I hear so much about this series, but I've found it really difficult to get into. With Index, I get bored because I find Touma uninteresting. With Railgun, I alternate between being annoyed by the creepy and unnecessary fan service and being bored because there's so little plot progression. Am I missing something?
To be honest I think it's just not for you, I thought the same but I finished the 1st season of Index and watched Railgun S. Other than the Sisters arc I just don't feel like you'd like it, there's barely any true plot progression, although there is less fanservice.
Just how good is the Sisters arc? I forced myself through Railgun until just after the Level-Upper arc (which I enjoyed well enough), but dropped it after because it went back to being slice-of-life-y.
It's one of the best arcs in the entire series. Definitely worth watching if you liked the level upper arc. Massive tonal shift from the rest of the series.
At first, when I was getting into the series my thoughts were exactly the same. I dropped Index on third episode and watched Railgun. Had to force myself through the first season of Railgun. But then second season came, that's when I understood that I have to give it a chance because, again, episodes 14-16 are one of the best episodes I've ever seen. Fanservice gets toned down a lot in the first season a few episodes in.
Index gets better in the second season and with introduction of Accelerator. As I said it focuses a lot on world building rather than the protagonist so that's why you might think that he is uninteresting. World building is basically over at the second half of the second season. Touma's character gets a lot of development in the novels, especially in the New Testement. So give it a try, it requires some patience (especially with Railgun, for some.)
If you think that I left out some details then don't hesitate to leave a reply with constructive criticism!
Sure, why not.
I don't feel like you ever qualified this statement:
As I have already mentioned, the universe of Raildex is very well done.
You talk a little bit about the setting and what Espers are, but you don't give any reasoning for why it is "well done". I could take your descriptive paragraph and just change all the specific terms into culinary terms and it would be a description of the setting of Shokugeki no Souma (science technology -> gastronomy, psychic powers -> culinary skills, etc). It's just description, it doesn't give a non-reader any reason to think the setting really is "well done".
This is especially important, because you then immediately claim:
It is very possibly the best fictional universe I've ever seen in media.
So now you're using the universe as a major selling point of the shows (and the first such point anyone will read in your WT). All the more reason to elaborate on this!
Now, let's get into some uncomfortable truths for a minute. The Raildex franchise is just one of hundreds of anime about "high schoolers with various superpowers who fight bad people". LOTS of those shows have convoluted "systems" that vaguely explain why/how these kids have superpowers... whether it be a magic puberty comet, vampirism, ancient hereditary calligraphy, science!Powers, the goddamned Lion King Organization (eurgh), finding ancient relics in your parents' basements, etc...
So listing out a vague explanation of yet another magic superpower "system" like this:
Students take part in Esper Development Curriculum which gives them the potential of gaining psychic powers. Espers are ranked starting from level 0 (almost powerless) ending with level 5 (super powers), latter being the rarest occurrence in the city (there are only 7 students with the power level of 5). While espers can be fully explained by science, there is another major part to this universe which is unreachable by science. {and the next paragraph}
...doesn't really do anything to distinguish this show from any of dozens of other very similar premises. It neither explains how the universe is "very well done", nor does it give a very compelling reason for why someone should [WT!]
If you're going to use the setting as a major selling point like that, I think you need to really elaborate on why it is so great, on how it stands out amongst the plethora of other shows that use a very similar premise.
(Alas, I can't offer you any specific suggestions... because I personally think the RailDex setting is drastically underexplained, underutilized and really only serves to give the show a tagline that never actually happens. But I'm sure a good argument could be made for it and editing it into your [WT!] is the best place to do it!)
I said it was one of the best fictional universes because I actually read the novels and it is explained really really well. I've seen a lot generic plots with supernatural powers and honestly, close to none were as explained as Raildex universe was in the LN's. I get what you're trying to say but my opinion there is not based on observations from anime itself but from reading the novels. Anime doesn't explain it nearly as good as LN's did and if I were to actually elaborate why I liked the universe I would be entering major spoiler territory of events which didn't even occur in the anime.
So everything I wrote about it being one of the best universes was solely my opinion and I kinda left the decision on readers to decide if they agree with me or not.
But I agree, I really should elaborate. Thanks for input!
There's nothing wrong with that, but if that's the case you should make it very clear, as some people reading this [WT!] may know absolutely nothing about this series or the level of adaptation from the source. This is a [WT!], not a [RT!] after all, so you need to be upfront about the differences.
Just say something like "The source material which this adaptation is based upon has what is very possibly the best fictional universe I've ever seen in media. And while this adaptation's scope does not cover the full extent of that setting, it nevertheless provides a dynamic context for the events of the show and many intriguing hints of the wider world seen in the unadapted volumes of the source material."
I'm glad that you mentioned that Index should be watched first. Too many people watch Railgun first and then ARGUE that it's the correct way - not if they want the whole story.
A month or so ago I watched the first season of Index and didn't like it at all. The only part I liked was the sister arc and that was much better in Railgun anyway.
I was going to watch season 2 of Index because I hear it is good but I just can't motivate myself to do it atm. Is it worth it? Is it better than season 1?
It IS better than season 1! A lot of things happen there as well as we get to see more of Accelerator. There are a couple of boring arcs, but the rest was really good in my honest opinion. Give it a shot!
Join us at /r/toarumajutsunoindex if you will like it enough to check out source material!
3
u/JBHUTT09:MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JBHUTT09Dec 31 '15edited Jan 01 '16
The only part I liked was the sister arc and that was much better in Railgun anyway.
I hate this argument. The two can't be compared. Index's version is a straight forward telling of the events after Touma gets involved. Railgun's version covers the entire series of events, and then slowly switches to an unreliable narrator format as the arc heads toward its conclusion. The two tellings are attempting different things and both achieve their goals well. You just can't say one does it better, since they aren't doing the same thing.
Edit: I'm not saying you can't enjoy one more than the other. I'm just saying that you can't simply say one "does it better" because they don't do the same thing. It's like saying "I like Gurren Lagann more than K-On! because Gurren Lagann did it better." What is "it"?
There is no objective "better", only a subjective one. I merely meant that I much preferred the Railgun version. Also having seen that first most likely colored my preference.
The fact that they're doing two different things does not prevent one from being subjectively preferable to the other.
It's totally fine to enjoy one over the other, but you said one did "it" better than the other, when the "it" they were doing is completely different.
7
u/Gulanga:MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pal-WakattaDec 31 '15edited Dec 31 '15
Yes because to me the Railgun version delivered what I liked about the sister arc better. The "it" is what I personally enjoyed about that bit of story, and to me the Railgun version did that better.
I'm not trying to be objective here.
*Edit: If you made two different movies about one event, one of them being a horror movie and one being a comedy, one of those movies can still be said to be "better" (subjectively of course) even though they tried to do different things.
Your movie analogy doesn't really fit this case. The two versions aren't that vastly different in tone, but in the material they cover and how it is covered.
And you have to understand that saying "X did it better" in this situation sounds like you're using "tells its story" as "it", not your personal enjoyment.
Basically "X did it better" is a very confusing and rarely used (I've never seen it before) way of saying "I enjoyed X more".
My movie analogy was perhaps a bit cartoony but lets say two movies following two different people during those events and what they experienced. One can still think one is better than the other there or that one told of the events in a way that you preferred. Even though one of those people also had a bunch of other things going on and only saw little of the event.
I still believe that you can say that one did it better when talking about this. Railgun did it better but Index was not in a position to ever compete because Railgun naturally follows the events more closely and the experience becomes more intimate. Therefore making the viewers experience with that arc better (subjectively) than the viewers experience with the Index version of that arc.
2
u/JBHUTT09:MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JBHUTT09Dec 31 '15edited Jan 01 '16
I still don't agree with your wording, but I understand what you're saying.
Edit:Really? This comment is negative? Holy shit, I'm sick of this fucking bullshit.
I personally recommend watching the first nine episodes of Index before starting Railgun if you're gonna do it that way, as it develops the world building better. Just me, though.
But watching Index first ruins the Sisters Arc. 16 episodes compared to 2 over a complex arc isnt really fair. You can watch the series split 1-9 index then Railgun but really I would watch it Railgun first just for the sisters arc and how its not ruined
I guarantee your watch order still leaves people confused, since one has to see the Three Stories arc before the Railgun Sisters arc to properly understand and appreciate the latter.
You better off posting that at /r/toarumajutsunoindex. My [WT!] was removed like 10 times I honestly think people hate indexfags at /r/anime. So post it there and I'll link that in my WT!.
I'm always surprised by that. I watched Railgun back when it aired and people hated it. Too much fanservice, too much focus on Kuroko to the point that you might as well re-name the show to "A Certain Lesbian Teleporter", too much slice-of-life cute girls doing cute things, too much boring filler nobody cares about. But since then the general opinion seems to have shifted, now people love Railgun and dislike Index. Personally, I still prefer Index.
I was thinking of watching this soon but the watch order seems really weird. And, after reading this thread, it's even weirder, as your suggestion of watching Index I first isn't advised by r/anime's watch order for this show at all.
So, who's right? I mean, no one's right but what's actually the optimal way of doing this?
The usual watch order is by chronological release. Index I -> Railgun > Index II > Railgun S. Don't trust what official watch order says. They're fascists.
/u/Sir_Factis is correct. The best way to be introduced to the series as a whole is starting with Index I. Though I'd tweak his suggested order a bit and suggest going:
Index I -> Railgun -> Railgun S -> Index II -> Index Movie
if those who watched the Anime only knew just how much shit goes down after episode 24 of Index II & Sister Arc (Railgun)
they're gonna consume the LN's & Manga like it's hot pancake
PS : i still think that mentioning Gemstones & Hamazura is minor spoilers. not so much for Gemstones but at the very least the reaction that the first time LN readers will make after volume 15 then watching episode 24 of Index is gonna be priceless
the term isn't used until much later. We know what they are, but not what they're called
4
u/JBHUTT09:MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JBHUTT09Dec 31 '15edited Jan 01 '16
One additional piece of information for those looking to get into the series for the long haul (source material and all):
Index and Index II are essentially the setup for the overarching story of Index. It starts off as a lot of "bad guy of the week", but it starts to come together towards the end of Index II. Index II's penultimate arc is really the turning point as the series begins its final conflict. Unfortunately, that journey towards a resolution hasn't been animated yet, and it is looking less and less like it ever will.
Also, as the series goes on beyond the anime adaptation, Railgun becomes much more integral to the Index PoV. Certain arcs of Railgun (be them in the manga or the side story novels) are vital to understanding Index arcs, and vice-versa.
This series is incredible and has the best universe and lore I've ever come across. I can't recommend it enough.
Edit 2: Even this comment is controversial? Wow. This comment is nothing but positive and it's still controversial. Can I talk about this series in any capacity without starting a shitstorm or getting downvoted?
Thanks. I wear it proudly. (For those who haven't seen Index, it's something the primary protagonist says a lot. It means "such misfortune" and is typically said sarcastically.)
I was under the impression that that Raildex was very successful for J.C. Staff. Are the LN done or something that they feel they don't need to advertise for them anymore? I'm struggling to figure out why they would stop animating the story.
I'm struggling to figure out why they would stop animating the story.
Anime are typically advertisements for the source material. Index: NT (the sequel, since Index ended) is one of the highest selling LNs of all time. There's no need to advertise it, so it's unlikely that they will make another season.
Basically it's already popular, so they won't make another season. It's infuriating and really counter-intuitive from our point of view, but it's the way the anime adaptation industry works.
Psh. Just terrible taste then. I have to admit that the LN is fun and really adds a lot (I'm currently waiting on my next shipment from Amazon before continuing and I'm only 3 volumes in anyways, but it definitely improves on the start of the Anime) even if the Railgun Manga is inferior :(
After watching the series I found a site with light novel translations. I got up to the point that .
One thing that was better explained in the LNs is that youths in Academy City are put through a regiment of experimental drugs and electroshock therapy to unlock their "personal reality", which allows them to use esper powers. It seems to imply that Espers are actually altering reality on a localized level so that things like electricity and vector control are possible for them.
Anyway, the drugs and electroshock alter your body to the extent that attempts to use magic results in physical damage. They basically explain that in the anime, but not in quite as much detail as the LNs.
Ah, that's okay. I stopped reading 6 or so months ago so I kind of wanted to go back a bit from where I left off to refresh myself on what all was going on.
To be totally honest, I do not like Austin Tindle's Accelerator. I think the subbed guy is fantastic. That being said, I really like Brittney Karbowski and Brina Palencia's performances, and Raildex is one of those shows I enjoy in both formats.
I'm guessing it had to do with when retards from AskReddit found out about it in one of those "small sub" threads, and took it literally when one of us jokingly said they needed to ask the /r/anime mods for permission before they could be modded on my sub.
7
u/Cloudflame :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Cloudflame Dec 31 '15
I love the series but for me I found Index to be more enjoyable than the railgun series, even misaka herself cant carry those 3 girls...
11
u/ViewtifulSchmoe Dec 31 '15
I hear so much about this series, but I've found it really difficult to get into. With Index, I get bored because I find Touma uninteresting. With Railgun, I alternate between being annoyed by the creepy and unnecessary fan service and being bored because there's so little plot progression. Am I missing something?
10
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Dec 31 '15
Sure, why not.
I don't feel like you ever qualified this statement:
You talk a little bit about the setting and what Espers are, but you don't give any reasoning for why it is "well done". I could take your descriptive paragraph and just change all the specific terms into culinary terms and it would be a description of the setting of Shokugeki no Souma (science technology -> gastronomy, psychic powers -> culinary skills, etc). It's just description, it doesn't give a non-reader any reason to think the setting really is "well done".
This is especially important, because you then immediately claim:
So now you're using the universe as a major selling point of the shows (and the first such point anyone will read in your WT). All the more reason to elaborate on this!
Now, let's get into some uncomfortable truths for a minute. The Raildex franchise is just one of hundreds of anime about "high schoolers with various superpowers who fight bad people". LOTS of those shows have convoluted "systems" that vaguely explain why/how these kids have superpowers... whether it be a magic puberty comet, vampirism, ancient hereditary calligraphy, science!Powers, the goddamned Lion King Organization (eurgh), finding ancient relics in your parents' basements, etc...
So listing out a vague explanation of yet another magic superpower "system" like this:
...doesn't really do anything to distinguish this show from any of dozens of other very similar premises. It neither explains how the universe is "very well done", nor does it give a very compelling reason for why someone should [WT!]
If you're going to use the setting as a major selling point like that, I think you need to really elaborate on why it is so great, on how it stands out amongst the plethora of other shows that use a very similar premise.
(Alas, I can't offer you any specific suggestions... because I personally think the RailDex setting is drastically underexplained, underutilized and really only serves to give the show a tagline that never actually happens. But I'm sure a good argument could be made for it and editing it into your [WT!] is the best place to do it!)
17
u/define_irony :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Geejones Dec 31 '15
Hello,
I'm glad that you mentioned that Index should be watched first. Too many people watch Railgun first and then ARGUE that it's the correct way - not if they want the whole story.
4
u/zanotam :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/zanotam Jan 01 '16
oh. my god!
