r/anime • • Jun 24 '17
[WT!] Nagi no Asukara (A Lull in the Sea) analysis - The duality of the soul
The sea is calm tonight.
The tide is full, the moon lies fair
Upon the straits; on the French coast the light
Gleams and is gone; the cliffs of England stand,
Glimmering and vast, out in the tranquil bay.
Come to the window, sweet is the night-air!
Only, from the long line of spray
Where the sea meets the moon-blanched land,
Listen! you hear the grating roar
Of pebbles which the waves draw back, and fling,
At their return, up the high strand,
Begin, and cease, and then again begin,
With tremulous cadence slow, and bring
The eternal note of sadness in.
-Dover Beach, by Matthew Arnold
What is it about?
Nagi no Asukara is a P.A. Works original anime from 2014.
Long ago, all humans lived beneath the sea. However, some people preferred the surface and abandoned living underwater permanently. As a consequence, they were stripped of their god-given protection called "Ena" which allowed them to breathe underwater. Over time, the rift between the denizens of the sea and of the surface widened, although contact between the two peoples still existed.
Nagi no Asukara follows the story of Hikari Sakishima and Manaka Mukaido, along with their childhood friends Chisaki Hiradaira and Kaname Isaki, who are forced to leave the sea and attend a school on the surface. There, the group also meets Tsumugu Kihara, a fellow student and fisherman who loves the sea.
Hikari and his friends' lives are bound to change as they have to deal with the deep-seated hatred and discrimination between the people of sea and of the surface, the storms in their personal lives, as well as an impending tempest which may spell doom for all who dwell on the surface.
The blurb doesn't quite sell the show, however. In essence, Nagi no Asukara is a romance-drama story, weaving a huge web of relationships. Hikari is in love with Manaka; Manaka has a crush on Tsumugu. Meanwhile, Hikari's sister Akari is tangled with another, while his friends Chisaki and Kaname each have crushes of their own. The point is that there is a lot of interpersonal drama; one throwaway line said may affect numerous people down the line, pain them or fill them with joy. Yes, Nagi no Asukara is a melodrama. But all this melodrama among middle-schoolers matters. Not simply because the drama hinges on these likeable, empathetic characters, but because the fate of the world does.
Through gorgeous backdrops, an intimate yet epic-feeling underwater world is rendered, the supernatural elements of which sweep up our characters. The thing that spurns each of them to one action or another, the thing that drives the domino of events which eventually decides the course of both the surface and the sea, is love. The same infantile, insignificant love that makes us laugh so easily around our crush, that makes children jump when they see their parents, that keeps us coming home each evening.
If you chip away all the stunning settings, the networks of characters, and the clashes among the characters, you'll see bare the heart of Nagi no Asukara: Love. A constant duality, a melancholy, bittersweet reality about love permeates every frame of this show, portraying its pains, its joys; the ways it holds us back within selfishness, the ways it inspires us to better ourselves and accept the truths of life that, like waves in the sea, are sad and beautiful.
To that end, every character changes and grows in their own way. Watching them develop is fulfilling not just because they've changed, but because we see every step through which they overcome their conflicted selves. We know what they've had to go through, what it means for them. No minute is wasted in bringing each character to life, whether that be animating their body language or lingering on their changing expressions. Much of their feelings are shown, not told. We are then allowed to understand them in our own ways, some of which you can't put into words but you just get it. Each journey is a sentence, worded in sympathetic cinematography, punctuated in nuanced dialogue, and stopped in an overwhelming catharsis.
Who is it by?
Nagi no Asukara was helmed and directed by Toshiya Shinohara, who has been a storyboarder for Legend of the Galactic Heroes and Higurashi no Naku Koro, and has directed Black Butler and four Inuyasha series, and has been part of numerous other projects. Shinohara brings to Nagi no Asukara years of experience, connections, and artistic vision.
Mari Okada acted as series compositor and co-scriptwriter; you may recognise her brand of work in Toradora, Anohana, Aria the Natural, and Hourou Musuko. Indeed, the kind of interpersonal drama she is known for is at its forte in Nagi no Asukara.
Yoshiaki Dewa was in charge of music, having previously worked on Flying Witch. Jin Aketagawa was sound director, and has played the same role in... well, just see the list. He is prolific.
Why does it work?
To break down the artistic skill that went into Nagi no Asukara, I'll forcibly separate the concepts of character and atmosphere. They are intertwined, but we'll use them to observe the purposefulness that goes into each shot of this show.
Demonstrating character
In episode 2, minor spoilers. This is their reaction shot. At this point, it's established these young teenagers each have their own crushes and holdups, hence why they blush at seeing a kiss: it's new, it's exciting, and it reminds them of desires they've only begun to have.
Manaka, the red-haired girl second from the left, is the most emotive and obviously in-love among the four. So she is placed frontmost in the shot, clasping her hands, as she barely holds herself together reminded of her own love. This trait of hers is important to the story.
Chisaki, the other girl, is more reserved, so she keeps her hands back. At the same time, she is angled at and situated behind Manaka; this is because she has a habit of letting Manaka take the spotlight, hiding herself. This fact is also vital to the story later.
