r/anime • u/babydave371 :Ej:myanimelist.net/profile/babydave371 • Sep 20 '17
[WT!] Belladonna of Sadness: Sex, Drugs, and Feminism (NSFW) NSFW
| ANN | MAL | Wiki | Trailer |
|---|
What is it?
Belladonna of Sadness is the final film in the Animerama Trilogy which was an attempt by Osamu Tezuka and Eiichi Yamamoto to push anime into being a greater and more respected artistic medium. The first part was 1969’s 1001 Nights, which Eiichi directed and Tezuka wrote, and this was followed shortly in 1970 by Cleopatra, which the two directed together. During the early stages of Belladonna’s production Tezuka left Mushi Productions to focus on his manga and later set up a new studio, so this one was mainly of Eiichi. Now that the background is out of the way we can go into what the story is and what this film is. In my little information booklet that I got with the Anime Limited release, Jasper Sharp describes the film as “an animated psychedelic porno prog-rock opera set in the Middle Ages” and he isn’t much off. The film tells the story of Jeanne, a medieval peasant in rural France who has just gotten married. On her wedding night, she is brutally raped by the local Lord under jus primae noctis, even though evidence suggests that this was historically never actually a thing, and so begins her tale of woe. Upon returning home she finds her that her new husband, Jean, is distancing himself from her, due to both his own emasculation and his perceived notion that Jeanne is now tainted. Soon after a phallic looking devil appears before Jeanne offering her money, power, and freedom. She reluctantly accepts and from here the real story begins.
But why should I watch it?
Radically Feminist:
In every way that one looks at Belladonna it is blatantly obvious that is a starkly Feminist anime. It has its roots in Jules Michelet’s La Sorcière (1862), a book which positions medieval witchcraft as an act of feminine rebellion against the oppression of Feudalism and the Church. A good portion of the left-wing thinkers of the 1960s and 70s caught onto Michelet’s work and adopted the idea of the feminine-led rebellion, though now aiming it at the male dominated military-industrial complex. This was the early 1970s after all, right smack bang in the middle of second-wave feminism. While first-wave feminism was mainly focused on suffrage and property ownership rights, second-wave focused on wider societal issues including the workplace, rape, domestic violence, and of course sexual freedom (in no small part spurred on by the development of the pill). Now that was a very very rough and ready primer on second-wave feminism, forgive me, but I would kind of hope you already know about it, however should be sufficient. It is in this context that Belladonna came out. Belladonna; a film based on a work already adopted by a good number of feminists, a film that draws parallels to oft used symbol of feminism Jean of Arc, a film that is boldly feminist in its own right. This film advocates that via sexual and social freedom Jeanne can gain more power and so free the other peasants, both female and male, too. The more that Jeanne is allowed to succeed the more the male powers decline and grow in fear. It is important to note that Jeanne is at all time ‘woman’. She is never like the modern stereotype of a feminist: a butch lesbian with short hair who is doing her best to shed herself of any feminine features. No, at all times Jeanne is woman with long flowing locks of hair, beautiful clothes, and a sexual sensuality. In many ways she typifies that ideal of the second-wave feminism: a woman who succeeds without need of compromising her womanhood. And all of this was made by dudes in Japan, a notoriously sexist country, in 1973! It is incredible in many ways that this even exists. It may seem passé and even anti-feminist to some people watching it in 2017 but at that time and in that place it is remarkable. Belladonna of Sadness is a striking image of the feminism of its time.
Radically Beautiful:
This film had a notoriously tiny budget and yet it still made Mushi Productions go bankrupt, this lead to a very unique look that anime critic Nobuyuki Tsugata described as “animation that is inanimate”. However, this is not an ugly film, in fact it is a desperately beautiful. The lack of animation is more than made up for by Kuni Fukai’s vibrant and exciting artwork. Drawing from artists such as Gustav Klimt, Odilon Redon, Alphonse Mucha, Egon Schiele, Aubrey Beardsley, and Felicien Rops he worked with his limited resources rather than against it. He used the fact he didn’t have to move the image to make them highly detailed, he used white space to enhance the images, and he didn’t feel bound to use the normal tools of animation, instead using texture and other non-traditional tools. This raw art was combined with deft cinematography as the camera purposefully moves around and explores different parts of the canvas during a shot. It all combines for a stunningly beautiful piece of art the likes of which anime has never seen again.
Radically Different:
No other anime is remotely like Belladonna of Sadness. Utena is similar in some ways, with the rumour being that Ikuhara was inspired to make anime by Belladonna, but also very different in many other ways. The Woman Called Fujiko Mine is probably the closest anime has gotten to Belladonna with its comparable use of sexuality and visual similarities, however it has action in a way that Belladonna doesn’t and also seems to be designed to titillate in a way that I don’t think that Belladonna is designed too. Even contemporary manga like The Rose of Versailles were approaching feminism in a very different, though no less important, way. Oh, and I haven’t even mentioned the drug scenes yet have I? Well they are there and they are batshit mental, only some of the weirder OAVs have done similar things. Belladonna truly is a one of a kind in terms of content and visuals.
