"I didn't think it was possible for opinions to be objectively wrong, but here we are."
Seriously though, Katanagatari's final episode wraps the story up better than most other shows out there, and better than a lot of other stories regardless of the medium. It's really a masterpiece, and hands-down one of my favorite shows.
The only reason I think it fits for Katanagatari is because the theme of the show is explicitly expressed throughout the series, and you'd have to not be paying attention at all to miss it.
I finished this show last week. That ending left me speechless. The show is masterpiece, nothing less than a 10/10 from me. The character designs, as you say, are brilliant, probably my favourite character designs in any anime. In terms of development, characters that appear in only one 50 minute episode of this show feel deeper and more fleshed out than a lot of characters in 25+ episode shows.
Very nice effort! The show shows(duh) that Isin is capable to write coherent stories(not that the lack is a bad thing for Monogatari but y'know). It's definitely worth a watch.
Thank you for the feedback! I agree, the Maniwani(don't tnink they need a spoiler tag, honestly, the first sword wielder is one.) are all amazingly unique and cool.
I think I mean something more towards "focused"(if that makes more sense for you)? Because the show is jumping from character arc to character arc with a bunch of different ideas about identity, humanity and human connection.
That is one of the greatest I was dying of laughter when Togame and Shichika were reminiscing about how great a fight it was at the end of the episode.
Hold up, what? What trailer/preview? I watched the show a long time ago, and it's probably time for a rewatch of my favorite series, but what preview? If you could link it that would be great. If it was one of the Episode Previews at the end of an episode, what episode? I'd really like to go back and watch that to understand what the troll was.
I have 5 episodes to go and unless the ending is really as ridiculously outstanding as everyone here says, this alone makes sure I'm not giving it a 10/10. Fuck that, the hype was built up so well and then we got that. Unforgivable!
I kidnapped my non-anime friend and made him watch it. He was hooked by episode 2 and speechless by the end.
I adore this show. I cannot express how the first watch of this made me feel. I had a zero-sleep rant about it after I had finished it for the 3rd time in a row. Never has a show made me want to do that before.
oh same author? and it seems more action oriented. alright, your WT! worked, after Monogatari series (im watching second season right now) i will watch this
Not one of my overall favorites (although it comes close), but definitely one of my favorites just in terms of visual style/presentation.
Definitely a series that left me with some feels. I had mostly forgotten about them, but man did they ever come back hard when I read your Togame quote.
Nice! This reminds me I should get to rewatch it myself, been a while since I last saw it. It's cool that it reminded you of S&W, I felt the same way. I love these kind of interactions between a male and female like in Katanagatari, Monogatari series and S&W.
It just feels so much more realistic, I think. People will joke and bicker at each other and stuff. I don't like some of the "perfect" relationships in some other anime; they just seem too perfect, to the point of being unrealistic.
I was in the middle of watching this series and really enjoying it, but the site I was using to stream it no longer has it. Any viewing suggestions of places it is available in 720p?
Not really. The ninjas become laughably incompetent, you get to meet the MC's edgy sister, and a bunch of bullshit about history or something. The show takes itself way too seriously as it progresses.
Im with this guy. I loved the show consumed it!... but not like binge watching it. I watched one episode a night but i loved it and looked forward to it. I literally couldn't stop myself from loving it.
I'm in the middle of watching it at the moment. I've got weird mixed emotions. I don't feel like I'm enjoying that much, but I want to watch it constantly. Evidently I enjoy it more than I think I do lol
I've had this on my PTW fo awhile, hadn't actually realised it was 50 minutes per episodes (which actually peeks my interest as that to me that means greater amount of time for world/character development). One question I do have is that since it's based on a light novel series, does the anime completely adapt the series?
I feel like I would have enjoyed this show so much more without all the random bs about history or whatever. If it had just been an action-drama with a great art-style and a more gripping plot it would have been much better. Not to mention that the sister(forgot her name) almost ruined the entire show for me with her bland and uninteresting personality.
It's worth noting that some of the episode previews at the end of each episode contain major spoilers, so I wouldn't watch them except the one at the end of episode 3.
If you haven't seen this show yet, I HIGHLY recommend it. The art style is gorgeous as well. This is a dialogue heavy show, since the author of the Monogatari wrote Katanagatari as well. In my opinion, I prefer Katanagatari over Monogatari. I do love both series to death, though. The fight scenes, when they come in each episode, are expertly animated. Also, please don't let the episode length pull you away. Yes, it is 50 minutes per episode but it honestly doesn't feel like 50 minutes. The characters are all great, the whole concept of collecting one sword per episode works so well with this series and the ending is just so great. I don't want to spoil it but from episode 1 to episode 12, it's all perfection. Some hate the ending and I don't see why, I think it's just great and fit the mood towards the end of the series. Katanagatari is in my top 5, right under Shin Sekai Yori and Evangelion. It's just that good. Anyways, I highly recommend it if you're on the fence about starting it.
