r/anime • • May 07 '16
[WT!] Hourou Musuko (Wandering Son): A Deep and Heartwarming Take on Transgender Struggles
Brief Plot Summary
Hourou Musuko is the tale of Shuuchi Nitori, a shy middle school biological male who identifies girl, and Yoshino Takatsuki, a tall and lanky, though attractive, tomboy who identifies as male. Nitori struggles with personal as well as social acceptance of her gender identity throughout the series as she deals with the hardships of romantic relationships and retaining childhood friendships while growing up as a transsexual.
Thematic Analysis
When the theme of gender identity and transsexual oppression is taken up in cinema or television, it is very rarely well executed. In the west, with a few exceptions, these works tend to be almost exclusively political, relying on somewhat shallow stock characters to focus on the political component of the topic at the expense of deep characterization and the personal nature of gender identity. At its worst, western writers use transsexuals as tokens to prove how politically correct they are or, even more offensively, as a shallow form of comic relief. In Japanese anime, LGBT issues are often poorly handled as well. Though Japanese anime tends to not get as overly political as western treatments of the issue, they more often than not treat LGBT characters as some sort of spectacle, like in most bad shounen-ai, or worse yet, as a comic relief through the use of offensive stereotypes (eg., Ryuka in Steins;Gate). Issues of gender identity have been, on occasion, well-explored in anime, most obviously in Shotashi Kon’s brilliant Tokyo Godfathers but also less obviously in the Ghost in the Shell movies from the perspective of transhumanist feminism a la Donna Haraway.
The show deals with the topic of gender identity in a decidedly serious tone that avoids almost all the problems that plague similar works. Unlike western attempts, Hourou Musuko does not over-politicize itself and develops the personality and individuality of Nitori and Takatsuki far beyond their struggles with gender identity. This more personal focus adds an element of depth to the social and political commentary that the most overly politicized western attempts could never hope for. After all, humans are political animals and issues of personal individuality and identity are never separable from the social and political context in which we exist. This fact is perhaps best typified by the issue of gender identity, a controversial political issue that is explicitly about personal individual expression. By focusing far more on the transsexual characters personally as individuals rather than as transsexuals in a transphobic political context, Hourou Musoko achieves a level of political depth both because the audience personally sympathizes more deeply with Nitori and Takatsuki, adding to its value as sentimental education, and because it is able to better deal with the complexity of humans as social animals.
The series also deals with the issue from a far deeper, more obscure and academic perspective that rarely gets discussed in popular media. This perspective (and the perspective I sympathize with the most) on gender is known in queer theory as gender performativity. Gender performativity is most closely associated with the work of poststructuralist feminist Judith Butler, who throughout her work (though most specifically in this paper) has argued that gender may be likened to acting in a theatrical work. In practice, our gender performance has the effect of reifying gender into something one can only have one “true” expression of, obscuring the unstable and complex nature of an individual’s gender act.
Minor Spoiler for Episodes 4-6
Though I could go on and on about this aspect of the series’ theme and I would like to write a more thorough analysis of gender performativity in this anime, that is outside the scope of this review and I am far from an expert on Judith Butler or feminist theory. Gender identity is not the only theme that is conveyed through this very simple, yet effective, plot. Also dealt with are typical fare in anime such as growing up, balancing individuality with healthy conformity to social expectations (an especially difficult topic in modern Japan as its historically collectivist culture has been challenged by interactions with western individualism since World War II), homosexuality, and the follies of youthful romance.
As intellectually engaging as Hourou Musuko’s plot is, it is not without its issues. The pacing is a little fast and uneven in certain places, particularly at the beginning where we are faced with an onslaught of new characters who are referred to by several different names, creating a difficulty in knowing who’s who. The dialogue is occasionally contrived and some of the social situations are a bit rushed into to the point of being unbelievable (particularly Nitori’s interactions with Doi near the end). However, over all the story is reasonably well-executed and is both deeply touching and intellectually challenging.
Characters
The character development in this anime is arguably its best feature. Nitori and Takatsuki are adorable and likable characters who are also very deep. Both are dynamic and well-written protagonists with a variety of very complex motivations and struggles who act as compelling foils to each other. The supporting cast of characters is equally well-written. Even when characters, at least the major ones, come off as cruel and transphobic to the protagonists, there is usually a deeper reason for their actions beyond simple transphobia: More minor spoilers Not only are nearly all the characters engaging, believable, and well-written, their relationships with each other strengthen the depth of the show; a number of characters act as in Takatsuki’s circle of friends act as parallel characters to Nitori’s, and there are numerous foils throughout the entire series.
Art and Directing
Artistically, Hourou Musoko excels far beyond your typical anime. The animation struck me as odd at first with its high brightness, background sets that look like water colors, minimalistic character designs, and heavy use of pastel colors. However, it works with the simple and sweet nature of the story and adds to the aesthetic atmosphere of the anime. The directing style is comparable with most of Makoto Shinkai’s wonderful films such as 5 Centimeters per Second or Mamoru’s Hasoda’s brilliant Wolf Children. There is an attention to detail in transition sequences, pillow shots, and camera angles that is rarely achieved in any style of film. Often, the focus will be on some minor detail that serves as a symbolic motif (such as Anna’s cell phone charm) during scenes of dialogue. It creates the relatable and charming vibe of a really good slice-of-life anime while having far more depth than most works of that genre.
Sound
The soundtrack, like most of the other features of this anime, is very simple yet highly effective. In very similar fashion to Tenomon’s work in Shinkai films, it mostly consistent of elegant, simple, and melancholy piano melodies that matches the emotion and atmosphere of the relevant scenes. The soundtrack accomplishes more, perhaps, in what it doesn’t do than what it does; there are extensive periods of silence or nothing but dialogue which remain intensely emotional. Even the lyrics and atmosphere of the closing song, with uber-kawaii matching animations of Nitori, contribute to the series. The voice acting is good but nothing to write home about as occasionally, especially in the case of Chiba and Mako, the parts are under-acted. Nonetheless, Asami Seto’s work as Takatsuki Kuosuko Hatakeyma as Nitori, and Yui Horie as Anna are very good performances and the voice acting overall is more than adequate.
Conclusions
The bottom line: Huroru Musoko is a deep, heartwarming, and phenomenally directed take on gender identity that should be viewed not only by anime fans, but anyone interested in LGBT rights as a thought-provoking work of art, anyone struggling with gender identity in their personal lives as a therapeutic and relatable story, or anyone who is opposed to trans rights as a work of sentimental education. It is particularly relevant here in America where recent issues of bathroom bills and transsexual discrimination laws have dominated political discourse. I do not know how anyone could come out of this wonderful series without their perspective on gender identity deepened or changed. I now consider it my second favorite anime ever made and would recommend it to almost anyone.
21
u/Gargoame :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/gargoame May 07 '16
Thanks for making this! I had wanted to for a while, but school and life got in the way. This is the show that got me to come out to myself, so yeah, I would heartily recommend it. It vocalized so many things that I had been feeling for a long time but didn't know how to express. If you have the time, I also highly recommend the manga (though an aspect of the ending is controversial), as it covers a lot more of the story including both before and after the anime and goes into depth for more characters (including my favorite, Makoto).
Also, before someone makes a comment about "but they use he for Nitori and she for Takatsuki in the show"
11
u/PM_ME_TRAP_BOYS May 07 '16
I think its worth noting that this is quite "heavy" for a slice of life, akin to the likes of "Oyasumi Pun Pun" and "Koe no Katachi" so viewer be warned of some heavy themes and "unsatisfying" arcs. For people who enjoy this sort of thing, I would also recommend a manga called "Bokura no Hentai" which deals with many similar issues and has similarly heavy themes. Also just a minor quibble, transsexual refers to post op transgender people and transgender is a blanket term for people who identify differently than their birth biological gender.
8
u/Nippoten :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/nippoten May 07 '16
This was the first show I ever gave a 10, this will always be a special anime to me.
Also, yeah, read the manga too. Also 10/10 material.
7
u/WhyIsThatImportant :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/PauseandSelect May 07 '16
OP, great job on the write-up, and I'm a huge fan of your analysis! While I focused on the semiotics (in my video which is totally not a less than subtle way of linking my own content) of the history of the LGBT community of Japan in Hourou Musuko, I love, love, LOVE your interpretation on performativity and its centrality to the show. Amazing write-up, and I totally agree with it!
It's hugely important to note that Hourou Musuko stands as a significant beacon in an upsurge in LGBT-aware manga material in Japan. While gender-benders have always been a staple of Japanese anime and manga, internal identity framed as natural is something that's rarely covered.
16
u/[deleted] May 07 '16 edited May 07 '16
Thank you so much for doing a WT for one of my favorite anime! I couldn't have said it better than you.
For anyone who's thinking about watching this, you don't have to be involved in LGBT issues to enjoy this show. It isn't about making political statements, rather its about the experiences of a couple of students and their friends and family. Its an extremely well made series, with interesting characters, great direction, and beautiful art. Directed by Aoki Ei (fate/zero) and with music by the same group as Haruhi Suzumiya and Monogatari.
