r/anime • u/SonicSlayer :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SonicSlayer • Jan 08 '16
[WT!] Bakuman. - An anime about making manga, but also so much more
First I would like to say that this is my first WT! post, so please keep an open mind even if you see some errors made by me!
Watch this: Bakuman.
Type: TV Series - 3 Seasons, 25 Episodes per season
Year: 2011 (1st Season)
My Personal Rating: 10/10 - A masterpiece, and my favorite anime
What is Bakuman.? Bakuman. is an anime from the creators of Death Note, where two guys team up to make manga. One of them is an average student but great at drawing, and the other is an outstanding student who is an up-and-coming writer, so they are a perfect match for each other.
Why Should You Watch It?
Characters
The most outstanding thing about Bakuman. is not some outlandish setting or an amazing super power, but it is its amazing characters.
The two main characters, Mashiro and Takagi, are amazing together on-screen and the bond they have is irresistible, and also their determination and hard work and integrity really make them admirable. The bond these two share take their relationship to a level beyond just bros.
Any show would be pretty dull if only its main characters were good, and Bakuman. definitely doesn't have that problem. We are gradually introduced to a host of other fellow writers, and each of them had their own characteristics that really define them well.
Aside from being good friends, they also share a rivalry to be the top manga author, and the whole cast just has an amazing synergy making the show a joy to watch. All the side characters are so well done that it would be a pleasure to watch a show based solely on any of them.
As the series went on, the characters also grew and a lot of their relationships changed as well; many people became closer, some got married by the end, and some rifts were also created. Overall, the characters were extremely well made and realistic, which furthered the brilliance of this show and made it even more surreal.
The characters were so well-made that I was regularly jumping up from my seat, shaking my hands above my head in celebration as someone finally got first place, and so on. Each of the struggles they also faced really hit home with me, and it felt amazing when (if at all) they overcame them.
Lovely Story-telling
Leaving the characters aside (because honestly, I could rave about the character some more :P), Bakuman. also used a lot of semi-subtle cues to "show" the characters' feelings throughout the whole series. I call them "semi-subtle" because while subtle to me, they are definitely well below OreGairu levels of symbolism and mind-blow levels.
And I think that's a good thing, because my thinking is that very few were able to grasp most of the hints in that show and looking in a discussion thread (while providing an A-ha! moment) is definitely less satisfying than being able to understand the subtle hand movement of a character you have known and have gotten attached to quite a bit (as in Bakuman.).
TL;DR: Watch Bakuman. if you want an anime full of wonderful characters, lovely story-telling, adrenaline-pumping thrills and victories, true friendship and an amazing anime overall.
P.S. Remember that it's made by the creators of Death Note?
Well, Death Note was made with one person (Ohba) doing the story, and another doing the art (Obata). So Bakuman. is kind of a story of their career in a way.
36
u/INanoI Jan 08 '16
Take my up vote for this awesome series and your work to write this WT.
I can only agree that Bakuman is worth the time watching it.
Started and finished the manga and I was overjoyed when the 1st ep of the anime aired.
9
u/wavyhairedsamurai Jan 08 '16
You might enjoy this a bit more too if you know the mangaka behind some of the popular WSJ manga at the time, such as Eiichiro Oda and Hideaki Sorachi. Their personalities find their way into characters in Bakuman.
7
u/Maester Jan 09 '16
I need a Niizuma Eiji spinoff, I would watch the hell out of that shit. Amazing voice actor. CRAWRRR!
8
u/SinnermightyBL :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sinnermighty Jan 08 '16
I was planning on writing one but this is much better!
Bakuman is an amazing journey as you see the characters grow up throughout the show and their lives.
Also there are Death Note references too as you pointed out it is by the same combo of Ohba & Obata (who just released a new monthly manga too which is amazing so far).
A complete adaptation for the most part, a few things were skipped, but overall great. One my favorite shows!
2
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '16
No wonder why I thought Hattori looked so similar to Ryuk
2
u/Cyneck :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cyneck Jan 09 '16
I really loved bakuman too. Haven't watched season 3 because i binge watched the first 2 seasons and the 3rd one felt a bit too much and i had to take a break. The anime has great character development, probably one of the best i've seen in any anime.
2
u/MARKRULZ1 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/KuyaMark Jan 09 '16
Bakuman. is also my number 1 favorite anime. I remember reading the manga when it first came out and I watched the anime about 4 months ago(I started watching more anime about 3 years ago but I've always been reading manga). I love all of the characters especially Yoshida and Hiramaru. Those two always gave me a good laugh, especially to the end.
3
u/FishyJizzSmell :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/KenshiroIsBae Jan 08 '16
I have only read it, and in my opinion, the ending is crappy. Did the anime do this better or no?
3
u/TinkleFairyOC Jan 08 '16
I understand it's an anime [but massive spoiler] (/s "I don't think any kid is gonna graduate from HS and ask his crush to be his wife after they've both got to their dream and decide to never meet until then but even they still met before") It's like [why] (/s "don't you just fucking date and achieve your goal while you date and get married later?")
Other than that one problem I had with it, I felt that the show was one of the better throwbacks in anime.
4
u/SAOtaku https://myanimelist.net/profile/Adagaki Jan 09 '16
Ohba and Obata recently started a new manga, Platinum End which is really good so far as well if anyone is into manga.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '16
bakuman is realy a great a story , but the end in manga is better.
1
u/Totenkopfgitarrist Jan 09 '16
Yeah... Bakuman is a nice show. Was actually on my list for my own WT!, but I don't have enough time right now :-/ So I'm being lazy and just scream +1 :D
I like the main theme of Bakuman with its shonen "If you just work hard enough, all your impossible dreams will become real!"-theme. And that's probably also the reason, why I kinda like the ending.
Of course one could nitpick a lot about being hypocritical/twisted in some aspects of its world/society views (especially from the western point of view), about unrealistic growth, stupid decisions, unrealistic romance, bla bla bla... but in the end the anime achieve what it wants to be... and sometimes that is just enough :)
1
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '16
As much as I didn't enjoy the anime, the manga was perfect. Read it if you dislike the anime version ! :)
11
u/lukeatlook :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/lukeatlook Jan 08 '16 edited Jan 09 '16
Nice series and I've had a blast binge watching it over Chirstmas. My personal nitpicks, though:
EDIT: Overall, personally, I cannot possibly agree with a 10/10 note. I wouldn't give that even to Shirobako, and by all accounts it was a better anime, even in its halfway done state.
3
u/FriiZyy Jan 09 '16
I've just finished it and it was awesome !
3
u/chuletron :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Chuletron Jan 09 '16
My biggest problem with the show has to be the characters, i understand that they are supposed to be caricatures of other people in the industry but there were times where the characters didn't even feel human (the biggest example of this being the awfully unrealistic romance).
I also always thought that the whole section where the director tells them that it's their fault and not the editor's is absolute bullshit but i guess that's Japanese culture for you.
Besides that the show itself was incredibly enjoyable and highly addictive, i would definitely recommend it to anyone since it really gives you a good (although obviously exaggerated) look at the manga industry.
7
u/7upXD Jan 09 '16
Holy crap it's been 3 years since the manga ( 2 years since the anime ended).
There is not much difference between the manga and the anime, except the anime leave out an arc (that many consider to be the worst), and the anime adds some extra fluff here and there (especially at the ending). Bakuman is not a perfect work, but it was very enjoyable. The main criticism I have read about Bakuman, which carries over from Death Note, is that Ohba does not know how to write female characters. They are often more shallow and some people have said his writing is quite sexist.
But, besides that I am very surprised that Bakuman is not talked about more, it seems many people know about it, yet it is never brought up. It is one of my top 5, very good characters and story imo. I re-read the manga recently and couldn't put it down. Would recommend Bakuman.
2
u/whiteyfang :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/alien007 Jan 09 '16
I finished this series last week. I was so impressed that I actually searched for the creators of this manga/anime. I never did this before. I was never interested in checking who made X manga/anime. But this series is special, will always have a separate spot for me.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '16 edited Jan 09 '16
Bakuman is great. I'd say it's the Ohba/Obata duo's best work. I like it more than Death Note (and, at the moment, Platinum End).
I loved all the references it had to real manga, like One Piece and Gintama. And some of the manga made by the characters looked awesome (Otters 11 got its own real-life one-shot, but I'd like to see Crow as a real manga).
2
u/FanEu7 Jan 09 '16
I liked the two main protags and also their rivals a lot (mostly) but I wasn't a fan of the main romance at all.
It just seemed so silly and childish. Thankfully there were enough good things to overshadow that aspect of the show (which wasn't even needed to be the main motivation, felt forced)
1
u/define_irony :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Geejones Jan 09 '16
Hello,
I just started this 2 days ago! I've only seen 3 episodes so far but it's really intriguing and I'm probably going to binge on it tonight.
1
u/ShockinglyNotTaken :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Shockstep Jan 09 '16
I've read the manga a few times and it still stands as my favourite of all time. I've came to understand it's not without flaws and isn't as perfect as when my first read through, but this series will always hold a special place in my heart. Thank you for doing this WT and I really hope more people get to read this fantastic masterpiece.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 09 '16
I read a few volumes of the manga years ago when I was getting into Manga/Anime. It was pretty great. Didnt realise it was so long.
1
u/fseventh Jan 09 '16
One of the most interesting points in Bakuman itself is how I find most of Takagi's ideas can be a hit manga. And the differences between many authors' and editors' styles. Thank you so much for making this thread.
But the anime definitely should use blue bird for the end scene though. It would be much powerful :-)
1
u/shipmaster1995 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/shipmaster1995 Jan 09 '16
I watched the movie on the plane and thought it was pretty funny and good. Is there a lot more in the anime?
1
u/Maridona :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/maridona Jan 09 '16
Bump. Great series and WT! I highly recommend it.