r/anime • u/7TeenWriters :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/7TeenWriters • May 13 '16
[WT!] Why Kara no Kyoukai is the Show You’ve Been Looking For
I’ve made a rec thread for KnK in the past (for reference), but this one is going to be a little bit different. This time around I’m going to cover why at some point after watching enough anime almost everyone I talk to ends up craving a show like Kara no Kyoukai without even really realizing it. To get to the root of the issue, I’ll first cover the aspects that make the show good:
The Characters: The main cast of KnK is strong, with the main duo in particular as well as some of the villains being brilliantly fleshed out to the point where they feel like people could be real. The relationship between the main duo also evolves very slowly throughout the series in a way that feels natural to the characters, without ever being enough of a focus to infringe on the plot.
The Subtlety: One of Kara no Kyoukai’s most attractive features to me is the fact that it doesn’t beat you over the head with what its characters are thinking most of the time (though I will admit that it does from time to time with philosophy). Internal monologues are practically nonexistant and you have to extrapolate what characters are thinking from their actions... sort of like dealing with actual people.
The Visuals/Audio: I’m sure you’ve heard this a thousand times before but it’s worth repeating: Kara no Kyoukai’s fight scenes belong in a museum. The animation is top notch and combined with an amazing and perfectly fitting soundtrack the battles are pretty much unmatched in any show I’ve seen to date. Everything else about how this show looks and sounds is pretty perfect as well.
The “Hype” Factor: KnK has some massively cool moments (in particular the end of movie 5, but they’re riddled throughout the series), and it knows how to use them. Instead of constantly trying to outdo itself like a classic shounen anime, KnK is mostly talking and downtime. This makes the quick bursts of pure awesome all stand out on their own without becoming white noise in a constant stream of action.
The Uniqueness: Kara no Kyoukai is a bizarre mash up of a lot of interesting concepts, and I haven’t found anything else really like it (even other Type-Moon works, Tsukihime included).
These four things end up encompassing a lot of what anime watchers end up looking for after they’ve seen enough shows. This is because there are very few anime that do all of these things well in tandem. After watching a few shows, here are some of the most common things that I see people asking for when they want recommendations:
A show with a strong female protagonist (check) A show with three dimensional characters (check) A show that’s unique and doesn’t really fall into anime tropes (check) A show that doesn’t treat the viewer like an idiot who needs everything explained (CHECK)
Further, some common complaints about anime include:
The adherence to a highschool setting The constant mid-combat monologuing The constant internal monologues explaining the protagonist’s exact motivation Copy/paste character archetypes The use of still frames or other lazy animation Predictable storytelling formulas
With the exception of the highschool setting (technically parts of KnK take place in highschools, wouldn’t really count it as the setting, but technically speaking it’s there), Kara no Kyoukai has none of this. Further, it has a lot of the aspects that make more generic shows worthwhile, and does them better. The reason people watch action/shounen #244 as it comes out each season isn’t because it’s stupid and they’re stupid. It’s because it actually does have some positive qualities that you’d be hard pressed to find in a different type of show.
First and most obvious is the hype factor, as I’ve already generally covered above. It manages to maintain a healthy amount of “OH SHIT!” moments that have spectacular impact without resorting to too much power creep or constant attempts at one-upmanship. Secondly, there’s the animation. The thing about more obscure thinky shows that their production values tend to be far lower than more mainstream anticipated titles. While this particular concern doesn’t apply much to me as I’m a colorblind animation casual, a lot of people have a hard time getting into shows further outside of the mainstream because of the derpy animation, character designs, or visuals. You’re getting none of that with Kara no Kyoukai, it’s straight up more beautiful even than most of the high budget mainstream stuff.
So yeah, that’s pretty much it. Kara no Kyoukai has a vast majority of the things that people ask for when they start to get tired of the repetition in mainstream anime. If you haven’t found a show that’s really intrigued you in a while or find yourself complaining about the above points then maybe it’s time to give it a shot.
Also when you finish, shoutout to /r/KaranoKyoukai. It’s been slowly developing into a pretty cool community for a while now, and while I don’t really reddit enough any more to take any credit for helping cause that it’s a fun place to go and discuss your thoughts when you’re done.
30
u/77remix https://anilist.co/user/Remi May 13 '16
Just got done watching movie 1, can't wait to watch the rest of them.
Music was god like I have to say
16
u/TRNielson May 13 '16
I have mixed feelings with this series.
From a technical aspect with regards to audio and visual, it is a masterpiece. It's an absolute orgasm for both eyes and ears.
