I mean, I get what you're trying to do OP, but you have to do better than that. You gave absolutely no reason to watch the show.
The TL;DR of what you said is this: People either hate it or love it. The soundtrack and animation are great!
While Guilty Crown does get a fair amount of hate, it actually also gets a lot of respect for the soundtrack, and I honestly can't recall anyone talking smack about the animation.
So in reality, you are not giving any good reason to watch the show. If you want people to try and give the show a try despite the hate for it here on the board, you could at least put in some effort, you know?
This is true, but as a tl:dr for a decent reason to watch it from my perspective.
The power? Is pretty interesting and it explores Lord of the Flies type of themes of kids running the place and shit like that. Won't go too much further in for spoilers.
No, people talk about the visuals almost like they're the best thing since sliced bread, they are good but there are tons of shows with better visuals that are actually good.
Watch FLCL, it has better visuals, better music and it's damn fun.
just.... just be prepared to drop it really quick if you find yourself disliking the second arch. I gave it too much of a chance and the second arch completely ruined the first for me. everything in the first arch has a method and madness association where nothing really makes sense but its happening in a very good storytelling fashion. then the resolution happens for the first arch and the writers had no where to go so they start bending rules making shit up and just contradicting themselves left and right. If i had dropped it sooner I would be able to rewatch the first arch but since I stuck with it until it was unbearable for me I can't do it
This so much. I loved the first half of the series. 9/10 for me. But then episode 11 (or 12 don't remember) came, and from then on it just turned to shit. 4/10 for the second half. As far as I can remember, the only other anime that made me feel this frustrated was Charlotte.
I remembered my experience on guilty crown and dropped charlotte episode 2 when i saw the gap between episode 1 and 2. I also dropped akiba's trip this season because i'm worried at how good episode one was and how meh episode 2 and 3 were. GC is the only rating below 3 I have on my MAL besides panty and stocking but thats for other reasons
I love Guilty Crown and I don't even think the ending is/was bad however can't say the same about this shit spoiler.
Guilty Crown has A LOT of symbols and themes which go lost for the average viewer. There's a lot of things going on with the cat's cradle and the soul in general.
I think most people would notice that there's a lot of hidden meaning in Guilty Crown but forget about it when they go salty over the ending and plot twist lol
Also introduced me to redjuice and EGOiST so I'm all glad :>
I was surprised to find the second half not only better than the first (it's much more focused), Shu's change makes sense in the situation he's in. It just wasn't strong enough. I've been engaged right up to episode 18 (where I've stopped for now) to see what people mean by anime Hitler, to see if anyone calls Shu out, and then having unwanted sympathy when he says he knows he's being an edgy jerklord.
That said, the cold Hitler Shu is far better than the timid, passive version. At least he's being proactive. The change is a good one, and shock horror, I wanted him to kick the treacherous students asses when
The biggest problem is Inori. How does she know Shu? Why the hell would she be in love with him. Her brief moments of sadism come off as trying too hard.
It's hit and miss - Gai and FP have believable motivations, Shu is just a generic spineless MC until he changes, then apparently reverts back
Fantastic soundtrack aside, the light tones, the voids, virus crystals and character designs are really good.
Yep. He's a god. His soundtracks are always amazing, especially his Aldnoah Zero one, which I happen to have downloaded like 13 songs from. Then you have Kill la Kill, Kabaneri of the Iron Fortress, The 7 Deadly Sins, Attack on Titan, and the list goes on. He's definitely the best soundtrack composer in anime right now.
I sometimes feel like I should watch GC, but the disappointment of other people who've seen it stops me (and I don't like GC).
I listen to the OST though, got to enjoy that Sawano goodness (βίος / Bios). As a Korean watcher said, in Korea the show is nicknamed "BGM Crown" for the epic soundtrack.
9
u/Saya_:MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Saya999Jan 22 '17edited Jan 22 '17
Honestly I think people are just being overdramatic of how bad it is and are/were riding on every else's opinions like it was a meme. I watched it while airing and was there for all the discussion threads and you'd have people sticking around till like episode 12 and being like "omg this is so shit how can anyone watch this". Then you read the episode 22 discussion and it's the same people "omg lolll this is so shit, I'm just here for the music I swear". Like the most boring and witless commentary just so that they could express their weirdly obsessive hatred.
GC has a pretty good premise, but it suffers from poor execution at times. Sometimes I think it's cause it tries too hard to be cool/dark/deep with plot points that it became convoluted, prioritising it's "image" over things like character development and a well put together story. But that doesn't mean it wasn't entertaining or impossible to follow. I may even rewatch it sometime so I can experience it without the immediate influence of others.
I would say watch it, if only to be able to form your own opinion. It's first episode is quite easy to digest too and I don't think it was such a bad representation of what the rest of the show was like. Just don't expect a masterpiece.
Oh man its been a minute since I've seen it but I loved the hell out of it... That is, until the very end where it seems a couple of characters develop ridiculous reasons for GC spoilers
Like another user said, you give no reason to watch the show, and I don't think there's any.
It's visually good but for me there not anything outstanding, it's more shinny visuals than actually impressive animation. Almost anything Gainax beats GC in the visual department and they are shows that actually have good story and characters.
Same for the music, I personally don't like EGOIST much but it's perfectly understandable that some do and I'd recommend them to listen to the OST on youtube instead of wasting their time watching 24 episodes.
This series is great. I had a hard time forcing myself to finally watch it because of those haters who spend most of their free-time finding new things to complain about (probably the same guys who cry about SAO), but in the end I started it and had such a blast that I binge watched it in 2 days. This thought me not to make any opinions about the shows based on complaints of the others. I really recommend this one!
I finished it. Promising start. Haphazard, confusing, and bombastic end. I didn't like it. The plot is just plain incoherent, and there simply was no logical flow. I wouldn't recommend people to watch it.
Anyone have an opinion about which is the best train wreck out of Guilty Crown, Mirai Nikki and Valvrave? I've had most of the plot to all of them spoiled already so I've just been putting them off.
45
u/MagicalForeignBunny Jan 22 '17
I mean, I get what you're trying to do OP, but you have to do better than that. You gave absolutely no reason to watch the show.
The TL;DR of what you said is this: People either hate it or love it. The soundtrack and animation are great!
While Guilty Crown does get a fair amount of hate, it actually also gets a lot of respect for the soundtrack, and I honestly can't recall anyone talking smack about the animation.
So in reality, you are not giving any good reason to watch the show. If you want people to try and give the show a try despite the hate for it here on the board, you could at least put in some effort, you know?
11
u/gopivot :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/gopivot Jan 22 '17
feel like the only reason that i gonna watch Guitly Crown is for visual art and music would it be worth it?
10
u/tryingthisok Jan 22 '17
Krone is amazing.
8
u/xFatty :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/xFatty Jan 22 '17
I love Guilty Crown and I don't even think the ending is/was bad however can't say the same about this shit spoiler.
Guilty Crown has A LOT of symbols and themes which go lost for the average viewer. There's a lot of things going on with the cat's cradle and the soul in general.
I think most people would notice that there's a lot of hidden meaning in Guilty Crown but forget about it when they go salty over the ending and plot twist lol
Also introduced me to redjuice and EGOiST so I'm all glad :>
6
u/Komnenos_Kasuki :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kirulas Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 22 '17
I was surprised to find the second half not only better than the first (it's much more focused), Shu's change makes sense in the situation he's in. It just wasn't strong enough. I've been engaged right up to episode 18 (where I've stopped for now) to see what people mean by anime Hitler, to see if anyone calls Shu out, and then having unwanted sympathy when he says he knows he's being an edgy jerklord.
That said, the cold Hitler Shu is far better than the timid, passive version. At least he's being proactive. The change is a good one, and shock horror, I wanted him to kick the treacherous students asses when
The biggest problem is Inori. How does she know Shu? Why the hell would she be in love with him. Her brief moments of sadism come off as trying too hard.
It's hit and miss - Gai and FP have believable motivations, Shu is just a generic spineless MC until he changes, then apparently reverts back
Fantastic soundtrack aside, the light tones, the voids, virus crystals and character designs are really good.
5
u/iamfvckingdone :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/iamfvckingdone Jan 22 '17
This anime is the reason why i know about Sawano Hiroyuki.
5
u/MaximalDisguised https://myanimelist.net/profile/MaximalDisguised Jan 22 '17
This is a better write down.
5
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17
The anime had such a cool premise and it feels super wasted on what it ended up showing off.
2
u/creamyhorror Jan 22 '17 edited Jan 22 '17
I sometimes feel like I should watch GC, but the disappointment of other people who've seen it stops me (and I don't like GC).
I listen to the OST though, got to enjoy that Sawano goodness (βίος / Bios). As a Korean watcher said, in Korea the show is nicknamed "BGM Crown" for the epic soundtrack.
2
u/Verone0 Jan 22 '17
Oh man its been a minute since I've seen it but I loved the hell out of it... That is, until the very end where it seems a couple of characters develop ridiculous reasons for GC spoilers
2
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17
Like another user said, you give no reason to watch the show, and I don't think there's any.
It's visually good but for me there not anything outstanding, it's more shinny visuals than actually impressive animation. Almost anything Gainax beats GC in the visual department and they are shows that actually have good story and characters.
Same for the music, I personally don't like EGOIST much but it's perfectly understandable that some do and I'd recommend them to listen to the OST on youtube instead of wasting their time watching 24 episodes.
2
u/bananeeek https://myanimelist.net/profile/bananek Jan 22 '17
This series is great. I had a hard time forcing myself to finally watch it because of those haters who spend most of their free-time finding new things to complain about (probably the same guys who cry about SAO), but in the end I started it and had such a blast that I binge watched it in 2 days. This thought me not to make any opinions about the shows based on complaints of the others. I really recommend this one!
2
u/M4DM1ND Jan 22 '17
I rate it slightly above meh. I don't feel like I wasted time watching it but it was far from the greatest thing I've ever seen.
3
u/Kyraira Jan 22 '17
I did like the show!
2
u/nivvd Jan 22 '17
It is sincerely not the worst thing ever. It's for lack of better word pretty average with amazing visuals. Still worth a watch though.
1
u/reddadz x3https://anilist.co/user/MysticEyes Jan 22 '17
I don't really care for the show itself but it gave me my favorite Sawano soundtrack so yes, watch it just for that.
1
u/GoldRedBlue Jan 22 '17
The Apocalypse Virus as a concept is real interesting.
If you've played Command & Conquer or Metroid Prime, you're gonna get some real familiar Tiberium/Phazon vibes from it.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17
I finished it. Promising start. Haphazard, confusing, and bombastic end. I didn't like it. The plot is just plain incoherent, and there simply was no logical flow. I wouldn't recommend people to watch it.
1
u/[deleted] Jan 22 '17
Amazing OST's! Must listen!!!!!!!
1
u/NekoWafers Jan 22 '17
Anyone have an opinion about which is the best train wreck out of Guilty Crown, Mirai Nikki and Valvrave? I've had most of the plot to all of them spoiled already so I've just been putting them off.
1
u/BlatantConservative :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/BlatantC Jan 22 '17
How's the dub?
1
u/ShikiRyumaho :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Chaostrooper Jan 22 '17
There are only a few anime like this. Most of its kind are just boring, but this one is so bad it's good. I recommend this non-sensical shitshow.