r/anime • u/Cowabungaaaaa :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/StandAtTheHeroes • Mar 29 '17
[WT!] Rokka No Yuusha
Rokka No Yuusha, or Rokka: Braves of the Six Flowers, is categorized by MAL as an action, adventure, fantasy, mystery, magic show.
I would pretty much just call it fantasy action mystery, but the other parts are true, just less so.
The show is probably best at the action part, the fantasy world is barely explored, and the mystery takes a backseat at many points.
First of all, the ending is trash. Not talking about the conclusion of the mystery, but the end of the last episode. Let's just say it completely invalidates everything that happened in the series. It's just a shitty setup for a second season that never came, so if you want a complete story, leave now, this isn't one.
It is however, a fantasy action show with a locked room mystery plot.
Plot:
The premise is pretty simple, the demon king is awakening/reviving or something, not that it matters, and six heroes, the titular Six Braves, will be chosen by this goddess. The main character, Adlet Mayer, the self proclaimed strongest man in the world, wants to join, and after some stuff ends up having the symbol appear on his hand, and heading off to join the to join the other braves, meets some people, and eventually all seven of them meet up at a temple, and someone sets off a trap that keeps them there. Yup, seven. That's the main overarching plot of the show and the mystery element. It's a locked room mystery, someone set off the barrier keeping them there, and they's trying to figure out who that person is. The plot is decent, the reveal has some nice callbacks to throwaway lines that referred to it, it's far from the best mystery ever created, but it was good. If you're really into going through each episode carefully and figuring it out beforehand I'm not sure if that's possible, but if you just want to sit back and enjoy the show it's fine. Most of what happens in the rest of the show is character interactions and fighting, since of course they start fighting amongst themselves as they suspect different people. There are some plotholes and weird decisions, but I think most of the decisions fit the characters.
Before I get into characters, I want to mention the magic system. It's a bunch of women(only women can become them) called Saint of blank. Saint of blades, Saint of Swamps, etc. They have some abilities related and some that are a bit of a stretch from their "theme" for lack of a better term. It's a pretty poor magic system if you want consistency, but is flashy and definitely not bad.
Characters:
I actually really like the main character. He's a lot more logical and intelligent than the typical action show protagonist, but naive and human enough that he's clearly flawed and makes some bad decisions. His fights are also really cool.
The rest of the characters are a weird and unique cast. You've got the OP loli, the bunny girl, the overprotective childhood friend of one of them, the catboy, and a few others. I'm not going to get into them, I had this whole section written out, but decided it's more fun for people to meet them, and was a bit of a spoiler. I generally liked them, Fremy was pretty boring, but the others were unique enough to make for fun interactions. In general the characters carry the show, since the plot tends to take a backseat many times. They are all distinct, with their own motivations and reasons for why they act the way they do. It has a romance subplot nearer the end, I wasn't personally a fan of it at all, but I generally didn't like the love interest, so maybe I was biased.
Action:
Okay, this part is my favorite. I'm a giant sucker for cool super power fights, and this show mostly delivers. The CG of the monster they fight for the first part isn't great, but when they start fighting amongst themselves it's great, and Adlet's opening fight was absolutely beautiful. The animation is nice, it definitely falls off hard later in the show, though I still enjoyed it, and the choreography is pretty good. The powers look cool, I won't spoil all that they can do, but it's mostly flashy attacks, except for one of the saints who's a bit different. The characters that don't have powers still have a theme going on, or a generally cool fighting style, the main character definitely fights differently from the typical action show protagonists, more of a bag of tricks type style.
In general, the show is a cool action show with a locked room mystery plot and a bunch of weird and quirky characters, and does a good job with tension. I would recommend it to anyone who likes a "who dun it" story but also wants lots of exciting action. I expect hardcore mystery fans will not enjoy it, but if you want action and like the mystery as a hook it's pretty awesome.
I would love some constructive criticism, I tend to ramble when writing, and generally don't have a ton of experience writing these, just written a few before. I also really wish reddit allowed for a better view of your post without installing add-ons. But yeah, please comment on which parts are good/bad, and why.
"If you want to be strong, smile! He who can smile, even when he's so sad that he wants to die, when it's so painful that he wants to give it all up and run away, is the one who becomes strong."
23
u/derpinat0rz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/derpinat0rz Mar 30 '17
Needs another season.
42
u/PPGN_DM_Exia https://myanimelist.net/profile/PPGN_DM_Exia Mar 30 '17
Surprised by all the negative comments. Honestly, I thought it was a pretty unique series with both fantasy action and mystery. Wasn't a fan of ending, but that's what you get from a lot of incomplete adaptations.
13
u/PM_YOUR_PETITE_TITS Mar 30 '17
watched it while airing and loved every second of it, sadly it wont have another season never
10
u/Falsus Mar 30 '17
Since it is the very last part I just choice to ignore that it ever happened.
But yeah the show was pretty good, and I loved the weekly discussion threads about the mystery.
31
u/Aryzal Mar 30 '17
I loved this - it has everything I wanted, mystery, human vs human (or at least battle among protagonists)and a ton of actions. They aren't against mooks (most of the time) and the tension is strong. I immediately looked for the LN afterwards, and loved it, though it became very thick at times.
8
u/bakakubi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bakakubi Mar 30 '17
Still one if my favorite series of all time. A same that its not all that popular in Japan.
4
u/Painn23 Mar 29 '17
Have you read the LN's
3
u/Yu-sempai :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Yu-senpai Mar 29 '17
I saw one episode of this a while back, and dropped it. You've actually convinced me to give it another try, since I love the "mystery" element enough that even if the logic is half assed I can enjoy it if the suspense is there.
I'm pretty new here and definitely no expert but this seemed like a good WT! (I mean it convinced me). I always feel like these are hard to write, since I always tend to mention spoilers when I discuss an Anime I've seen. This seems like just enough to give a much better premise than a synopsis, without spoiling anything.
I tried to write one of these once, and I found the same problem you mentioned of rambling on. The length wasn't overwhelming so I think leaving out a detailed character description was a good idea, not only to shorten it, but to leave curiosity. I have a pretty concrete image of what the show might be like, all that's left is to watch it.
Honestly I should probably be taking notes on this, so I'm not the best person to review it aha. Nice job in my opinion XD
2
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '17 edited Mar 30 '17
Hey cute shy girl with emotional problems, its me the generic mc, like I totally met you yesterday but I love you.
I finished the anime but that scene was pure cancer.
17
u/Dragon_Yeti Mar 30 '17 edited Mar 30 '17
I watched it when it first aired and enjoyed discussing the mystery aspects with my friends. The show could have benefitted from a second cour to elaborate on the last couple of minutes of the final episode. I am an anime only viewer for this one but I've heard that there is considerably more to everything than we were given during the show itself.
6
u/DimmuHS https://myanimelist.net/profile/DimmuOli Mar 30 '17 edited Mar 30 '17
You know, RnY was an anime that watched out of nowhere, when I have a HUGE hiatus since the last anime I watched (5 years or more), I don't know if it was the sensation of watching anime again, but I really liked this anime.
The main character can be annoying for some people with his repetitive line he says time to time, but I didn't mind it, because he actually tries hard to be stronger, so, it's not like he's covering his weakness. So in the end, I liked the MC, he's honest with his philosophy, kinda dumb but smart and tough in his own way.
The other characters are interesting aswell, with their own made up minds and so different from each other. It's makes the mystery more engaging. You kinda like someone and then you realise: "wait could it be him? or is it her?" Like, you symphathize with them. They're not boring and you never know what to expect really. I wasn't trying hard to discover and the show keep me at it.
