r/anime • u/7TeenWriters :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/7TeenWriters • Dec 29 '15
WT! Millennium Actress (no really, watch it right now)
To reduce this entire recommendation to one sentence: watch fucking Millennium Actress. Not only is it now my favorite anime of all time, I would argue that it is also one of the best anime out there by the metrics of story and how well it utilizes its medium. For starters, the film is an hour and half, so there can be no arguments made about time investment. Even if there’s a chance you’ll think it’s absolute shit it’s completely worth the small time investment for the possibility that you’ll think it’s just as amazing as I do. If that’s enough to convince you, stop reading and watch it right now. This is a WT! thread, so it’s spoiler free, but I think it’ll be more fun to discuss with people who weren’t going into it with any preconceptions about the sort of movie it is. If that isn’t enough, on to the actual analysis of why it’s good.
Millennium Actress is a movie that follows the life of an old actress as she tells her story to a couple of interviewers who are making a documentary... but it’s also a whole lot bigger than that. First and foremost, Millennium Actress is a metaphor filled ‘artsy’ film. Normally, this would be a huge turnoff for me right from the get go. In my experience with western media, an ‘artsy’ movie is almost always something that’s trying way too hard to be 2deep4u. It is literally the definition of pretentious, with the mission statement to be stylistic and vague so that people can pretend they’re smart by saying “ooh, what does it mean?” and their friends will play along so as not to appear the idiot. In short, I think that most artsy films in western media are complete and utter trash. I’d liken my apprehension about them to my apprehension about shows with prominent tsunderes: they’re fine as long as the archetype isn’t used as a replacement for actual depth... which is, unfortunately, something that happens all too often... But I digress, Millennium Actress is obviously none of that. I bring up the pretentious ‘artsy’ films to draw a parallel between their failings and what Millennium Actress excels at. Most films of this type use obfuscation to make it more difficult to identify what exactly their supposed depth is. By contrast, Millennium Actress pretty much tells you what it was all about at the end... and you could guess with relative ease even before then. You can probably predict a lot of what will happen at the end just from the first couple of scenes, and more of what the story will eventually lead to becomes increasingly clear as the film goes on. Everything in the movie is building towards the final line, which can loosely be described as the ‘point’ of the film. It was so well structured, in fact, that there’s a point towards the end when it seems as if the film will end before the final line is actually completed, and I said the rest in my head almost verbatim only to have it echoed back to me on the screen a moment later...
... And this predictability is the exact opposite of a problem as well. Normally the major issue with predictable shows is that they’re predictable because we’ve seen it all before in a thousand different ways. I can almost guarantee that you haven’t seen anything quite like Millennium Actress. Because of its lack of reliance on twists, Millennium Actress also gains a boost to its already tremendous rewatch value. You lose nothing the second time through, and you actually gain perspective that allows you to notice more little details thrown in to serve the narrative. I’m on my fourth rewatch and still noticing new stuff. Millennium Actress is a film made in layers, all of them sharing the same vision and directionality. What this means for the viewer is that on a casual watchthrough you get a simple and charming experience and understand pretty much what the film was supposed to be about. The more you pay attention, the more you notice just how full the movie is of visuals, symbolism, and dialogue, that all lead to the same conclusion that both the viewer and the film reach at its end. That, ultimately, is why I consider this film to be the best example of a “near perfect” anime that I have seen. What I mean by “near perfect” is a show that has very little that is extraneous and very little that could be added in to enhance the experience. A show that executes its intent to close to the fullest extent that it possibly could. Of course there is still measurement within the hierarchy of ideas. An imperfect execution of a genius idea can still end up being better than a perfectly executed mediocre one. It just so happens that the idea behind Millennium Actress is also amazing. Now, when I say that Millennium Actress is “near perfect”, I’m underselling the magnitude of that accomplishment. I will not hesitate to point out flaws in my other favorite shows, I often find that my ability to tear something to shreds kind of follows pretty much an inverse normal curve (bell curve). The more I love or hate something, the more interest I have with which to find its problems. This means that I’ll be the first to tell you exactly what was wrong with Code Geass (a show that I love to death). For Millennium Actress, I would be hard pressed to find a frame that I would remove, or anything that could feasibly be added without muddying its near perfect presentation.
