Thing about flying witch is it really seemed like a labor of love for J C Staff. It even seems they delayed episode 11 for a week to do justice with extra detail work for what is the most visually stunning chapter from the manga so far. This combined with other things like rippling water in a puddle cause by a certain something along with character portrayals among others. It really shows they cared about this project.
Nice review! Flying Witch is definitely one of my AOTS and an excellent show to unwind to. As a side note, the manga is relatively easy to read for Japanese-language learners as it includes furigana. The only difficulties are in the lore/world building parts.
Also, you kind of touched in your review, but Flying Witch also has this underlying tension in regards to modernity and change. In Aomori, Makoto is in an environment where time is staggered (not stagnant) - change is present but slow, unlike the fast-paced nature of Yokohama. Nature is emphasized and sterilized to create this ideal rustic life in the countryside where Makoto (and the others) is in control; a place free of conflict and the hustle-and-bustle of city life.
I'm kind of cringing at the idea of this very 'anime' anime being called 'not-so-anime' as though it is some kind of compliment. It has the clumsy good-hearted protagonist and her lazy yet talented sister and the bratty little girl and heck, the token male character in all his serene one-dimensional glory.
No, I think that Flying Witch has plenty of merit elsewhere. What I think is that, in the vein of Harry Potter, by surrounding the various bits of magic with mundane rural life, it makes the magic seem more incredible relatively speaking.
Sorry for the late reply, things got in the way and then I forgot.
I may have been looking through my AOTY goggles a bit too much when writing the title and I agree with most of your points to some extent. However, I wouldn't call Kei one-dimensional. Sure, he isn't the most layered of characters, but certainly different from generic self-insert characters most harems etc. tend to have.
Just finished it yesterday. I really enjoyed the characters and the relaxed atmosphere. It's become one of my favourite anime and I really wish for a second season
The soundtrack is composed by Dewa Yoshiaki, the same guy that did Nagi no Asukara's, I keep listening to it regularly when I want some peaceful music.
Well, I'm sold! I watched Amanchu instead of Flying Witch for my comfy anime of the season in summer (and it became one of my favorite anime of all time), but with all the hype sequels coming up, I could definitely use a show like Flying Witch to calm me down. I've heard a lot of good things about it, and I'm sure I'll love it. :)
AotY for me. Is this necessarily the most ambitious anime ever?
No.
But in terms of knowing what it wants to be (max comfy), it's execution was near-flawless. I really can't think of anything more it could've done be more comfy.
As boring as I thought it was at some points, I don't regret watching Flying Witch. Great stress reliever, and had some awesome feel good moments. Nice WT, btw!
On a side note, yeah, I don't really agree with that Digibro video. Even if there is fanservice (which I don't think there is, bc there definitely is a difference between being dressed and undressed, its not just "changing some textures and colours"), it doesn't really detract from the show imo. When I watched the show, intuitively, I didn't see the characters as sex objects, even though their designs may imply that. They felt like real people doing comfy things.
I think my biggest problem with the Digibro video that he's acting like Amanchu and Flying Witch were really that similar in their presentation. There are a few specific outfits in Flying Witch that suffer from the 'too form fitting' argument but even he had to know how much that was heavily Amanchu focussed with how few clips of Flying Witch he used in that entire section of it. The school uniforms were actually unflattering (not awful) in Flying Witch, which you can see in the video, and the rest of the outfits mostly comprise of fairly baggy or loose fitting clothes that (as someone who has many friends who regularly update their wardrobe) looked only slightly better than the somewhat decent quality, well fitting clothes you'll get if you are into clothes shopping.
The main characters were attractive girls, but that's nothing new or special about any visual mediums. It is very widely true.
I wouldn't really call fanservice turning women into sex objects anyway, unless it's way over the top. I dare say even in most harem shows women don't become just sex objects.
Fair point. Context also matters too. Yoko from Gurren Lagaan and Major Kusanagi from Ghost in the Shell come to mind. There's a degree of sexualizing them, but it actually adds to the show because it's there to add a liberal and independent attitude to the character.
