r/anime • u/roxer123 • Feb 11 '18
[WT!] Sword Art Online. Yes, I'm not joking.
I apologize for any mistakes in my writing, for I am not a native speaker of English.
Recommending Sword Art Online in any fashion is most of the time a death sentence, specially when done in a wide spread discussion space with lots of anime fans. Wherever you go, treating SAO as a bad show is essentially dogmatic. There'll always be people to defend it, but those are more often than not swarmed by their peers, and they claim immaturity, lack of taste, among other things, from whomever tries to defend SAO.
I'm not here to play devil's advocate. I very much agree that SAO is a bad show. However, these reasons are not absolute, they aren't the lost 11th commandment. They are solely based on my own experience with the show, and not on some hive mind consensus that SAO is bad. While one may expect this to be true for everyone, a lot of people base their opinions on so-claimed authorities on the subject, like Digibro or Geoff from Mother's Basement (This isn't to say that I disagree with their argument regarding SAO or to attack them in any shape or form, but rather to demonstrate examples of "authorities" whose opinion some take as word of law). Rather than using their own experience and opinion of the show, some use the experience and opinion of others to judge it.
This isn't to say that defending a point with an argument that has already been made is wrong, but rather that basing your argument regarding something on the opinions and experiences of others is detrimental, for you are not arguing with your own taste, but with the taste of others, thus not adding anything new to the discussion. Furthermore, you can only ever really confirm someone else's point about a piece of art by experiencing it yourself, and you may very well draw different conclusions than them. If you don't watch something because someone else said it is bad, you're excluding yourself from what may be a good experience.
As so, my objectives with this Watch This post are two: To encourage people who've never watched SAO to give it shot, for it is a show that has a myriad of things for a new viewer to possibly enjoy and enough cultural relevance for the experienced viewer that hasn't yet watched it to, well, watch it.
Some may see this as a bit of hypocrisy: How could one recommend a show they admit is bad? It's a simple matter to answer. SAO is only really bad to people that have a benchmark of what is good anime. Someone that is new to anime probably has no such benchmark, and thus is more inclined to have a good experience with SAO. The more experienced viewer will immediately notice the flaws in SAO, however, the newcomer has no such perception and will be more inclined to enjoy what the show has to offer. This, of course, depends on the fact that SAO even has anything to offer, which is surely and absurd right? Well, not really.
There's a reason for SAO's wild success. No show can become a cultural landmark like SAO for no reason. While it is a flawed show, it is not riddled of good points. It doesn't look terrible at a glance, the soundtrack is exciting, the premise is cool as fuck and it has a sweet romantic undertone. As baffling as this may seem to some, there is reason to watch SAO, and if any of the previously mentioned things are right up your alley, SAO is a show to check out. However, these are not the only reasons to watch SAO, because, as I have previously mentioned, it is a cultural landmark. SAO is an overwhelming presence in the anime community; It reached out to people that weren't even aware anime existed, created hours and hours of discussion and set the bar for what anime in the near future was gonna be like.
SAO is most definitely not the first of its kind. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya left a scar in the community that will most likely never heal. It kick-started "moe dances", set the bar for high school anime and for what ALL anime should strive to look like for the next DECADE. It was the first otaku-centered show with this level of quality and warranted a lot of attention. It's success was pre-destined. Similarly, Neon Genesis Evangelion altered anime eternally with its crazy themes and the success that came with them, setting the tone for what most anime movies and OVAs were going to be like for a decade.
Like the previously mentioned shows, SAO came at a time were the future was uncertain for anime (As in, no anime had set the stage for the future yet. While there were a whole bunch of popular anime, I believe none were as relevant culturally as was SAO): There hadn't really been any cultural landmarks and wide reaching shows as impactful as Haruhi and Eva, and whatever scar those shows had left was fading away. It was the first wide reaching show with such a premisse executed at this level of perceived quality. It was captivating and basically everyone heard of it, even people that weren't fans of anime. It almost single handedly extended the reach of anime from a very niche sub-culture to one of the biggest, if not THE biggest cultural phenomenon of the entire decade. This isn't to say that anime wasn't heading is this direction, but rather to say that SAO was what kick-started the explosion; The last straw that caused the anime dam to leak tremendously. Wether you like SAO or not, its relevance is undeniable. It is impossible to determine wether or not SAO left as big of a mark as Eva and Haruhi have, but the fact that we still talk about it six years after release is perhaps indicative of it.
This isn't to say that SAO was the only anime that pushed forward the medium to popularity. After it, Attack on Titan was probably as big a hit as was SAO, and did a good number to push everything even further forward into popularity, specially among a more mature audience.
When put like that, I think it becomes clear why I believe watching SAO to be of extreme importance to any anime fan, wether or not you think you'll like it. Understanding and being able to take part in anime culture basically takes for granted that you've watched and have an opinion on SAO. This means that, for anyone just getting into anime and its culture, SAO is a required watch.
As I mentioned before, its relevance is not the only reason to watch SAO. The show has qualities that might make for a really entertaining watch. While it is universally agreed that the second half of the show lacks a lot of the qualities of its arguably better-half, it is not entirely terrible.
The first thing that comes to the eye is the production value of the show. While it is perfectly fine to say that the show is badly animated when compared to things like Redline, Hyouka and Evangelion, the show's digital effects and occasional sakuga make for a very pleasing viewing experience to the untrained eye. Similarly, the soundtrack enhances the show's moments spectacularly, as is typical for Yuki Kajiura. While A-1 is obviously guilty of the A-1 face, the character designs are really attractive and animate well. Adding to all of this, Aincrad is a marvelous setting that really brings about a game-y feeling. Overall, SAO doesn't look terrible at all, and it is perfectly reasonable to think that someone that hasn't basked their eyes in the glorious animation of other shows like Space Dandy and One Punch Man will really enjoy the way SAO looks.
The second thing that comes to mind is the premise of the show. While premise is arguably the least important factor to determine wether or not a show will be enjoyable, it builds lots of hype. The idea of getting trapped in an MMO death game is really cool, and at the time the only thing to come close was .hack. In a sense, SAO was the first of the popular Isekai genre that plagues the anime scene today. The sheer existence of this premise in a show can single handedly carry the show in the backs of some people, specially self-inserts. And to be honest, self-inserting into Kirito is the easiest thing ever.
I can blab all I want about what SAO has in terms of redeemable qualities, but that is best left for the eye of the viewer. In fact, SAO is a great way to figure out what exactly you're looking for in an anime. Due to SAO's wide reach in audience, it contains something for basically everyone, and thus, by analyzing what exactly you enjoyed in SAO, you can find many other shows to watch yourself, further accelerating your fall in the anime hole. This all culminates in a single fact: SAO is a great gateway to anime. In one way or another, the show has just enough to make a new viewer find something to like it.
An important observation that I feel like I have to make is that being experienced does not automatically invalidate SAO as a possibly good experience. It is ok to like Sword Art Online. If SAO falls on your net of things to like, then that's totally ok, wether you are new to anime or an oldfag. You should never be ashamed of liking something due to some consensus. Also, don't force yourself to watch a show just because somebody said so for whatever reasons. While I do believe that there is plenty of reason to watch SAO, if you don't find reason to watch it, don't.
All in all, I don't think there are many people in this sub-reddit that haven't watched SAO yet. This post is aimed at the few that haven't yet watched for one reason or another, and to those I hope I have provided an interesting read and yet another reason to enjoy SAO.
208
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Feb 11 '18
Ok, I get the general idea you're going for, but a few things stood out to me. In particular:
is an odd thing to say given that Madoka Magica and Fate/Zero (two of the best selling anime of all time) came out a year before SAO. Throw in the likes of Steins;Gate and Usagi Drop, plus the beginning of Hunter x Hunter all starting up in the same year, and I can't really look at the anime scene as being especially uncertain.
