the dog actively ruins the characterization of both Yuki and Miki.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 30 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 29 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment