r/anime • • Feb 08 '18
[WT!] Shimoneta: enjoying the Reddit censorship drama? Take a look at an anime that takes it up to 11.
My Anime List | Sub/Dub = Funimation | Anilist | nyanpass | Anime Planet | ANN | Kitsu | AniDB |
The recent Reddit drama has brought to light one of the most heated debates concerning the anime community: censorship. What should be considered obscene? What should be keep away from out kids? How should we implement filters to enforce our rules? Shimoneta is a satirical depiction of a Japan that has taken this to the extreme. As the OP narrates before every episode:
A few decades have passed since the use of indecent words and phrases, in both public and private, have become prohibited throughout Japan.
Thanks to relentless legislation and the introduction of the PM surveillance system, Japan attained its status as the nation with the most pristine public morals in the world.
This is a story about a group of boys and girls fighting to overthrow this boring world where the concept of dirty jokes does not exist.
The backdrop might be serious. The anime is not
Reddit censoring, Japan's censoring, all of that is serious business and Shimoneta does indeed cover this. But the manner in which it is all carried out is anything but. The setting for the anime is a near future Japan, where all citizens are forced to wear PM collars that also act as wearable computers. Due to absolute and complete censorship of NSFW material by the government, nobody in the highschool setting is aware of sex jokes or even the concept of sex. This leads to a bizarre situation where students act more bizarrely towards the idea of sex than normal people did before the ban. Quite the setting for a comedy.
This bizarreness is best represented in the character of Anna. As the head of the student council and the daughter of the politician pushing for stricter censorship laws she should be the purest character in the entire anime. However, as she has no knowledge of how to act on her desires she turns into a sexually aggressive monster all while still maintaining the purest of intentions.
To fix this broken world
A common criticism towards this anime is the abundance of 'reverse' rape situations where President Anna sexually assaults the MC. An important point to keep in mind though is that the anime never condones these advances nor does it paint it in a good light.
This is where the main characters of this anime are brought in. The story follows Okuma Tanukichi and the anti-censorship terrorist organization on grounds: S.O.X (Sex happens most Often on Xmas), led by the charismatic 'Blue Snow'. Their goal is to show off to the world how oppressed everyone in this world is, and to fight for the rights of those who enjoy NSFW material. All this while armed solely with sex jokes and a few porn magazines left over from before the censorship days. Their mission is to protest loudly and to distribute knowledge to those who have been too brainwashed so not to allow monsters like Anna to be created.
What are we censoring? A little serious thought.
In the end, the world of Shimoneta will never actually happen. But it is also interesting to look into what it has to say about our world. What are we censoring, and for what purpose? Some things are NSFW and should always be tagged as such, but would the world truly be a better place if nobody had access to them at all times? While thinking about the children, are we inadvertently going to craft our own Annas who wouldn't know how to act when faced with their own desires?
But on the other side of the token, The PM system has reduced crime and improved neo-Japan's reputation is a pristine and low crime nation. If a country right now was promised similar results by implementing the PM system, would it not make sense for them to take up that offer?
This analogy becomes even more interesting as it is applied to websites like Reddit. As the 7th most popular website on the internet with no age limit it has a reputation and userbase to worry about. And unlike with nations, it won't really be restricting users freedoms with any censorship rules as those affected can effortlessly switch to other platforms. At this point a slightly controversial censor to vastly improve image almost sounds like a nobrainer.
A vision of hope, and back to the fun
This unanswerable debate is part of the reason that even by the end of the anime, neither side has a comprehensive victory. The anime does not try to answer the question of which side is correct, but is content at celebrating the Perorists' struggles for our fetishes and lewd animu. And we as an audience don't have to actively join the fight, but can be happy that there are those who will stand up for our hobbies.
To close off this [WT!] I'll leave two of this anime's most famous and enjoyable assets: The hilariously retro and epic Opening theme and the insanely catchy Ending theme
125
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18
Thats us in 10 years
25
u/SomeGuyNamedJason Feb 08 '18
What reddit censorship drama?
11
u/XanTheInsane :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/XanTheInsane Feb 08 '18
The opening has some amazing GIF material https://i.imgur.com/rOOfWGj.gifv
And some scenes exist purely to give a middle finger to censorship.
13
u/feanor0815 Feb 08 '18
I have some minor problems with your analysis:
sorry but with the omnipresence of smartphones, their capability of listening in and a resurge in religious right-wing ideology this isn't to far fetched if sane people aren't vigilant!
next: besides stupid ideology reasons, why is there NSFW material, which is deemed inappropriate for children? i mean i heard many times the argument that small children can't possible understand that little Timmy has two mothers but no dad... but the fact is this is a fucking LIE. members of my family worked in kindergarten and elementary schools... you can explain simple concepts like that to children without any negative consequences... on the other hand, not teaching children does lead to immense problems... its like not telling children that stealing is wrong and then wonder why so many children steal stuff...
edit: spelling
67
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18
When I first watched Shimoneta my thought process was something like this.
This show looks cool
"Cock and balls!"
Yep definitely cool.
23
u/Kiyo_is_my_Hime Feb 08 '18
This show teaches you how to make a DIY Onahole. It's amazing!
3
u/GenesisEra myanimelist.net/profile/Genesis_Erarara Feb 08 '18 edited Feb 08 '18
Just so you know, people used to think this about Donald Trump becoming president
and Ash possibly losing the Kalos League in XY&Zbut look where we are today.I treat “never say never” as a warning.
Also, u/YoruDance? 10 years? That’s a cheery outlook. I half expect something like The Fappening Mk 2.0 and the resulting reactionary ban on all NSFW content to happen in the next five years.
Heck, this WT won’t survive the temperature of 451 degrees F.
8
u/Zeta42 Feb 08 '18
Wish they animated the rest of it. The only thing it wouldn't have is the lovely Matsuki Miyu ;_;
7
u/joeyvalentino :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Joeyvalentino Feb 08 '18
A great example of a show that I decided to check out for the hell of it and ended up binge watching the whole series in one sitting. Highly recommended.
6
u/ChaoticRyu :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarkRyu8 Feb 08 '18
The fact this show also had to air censored adds a layer of irony which made it funnier.
14
u/zenithfury Feb 08 '18
I'm constantly amazed that censorship exists. Not just for minors, but for adults as well. Pornography banned in many countries. Books banned for offending some religion, or endorsing some taboo philosophy or lifestyle. Censorship is condescension of the highest magnitude imposed by some people over all the others.
I can accept that we shouldn't show just anything to minors because it can be too shocking if shown all at once... But for seasoned adults I can't think of a good reason to prevent them from studying any sort of material should they want to. Adults are perfectly capable of self-censorship, limiting their exposure to materials that they do not want to see.
5
u/generalecchi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/GeneralEcchi Feb 08 '18
The entire fucking internet
4
u/Icekong123 Feb 08 '18
Ah the semen demon.
4
u/WoodpeckerNo1 https://anilist.co/user/Nishi23 Feb 08 '18
Recommended, great show. Plus, nice pics at the last episode if you know what I mean.
19
u/serverthreat Feb 08 '18
Great show, loved it. Sad to see that reddit has placed their American standards above everyone, saying anyone below 18 cant even have sex. I am not hebesexual, just pointing out facts.
1
u/Malorn44 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Malorn44 Feb 08 '18
What's the best way to watch this legally? I couldn't find it on crunchyroll unless I was mistaken.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18
I normally don't like ecchi anime, but it was just a lot of fun to watch; probably because it didn't take itself seriously, which I appreciated. Just a lot of fun to watch imo.
2
u/Melbuf Feb 08 '18
WTF you talking about willis?
2
u/jnd3r :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/jnd3r Feb 08 '18
Very thought provoking show. More than once I went from "This is so funny!" to "Oh wow, this is quite uncomfortable" in seconds. The world needs more sex-ed, not complete censorship. And yes, the ending song is one of the best ever, I love it!
2
u/HeitorO821 :K:https://kitsu.io/users/ZathuraVentura Feb 08 '18
So we should do the SOX thing and send all our loli hentai to the houses of everyone working on Reddit? I'm in.
1
u/deathsay :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Deathsay Feb 08 '18
I've always wondered what is the perceptions of shows like this in Japan, do they hate it, love it, or what.
-3
u/ChokeBee Feb 08 '18
Well, it's not like pleddit is all there is. At least we can make a good laugh from these stuck up morons elsewhere so they can grow with unspeakable (and unreasonable) anger when those jokes are reposted here.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 08 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment