r/anime • u/kaverik :Ef::Eh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kaverik • Nov 25 '15
[WT!] Mawaru Penguindrum
"I hate the word "fate." Birth, encounters, partings, success and failures, fortune and misfortunes in life. If our lives are already set in stone by fate, then why are we even born? There are those born to wealthy families, those born to beautiful mothers, and those born into the middle of war or poverty. If that's all caused by fate, then God is incredibly unfair and cruel. Because, ever since that day, none of us had a future and the only certain thing was that we wouldn't amount to anything..."
- Shouma Takakura, episode 1.
Steins;Gate, Fate/Zero, Usagi Drop, Mirai Nikki, Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica, Anohana, Ao no Exorcist, Hanasaku Iroha, Gosick, Nichijou... What do these such different anime have in common? First of all, they were released in 2011. Indeed, it was probably the most productive and great anime years recently. Many diverse and interesting shows appeared that time. However, one of the titles released in 2011 was met with rather timid praise not only because the year was so tightly packed, but also thanks to its complexity and weirdness. This anime mainly showed up in blogs with huge wall of text explaining in detail every event, symbol and character appearance. Slowly but surely this anime started to get wider and wider acclaim, and more and more people gave it a chance, often being satisfied by the result. Nowadays many people have Mawaru Penguindrum in their "plan to watch list", or at least heard about this anime once. Still, not everyone knows why exactly it's considered to be such a great series and what makes it stand out from the other seemingly identical anime out there.
So what is Mawaru Penguindrum, anyway?
Mawaru Penguindrum (Spinning Penguindrum, or simply Penguindrum) is an anime-original series released in Summer 2011. It was directed and co-written by Kunihiko Ikuhara, famous for his work on Revolutionary Girl Utena and later Yuri Kuma Arashi, and animated by Brains Base (Baccano!, Durarara!!, Oregairu S1).
The story follows the three siblings of the Takakura family: twin brothers Kanba and Shouma, and their little terminally ill sister Himari. Their parents are gone, and they live in a small bungalow alone. Poor Himari dies during a trip to the aquarium in Ikebukuro; while Kanba and Shouma grieve over her death, she is suddenly brought back to life by a mysterious entity (one who apparently resides in a souvenir hat purchased at the same aquarium) who offers them a chance to extend Himari's life for a price: to bring her something called "Penguindrum." The brothers are confused about this task as much as you do reading these lines.
At the same time, they receive three mysterious penguins who understand the orders of the Takakura siblings. The only clue given to them by the Penguin Hat is to follow a certain Ringo Oginome, a girl the same age as the boys who might possess (or at least know something about) that odd "Penguindrum".
I got that this anime is very weird, but why should I watch it?
Well, let's put it straight - Mawaru Penguindrum is a very bizarre show with a lot of things that you should keep in mind or simply tolerate. Plot is one of them. Prepare yourself to be confused. And yes, it's misleading. And yes, it's hard to perceive if you don't pay attention to it. It starts off as weird, and becomes only weirder later on, turning into absolute mind screw at the end. However, if you still follow the plot closely, try to remember previous events and characters' motivations you will be rewarded with astonishing story that is hard to compare to anything else. Every event, every flashback, every little detail falls into one big picture that reveals the complcated fate of Takakura siblings, their struggles and their ultimate destination. By its extraordinary presentation, Mawaru Penguindrum dares to be blunt and different from the medium. It never tells something explicitly, and it doesn't treat you like a child - instead, it tries hard to make you think, and draw your own conclusions. Mawaru Penguindrum respects your intelligence (something that most anime usually refuse to do), challenging it in a good way.
This plot complexity is not in vain, and goes hand in hand with different themes, implemented by rich usage of symbolism. Japanese culture has special attitude towards the word "fate" - it is the word that defines mysterious nature of Japan, their rich culture and famous history. It's the word that could be found in their religion, literature and the very way of life of every Japanese person. Mawaru Penguindrum touches the topic of "fate" with very interesting, unusual angle - it incorporates ideas of classic Japanese novel Night on the Galactic Railroad, while also presenting it in a different light - it is not a straight up retelling, but rather major influence that ties the story together. If it was not enough, Mawaru Penguindrum also touches the problem of contemporary Japanese society, masterfully pointing out its flaws and the growth of young generation's despair. Here, the anime was influenced by famous author Haruki Murakami, but once again - it was not just an adaptation of his work, but mostly re-examination of his ideas. With such rich background, Ikuhara with his distinctive masterful presentation was able to tell resonating story about fate, punishment and... love.
Ultimately, of course, almost every anime is about love, resolve and determination. However, Mawaru Penguindrum takes this notion to the whole new height. It tells love story without even mentioning it, and it's for sure not your ordinary story about love between man and woman. It's a story about family, about struggling to get across your feelings, about painful existence when you're all alone. Mawaru Penguindrum doesn't need to show it explicitly, with pointless drama and over-explaining - it's above it. What you have instead is group of characters regretting their old mistakes, trying to atone for their past, and not hurting the loved ones. Is it possible to save your love and yourself, when your opponent is no less than fate? Don't haste with your answers - Mawaru Penguindrum is not that simple, and it does give you a lot of food for thought after final credits.
Imagine!
Now you're probably wondering, how everything looks and presented to us. Well, it's absolutely gorgeous. The colors are vivid and bright, character designs are remarkable and distinctive, animation is also quite nice. However, even here you should make a note - often enough in Mawaru Penguindrum the boundary between real world and imagery is non-existent, and the show ends up being surreal, and sometimes simply absurd. It's just the way how Ikuhara makes his anime - with heavy usage of repetition, wild colors and symbolism. Speaking of the latter - yes, there are lots of symbols in the show, but they all make sense, and even then they are all rather simple to interpret. Still, don't feel ashamed if you did not understand something, or if it flew over your head - don't hesitate to use google or search option on reddit - you'll find out all the needed answers. I also didn't figure out all plot points after completing the show, and only after a bit of research and rewatching several scenes I got everything. It's normal - Ikuhara's anime are meant to be watched (and rewatched!) this way.
Even if it's sometimes difficult "to get" the anime, Mawaru Penguindrum is extremely enjoyable to watch. Partially it's achieved by aforementioned presentation, and partially by incredible cast of characters and their certain quirks. Characters are memorable and easy to distinguish, with some of them having catch-phrases that will be stuck in your mind long after finishing the anime. And, of course, the penguins. People still argue about their true nature and purpose in the show, but everyone agrees on one point - they are super adorable. Their presence makes every scene cute, they lighten up the darkest parts of the anime, preventing it from becoming overdramatic. If there is a part where Mawaru Penguindrum truly excels at, it should be perfect balance between light and funny comedy and serious, mature drama. Comedic elements are very well placed and never ruin the mood of some heavy scene. And the whole anime, starting as upbeat and a bit odd adventure (so you could grow attached to the characters), later on turns into dark and even grotesque story.
Finally, it would be crime not to mention outstanding OST. It varies from jazzy tracks to electronic, from faster pieces to more melancholic ones. It also has two stunning OPs performed by Etsuko Yakushimaru (first and second), myriad of EDs (ten, to be exact - here's the link to the first one). Also, it has the greatest insert song ever, or at least one of the most addictive ones in anime.
Conclusion
So eventually, what is this anime, and will other directors try to create their own version of "Mawaru Penguindrum, but better"? Hardly. While impact of Mawaru Penguindrum might last long, it did not (and would not) spawn the new generation of anime. No one would challenge Ikuhara on his own field of surreal stories full of symbolism, deceivingly bright picture, yuri undertones and NGE-like endings. He's the master of his own genre, he creates truly unique stories that are impossible to replicate. He spent more than 10 years to come up with Mawaru Penguindrum, and the result was ultimately worth it.
What else do I have to say?
Let's Initiate the Survival Strategy!
"I love the word 'fate'. Because, you know how they talk about 'fated encounters'? A single encounter can completely change your life. Such special encounters are not just coincidences. They're definitely... fate. Of course, life is not all happy encounters. There are many painful, sad, moments. It's hard to accept that misfortunes beyond your control are fate. But this is what I think: sad and painful things definitely happen for a reason. Nothing in this world is pointless."
- Ringo Oginome, episode 2.
20
u/Mabroon :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Mabroon Nov 25 '15
Great WT! In fact, I actually finished this show yesterday, so seeing this today is like...
fate
But the show was absolutely incredible, and I'm actually still trying to puzzle together the ending...
All the characters were great and grew on me. Music was fantastic and especially love the first OP!
18
u/keokl :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/keokl Nov 25 '15
I like you OP. I always thought about making a WT! on this show but never thought I'd do it justice. You did pretty well here and I applaud you friend.
I may or may not be writing a Kyousougiga WT atm..
3
u/kaverik :Ef::Eh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kaverik Nov 25 '15
As always, any feedback and criticism are welcome. It's an improved version of my previous thread (which left much to be desired), and on the contrast with FLCL and Space Dandy attempts, I tried not to overburden the thread with images and make it as clean as possible. Hope it doesn't look too dry now. Let me know what you think, and thanks for reading!
2
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '15
Ikuhara is the man! I watched Penguindrum right after Utena, which are still two of my absolute favorites. I still have Yuri Kuma Arashi to watch, I hope I like it as much as his other works. Good write up OP!
2
u/Soupkitten https://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Nov 25 '15
I watched Tatami Galaxy recently and loved it. Would that mean this anime is instantly amazing to me?
24
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Nov 25 '15
As someone who doesn't watch the weird ones (I go out of my way to stay away from them) this was still a very fun watch! So if you're like me and scared to try it don't be since it's one heck of a ride :)
SEIZON SENRYAKU!!
2
u/wqnm :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/standish84 Nov 25 '15 edited Nov 25 '15
I really liked this show. That said, you have very diplomatically described the convoluted nature of the plot. The blunt truth is, for any potential first time watchers out there, that the show turns into an incomprehensible mess. I'd say it's a mess in the best way possible, because I still thoroughly enjoyed it all the way through and would definitely recommend it. Just don't expect a Miller's Crossing type of complex plot, where if you pay attention you might understand what's happening in the final act. It gets REALLY heavy in the abstract symbolism and metaphorical department, especially near the end. It almost felt like every time it was heading for some kind of reveal or explanation that would finally piece things together, the show would just double down on the abstract weird stuff, and leave you going "wait, what?", until eventually it ends. One crucial piece of info thing that kinda puts it all together (emphasis on "kinda") isn't revealed until near the very end; there's no way to "piece it all together" before that. My only other major complaint is that I felt the penguins, as the primarily comic relief, were pretty unnecessary and felt really out of place. I disagree with your assessment that they help keep the balance in tone. More often than not, for me at least, they distracted from and lessened the scenes they invaded. It's not a huge deal in the grand scheme of things though. Still an excellent and incredibly unique show.
Also, just a small thing I'd add, because you pretty much covered everything, is that I really liked the sister's voice actress. I was disappointed to see she hasn't done much else. She's got a very unique voice.
5
u/Fomalhaut-b Nov 26 '15
I've been meaning to watch Penguindrum ever since I saw I Will Die For You AMV (Anime Boston 2013 Drama Finalist) which probably has spoilers for the whole series. It looks incredible.
4
u/LoonyMoonie :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kasumicc Nov 25 '15
I was fortunate enough to catch Penguindrum as it was airing; it turned into an addiction, one of the biggest I've had in recent years. Having to wait for the next episode ended being hard to bear.
It is a mess, no doubt about that. Especially the early episodes, which are as weird as you can imagine, and it really gives you the impression that it's going literally nowhere. But it's an entertaining mess, nevertheless. When drama started to make its way in, it became one hell of a ride. It was my anime of the year, back in 2011, and it's always nice seeing it getting more recognition.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '15
Thank you for doing the anime justice!
How do you feel about Utena? I think a WT for it by you would be very convincing and help spread the good word!
1
u/andehh_ https://anilist.co/user/Andehh Nov 25 '15
Brilliant WT!, brilliant series. I don't think any show could be absolutely perfect but I strongly believe that Penguindrum is the closest an anime will ever get. Alas, I haven't watched Utena yet but it doesn't have penguins (^:
I knew you'd put Ringo's fate quote at the end after opening with Shouma's; they're my favourite pair of quotes. (btw you wrote Kanba instead of Shouma. Kanba says something different at the end of ep1)
1
u/scheranadi Nov 26 '15 edited Nov 26 '15
I generally point to the first episode of Penguindrim when attempting to convince anime "haters" that the formal principles found in film - cinematography, sound design, narrative pacing, etc - are well and alive in anime. It's seriously a great first episode. I've seen it over twenty times, and I still love it. Great series as well
3
u/wavyhairedsamurai Nov 25 '15
I can attest to how good Penguindrum is, watched it on a whim after hearing the good things about it and I was blown away. Absolutely fantastic show, and personally, I think the less you know about it (other than that its director is an odd fellow) the better the experience will be.
5
u/EnderPete :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/EnderPete Nov 25 '15
This is 100% objective best anime ever fight me.
So you're doing yourself a favor by watching it.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '15
The first time I watched this show, I didn't really enjoy it at all. Currently going through a rewatch of it, halfway through at the moment. Enjoying it much more than the first time, also, those penguins are so damn cute!
I think it's a very unique show, and definitely one worth watching.
Gj on the write-up :)
2
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15
my favorite show, at the moment.... you should watch it, if you haven't.
2
u/ClearandSweet :K:https://kitsu.io/users/clearandsweet Nov 26 '15
Wonderful post and a great representation of the series. Penguindrum is one of the masterpieces that gets lost the endless popularity of ecchi and action in the medium.
Beware though: you cannot passively consume this show. It forces you to consider themes and character decisions.
If you'd like to explore Penguindrum further in the further depth that it demands, I wrote quite a bit about the show's initial themes and authorial trackrecord on /r/trueanime some time ago.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15
My only 10/10.
Really love this one.
2
u/shadowswalking :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ShadowsWalking6 Nov 26 '15
2
u/LeeCarvallo Nov 26 '15
Top 5 for me certainly. The 2nd OP chimes are my discreet anime ringtone (and the guitar riff of the flcl ending is my text tone so good taste OP)
This was the first show I watched where I couldn't place my finger on why I enjoyed it so much. This summary sort of helps me rationalize that feeling.
1
u/BanishedLink :AP:https://www.anime-planet.com/users/BanishedLink Nov 26 '15
Pretty good write up for a pretty good show. I started watching and finished everything Ikuhara right around when I first watched Yuri Kuma when it was airing minus Adolescence of Utena. Even though it's my least favorite Ikuhara show I still really enjoyed Penguindrum.
1
u/The-Sublimer-One :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/The-Sublimer-One Nov 26 '15
TL;DR
But, seriously, this show kicks ass. As do all of Ikuhara's shows. Be sure to give them all a watch!
1
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15
watching this anime
9/10 anime! top tier!
they cut the transformation scene with the best song of the series
8/10 anime! it was good and all but I've seen better.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15
I'm in the 4th episode and I got 2 predictions: either, I'll be dead by the end of this or with my mind blown.
Also the opening is too good.
1
u/randylek :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/randylek Nov 26 '15
this was the first anime i ever went out of my way (aka not on tv eng dub dragonball z/naruto etc) to watch, and i hated it at first but back then i hated all anime, now im a filthy weeb and i think it is amazing
1
u/Mnemniopsis Nov 26 '15
10/10 show please watch
1
u/Locketpanda Nov 26 '15
Only Anime able to question my number one being TTGL, and I'm a freaking explosion loving dinosaur with a soft spot for GAR...And cute girls doing cute things after I come home from work, but that's beyond the point.
I amply recommend this show as long as I confirmed you have a sliver of taste for art in your body.
1
u/rubyleehs Nov 26 '15 edited Nov 26 '15
FINALLY SOMEONE RECOMMENDS MAWARU PENGUINDRUM. YAY.
10/10
Thank you for doing this anime justice /u/kaverik
1
u/PinguruLee :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pinguru Nov 26 '15
Penguins. All you need to watch.
1
u/PinguruLee :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pinguru Nov 26 '15
peeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeenguuuuuuuinsssssssssandbears
1
u/morzinbo https://anilist.co/user/morzinbo Nov 26 '15
I just started watching this a few days ago and it's been a pretty wild and strange trip! Hoping to finish it soon!
1
u/FindxThexWay Nov 26 '15
One of the top five shows in this decade that have advanced the medium. Personally, I enjoyed most aspects of this show from character design, soundtrack, plot, animation, and dialogue: so much of it can be considered good to great.
1
u/lftenjamin :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/lftenjamin Nov 26 '15
It's a show in my personal top 5.
I love every moment from this show.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 26 '15 edited Nov 26 '15
The only reason why I haven't watched this yet, is because I prolly have to watch it a second time before I'll fully grasp it. And with 60 entries currently in line, I have no time to rewatch. And I don't like to finish a show without fully understanding it :( but I'll watch it for sure, someday. Certain links in the comments sure are helpful in further understanding the anime after completion.
1
u/torimatsuko Jan 02 '16 edited Jan 02 '16
Nornir I think was never out of my mind. I knew that It was Mawaru Penguindrum, because of the first line of the song.
I have actually watched this anime back in '10 but I got
weirdedby it and I wasn't into deeeeeeeep and complicated anime that time, and frankly I didn't understand what was going on thus I stopped watching it.But this post made me watch Mawaru again so, kudos for you OP!
And probably gonna binge-watch it today. :)
1
u/tj_odee May 20 '16
/u/imnublet
1
u/[deleted] Nov 25 '15 edited Nov 25 '15
The first time I tried watching this show, I hated it. And then I tried again, and it became my absolute favorite! I don't think any other show can take that spot.
My favorite part of the show is how the characters are done. Pretty much all of them, even the side characters, get a great amount of development. They all change, have great explanations for their changes, have interesting pasts, and are just very unique. It's definitely one of the most psychological shows I've watched, despite not looking like one at all.
Now if you'll excuse I'll start rewatching Penguindrum (your post made me want to watch it again) and continue Revolutionary Girl Utena. Great post OP (and great taste. I agree with way too many scores on your list)
0
u/Wearon :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Wearon Nov 26 '15
I guess I'm one of the few people who don't like Penguindrum. I dropped it after 8 episodes because the only thing I could see was Spoiler Every symbolism up to this point probably flew over my head.
I don't think people are wrong to like this anime I just don't get it.