SOMEONE NOTICED MY WATCH-ORDER! :D
time to write a spoiler-free version that isn't just for rewatchers
7
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15 edited Dec 31 '15
I'm seeing more railgun love in this thread. I guess people prefer the cute girls talk filler over index's constant action
3
u/David182nd :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/david182nd Dec 31 '15
I was thinking of watching this soon but the watch order seems really weird. And, after reading this thread, it's even weirder, as your suggestion of watching Index I first isn't advised by r/anime's watch order for this show at all.
So, who's right? I mean, no one's right but what's actually the optimal way of doing this?
5
u/VAVAvile Dec 31 '15
Personally I think Railgun is easier too watch, because the arcs has more connections between them (except for that silent party arc, it was boring).
I watch Index after Railgun and was very confused because enemies just appear out of nowhere.
Overall Railgun S Sister Arc > Railgun > Index II > Index > the rest of Railgun S.
8
u/immanoel https://anilist.co/user/KoroneFan Dec 31 '15
S3 when? Also obligatory /r/OneTrueBiribiri
2
u/broimthatguy Dec 31 '15
cool will watch!
2
u/Stacia_Asuna Feb 11 '16
Index sux go watch RailgunRailgun sux go watch IndexSAO sux go watch Raildex4
u/6210classick Dec 31 '15
if those who watched the Anime only knew just how much shit goes down after episode 24 of Index II & Sister Arc (Railgun)
they're gonna consume the LN's & Manga like it's hot pancake
PS : i still think that mentioning Gemstones & Hamazura is minor spoilers. not so much for Gemstones but at the very least the reaction that the first time LN readers will make after volume 15 then watching episode 24 of Index is gonna be priceless
4
u/JBHUTT09 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JBHUTT09 Dec 31 '15 edited Jan 01 '16
One additional piece of information for those looking to get into the series for the long haul (source material and all):
Index and Index II are essentially the setup for the overarching story of Index. It starts off as a lot of "bad guy of the week", but it starts to come together towards the end of Index II. Index II's penultimate arc is really the turning point as the series begins its final conflict. Unfortunately, that journey towards a resolution hasn't been animated yet, and it is looking less and less like it ever will.
Also, as the series goes on beyond the anime adaptation, Railgun becomes much more integral to the Index PoV. Certain arcs of Railgun (be them in the manga or the side story novels) are vital to understanding Index arcs, and vice-versa.
This series is incredible and has the best universe and lore I've ever come across. I can't recommend it enough.
Edit: Also, here's part of an AMV I've been working on that will give you a feel of the action involved.
Edit 2: Even this comment is controversial? Wow. This comment is nothing but positive and it's still controversial. Can I talk about this series in any capacity without starting a shitstorm or getting downvoted?
3
u/The-Sublimer-One :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/The-Sublimer-One Dec 31 '15
Wait... You're not /u/JBHUTT09.
Or me!
2
u/caspissinclair Dec 31 '15 edited Dec 31 '15
After watching the series I found a site with light novel translations. I got up to the point that .
One thing that was better explained in the LNs is that youths in Academy City are put through a regiment of experimental drugs and electroshock therapy to unlock their "personal reality", which allows them to use esper powers. It seems to imply that Espers are actually altering reality on a localized level so that things like electricity and vector control are possible for them.
Anyway, the drugs and electroshock alter your body to the extent that attempts to use magic results in physical damage. They basically explain that in the anime, but not in quite as much detail as the LNs.
2
u/The-Sublimer-One :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/The-Sublimer-One Jan 01 '16
Hey, it's back.
2
u/gajaczek :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/gaiacheck Dec 31 '15
I highly recommend the dubbed version.
1
u/IgorJay :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/igorjay Dec 31 '15
I still haven't touched Index after watching Railgun over two years ago...
I'll get to it someday.
0
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15
[deleted] — view deleted comment
12
u/[deleted] Dec 31 '15
[removed] — view removed comment