r/anime • • Dec 20 '17
[WT!] A Little Sister's All You Need, the feel-good Slice of Life you may have skipped this season.
Imouto Sae Ireba Ii gained a lot of infamy in the beginning of this Fall season due to its rather unorthodox opening sequence. Some people theorized that its unpopularity, sitting at a slightly lower score than a 7 on MAL, is mainly due to people watching 1-off clips of the show completely removed from their context. This is, to some extent, true but the show itself doesn't exactly make it an easy task for us to accept the "normality" in which its characters live.
If I had to pinch this anime with other titles, it would be as a mix of Shirobako, Just Because! and Eromanga-Sensei:
This may seem like an odd mix but ISII handles it in an amazing fashion:
The meta-humor a la Shirobako is handled hilariously, while still giving meaningful commentary into the lives of artists in the Light Novel industry; this is mostly seen towards the latter half of the show.
The romantic drama a la Just Because! is sprinkled in carefully, mostly in after-party scenes where characters and people, in general, tend to be more open about their feelings. Not fitting into the rather tired out pattern of "let's start of funnily and descend further and further into a drama as the episodes go by." This drama also carries as much weight, in my opinion, as in the aforementioned since we're talking about characters which are usually displayed as cheerful and unconcerned while being brutally reminded that even those kinds of people have emotional breakdowns of their own.
The lewd comedy, which may be a turn off to some, a la Eromanga-Sensei may be the least universally liked the aspect of the show, with some scenes which could be considered out-right Hentai. However, we're at least assured that we are, in fact, being presented adult characters in, rather unrealistic, but none-the-less adult scenarios.
Some people are going to butcher me for the Just Because! comparison and my allegation that the drama is handled as well in ISII but, what we can't lose track of is that we're being presented a group of authors. Authors aren't average citizens and, young authors, in particular, tend to have a much more different outlook on life. Of course, this alone isn't able to account for all the disparities seen between normal people and ISII's characters but it's comforting. While Just Because! is inherently tense due to the characters having to make decisions about their professional lives which will affect them, and thus having most of the drama laid out for them, ISII has to build its own drama up which isn't an easy task, especially in a 1-cour season; these authors aren't in risk of bankruptcy, since most of them are fairly popular and their pasts, although hurtful, aren't so traumatizing as to emotionally disturb them in their daily activities and thus serving as barriers for them to overcome. This all means that the show has the go the extra mile to make us like these characters and wish the best for them since any drama caused would have to be born from their interactions.
Have you noticed that I haven't mentioned the "little sister" part of the show even once? That's not because I'm trying to purposefully avoid it in order to make this show look more approachable than it actually is but is instead because the "little sister" doesn't actually exist for the entirety of this 1-cour. You have to watch it in order to understand what that actually means and I don't want to get into spoiler territory but just be reassured that our MC's little sister obsession never actually affects the story in a meaningful way, just having its presence in unimportant scenes.
When it comes to the lewd comedy, there isn't much to say about it except that Silver Link has once again proven that they can make attractive-looking characters in awesomely colored and animated environments.
I could also talk about how this show handles its modern setting fairly well and isn't at all an example of adults not knowing how to write characters who are younger than them so if you're worried about the "How do you do, fellow kids?" aspect that this series may have, don't.
One last thing, I initially had trouble getting into this show too! Even considering a drop by episode 4. I then proceeded to rewatch it (and chose the dub for whatever reason) and now I love it 10 times more than I ever did before.
My purpose with this post is not to shame anyone who early-dropped this show nor to do so to people who just found it unwatchable, even after giving it a chance. It's to raise awareness for an Anime which I believe has been treated unfairly by the community and deserves another shot before the Winter Ball begins and we all start dancing to different music once more.
80
u/iamfvckingdone :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/iamfvckingdone Dec 20 '17
One more plus: This anime also has a beautiful ED
65
u/SpaceCowboy321 https://anilist.co/user/SpaceCowboy321 Dec 20 '17
I really like the scenes where they just hang out and play tabletop games. It's cool that they actually play real games and explain the rules. I could honestly watch an entire series of people just playing different tabletop games.
107
u/the_swizzler https://myanimelist.net/profile/Swiftarm Dec 20 '17
This is actually my second favorite show this season. I'm just always excited for the new episode.
16
u/InfiniteTurbine Dec 20 '17
I was slightly interested in watching this show when the season began, but I ended up not getting into it. That infamous 1st episode 'normie filter' (I've seen others call it that) wasn't even what caused it: I'd seen that clip along with other clips and fanart over the last few weeks, and while it actually looked alright, I just wasn't feeling it enough to watch it.
Recently, though, it came back into my mind, and now this WT! has convinced me to give it a looksy sometime.
32
u/four-point-five Dec 20 '17
The MC is pretty bland, the jokes get old fast, visuals aren't anything impressive. It's not a great show, but it's a perfectly decent show that you can watch to fill 20 minutes of your day, especially if you're looking for your fix of attractive girls.
Personally a 6/10 for me. I'm really not a fan of the "main cast admires MC for one reason or another" thing, especially since the MC is mostly a freaking weirdo in my eyes. The siscon "humor" or whatever they're trying to do with the MC fails for me, Nayu's antics, while adorable at first, got old pretty fast, and I've seen people talk up the mature aspect of this show, but it isn't there. Sure they have their careers, they drink alcohol, but those along with its setting are really the only difference between ISII and the other "Just Because!" of anime.
It has its "aww" moments, and Glasses guy and Miyako (godbless that undressing scene) are pretty nice and relatable characters, and the cast overall feel like they're good friends, not just some "MC getting forced into a random club" scenario. And there's that calm, moody ost that I really like.
3
u/sidhantsv :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sidhantsv Dec 20 '17
AOTY if I had to say. Personally that is.
3
u/minzart :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/minzart Dec 21 '17
I just binged this all the way to episode 7. The references to Raildex and Fate/sn have convinced me, along with previous references to various siscon works, that this show is the ultimate parody. It, in a way remarkably similar to SAO Abridged, builds upon the parent genre (LN author metastory) and manages to take a fresh angle which creates real, lasting emotional impact.
I love it. Thank you for recommending this.
3
u/Goldieeeeee Dec 21 '17
This is a professional edit. I have great respect for you, OP
5
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '17
TL;DR: Certain parts (but not all) of this show is a meta commentary of the genre, and those parts are very good.
Normally I would hesitate to call a show a parody of a genre, because sometimes that will be abused to justify bad writing.
But when your opening scene is an over the top hentai plot with the early 2000's art style you need look no further.
The show is good, mostly because you expect nothing from it. Yet, again and again it hits you with meta jokes about a culture so specific and strange that the results turn masterful. I won't say that everything in this show is a parody though, because a lot of it is just fanservice. Fanservice built on parody-character-designs, but fanservice nonetheless.
I watched this show at school, with a bunch of my friends, on speakers, every single monday. We expected nothing, some of us didn't get all the meta-jokes, but generally we all had a good time. (We called it "Social Suicide Monday". We're now planning on making it a tradition.)
Regarding... that scene, I would like to think that it's a comment on how shows like this handle consent. It gives off a creepy vibe (which I hope is intended), and really shows what would happen if certain characters were to meet people who didn't like or agree to their methods. There's another scene like this later on (2nd last episode I believe), but it doesn't give off the same vibe (even though it's a "do it till they like it" scene, which really doesn't make it any better). Is it actually a comment on what's okay and what's going too far with characters in shows like this? I don't know, but I hope that it is.
2
u/Sky2042 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sky2042 Dec 20 '17
So if I liked Monogatari...?
2
u/swordmalice https://myanimelist.net/profile/swordmalice Dec 20 '17
Hmmm, ok. Is this available for legal streaming anywhere?
2
u/hypophrenia2 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/hypophrenia Dec 21 '17
Alright you convinced me to give the show another try.
3
u/3brithil :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DefinitelyNotEscolyte Dec 20 '17
So what you're saying is I should watch Shirobako (done, it's fantastic) and Just Because! (just waiting until it's done) and avoid Eromanga like the plague?
22
u/Hanede https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hanede Dec 20 '17
I have to admit after hearing about an anime with "Imouto" in its title, I didn't even take a look at it seeing how much I disliked Eromanga Sensei (and the whole incest topic). I was still skeptical when my boyfriend convinced me to watch it, saying it was very different.
I was pleasantly surprised. The characters and their relationships (both romance and friendship) are very endearing, and the situations are genuinely entertaining, whether they are comedy or drama. I'm not a fan of ecchi/fanservice scenes in general, but they are mostly done well enough to make me laugh at their ridiculousness (which is kinda the point) so I don't mind them too much.
36
u/MizoreSSB4 Dec 20 '17
To be honest, if you fail to surpass the normie-filter at start of episode 1, you don't deserve to experience the rest of it's greatness.
3
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '17
I'm holding out hope that this is the one anime that actually has a healthy sibling relationship even though one of the siblings is siscon/brocon. I'm hoping Spoilers
But I also liked Eromanga-sensei and Oreimo despite their flaws, so my taste is shit anyway.
3
u/shadowridrs Dec 20 '17
I quite enjoyed it. I think a lot of people are assuming its like eromanga or oreimo.
3
u/johandedude Dec 20 '17
A true hidden gem only thing it could expand upon (in my opinion) are the backstories and personal problems, but the rest of it is truly amazing it feels really relaxing and natural and i can never wait for the next episode like with sangatsu no lion.
3
u/laod :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/laod Dec 21 '17
This show is most likely to make me want a drink this season. I'd like to thank the sponsors.
That said, I sucked it up after quitting five minutes in and tried again and I've been very glad. It's charming satire.
3
u/heartscrew Dec 21 '17
I was laughing the hell out of the first two minutes. It was so absurd that it had to be something of a fakeout.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '17
i watched episode 1 yesterday
one question i have is that: isnt the girl 18?why cant she drink?also...is it normal that she literally asks the main character to sleep with him in front of everyone?like its too weird
i like her tho...
4
u/MakeShiftGod Dec 20 '17
Yeah, too bad the first minute of episode 1 gave people a bad persona. It really is a fun anime. It goes really in depth of what it actually is like to be a novelist, and I really hope more people come to realize it’s a good anime in disguise
4
u/Vindex101 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vindex101 Dec 20 '17
Liiies! I call liiiees!
2
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '17
I dropped it to backlog after 3 episodes, but I'll probably give it another go at some point
2
u/Rutherfor_ Dec 20 '17
Guess I'll give this a try... I just watched the first episode and didn't come back to it, I only stuck to inuyashiki and houseki no kuni. I always try getting back to shows when I see posts like these lol
2
u/DrugrixhTae99 Dec 20 '17
FACTS
2
u/ScorchedEarth22 Dec 21 '17
Look, Mr. Bubbles! An Angel...
3
u/IQsShoes Dec 20 '17
Legal Lolis
2
u/Esterier Dec 21 '17
I watched about 4 episodes and don't want to watch more. I didn't dislike it, but have no interest in continuing either.
1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '17
Praise a la!!
1
u/Hentai_Hulk Dec 21 '17
I tabled it after the first EP (not because the 2 opening minutes threw me off, but mainly because I was watching too much) but I need to pick up stuff I left off this season
1
u/OniiChanStopNotThere Dec 21 '17
I loved the first 2 mins of the first episode. After another 5 minutes, I dropped the anime. I got baited so hard.
1
u/kancolle_nigga Dec 21 '17
I usually like slice of lifes like this but I had to drop it after episode 4. It was just too boring and average.
1
u/ThatguyJimmy117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ThatguyJimmy117 Dec 23 '17
This post real?
1
u/jixs203 Jun 16 '18
Any idea if the show will get a second season?
0
u/ColdBlackCage Dec 21 '17 edited Dec 21 '17
It's times like this where I remember a lot of users on this subreddit are absolute tasteless hacks who wish for minimal narrative complexity and just want cute girls. I can understand that, but this anime lacks so little substance that I'm hardly surprised people ignored it.
I wouldn't say it's particularly bad, and it's certainly not particularly good. It's exceedingly average in every aspect. If anything, it's most notable feature is the procedural discussion of board games, but is otherwise unworthy of any attention what-so-ever.
I feel like the producers knew this, which is why episode one has such blatant ecchi bait. It has so little under its belt that its literal only saving throw was to create a stir in the community with the first episode.
It's by no means an insult or saving grace to the industry as a whole, but it turned into such a thin experience that a newcomer is gonna fall through it into far more interesting things - which is what has certainly happened, as it has been banished to the realms of mediocrity.
-7
u/stormarsenal :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/AsherGZ Dec 20 '17
Yeah, well I'm one of those people offended at your comparison of this show with Just Because, whose key strength is how real and natural the relationship drama and even general character interactions feel.
There is no pandering, which is the exact opposite of this show. People like the characters for who they are, not because they're the personification of the viewer's fetish, which is exactly what Nayu, or Sagiri 2.0 as I like to call her, is. A character created for the sole purpose of being a "my waifu" for the otaku, this time with a legal age in canon, so you don't feel bad for lewding her, but still loli enough in looks for you to get your rocks off.
And let me not even get started on the Shirobako bit. A few meta references do not a deconstruction make. The shows main purpose is pandering, and everything from the pantyshots to the meta is a means towards that goal.
Sorry but your comparisons are way off mark in the least, but mostly they're just insulting to the shows mentioned.
-1
u/YoshiYogurt :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/YoshiYogurt Dec 21 '17
This is by far one of the worst show's I've seen.
-1
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '17
NOOOOOPE
-7
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '17 edited Dec 21 '17
I ended up dropping this show because it was extreme ecchi for not reason other than to check a box it felt like.
The comedy was good sometimes, and the two guys and tax person were funny, but it felt like it was forcing itself to be fanservice.
So I literally can't see how this is "the feel good slice of life" you are saying it is.
edit, nah you guys are right. I love my slice of life with egg deepthroating and constant sex remarks
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 20 '17
[deleted] — view deleted comment