And yeah, fanservice can't COMPLETELY turn a character into just a sex object, but there is at least degree where it becomes part of their identity.
I spent the summer of 2016 recommending this show to people who were going through depression and people on r/SuicideWatch. The effect that a simple show about the daily life of a witch in highschool can have on a person is amazing.
I really really miss clapping along with the opening song.
I also recommend watching Ichigo Mashimaro if you are looking something thats a cross between Flying Witch and Yuru Yuri.
Non Non Biyori. Country life with young kids (elementary and junior high).
Aria. Rather than a country life; it takes place in a replica of Venice on Mars.
Not necessarily the same feeling. Gin no Saji/Silver Spoon is a story of a young man who decides to escape to an agricultural school in the country side. There's a bit more drama compared to the other series. I've only read the manga so I'm not sure how much the anime takes advantage of the environment.
I know some people definitely enjoy this show, but I just could not get into it. There are some shows that I enjoy the entire time, other shows that I have to watch at faster speeds (usually like 1.2x) and there are some shows that I progressively speed up in order to finish episodes (going up to 1.6x or higher). This show was the latter until I just couldn't deal with it and dropped it. I don't think I'm a fan of 'comfy' :/
This is the only anime which the brother/sister were not annoying/troublesome. In fact I was excited every time the little sister came on the screen! Everything she did was oh so loveable that I wish I was related to her too!
The only thing that annoyed the hell out of this anime is the Spring Fairy guy? Yeah, he's pretty favored in the opening but only has about 8 minutes of screen time. What's up with that!?
29
u/max_comfy https://anilist.co/user/maxcomfy Jan 02 '17
This anime is maximally comfy.
25
u/Skynet_0 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Skynet_0 Jan 02 '17
Just finished this over the new year. Really good relaxation anime.
I don't know why I loved this so much but all the characters' mouths look like cat mouths like a little '3'. That was so cute for some strange reason.
34
u/thrilllex Jan 02 '17
One of my favorite shows of the year. Love the soundtrack and the show in general. I knew I would love the show right from the first episode.
13
u/heimdal77 Jan 02 '17 edited Jan 02 '17
Thing about flying witch is it really seemed like a labor of love for J C Staff. It even seems they delayed episode 11 for a week to do justice with extra detail work for what is the most visually stunning chapter from the manga so far. This combined with other things like rippling water in a puddle cause by a certain something along with character portrayals among others. It really shows they cared about this project.
13
u/gst4158 Jan 02 '17
Shalalala
11
u/myriad_truths :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TrainerOfLegend Jan 02 '17
This show has been on my radar for a while. I like the idea of watching a relaxing show.
8
u/l3eater Jan 02 '17
Nice review! Flying Witch is definitely one of my AOTS and an excellent show to unwind to. As a side note, the manga is relatively easy to read for Japanese-language learners as it includes furigana. The only difficulties are in the lore/world building parts.
Also, you kind of touched in your review, but Flying Witch also has this underlying tension in regards to modernity and change. In Aomori, Makoto is in an environment where time is staggered (not stagnant) - change is present but slow, unlike the fast-paced nature of Yokohama. Nature is emphasized and sterilized to create this ideal rustic life in the countryside where Makoto (and the others) is in control; a place free of conflict and the hustle-and-bustle of city life.
7
u/zenithfury Jan 03 '17 edited Jan 03 '17
I'm kind of cringing at the idea of this very 'anime' anime being called 'not-so-anime' as though it is some kind of compliment. It has the clumsy good-hearted protagonist and her lazy yet talented sister and the bratty little girl and heck, the token male character in all his serene one-dimensional glory.
No, I think that Flying Witch has plenty of merit elsewhere. What I think is that, in the vein of Harry Potter, by surrounding the various bits of magic with mundane rural life, it makes the magic seem more incredible relatively speaking.