Hikari, the rightmost boy, is the most taken aback among them, since it's his own sister and he hadn't known about her relationship. So he is placed the farthest. His immediate surprise + outrage is a sign of his impulsiveness, a fact that is deeply ingrained in his character.
Kaname, the other boy, is the most "insignificant" of the four, which is why he is placed back from the girls. With the least screentime, he is generally a quiet observer; he does not let his feelings show, even though he very much has them. You can see this subtly shown by how his hands are apart at his sides. He doesn't know what to do with them.
Clever blocking, shot composition, and body language come together to show this shot, one of the least bombastic shots in this episode. The point is that even if many viewers wouldn't consciously note these nuances, Nagi no Asukara does this consistently throughout its 26 episodes to convince us the characters are living beings. This same level of detail goes into every episode.
To add to the impressiveness of this shot, the key differences between the characters demonstrated here are vital to the plot in the future. The characters take actions precisely because of their personality and circumstances; if you change one of these people one bit, the entire plot would likely change. For a character-driven story, it's important to demonstrate character at every opportunity, and it's a task Nagi no Asukara is dedicated to achieving.
Another comment on how the show contrasts these characters. It's not just in the expressions that they differ. They have important similarities and differences to one another that are brought out in the writing as well. Each character is constructed as a foil to another; every person's internal conflict gives us insight into another's. And when a character adds a little different from usual, or acts in the same way in a different context, that is a sign of how they've changed.
I can't explain more without spoiling, but the conclusion is: Nagi no Asukara builds on itself layer by delicate layer, using contrasts and your own intelligence for character and thematic density.
Rendering atmosphere
Every background feels lived in and three-dimensional. In contrast to big establishing shots like this, which is given a sense of dimension and continuity by the bridge & stairs going into the town, there are intimate shots like this. Together, they flesh out the big and small feel of the settings.
Consider this background; layers and layers of buildings, signposts, and people take up the entire frame, to give it dimension across the frame as well as in. There is even height there as well, with the train track arching above everything. It all seems trivial, but bringing places to life like this takes much artistic vision and know-how. P.A. Works is infamous for its stunning backgrounds, and I think Nagi no Asukara is where they stunned the most.
It's not just about the pure background, though; it's how they work with the characters and with one another. Choosing these details carefully, the show gears us subconsciously to feel certain things easier. This way it has an effortless manipulativeness, a trait every story desires.
By blocking characters like this, the settings in this show feel inhabited and real, like you could go in anytime and step anywhere you like. Someone has been busy, or has at least tread, in every space there is.
Many settings are used multiple times. As events keep happening in them, we associate certain emotions to the places. The back of the school here is first seen when the two children meet Hikari & friends. This meeting is where their friendships begin. The fateful encounter adds meaning to this place, a feeling of nostalgia and change, as characters enter and leave the scene throughout the series.
I must appreciate the sense of depth and realism given in these shots of a summit, how the boy climbs a visible path to this place. More importantly, this clearing at the summit changes gradually, representing how the relationships change between the characters that inhabit it. At one point, they make a pool here where they play and relax; at another, they come and work together on common goals. These feelings of camaraderie are given new light as the story progresses.
Certain kinds of places have only certain kinds of events happen in them. This abandoned school, which the kids used to attend, takes on feelings of melancholy, resentment of times gone by. Here characters are most vulnerable; indeed, it's where many of the plot's turning points and climaxes kick off.
The colour palette of blue, like everything in this show, takes on dual meanings of both joy and sadness. Underlying all the inner workings of this show is a deeply resonant duality, a truth the creators want to tell.
Conclusion
So what is Nagi no Asukara? It's too many to count. I could go on and on in this post, but to truly understand the show you'll have to experience it. The amount of work that goes into every scene just makes me squeal - the passion! The love for this medium these creators have! The people in the story, the atmosphere!
The beauty and melancholy that permeates its aesthetics aren't there for show; they grant the story an ephemeralness, a sense of poetry that makes the drama engaging and important.
If you want a layered interpersonal drama, watch this show.
If you want good, believable character development, watch this show.
If you want emotional highs and lows with melancholy aplenty, watch this show.
If you want a simple, but thoroughly explored theme, watch this show.
If you want a genuine, passionate story, watch this show.
3
u/TheYorouzoya :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/YorouzoyaHouse Jun 24 '17
While it is a good write up and I commend you for writing such an interesting piece, I have issues with your title of "Duality of the Soul".
Duality of the Soul refers to the Soul Dualism or the Mind-Body Dualism - philosophical concepts I am deeply interested in (you can google "duality of the soul" and they will be the first two search results). They usually talk about existence and whether the mind and the body (denoted as two kinds of "souls") are separate entities or one. So when I read through your post, I was disappointed that nothing of the sort was mentioned.
Now, my question is, does this show talk about those concepts?
P.S. Please do not take this the wrong way. I'm not hating on what you've written, it's just your title has me confused about the said show's nature.
74
u/_vogonpoetry_ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThisWasATriumph Jun 24 '17 edited Jun 24 '17
Really? All that text and no mention of the soundtrack? It's one of the best soundtracks I've ever heard. Every moment of the show is filled with perfectly fitting and emotional music which just pulls you into the story that much more. It's one of the few OST's I listen to regularly outside of the anime.
Aired October 2013 actually but it was split cour. Interesting thing was that there was a 2 week break in between the first and second cour so Nagi no Asukara
17
u/TomaToaro https://anilist.co/user/Toaro Jun 24 '17 edited Jun 24 '17
Would also like to mention that another main theme of Nagi no Asukara is change. Change is very prominent throughout the whole 26 episodes, especially the second cour, after the timeskip. One of the most prominent points about change that hit me the most was when Minor Spoilers and it just proves to show how the characters try to grasp and adapt to change, or try not to change at all, and really expresses their feelings throughout the show about change.
All in all, a very good analysis by OP on my favourite show of all time, and hope this would inspire others to watch the show as well!
Edit: Fixed the spoiler tag that was broken
10
u/derpinat0rz :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/derpinat0rz Jun 24 '17
One of the most beatiful anime i have watched.
27
u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian Jun 24 '17
Great anime that's worth watching for aesthetics alone but hits you with so much more with its characters, plot and ships!
19
u/Mage_of_Shadows Jun 24 '17
It's got amazing music as well, one of if not the best lead ins into the ED Iv'e seen in any anime delivering every episode ending you with an empty feeling inside, Anohana by the same scriptwriter and series composer would come a close second.
Plus an amazing OST
8
u/kannyk :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kannyk Jun 24 '17
Chisaki Best Girl
7
u/ABoredCompSciStudent x3myanimelist.net/profile/Serendipity Jun 24 '17
Aquaterrarium might be my favourite ending. Nice write-up. :)
5
u/Sphexus :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Alsus Jun 24 '17
Been thinking I should give this another go. Only gave it 2 episodes before dropping it. I really just couldn't handle the melodrama.
2
u/NyeasB0s :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ElPsyBankai Jun 24 '17
Recently watched this show, each episode felt like it was worth 10 episodes of drama build up and tears and the animation is really good. I'd say it's worth watching.
2
u/Smudy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smudy Jun 24 '17
It's in my top 6 favourite anime so i'm glad it gets some recognition here.
Love the animation and the music that create a fantastic atmosphere.
The plot is also very good.
2
u/UnravelTK Jun 24 '17
Thank you so much for your review, I thoroughly enjoyed the read and reminiscing about the show's brilliance. NagiAsu really gave me a lot to think about as I watched it on a weekly basis.
3
u/Sympah :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/azakuz Jun 24 '17 edited Jun 24 '17
I loved the concept and the art. Really beautiful. The water theme and discrimination stuff going on was really great to explore. Don't know if I'm alone in this, but I found the romance really bad and stupid and kinda ruined the show for me.
Good and believable character development? Give me a break. The show's premise is all about it being a love pentagon. The relationship between the characters never goes really deep. And the only time anything really changes is at the very end of the anime... since the pentagon broke.
EDIT: sorry if I'm not making any sense as it's been a year since I didn't watch this. I just remember feeling like the romance ruined how beautiful everything else was. Cheap middle-school love triangles but cranked up unreasonably. Probably why I loved Shinsekai Yori where romance is present, but does not define the anime.
2
u/stitches_dc :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SAUT94 Jun 24 '17
As a random side point regarding the show, Miuna became by far my favorite character in the show. I just ended up finding her so endearing. Also, I found Sayu's voice the funniest thing ever. Those two were a fun pair
1
u/BBSNYPUR Jun 24 '17
Rewathced the show about a week ago. My opinions of it were higher than when I first saw it. Being able to go through the show without waiting a week between episodes helped it a bit. The look of it is fantastic and the music complements everything so well. I still have issues with it all, but the show is pretty nice overall. Not my favorite P.A. Works show, but it's still well worth a watch if you're into romance or just wanna stare out how gorgeous the visuals are.
1
u/MetaThPr4h https://myanimelist.net/profile/MetaThPr4h Jun 24 '17
I would need to rewatch that anime to have a better opinion on the story, but it's definitely still #1 in the art style part, absolutely beautiful.
Thanks for this WT! I appreciate it.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '17
I really love that PA make so many original shows seemingly about whatever they feel like. Between NNA, Kuromukuro, Shirobako, Sakura quest etc they're probably the best studio for quality originals these days.
1
u/mobijet Jun 24 '17
Soundtrack + the scenery. THE SCENERY OMGAHSH!!!!
I fell madly in love with the peaceful seaside town and the underwater wonder!
0
u/bobbywebster22 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bobbywebster22 Jun 24 '17
No, because they will have no clue what I meant by that until they see the show, but they can ready your spoiler tag and know all about it.
-15
u/Shame_Car_2 Jun 24 '17
nah its bad and not worth watching outside of the aesthetics
0
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '17
[removed] — view removed comment