However, for me, in terms of characters and overall plot, I don't find myself enjoying it that much. People like to talk about how Shiki is such an awesome character and this, that, or the other. I've never once seen that. To me, she's just a psycopath. Mikiya is just as bad because he knows she gets a thrill from killing people and he's still head over heels for her. These are our protagonists? Are you sure?
Of the main cast, Touko was the most interesting yet we hardly see her do anything. All she tends to do is provide expositions and explanations, which is a damn shame cause her scenes at the end of Movie 5 show she's a lot smarter and powerful that she lets on for the rest of the series.
The villians were kind of(?) enjoyable, with Fujino in Movie 3 being my favorite. While I liked Souren's presence as this big, bad mothaf**ka, his motivations didn't seem too well fleshed out or explained for me. He wound up reminding me of a certain antagonist from SAO. The villians in Movies 1,6,7 left absolutely no impact on me. While I sympathized with Villian 1, I ultimately didn't care what happened to her.
Ultimately, for me, the hype this series gets felt undeserved. I didn't waste my time watching it but I didn't think it was the absolutely amazing series that a majority of the fanbase makes it out to be. But, I've disagreed with the fanbase on multiple occasions, so it might just be me. Just my thoughts on it.
2
u/[deleted] May 13 '16
As someone who rates the Fate series (anime) about 5-6/10, should I still watch KnK?
4
u/Lycieratia :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ScarletCrescent May 13 '16
As someone who has not invested much time into Type-Moon beyond the Grail Wars of the Fate series, I found KnK extremely difficult to follow in terms of the in-universe technicalities. There are certain organizations and other preexisting supernatural concepts in the Nasuverse, and KnK seems to assume the viewer has read the LNs or is familiar with the verse in general. I had to constantly reference the
dreadedTM wikia in order to understand how certain things worked, and I was never sure whether or not some scenes were asspulls because I didn't have a clear idea on the concepts behind them.For a standalone series, KnK's first movie failed to pull me in years ago before I touched Fate, despite the cinematographic quality and soundtrack (Kajiura was already my favorite composer at the time). There seemed to be way too many concepts thrown at the viewer at once without actually explaining them, then wrapped up the arc in a confusing manner that felt quite sloppy. Only after I found out it was part of a greater universe did I give KnK a second try, and even then I had to force myself through much of it. KnK It was all really difficult to digest and it constantly felt like the series was throwing out concepts and saying here, just accept this. Then again, what was I to expect from a multiverse where one could summon legendary and historical figures alike to a battle royale?
Overall I think the main problem I have with KnK stems from the complexity of the Nasuverse. It's extremely difficult (or downright impossible) to cram in all the information needed to completely understand what's going on into an anime adaption. Fate/stay night adaptions have this similar issue, though less apparent, while Fate/Zero was more or less able to circumvent it entirely by focusing solely on the war itself (with the help of a few info-dump scenes at the beginning). Unlike KnK, Fate Though I've yet to finish reading the route to know for sure, the Heaven's Feel adaption may or may not suffer from the same problem, or it might actually help clear some things up. Or I may just be going off on a tangent entirely, and I didn't need to worry about the technicalities to fully enjoy KnK.
tl;dr someone who has only stepped half-way into the Nasuverse gets overwhelmed by concepts introduced in KnK that assume prior knowledge
3
u/define_irony :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Geejones May 13 '16 edited May 13 '16
I really need to finish this series. I watched up to halfway through the 5th movie and kinda dropped it for no particular reason other than it being too long.
3
u/David182nd :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/david182nd May 13 '16
I tried KnK but I finished movie 3 and I still felt like I had no idea what was going on. Movie 1 just completely passed me by in that respect, but 2 was better as it gave some sort of understandable plot.
Is there some kind of payoff to the non-chronological order that they were made in? Something that makes it so you should watch in that order? I just felt so confused.
11
u/Xarvon :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Xarvon May 13 '16
Well done, KnK deserves more love!
3
u/illtima :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/illuminatima May 13 '16
There's something that usually prevented me from watching this show. It has a reputation for being a little bit... well, fucked up.
4
u/HitsuWTG :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hitsu May 13 '16
I was having huge issues with Kara no Kyoukai just for how terribly inconsistent it was in quality. Movie 5 was the only one that I'd really call good here. 2 was okay. 7 could have been good, until the saliva scene happened. 6 was a mess, while 1, 3 and 4 were just... well, there. The visuals and OST were good, but that's all there was to it for me, really, which is a shame - I wanted to like this.
5
u/kancolle_nigga May 13 '16
Kara no Kyoukai is great. I don't understand why it gets so many hate among anime fans
4
u/[deleted] May 13 '16
I just finished the 8th movie and found this thread! I loved it. 6.8/10 at this point, I do plan to watch Mirai Fukuin and Extra Chorus tho.
3
u/SyntheticValkyrur May 13 '16
A very great read 7teen, and to everyone who wants to discuss this series with more people: "You are welcome in our sub /r/karanokyoukai " :D
2
u/capser22 May 13 '16
Been wanting to watch kara no kyokai for a while now. Cannot find a copy instore in Australia, the supplier madman even told me they aren't printing it anymore, and I'm currently in Japan on holidays and cannot find a copy with English sub anywhere.
Why you so hard to find KnK
2
u/jacool17 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/jacool17 May 13 '16
I'm probably going to watch KnK now, literally right now. thanks for the recommendation.
2
u/Respective https://anilist.co/user/Repective May 13 '16
The 1st movie has been on my PTW for a good while now. I think I'm going to pick it up now.
4
u/Ftimis :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ftimis May 13 '16
I've watched the first 2 movies. While they're undeniably objectively good in terms of aesthetics, both audio and visual, I found myself bored to death. Particularly in the second one, there were moments I was suppressing the urge to skip forward. Can't really say I had any interest for Shiki either.
Maybe the whole package just isn't for me, which is too bad because I was really looking forward to this series.
Edit: I also tried watching the third movie afterwards but couldn't make it and started skipping 10 minutes in, so I really can't say I've watched it.
I've also watched moments from the fifth one.
1
u/[deleted] May 13 '16
WADDUP
1
u/yumcake May 13 '16 edited May 13 '16
That's a hell of a pitch! You've definitely caught my attention. I'll look into this show. Where can I go to get it?
Really, I wish all anime shows had spoiler-free, qualitatively-rich descriptions like this available to me. It'd make it a lot easier to figure out whether or not it's going to eventually produce something I'll want to see if I choose to commit to a show.
1
u/ifonefox :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ifonefox May 13 '16
Good luck getting it legally, though. The Bluray box set costs at least $300 USD.
1
u/TwatBrah May 13 '16
Just lol if you're not watching this movie series
1
u/EBOLANIPPLES May 13 '16
What if I don't want fighting and just want cute girls kissing? :c
1
u/RealityRush :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/RealityRush May 14 '16
I actually just watched this whole series while I was flying back from Japan. It was pretty cool, I enjoyed it. I have been thinking about rating it and having a hard time though, because I wish the whole series was just one entry on MAL instead of the 7 movies. It still all sits unrated because I really don't know how to do so, it's such an odd series. Most of the movies stand on their own, but without the whole series and conclusion, none of it really makes sense sense, so I feel rating them individually is illogical. Honestly, until the final movie, the series makes you feel quite lost while you're trying to figure out what the hell is going on. That can be a positive or a negative I suppose... but I think in the end the ride was worth it. It certainly kept me thinking and curious, and I even think a rewatch is in order at some point to try and catch everything I missed.
I do think the show had its weak parts, namely the 6th movie felt a little out-of-place and the Epilogue was a complete was of my time that just rehashed the same themes already laid out in the movie. I don't think the 5th was as strong as everyone else seems to, and I enjoyed 1/2/4/7 more. Overall though, I enjoyed most of it, and to be honest, I have to give the show credit for tricking me by the end. I thought I knew, I didn't.
The characters are certainly interesting and have some weird fucking outlooks on life, the two MCs are just completely hopeless, lol. I am always a sucker for an anime with a properly concluded ending, and KnK had that. Shiki is someone you could certainly do an interesting character study on. The music/visuals were obvious fantastic. Just overall a good show.
I'm tempted to buy the blu-ray myself, but lack of an English dub (which from the sounds of it will never happen) and more importantly the $400 price point make me hesitate. That's more expensive than some friggin' figures I own. I'll have to think hard on this one, and I already have been to some extent.
-2
u/MightyDave May 13 '16
It's okay. A lot of the dialogue was pretentious and didn't really mean anything. The action scenes and art was amazing though, but it's Ufotable so that goes without saying
-11
u/notveryhardboiled May 13 '16
Dont tell me what ive been lookig for. If you knew what i was looking for you wouldnt have suggested this.
Just suggest things c'mon..
0
u/[deleted] May 13 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment