r/ •
[WT!] Valkyria Chronicles - A pseudo-WW2 tale of Comedy, Romance, Loyalty, Drama, Racism and Concentration camps.
[deleted] — view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/ •
[deleted] — view deleted post
31
u/illtima :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/illuminatima Jan 19 '16
Huh, I was sure that the anime is not necessarily for viewing if you've played the game.
Okay, as a big fan of the game I have a couple of questions.
It's also good to hear that Faldio is better written in the anime, than in the game. I still can't get over
Also, if you want to check out the game, then DO IT! It's awesome! The cast is great, including the villains, the gameplay is very unusual, but enjoyable, and the story overall is really, really solid. HOWEVER. a) Play it on PC, because it's 60 FPS and supports mouse control and b) CHEAT! Cheat and get yourself extra bits experience and money with Artmoney, if you want to enjoy the gameplay to the fullest. You see, the rating system in the game is absolute bollocks. It doesn't reward you based on your accuracy, or how many soldiers you've lost etc. No, it rewards you based solely on how fast you've cleared the mission. So, majority of missions will be cleared by one single scout that rushes to the point.
9
u/Captain_BDS :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Captain_BDS Jan 19 '16
If I plan on playing the game, would watching this first spoil the game for me?
5
u/wave32 Jan 19 '16
What bugged me was that tactical stuff was oversimplified so battles look naive. They could have at least put some thought into them since they're adapting a tactical game.
5
u/thatdudewithknees Jan 19 '16
I would actually recommend the game (especially Valkyria Chronicles 3, which imo has better characters and 2 standalone ova episodes) over the anime. The pacing is better, and with less stupid drama. The anime not bad or anything, but it's not great either.
7
u/derkrieger https://myanimelist.net/profile/DerKrieger Jan 19 '16
The anime isn't bad but the game's story is significantly better. The anime does flesh it out in a couple spots where the game was lacking but overall the game is less tropey and is missing some of the bull the anime added in because reasons. It's still a fun watch but I would recommend you play the game first if you have any interest, its a lot of fun.
3
u/Totenkopfgitarrist Jan 19 '16
Hmm... that's one of the anime, where I like the idea, but the potential isn't fully used. There are some really great scenes in it, but on the other hand some things were overly annoying. Like this forced love triangle just to have a bit drama in there... it goes on and on and on and on for forever and I couldn't really stand it, because it felt out of place...
This anime tackles so many great themes, but things like the concentration camps felt rushed, when the next thing I see is dragged on love drama. I often have the feeling that together with the pacing the actual time could have been used better.
This could have been a great anime for me, but it ended as a good one with quite a few flaws. Still... because of the lack of similar anime, because of some really great scenes and because of most characters this is an anime, I would recommend to anyone who thinks that the theme sounds interesting...
2
u/Soupkitten https://myanimelist.net/profile/Soupkitten Jan 19 '16
Wow, didn't expect the Valkyria Chronicles anime to get a [WT!]. I really have to rewatch it.
2
u/TheValkyrieAsh Jan 19 '16
I liked the game quite a bit more, I'm still devastated about that one friendship scene.
2
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '16 edited Jan 19 '16
Valkyria Chronicles franchise! Always welcome. However...
Honestly, I watched the first seven episodes or so awhile ago, and dropped it, at least for now. I couldn't STAND Alicia's tsundere attitude or Faldio's role in the show, and, personally, I don't really like the art style, but that's not really a big consideration. I really want to see how they handle Selvaria, the Barious discovery, Fouzen, and huge story spoiler, but I can't force myself to endure the changes I don't like.
My recommendation would be to play the game, obviously, then go pick up the manga version; it fleshes out the other non-essential squad members in a really enjoyable way, explores some aspects of the personalities of the main characters that didn't get touched on in the game's story, and I really liked the way the story was re-interpreted, although the basics are the same.
All three, the game, manga, and anime, interpret the story a bit differently, so if you like one, you might as well try the others; I just don't enjoy the anime at all.
2
u/intoxbodmansvs Jan 19 '16
it was on my list for a long time, and I got time now ;D thanks for giving that last push
2
u/ytsejamajesty Jan 20 '16
I've been considering replaying the game for a while, but if the anime expands on the plot, it might be worth watching it instead.
2
u/kazrya Jan 20 '16
I can't recommend this series and game enough. Easily one of the best I've seen/watched!
2
u/Anbu_Leo :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AnbuLeo Jan 20 '16
Woah reading through this sounds like something I am totally down to watch. I am gonna put it on my plan to watch and definitely get around to it soon! Thanks for putting this thread up!
1
u/Rinarin Jan 19 '16
This is quite enjoyable even if the pace was a bit slow at some points from what I recall. The cast is fun and interesting to get to know since they all have various reasons for doing what they are doing.
Nice WT!
Oh, also, it's not really important but you have a little typo, in case you want to change it :
1
u/LunchTrey Jan 19 '16
I love the game and the anime. Wish they had dubbed the anime though since that's how I played the game.
1
u/Kuryaka Jan 19 '16
Flying pig is cute. That is all.
I remember having issues with how the beginning was set up, but decided to watch it through to the end. I think I also had issues about how some of the darker stuff was cut out.
Overall, I'd consider it the movie version of a "book" which takes some liberties in order to portray stuff a little better in that form of media. The game actually got me more connected to the characters, but anime is definitely faster and less frustrating.
Also, I'm a sucker for WWII stories.
1
u/Gulanga :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pal-Wakatta Jan 20 '16
I misread the title and thought you were on about Valkyrie Drive for a moment and was very confused.
This sounds interesting though.
1
u/NekoWafers Jan 20 '16
Does Alicia get less annoying as the series goes on? I think I watched the first two or three episodes and it felt like they were laying on the tsundere too much with her. I imagine it would matter less if the focus shifts to different characters, but I'm not sure I could make it through the show if she is one of the characters that the story stays centered around.
1
u/Starterjoker :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/starterjoker Jan 20 '16
JUST PLAY THE GAME :)
1
u/AlreadyGoneAway :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AlreadyGoneAway Jan 20 '16
If anyone is interested, a small Let's Player named Kay is currently playing through the game blind on her channel. She posts videos almost every day. www.youtube.com/#/channel/UCu3T-57vLRVEjF8viOEjm9g/videos
1
u/Tomotomi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/tomotomi Jan 20 '16
I have this on my plan to watch list, but because I've played a lot of the game before, I haven't been all that enthusiastic about watching it. Just the knowledge of Selvaria and Jaeger having larger roles makes me actually want to try watching it at some point soon though.
1
u/ChuckCarmichael Jan 20 '16
You forgot to mention the unique artstyle the show has. Everything looks like it was drawn on parchment or a piece of wood, giving dark colored areas a rough structure. Here's an example. It can look a bit strange, but it's mirroring the look of the game.
1
u/adamkex Jan 20 '16
The 2nd OP is a massive spoiler
0
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment