r/anime • u/awerture :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/awerture • Oct 04 '15
[WT!] Aoi Hana aka Sweet Blue Flowers - realistic yuri anime that respects its audience
Why should you watch this?
Aoi Hana is 11-episodes anime adapted from the manga created by author of Hourou Musuko (WT! thread). So even if at first glance it looks like simple high-school/SoL romance, it is something more than that. It is series which is gravely serious about what it means to experience adolescent love - you won't find almost any comedy here. It's oriented entirely on emotions caused by small meaningful events and main characters' quest on establishing meaningful links to others.
What makes their struggle complicated is the fact these characters desire someone of the same sex. As stated in the title, Aoi Hana is yuri anime. But it's not exactly like most yuri anime - characters live in a world resembling our own, where homoerotic relationship is an exception, not the norm. And this has consequences they must face - not lethal discrimination or public outcries of disgust (Japan is a civilized nation, after all) but the simple fact in the country of Class-S relationships their affections aren't treated seriously. They are not treated seriously by artists who write stories about them and they are looked down upon by society in general. What's more and absolutely the worst same sex pairings may not be treated seriously also by the very people engaged in them.
Protagonist of the show, 16-years old Fumi Manjoume finds herself in such a world. She begins her journey with a goal of finding happiness and staying true to herself. It won't be always easy for her - after all, in realistic world (or one of the closest thing to 'realistic' anime has) people are fundamentally selfish beings.
The narrative is slow-paced and told mostly in a subtle way - it relies mainly on "showing, not telling". As a result one must pay attention to what is happening - many things are told in passing, there are many cuts, many things are left implied - e. g. first episode is heart-crushing BANG! even on a surface level, but part of it is told through such small clues I've realized its full meaning only after rewatch.
Art style is similarly toned-down - watercolors, round faces and lighten up contours make it look unique and very pleasing. And it fits the above style of storytelling very well - everything about the show has the aura of quiet melancholy and elusive sadness.
On an unrelated note Aoi Hana doesn't contain any fanservice and is free of yuri-baiting. Also it's not the type of anime in which the biggest problem of characters is "how to confess to their beloved". On the contrary, some girls in the show are determined enough to actually go for their crushes almost immediately. It's really a breath of fresh air in the medium.
I realize for many of people the above description may not sound appealing - in such case it means that it probably isn't the show for them. But if somehow it sounds tempting, watch it immediately.
This is also one of the shows you should try to watch if you liked White Album 2.
Warning
I'd consider this anime a great romance, if not one gigantic flaw. It's incomplete - it isn't full adaptation of manga. Theoretically there was possibility to tell even this incomplete story in a more conclusive way, but anime through its pacing, choice of opening and structure clearly suggests there is more to come. It may leave the audience disappointed and encourages strongly to read the manga.
That saying ending is far from being wholesomely inconclusive. It wraps up significant part of the plot, so it's marginally possible to leave the story at the final episode.
TL;DR - for everyone
Even if it's only kind of broken bird, Aoi Hana is a rare breed of serious contemplative romance with beautiful visuals and haunting emotional moments. Watch it, particularly if you want romance series from the more realistic side of the genre.
TL;DR - for yuri fans
You are waiting for Girl Friends adaptation? You can make waiting more pleasant - watch Aoi Hana. Given the quantity of interesting shows you don't have much choice anyway.
5
u/UnavailableUsername_ Oct 04 '15
Is it a "gigantic flaw" if its a common trait on anime?
I mean, find an anime with a complete adaptation is not exactly common.
2
u/singe8 Oct 05 '15
I watched it a few weeks ago, and it was one of the most mediocre anime I've ever seen, and I kind of hated how disappointing it was. The main character was completely passive, and it was hard to care about her, when she didn't care for herself. She would've been fine with anyone. The anime is incredibly slow, and the way it turns out makes the entire thing feel a pointless prelude to the real story, which never truly began. Spoilers.. Nothing more than a cheap commercial.
As for how realistic it was, I don't know. Like, I'd imagine unrequited love is more prevalent among the LGBT community, but at the same time, it's never that way in the anime. Spoilers. The drama it had was never anything more than simple love triangles, and there weren't many emotional moments. I have no idea what you mean when you say the first episode was a "heart-crushing BANG". There wasn't really an emotional focus throughout the anime, and I came away with the anime feeling thoroughly underwhelmed. Things happened and then it was over, which is the worst thing I can say about an anime.
I did appreciate that it wasn't just fanservice. That puts it miles ahead of Yuri Yuri and Sakura Kiss, in my opinion. And I did like the anime's focus on self discovery (though not as much as I would've wanted). The opening was also really good It just wasn't a good anime, and I still have yet to see a good yuri anime. Citrus might be that. This wasn't.
Mari Okada did the series composition and script for Hourou Musuko, and I think that anime turned out better as a result, though it's still not what I want out of an anime dealing with LGBT issues.
26
u/[deleted] Oct 04 '15
For a second here i read it as "Ano Hana" followed by "realistic yuri" and was like
No.. no no no thats nooooooot it at all!
6
u/SinnermightyBL :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sinnermighty Oct 04 '15
After finishing it, I really suggest others to read the manga after the anime too! I'm only a few chapters in past the anime after just recently watching it and it's great.
6
u/Tentaculat :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Tentaculat Oct 04 '15
Aoi Hana is my favourite yuri show and one of my favourite romance too. It handles the yuri relationships in a way that feels both natural and mature without turning it into fanservice.
The colors and character design fit perfectly with the tone the show is going for and is very easy to relate to the character's struggle to find their identity.
Also, random irrelevant trivia, Ikuhara did the storyboard for it ( which doesn't really matter but if it gets you to watch the show then I'll mention it... whatever )
1
u/[deleted] Oct 05 '15
I liked where the anime ended way better than where the manga continued on.
2
u/korisc2 :K:https://kitsu.io/users/kori Oct 05 '15
I'm not sure if this actually helps anyone here considering either show get barely any attention, but Aoi Hana was written buy the same Mangaka as Wandering Son! She is bloody brilliant
1
u/dabritian :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/dabritian Oct 04 '15
I have a question: I have read the full manga, at what point does the show end on?