r/anime • u/the_swizzler https://myanimelist.net/profile/Swiftarm • Apr 18 '17
[WT!] Bang Dream!
Posting my first WT! thread about a show I've been very passionate about this season. MRN
One of the things I love most about watching seasonal anime is finding shows that I've never heard of, that no one has ever watched before, and realizing that they're actually really good. It's very much like being an explorer. Or posting 'FIRST' on a popular Youtube video. This season, that feeling has been exemplified by BanG Dream!
What's it about?
At first glance, Bang Dream might look very similar to K-On, and to be fair, I frequently use K-On as a shortcut when describing BanG Dream, but it's so much more than that. While I'm not a musician myself (though I did pay a little bass when I was younger), I suspect anyone who is, or is at least interested in music, will appreciate this series. In my opinion, it does a much better job of showing what it actually is like trying to learn an instrument for the first time.
Our main character, Toyoma Kasumi is an energetic girl with the desire to find what she calls a 'Star Beat', a certain something that sets her heart racing. Through the course of the first third of the series, she'll find that beat, and will become inspired to start a band with various class-mates.
How does it stand out?
BanG Dream! is extremely strong in both characterization and character interactions. Most of the main characters are great on their own, but putting them together is always hilarious and heartwarming. Kasumi especially is an extremely well developed character. She spends most of her time being a boundless bundle of genki, but also has some extremely well directed moments of self-reflection and responsibility. The Keyboardist, Arisa is a wonderful example of a straight man that goes up against Kasumi's genki-girl shenanigans, and O-Tae, the lead guitarist, absolutely nails what I like to call a 'subdued genki' type of character. Trust me, it makes sense if you watch her. While less notable, but stil good characters, the bassist Rimi and drummer Saaya are both lovely characters that balance out the rest of the group. Saaya especially has her own very meaningful arc. The drama in this show is also one of it's strong points. When things go wrong, the issues and their solutions are usually meaningful and even relatable.
The music is also very well done for this show. Particularly in the way it's presented. Kasumi is not some musical savant who can master anything in a week. She starts out picking individual notes to Twinkle Twinkle Little Star, and then through dedicated hard work and practice, learns to passably play Rhythm guitar. The sound Director for this show, Toshiki Kameyama has many noteworthy shows under his belt, including 3-Gatsu no Lion, Hidamari Sketch, Mahou Shoujo Lyrical Nanoha, Non Non Biyori, Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei, and Nisekoi.
Ok, what's the catch?
I frequently compare this show to a fusion of K-On and Hibike! Euphonium. It's very much like K-On in both the premise and the comedy, but the drama and art style remind me more of Hibike!. Unfortunately, the animation quality does not inherit from those two shows. The CGI bits in the performances will be hit or miss with people, though personally I think they're generally fairly well done. Certainly nothing like Hibike or A-1 Pictures Idolm@ster. For the most part, the animation is pretty average though, but all of it's positives more than make up for that.
Miscellaneous thoughts
The director of BanG Dream!, Atsushi Ootsuki, appears to be involved quite heavily with the show's studio Xebec, and is also the main director for much of the To LOVE-Ru series. Despite Ecchi shows making up a not insignificant body of his previous directing work, BanG Dream! manages to be extremely tame, avoiding a lot of pointless fanservice. Another fun fact about the cast, the seiyuu's for the main five characters are all a part of a real life band called Poppin' Party (the same name as the characters in the show.
Unfortunately, this show started very late into the season, so I suspect by the time it started airing, most people had already chosen the shows they wanted to watch for the season, and simply didn't even pick it up. This is completely anecdotal, but from what I've seen many of the people who picked this up mid season after missing it at airing seemed to really have enjoyed it.
TL;DR
BanG! Dream is a very good music oriented show that should be a breath of fresh air for anyone who was disappointed by Fuuka. Animation is somewhat lacking, but the characterization and interactions are top notch, earning this show a 9/10 for me (which is the highest I give because Madoka Magica exists), and I would proudly put this as my AOTS, or at least as a contender alongside Maid Dragon, Demi-Chan, and Kono2ba. If this sounds even remotely interesting to you, please give this show a try.
Edit: Should have mentioned, the last episode airs this Saturday, so you have time to catch up before the finale.
11
u/1ntestine :AMQ::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/1ntestine Apr 18 '17
You should've said that's it's similar to Love Live! That'll get more people interested. While it does look like K-ON! I really can't see any similarities beyond the band and setting, it's a hell of a lot more similar to Love Live.
5
u/jonjoy Apr 18 '17
Great, a WT about bang dream. We really need this. Bang dream is criminally underwatched.
3
u/PPGN_DM_Exia https://myanimelist.net/profile/PPGN_DM_Exia Apr 18 '17
There's a guy in my anime club who plays the mobile game and is obsessed with this show. I'm not really into these LL-type idol shows, but if it's rock music, I may give it a shot, especially if the fanservice level is low or non-existent. Thanks for reminding me about this series, OP.
7
u/VincoP Apr 18 '17 edited Apr 18 '17
Below is a comment I had put together (originally here) upon the release of the rhythm game Girl's Band Party, for BanG_Dream. A comparison of note regarding one bit of appeal - much like Love Live's seiyuu actually dancing the same choreography as their characters, the intent with BD is to have their seiyuu play the same music as their characters. Poppin' Party and Roselia have played live, but I wouldn't know as of now if the other bands will do likewise. While my personal interests are in iM@S (if you wanna get into iM@S, let me know!) if anyone wants to get into BD, please subscribe to /r/BanGDream! In the original comment, I only highlighted the iM@S seiyuu involved, but I'll try and include one role (off the top of my head, lmk any typos!) from everyone else that I hope others here recognize. Some I recognize, but I'm not familiar with their roles or other work. Stuff may have been mentioned in the notes redundantly, along with a few additions here and there, but I don't feel like making major revisions. Anyway, read on!
Just gonna throw this in here, since I feel people might be interested in the cast list. A few I recognize elsewhere, but those relevant to this sub will be bolded where relevant:
Poppin' Party
Afterglow
Glitter*Green
Pastel*Palettes
Roselia
Hello, Happy World!
Notes:
rumoredconfirmed CG seiyuu Ayaka Asai) in the Kitauji Quartet, the main 4 girls of Hibike! Euphonium. Moe Toyota is also currently active as part of Pyxis with Miku Itou. They both came from seiyuu idol unit StylipS, which included Maho Matsunaga (now graduated from Stylips and retired from voice acting, previously voiced Erena Todou of A-RISE in LL) and is led by Arisa Noto, who also works as a motion capture actress (official credits include the iM@S One for All game and the iM@S film, but someone had mentioned deresute too).Things worth mentioning for BD's lives:
it's almost like Bushiroad made BanG_Dream because of her. #aiminappreciationsquad1
u/VincoP Apr 18 '17
A good bit of its appeal in Japan actually has to do with the voice actresses. I can note for now that one interesting point is that voice actresses from K-ON, Love Live, and iDOLM@STER are involved with the recent rhythm game. If you would like, I can dig up some older comments I've written on BD, and expand a little.
1
u/bigfatround0 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bigfatround0 Apr 18 '17
You should have waited until it finished airing.
1
u/cottonycloud Apr 18 '17
I started watching it because I enjoy music anime. It's been really testing on me though; don't know if I'm just getting old or something. I find Kasumi pretty annoying due to her energy, but maybe I'm just comparing the show too much to K-ON! and Hibike!. Also not a fan of drama (it's hard for me to reason one of the characters not just talking about stage fright).
The name of the anime is also quite nonsensical.