6
u/SoaringPhoenix321 Jan 02 '17
Just finished it yesterday. I really enjoyed the characters and the relaxed atmosphere. It's become one of my favourite anime and I really wish for a second season
15
u/Atronox :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Atronox Jan 02 '17
Really great show, I love shows like Non Non Biyori with the countryside feel.
All the characters were fun in their own way. Chinatsu was adorable in her live for Matoko and her magic.
8
u/NotYourAverageJoey Jan 02 '17
One of my favorites of last year and that OP, Sha la la laaaaa
4
u/frnxt Jan 02 '17
The soundtrack is composed by Dewa Yoshiaki, the same guy that did Nagi no Asukara's, I keep listening to it regularly when I want some peaceful music.
4
u/blinky64 Jan 02 '17
http://webmshare.com/1wWvL
4
u/NovaBlue142 https://anilist.co/user/NovaBlue Jan 02 '17
Well, I'm sold! I watched Amanchu instead of Flying Witch for my comfy anime of the season in summer (and it became one of my favorite anime of all time), but with all the hype sequels coming up, I could definitely use a show like Flying Witch to calm me down. I've heard a lot of good things about it, and I'm sure I'll love it. :)
4
u/PPGN_DM_Exia https://myanimelist.net/profile/PPGN_DM_Exia Jan 03 '17
AotY for me. Is this necessarily the most ambitious anime ever?
No.
But in terms of knowing what it wants to be (max comfy), it's execution was near-flawless. I really can't think of anything more it could've done be more comfy.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 02 '17 edited Jan 02 '17
As boring as I thought it was at some points, I don't regret watching Flying Witch. Great stress reliever, and had some awesome feel good moments. Nice WT, btw!
On a side note, yeah, I don't really agree with that Digibro video. Even if there is fanservice (which I don't think there is, bc there definitely is a difference between being dressed and undressed, its not just "changing some textures and colours"), it doesn't really detract from the show imo. When I watched the show, intuitively, I didn't see the characters as sex objects, even though their designs may imply that. They felt like real people doing comfy things.
6
u/sarkarnor Jan 02 '17
Sold. Will watch next. Thanks :)
6
u/Kronosfear :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/WizardOfAce Jan 02 '17
I spent the summer of 2016 recommending this show to people who were going through depression and people on r/SuicideWatch. The effect that a simple show about the daily life of a witch in highschool can have on a person is amazing.
I really really miss clapping along with the opening song.
I also recommend watching Ichigo Mashimaro if you are looking something thats a cross between Flying Witch and Yuru Yuri.
3
u/Jagin26 Jan 02 '17
Relaxing Witch is Sooo smooth
5
u/RainInsane :AMQ: Jan 02 '17
Probably the most relaxing show of 2016 next to Tanaka-kun.
2
u/stopreplay Jan 03 '17
What would be some good recommendation for anime like this? I love the country side SOL feeling.
2
u/topurrisfeline Jan 03 '17
Not a fan of the iyashikei genre here, had to struggle to finish Aria. And I still loved Flying Witch, surprisingly.
2
u/Convolutionist :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/convolutionist Jan 03 '17
I know some people definitely enjoy this show, but I just could not get into it. There are some shows that I enjoy the entire time, other shows that I have to watch at faster speeds (usually like 1.2x) and there are some shows that I progressively speed up in order to finish episodes (going up to 1.6x or higher). This show was the latter until I just couldn't deal with it and dropped it. I don't think I'm a fan of 'comfy' :/
2
u/KaalVeiten Jan 03 '17
Really sad they didn't get to the rabbit in the anime. Maybe we get an ova of it.
1
u/VritraReiRei Jan 03 '17
This is the only anime which the brother/sister were not annoying/troublesome. In fact I was excited every time the little sister came on the screen! Everything she did was oh so loveable that I wish I was related to her too!
The only thing that annoyed the hell out of this anime is the Spring Fairy guy? Yeah, he's pretty favored in the opening but only has about 8 minutes of screen time. What's up with that!?
-1
u/Kizrock94 Jan 03 '17
Does this have yuri?