If even still none of the above has convinced you, I’ll try the approach of comparing its elements to other shows. Seriously, check my MAL for all of the classics that I’ll ultimately end up rating lower than it. Now, the way my ratings system works is that 10/10s and 1/10s are reserved for my absolute favorites and least favorites. Everything else exists somewhere in between. Before I watched Millennium Actress, I had six 10/10s. Once I finally get around to editing my ratings, I will now have one. Millennium Actress doesn’t necessarily exceed my favorite shows in every single aspect. The visual elements are tied with a couple of others for the best I’ve seen, given that while the art isn’t the most impressive (though still pretty damn great) the transitions, visual symbolism, and general aesthetic are top tier. The music gets a 9/10, not because of any particular failing but just because there are definable soundtracks that I like better. I still love this OST though, I particularly like the tracks Run and The Gate of Desire and listen to them regularly now. Characters are another element that only gets a 9/10, simply because I’ve seen better ones... and also because the characters aren’t really the point of Millennium Actress, regardless of the fact that it’s a character driven story. The characters are really kind of meant to be foils for people in general anyway, and yet still somehow succeed to have a lot of implied depth to their own stories (even side characters who are largely glossed over have clues dropped as to their backstories and motivations, they just aren’t focused on because they are not the film’s intent)... and I obviously also consider the plot to be one of the best out there... but here’s the thing that makes Millennium Actress stand miles above all the rest: It doesn’t fail at anything, and it’s sort. It’s “near perfect” nature means that there’s nothing to detract from its good qualities, everything ads. The fact that it’s short more comes from my personal respect as a writer. If you can convey all of the emotions and feelings in one page as someone else can convey in a hundred you’ve completed a far more impressive feat (this is not to say I’m a literary minimalist under all circumstances, the raving over “For sale: baby shoes, never worn.” is completely retarded to me... but that’s getting into a completely different literary debate). Satoshi Kon fits into a 90 minute runtime the emotions and setup for ideas that I would expect from a 24 episode (~480 minute) show. When I praise shows, I normally talk about specific elements of them, for example Kara no Kyoukai’s fight scenes belong in a museum. Millennium Actress belongs in a museum.
This WT! is the second entry in a series of posts I’ll be making every Tuesday for a little while on the works of Satoshi Kon. After these WT!s are done I’ll then set to reviewing each of his shows and post a final analysis of Kon’s writing and visual style. I’ve set my first review to Millennium Actress, which will drop January 26th. That’s another reason you should watch it actually, because it’s set to be both the best and the longest analysis that I have ever written, so if you like my writing at all get hype. I'll be sad if this doesn't turn into a pretty big discussion since I'm basically watching the film on repeat so as not to miss a single detail. You can check out the full announcement for my Kon WT!s for more information. Here is last week’s Tokyo Godfathers WT!. This week I’ll be watching Perfect Blue, so there’s every chance that I’ll have my MAL rocked twice in a row given how much praise it gets. See you guys next week for that WT!
8
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '15 edited Dec 29 '15
My favorite of Kon's movies. I talked about this in another thread but I was lucky enough to seeing this about a week after his passing on a 35mm double bill with Paprika. As sad of an ocassion it was, it was also great to see one of the medium's finest artists in the best possible way. I'd watched the film before but seeing it like that just cemented it as one of my favorite movies. Susumu Hirasawa's soundtrack is stunningly good as well:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tGb_fYB3FXg
5
u/WingsOfLight :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Wings_of_Light Dec 29 '15
Millennium Actress is a fantastic film that as you said, I can't actually point to any big flaws to it (just like Mononoke Hime for me for example). The scene transitions are amazing and the movie leaves you pondering for hours on end. Would be an easy 10/10 if I did my ratings differently.
5
u/Zelkiiro :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Zelkiiro Dec 29 '15 edited Dec 29 '15
Millennium Actress is a goddamn masterpiece, and I will hear no word to the contrary. I wrote a review on it a few years back, and I had a decent amount to say there, so I won't repeat myself here. Easily in my Top 10 films of all time--not just anime films, all films.
5
u/jonwooooo :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/jonwoo Dec 29 '15
First time viewer here!
This is probably going to come off as ironic from someone who's favorite anime is The Tatami Galaxy, but I found the plot of Millennium Actress to be a little too simple. Satoshi Kon twists his story with brilliant visuals and symbolism yet, for lack of a better explanation, I just didn't get as attached to his work as I was anticipating. I don't mean to downplay this film though, it's still one of the best things you can spend your time on in the medium and I have some high respect for it.
Moving on to my favorite thing about this Millennium Actress: Genya Tachibana. Everything about Genya was compelling to me and I get super giddy just thinking about all the little details regarding him throughout the movie. Why not Chiyoko? Hard to say. Even after recognizing the motif of Millennium Actress, my attachment towards Genya over Chiyoko probably seems a little bit imbalanced. Oh well, that's how I feel about it currently after my first watch and that may or may not change in the future.
Looking forward to Perfect Blue!
3
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '15 edited Dec 29 '15
I need to rewatch this soon. The cinematography and music in this film is fucking flawless, and the story is incredible as well. My favourite piece is 'Chiyoko's Theme' as well as the 'Run' OST that plays during that glorious scene that I won't even begin to describe, you need to see it to appreciate it. It's a beautiful film, and the ending made me tear up.
Perfect Blue is fantastic as well, probably my favourite anime movie alongside End of Evangelion. I need to check out the rest of Kon's work, but he's easily one of my favourite directors already.
EDIT : I'd also recommend this video which does a fantastic job of breaking down the cinematography and editing used in Kon's films. It's a great watch.
3
u/grumpybumblebutt Dec 29 '15
After watching this, read Satoshi Kon's final letter:
http://www.makikoitoh.com/journal/satoshi-kons-last-words
What a great perspective on life.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '15 edited Dec 29 '15
Hey 7Teen just finished watching it.. Just wow... Fucking wow.
Incredible.
2
u/Xator_Nova :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Xator Dec 29 '15
Favorite Kon film, probably best anime film ever made. That ending was totally brilliant.
2
u/HotStep :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/HotStep Jan 02 '16
Wow. I was really looking forward to watching this after reading your WT, but I could only watch it now, sorry I'm late. That was simply amazing, if I had more time I would rewatch it again in a heartbeat. Almost had me crying at the end, and it was never dull for a single second throughout the whole movie, which is suprising since I watch anime at a very slow rate, and sitting for one-hour and a half watching the same thing is something I usually have a very hard time doing. I don't think I can rate this anything other than a 10/10, just like you mentioned, it's so hard to find a single flaw in this movie.
Visually it was magnificent, I love the way it started with a black-and-white-ish colour pallete and as the movie kept going, and the memories became more recent, it started getting more colorful and vibrant. And that sequence where she was running, while the times kept changing and changing was an absolute chill-fest, not to mention the ending sequence where she was in the rocket...I was shivering at how perfect the whole thing was.
I have a question - what is your interpretation on the old ghost woman with the string? I'm not sure about what she meant by the whole "I love you/I hate you" thing, and while I do have some ideas scattered around my mind, I would love to hear your interpretation on it. And thanks for the great WT!
13
u/ShaKing807 x3myanimelist.net/profile/Shaking807 Dec 29 '15
I watched Millennium Actress a few weeks ago and was really blown away with how much I enjoyed it! The story was really nice and the transitions between film settings was absolutely amazing!
Would definitely recommend that everyone should check it out!
9
u/McWaddle Dec 29 '15
It's Satoshi Kon, of course it's good.
R.I.P.
2
u/amazingmandibles :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/amazingmandibles Dec 29 '15
In my opinion, this film places too much emphasis on artistic flair and not enough focus on developing the story and its characters.
1
u/Just_One_of_Three :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/OneofThree Dec 29 '15
My anime club watched this, one week, but i was late and so i only saw the last 20 minutes and let me tell you. I have no idea what was happening.
3
u/KNIRKY :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/KnirK Dec 29 '15
I'm an easy man, first paragraph was perfect and all I read. I'm now going to watch this very soon.
2
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Dec 29 '15
I watched it last night! Great movie, amazing directing.
2
u/BBallHunter :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/IdolHunter Dec 29 '15
Amazing movie in every regard.
2
u/keithioapc :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/keithioapc Dec 29 '15
I probably should have already had this on my PTW, since Paprika is one of my top 10 favs, and I also liked Perfect Blue & Tokyo Godfathers. I'll give it a watch soonish :)
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '15
Dear god this write-up. I'll tell you what, I'll watch it tonight and come back and reply tomorrow morning or before I go to sleep :)
2
u/huoyuanjiaa :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Freestylex Dec 29 '15
After seeing Paranoia Agent on Adult Swim I watched all of Kon's movies, this one is sooo good though.
0
u/AutoModerator Dec 29 '15
Hi 7TeenWriters, it seems like you might be looking for anime recommendations!
The users of this subreddit came up with an awesome recommendations flowchart. Maybe you can find something there that you'll like ^.^
You might also find our Recommendation Wiki helpful.
The following may be of interest:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
-2
u/AlluraHikaru Dec 29 '15
Dropped this artsy trash 35 min in. What a waste of my time.