I've never felt so conflicted at the end of a show. I enjoyed the show almost all the way through, but I don't have any idea what emotion i feel after the last episode. I guess i understood what happened but it just feels like a punch in the gut.
Katanagatari will absolutely always be in my top 5. The show piqued my interest at first with the interesting art style, and by episode 4 I was totally invested in the series. The show drags a bit in the middle, but the grand finale with episode 12 is probably the best episode of an anime I've ever seen. The build up and pay off for the final fight is incredible, and the show left me Torn to Pieces when it was finally over.
I liked it but I think they could have done more to show the art style. The animation is pretty limited where IIRC the only times that they really pushed the animation were the Episode 4 teaser (lol) and Shichika's killing moves. The rest have the characters standing/sitting still a LOT, and jazz hands.
There's a lot of dialogue but it sometimes gets draggy, like in EP4. The catchphrase sequence in particular felt like it took forever.
It's pretty good but I wish the animators had done some weed or something, maybe it would have helped improve the visual storytelling. The animation/art style we got is just...there.
Not a good writer nor am I an expert, but these are my thoughts.
Hey man, thank you for your opinion. Yeah, there's a lot of dialogue, but the flow of it is expertly done, and I, at least, don't get bored. I know that some people go in expecting constant fighting, and I tried to halt that, since it really ruins the enjoyment of an otherwise amazing show.
I just tried giving it a second chance. Nope. Still fucking boring and I hate the characters. It isn't even that I dislike the creator because I liked monogatari.
84
u/CC_ER Nov 27 '15
I can't upvote this hard enough. Katanagatari is a gorgeous show with one of the best endings I've seen. I'd recommend it to anyone.
28
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '15
No worries. People generally like to talk about their favorite shows regardless of how well they can communicate their thoughts on them.
You did a pretty good job with going over the anime's strengths. What I would suggest is expand more on the "Art and all that other stuff" section.
26
u/Magniras Nov 27 '15
You might be able to get to episode 12 of this anime. However, by that point, you'll have been torn to pieces
19
u/__Clever_Username__ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/clever_username_ Nov 27 '15
I finished this show last week. That ending left me speechless. The show is masterpiece, nothing less than a 10/10 from me. The character designs, as you say, are brilliant, probably my favourite character designs in any anime. In terms of development, characters that appear in only one 50 minute episode of this show feel deeper and more fleshed out than a lot of characters in 25+ episode shows.
17
u/Prodef :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Prodef Nov 27 '15
Can't agree more here. The Katanagatari spoiler? especially.
Very nice effort! The show shows(duh) that Isin is capable to write coherent stories(not that the lack is a bad thing for Monogatari but y'know). It's definitely worth a watch.
15
u/iDannyEL Nov 27 '15
[I still twitch] (/s "when I remember how hard they trolled us with that preview.") What they replaced it with was still pretty good though.
8
u/Maze-san :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Mazelord Nov 27 '15
I kidnapped my non-anime friend and made him watch it. He was hooked by episode 2 and speechless by the end.
I adore this show. I cannot express how the first watch of this made me feel. I had a zero-sleep rant about it after I had finished it for the 3rd time in a row. Never has a show made me want to do that before.
6
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '15
Katanagatari is my favorite show as well and I'm glad it got a decent [WT!]
5
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '15
For a long time i thought this anime was a monogatari's spin-off
5
u/keithioapc :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/keithioapc Nov 27 '15
Not one of my overall favorites (although it comes close), but definitely one of my favorites just in terms of visual style/presentation.
Definitely a series that left me with some feels. I had mostly forgotten about them, but man did they ever come back hard when I read your Togame quote.
4
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '15
Katanagatari is dope.
4
u/Neimi45 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neimi45 Nov 28 '15
Nice! This reminds me I should get to rewatch it myself, been a while since I last saw it. It's cool that it reminded you of S&W, I felt the same way. I love these kind of interactions between a male and female like in Katanagatari, Monogatari series and S&W.
Also Togame best girl. Cheerio!
3
u/Khedius Nov 27 '15
I was in the middle of watching this series and really enjoying it, but the site I was using to stream it no longer has it. Any viewing suggestions of places it is available in 720p?
3
u/Xilient :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Xilient Nov 28 '15 edited Nov 30 '15
Katanagatari is the most recent 10 I have. It is an incredibly memorable story and I can safely call it a masterpiece.
3
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '15
This show gets a 10/10 from me
3
u/Srakin :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/srakin Nov 28 '15
Easily one of the best shows I've ever watched. Absolutely fantastic.
2
u/andehh_ https://anilist.co/user/Andehh Nov 27 '15
I'm 3 episodes in to this atm but I'm not really feeling it. Does it pick up later on?
2
u/JayList Nov 28 '15
Watch this show only if you like heavy dialogue.
2
u/theroarer Nov 28 '15
Best everything. Demos review is pretty great.
2
u/Melopahn Nov 28 '15
Im with this guy. I loved the show consumed it!... but not like binge watching it. I watched one episode a night but i loved it and looked forward to it. I literally couldn't stop myself from loving it.
2
u/Bartimeo :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Aryadne Nov 28 '15
I love this anime, watched it when it was airing and i remember the sadness after almost every episode.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '15
This is definately high on my list. I want to get through Jojo, Steins;Gate, the last bits of Monogatari, and Psycho Pass first though.
1
u/DangerKitty001 Nov 27 '15
I'm in the middle of watching it at the moment. I've got weird mixed emotions. I don't feel like I'm enjoying that much, but I want to watch it constantly. Evidently I enjoy it more than I think I do lol
1
u/[deleted] Nov 27 '15
Cheerio!!
Love this anime, the ending is awesome too.
1
u/redspecs Nov 28 '15
I've had this on my PTW fo awhile, hadn't actually realised it was 50 minutes per episodes (which actually peeks my interest as that to me that means greater amount of time for world/character development). One question I do have is that since it's based on a light novel series, does the anime completely adapt the series?
1
u/YOU_FACE_JARAXXU5 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Iscariot127 Nov 28 '15
I feel like I would have enjoyed this show so much more without all the random bs about history or whatever. If it had just been an action-drama with a great art-style and a more gripping plot it would have been much better. Not to mention that the sister(forgot her name) almost ruined the entire show for me with her bland and uninteresting personality.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 28 '15
It's worth noting that some of the episode previews at the end of each episode contain major spoilers, so I wouldn't watch them except the one at the end of episode 3.
1
u/tj_odee Nov 28 '15
If you haven't seen this show yet, I HIGHLY recommend it. The art style is gorgeous as well. This is a dialogue heavy show, since the author of the Monogatari wrote Katanagatari as well. In my opinion, I prefer Katanagatari over Monogatari. I do love both series to death, though. The fight scenes, when they come in each episode, are expertly animated. Also, please don't let the episode length pull you away. Yes, it is 50 minutes per episode but it honestly doesn't feel like 50 minutes. The characters are all great, the whole concept of collecting one sword per episode works so well with this series and the ending is just so great. I don't want to spoil it but from episode 1 to episode 12, it's all perfection. Some hate the ending and I don't see why, I think it's just great and fit the mood towards the end of the series. Katanagatari is in my top 5, right under Shin Sekai Yori and Evangelion. It's just that good. Anyways, I highly recommend it if you're on the fence about starting it.
1
u/Radioactev Nov 28 '15
Is there a place where I can stream this legally online?
1
u/[deleted] Dec 01 '15
I've never felt so conflicted at the end of a show. I enjoyed the show almost all the way through, but I don't have any idea what emotion i feel after the last episode. I guess i understood what happened but it just feels like a punch in the gut.
1
u/DueLearner Dec 01 '15
Katanagatari will absolutely always be in my top 5. The show piqued my interest at first with the interesting art style, and by episode 4 I was totally invested in the series. The show drags a bit in the middle, but the grand finale with episode 12 is probably the best episode of an anime I've ever seen. The build up and pay off for the final fight is incredible, and the show left me Torn to Pieces when it was finally over.
1
u/KarnoffeL Nov 27 '15 edited Nov 27 '15
I liked it but I think they could have done more to show the art style. The animation is pretty limited where IIRC the only times that they really pushed the animation were the Episode 4 teaser (lol) and Shichika's killing moves. The rest have the characters standing/sitting still a LOT, and jazz hands.
There's a lot of dialogue but it sometimes gets draggy, like in EP4. The catchphrase sequence in particular felt like it took forever.
It's pretty good but I wish the animators had done some weed or something, maybe it would have helped improve the visual storytelling. The animation/art style we got is just...there.
Not a good writer nor am I an expert, but these are my thoughts.
0
u/Avechan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/vexelpops Nov 28 '15
I just tried giving it a second chance. Nope. Still fucking boring and I hate the characters. It isn't even that I dislike the creator because I liked monogatari.
-3
u/Buuburn Nov 27 '15
Yeah it was alright.