Don't truly agree with people telling that the mystery is a joke and that it's really easy to discover everything. Maybe it's just me, but I really didn't want to solve it. I wanted to watch every episode expecting what's going to happen next, because the series of events are all relevants: the dialogue, their expressions, their actions, and to top it off, their battles (and mindbattles++).
Sometimes I questioned myself why I rewatched this more than 5 times (and on specific episodes only), and I figure out that it's more about the characters and their reactions, than the mystery itself. Of course I just hit the LN right after and the history becomes much more interesting, like, the anime is just the tip of the iceberg, the character development has a HUGE increase, even though the writing is kinda lacking (compairing it with spice and wolf writing, it is actually a joke).
Too bad it's not getting a S2, The characters are the best in the show, fights are average but fun, the dialogues are great and time passes so fast when you watch this (that means it's good right?)
Ahh and fremy best girl!
6
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '17 edited Mar 30 '17
Such a pity the rest of the series won't be animated. The author knows how to write a really damn intense and gripping story without relying on "anime" tropes.
1
u/Eyliel Mar 30 '17
While I wasn't a fan of some of the... personal opinions you expressed, it's great to see a recommendation of this series here.
1
u/zuruka Mar 30 '17
It is a big shame that after a really good adaptation of the author's first series, Tatakau Shisho, Rokka No Yuusha started off so badly that we might not see the rest of the series.
If anyone is interested in the author's style, I highly recommend that you check out the anime adaptation of Tatakau Shisho. It is a really good adaptation; the series itself is in many ways quite similar to Rokka No Yuusha.
1
u/Squidiscipline Mar 30 '17
I watched it as it aired and did enjoy it a fair bit for the most part, particularly the mystery elements, but that ending really bothered me.
The comments on this post have convinced me to check out its unlikely to exist sequel should it come out though.
3
u/zz2000 Mar 30 '17
The anime only adapts Vol 1 of the story.
Vols 2-6 (from what I hear) contains more action and fights, but also raises the dramatic tension of who the new traitor is across the 4 books.
The author only releases 1 vol a year.
1
u/the1Rabbit :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/surugamonkey Mar 29 '17
Hmm, it never really came together for me (2 eps) but the character designs are cool.
2
u/ZeroAika99 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ZeroAikatsu99 Mar 30 '17
The white girl is such a waifu
2
u/Yamilord Mar 30 '17
Was not a fan, characters felt bland and the traitor was obvious to me :/.
2
u/AgentPhantom Mar 30 '17
I fucking loved this series so much, and I actually had no issues at all with the ending. I just wish the resolution to the mystery was done a little better, felt a little undercooked, imo.
0
u/DarkPrinny Mar 30 '17
Feel like it has been so long. I felt like the potential was there but the whole "mystery half" dragged on and on. I honestly felt like it could have been presented in 2 episodes rather than over half of the whole series.
That was my only complaint really. To be honest it is very forgettable and not something people will remember very well.
0
u/Not_Sure11 Mar 30 '17
It was so dragged out than it needed to be, to the point where the "Surprise" wasn't really that much of a surprise and more of a "Thank you! now we can go forward with the plot but oh wait".
1
u/MrTripStack Mar 30 '17
I loved the show the entire way through. Probably even one of my favorites from its season.
Of course the final two minutes of the last episode would piss a lot of people off, but I actually had that twist spoiled for me early on, so I wasn't too bothered by it.
I wish we'd get another season, but I plan on picking up the novels at some point.
1
u/KyojinJaeger :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ErenxMikasa Mar 30 '17
I read the summaries of the LN after the season finished and I hate how the writer explained the 7th and immediately lost interest.
-1
u/Inevitable3 :AMQ: Mar 30 '17
Watched it when it first aired and I can say that this was show was a waste of time.
-2
u/AlexxJoshee :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/OneTrueJojo Mar 29 '17
Does it have a dub?
No.
1
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '17
[removed] — view removed comment