A word of warning: the first episode is a bit confusing. They introduce a lot of characters quite quickly. This is due to them cutting the first few chapters from the manga. Useful chart with all the characters and their relationships as of the first episode
If you liked Hourou Musuko, I recommend Aoi Hana, by the same Mangaka. I didn't like it quite as much but its still worth a watch.
Edit: Added chart. Credit to /u/Gargoame for posting that.
3
u/TheHaruWhoCanRead May 07 '16 edited May 07 '16
Damn it OP I'm supposed to be hard at work on a ton of different things today, and instead I charged off to watch the first episode of this. Now I won't be able to stop until I've seen it all.
Thank you for this rec, because I'd never heard of it before. And here I was thinking I was pretty savvy on the catalogue of LGBT+ anime out there. I can't wait to watch the rest.
Edit kind of hijacked this thread by accident with talk of other LGBT anime so voters, try and keep this comment low-down :) I don't wanna take away from the discussion about Hourou Musuko.
5
u/discovolanate May 07 '16
Thank you Op, glad you did this WT. This is my 2nd favorite anime after Darker Than Black. Everything about this show is just beautiful.
4
u/cambronshinn :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BarcodeBandit May 07 '16
I would recommend this show as well. You can watch it on crunchyroll but it's not licensed for home release.
3
u/Spiranix :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Spiranix May 07 '16 edited May 07 '16
excellent write up for a super special show, good job at nailing some of its best points!!
easily one of my top 3 and a series I recommend to anyone given the chance. the character designs, shot compositions, background art style, animation (unf all those inbetweens), visual pacing, soundtrack, voice acting, just everything about it is as high quality a production as a tv series can possibly get, and Shimura's storytelling is so rich with insightful commentary and incredibly realistic characters that the writing for it is outmatched for a television drama. one of the finest anime or tv series ever made imo, a masterpiece in full form. <3
anyone curious to watch it should also watch the specials when they get to episode 10, as the TV version aired as only 11 episodes while the BDs were 12. the episodes mark up the climax of the show and expand upon it, so it's an important watch to round off the experience.
edit: ayyy JSTOR citations on an /r/anime post, I like you OP. I've run into Silvio's essay back in my film studies certification when I was in uni. great to see that same essay pop up here. :P
3
u/TheEliteNub :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheEliteNub May 07 '16
Great WT! OP, best one I've read in awhile.
I watched Hourou Musuko 2 months ago for its unique premise and was really impressed with how it handed its themes. It has definitely impacted me in a special way, really opening my eyes to gender identity issues and how it affects people.
2
u/[deleted] May 07 '16
It's funny how I'm so interested in these kinds of issues yet unable to find an anime that seriously talks about it. Thanks for this, I'll bookmark this so that once I finished the anime, I can come back and read it.
2
u/KaminariKillua May 07 '16
Hey, I just wanted to get in here and thank you for this. I just finished bingeing all episodes after I saw this post, and it was truly an emotional rollercoaster.
1
u/Shippoyasha May 07 '16
I see it as a bit of a crossdressing issue as well, considering that in the end, the characters made peace with being their respective genders. I think the fact that biological urges and changes are going to happen no matter what is a source of some angst, but mostly because it felt like it was so interchangeable at that age when interchangeability is such an easy thing for kids and teens by that point. It all being hinged by a girl who helped push for that gender duplicity, plus the nostalgia factor behind it is why the characters were in such anguish, despite them seeing that there are adults who decided to make a more drastic change to live a transgender/homosexual lifestyle more earnestly and fully.
It's a really nice and complex look at the issue that doesn't intend to demonize any one path or say any path is wrong. Just that in the process of growing up, the changing of the status quo (even for cross dressing) is going to be painful and difficult to come to grips with.
I really empathize with the story as someone who did have many feminine traits myself and was even mistaken for another gender during my childhood as well. I know how it feels like to have that certainty of beauty and gender identity changing and being swept away through age and growth.
-2
u/JazzKatCritic May 07 '16
I don't know if it is specifically about "trans" matters? There are some rather interesting depictions of gender and sexuality in Japanese media, so on this specific issue perhaps it is not completely analogous to what Western society refers to as "trans." The fact that the protagonists both coincidentally happen to still be the other gender to engage in a heterosexual relationship makes me wonder if it is no different in concept or presentation than various other works which simply use gender-bending as a way to try to differentiate the familiar narrative structure of romance, adolescence, and coming-of-age by adorning it with a slightly different facade. By which I mean the structure of and focus on those aspects are what the work is about, and what is mistakenly referred to as "trans" is just how the conflict of a very traditional story is presented.