Conclusion
Belladonna is a must watch film for any anime fan who wants to truly see what the medium can be. It pushes the boundaries visually and, in many ways, it continues to push the boundaries socially. Its brand of feminism might have fallen out of favour with many but that makes its message no less powerful now than when it was released in 1973. It certainly isn't for everyone but if you want to try something a bit different that will maybe challenge you a bit then give Belladonna of Sadness a go and prepare to exclaim I am Woman!
Sources: Helen McCarthy, Jasper Sharp, Gabriella Ekens, and Alissa Wilkinson
43
u/MrManicMarty https://anilist.co/user/martysan Sep 20 '17
1973, feminist and MAL is saying hentai? Nani?
Okay, yeah. This sounds weird and trippy and more experimental stuff is worth trying out - I'll add it to my PTW, and if I go on a movie watching spree, I'll keep it in mind! Thanks Dave!
16
u/RainInsane :AMQ: Sep 20 '17
I watched this a couple weeks ago and definitely can say that it was the weirdest anime movie I've ever seen.
It was worth it.
11
u/Acrymonia Sep 21 '17
They told me Satan would be attractive....
9
u/GiftoftheGeek :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/CatSoul Sep 21 '17
I recorded this off the Turner Classic Movies channel (yes, you read that right; there was borderline hentai on American basic cable) a few months ago. Really need to get around to watching it.
7
u/Nykveu https://anilist.co/user/Nykveu Sep 21 '17
Lol, I didn't know about the movie's themes. And all the screenshots are beautiful! I'll really have to pick it up one day.
And also, this song is dope.
27
u/SolsticeWrath Sep 20 '17
The last thing I'd expect out of anime is feminism lol
5
u/greasy_minge Sep 21 '17
I still can't believe TCM aired this uncensored without any controversy. So glad I got to see this last year in the Cinema.
4
u/babydave371 :Ej:myanimelist.net/profile/babydave371 Sep 20 '17
/u/thetaomega
/u/nykveu
2
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17
I enjoyed this movie. Thanks for posting. Beautiful art and it makes you think. From one perspective, she's the devil, from another perspective, she's taking charge of her life.
4
u/ShikiRyumaho :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Chaostrooper Sep 21 '17
The movie took the concept of limited animation too far. It had it's moments, but overall I didn't like it.
5
u/Moarbid_Krabs Sep 21 '17
I got to see a screening of this a few months ago. I think I have an idea where SHAFT got a lot of their influences from...
The visuals are only half of what makes it so unique. It has a really great psych-rock soundtrack that really adds something special to it's whole aesthetic.
It's a pity that it isn't more well known.
1
u/ChainEnergy Sep 21 '17
Ideological agendas aside, I'm usually into more obscure things like this, but this one just didn't keep me engaged.
2
u/Arraby Sep 21 '17
It's cool. Got to see it at our local Alamo theater with some friends.
2
u/mergedkestrel Sep 21 '17
I saw this at a special showing in an Alamo Drafthouse a few months ago, and I'm pretty sure I've never been more uncomfortable in a movie theater. My mom first tipped me off to it, and was about to join me to see it. I'm so glad she didn't. I enjoyed it overall, and felt like it was worth seeing once, but I don't think I'll ever be watching it again.
1
u/DivinePrince2 Sep 21 '17
I'm not a feminist, so I do not think this would interest me. I also do not like anime from before the mid 90s.
-10
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17
Seeing it marked as "feminism" is extremely off putting, was hard to get through the WT with that initial statement. I dont much care for social agendas in entertainment. I will watch this because it is an anime, same reason why i watch everything else. I am going to blind myself in the assumption this is your preferred interpretation of it as well and not its definitive meaning. I will just watch it the same way I watch everything else "Lets sit down and see how this character deals wih stuff"
I have watched many all girls cast shows. From children to NSFW. If at any time someone sat down next to me and stated "Ah yes this piece of animation was the direct result from the social ques that have made woman outcasts in a male domimated society. You can see from the -" I would then proceed to dump them over the balcony.
I support anime because of its whimsical side. I stay away from real tv and movies (and iRL community protests) because I hate social morals shoved down my throat in a 2 hour message that can be summed up with "why act like that when you can be like this" Normally to a crowd of whom are already like that.
I get it we all want to be recognized, validated, made to seem important, generally useful, respected and treated equally. Thats all life right down to the animals.
I would take a hole in the head over any humantarian agenda dictated to me through what is supposed to be entertainment. If I want real values, life lessons, social ethics or a moral code. I will go to a real history book and read about it talk with others and get involved in my community more. Thats why we have those protests, librarys and history lessons. So i know where NOT to go.
we have entertainment to take a break from that. I would not trust the mind of someone being changed by a show or movie either. I believe if you want things to change you deal with people 1 on 1.
8
u/[deleted] Sep 21 '17
[removed] — view removed comment