Aside from that, I don't think forcing yourself to watch something just because everyone else has is necessarily the best idea, but that's just my opinion.
80
u/Nvaaaa Feb 11 '18
Everything here is probably going to be downvoted anyway, but well...
That is what people always get wrong. The premise is not the death game in Aincrad. Aincrad is the starting point to change the views of reality for the SAO characters. The premise of SAO is the question of how YOU see your reality.
Are memories, friendship, love only real if they happen in our real world? Are those connections to people we meet online fake, because they don't happen face to face in the real world? Or is every emotion we have online still real?
This is referenced in every SAO arc and starting by the fact, that the people got trapped in Aincrad and had to adapt. So Kirito took Aincrad as his "real world" for the time being and that's what he does with every other world. For him - no matter the place - the feelings are real and that's why the anime resonates with me and what makes it one of my favorites. Especially because I always had that stance, while others around me - when facebook and social media was not that big as it is today - laughed about it.
And no, I already watch anime for over 20 years so I am not new.
5
u/fearstone Feb 12 '18
What does WT mean? I'm new here.
54
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
I'm in the middle of reading your writeup but let me say this first and foremost.
I enjoyed the fuck out of SAO. Regardless if me, or anyone else, found it terrible, I had a good fucking time watching it, and I think that's all that should matter.
165
u/catjobber Feb 11 '18
"I apologize for any mistakes in my writing, for I am not a native speaker of English." Proceeds to write an essay in better English than most native speakers.
Jokes aside, I don't know why SAO gets so much hate on this sub. Is it the reddit circlejerk thing again?
15
u/LittleIslander https://anilist.co/user/LittleIslander Feb 11 '18
Surprisingly enough, this actually has made me consider changing my mind on it. I had no intention of ever watching it, but of all things, the part of on its impact and history swayed me. Would be interesting to see what was behind the impact, so long as it's not godawful.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
Sao got me back into anime after 10 year+ hiatus. Also got my wife watching.
8
u/sirhatsley :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sirhatsley Feb 12 '18
This exact [WT] has been done before, but you wrote it a little better. At this point i think SAO already has all the popularity it needs for people to watch it, and most people won't watch it to critically evaluate it, they just watch it to shit on it.
37
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '18
I respect the effort you put into a post that will most likely get downvoted.
18
u/DEERROBOT Feb 11 '18
SAO was my second anime, and I thought it was godly. Mostly because I didn't have much to compare it to, but now that I think about it I enjoyed it a lot, even if it was a bit messy.
9
u/Comander-07 Feb 12 '18
Maybe at some point we will reach a state where actually liking SAO is considered cool.
I liked SAO, then again I loved Cross Ange and was really disappointed with Cowboy Bepop. Taste differs.
9
u/PPGN_DM_Exia https://myanimelist.net/profile/PPGN_DM_Exia Feb 12 '18 edited Feb 12 '18
I watched SAO and SAO II as a fairly experienced viewer compared to many (watched it in 2015 with 100+ titles already under my belt). I came in with no expectations, half expecting to drop halfway through Fairy Dance or or even earlier because I was already well-aware of the backlash. And while Fairy Dance was bad, mostly because of how victimized Asuna, I finished it and still had a somewhat positive opinion of the series (scored 6/10).
SAO II is what really turned me into an unapologetic fan. Sure, the show still has a bit more fanservice than I would prefer (Sinon's Ass Online was not a good call IMO), and the show STILL cannot write villains to save its life, but I think Sinon and Yuuki really added a great dimension to the series. Overall, it was a major improvement in my eyes (scored 8/10), though admittedly a lot of flaws still remain.
Yuuki in particular is still my waifu, and Mother's Rosario brought me to tears, perhaps more than shows like Your Lie in April or Anohana. Not only that, but it developed Asuna to a point where I felt she'd grown beyond her Perfect Otaku Wet Dream GirfriendTM reputation and become a more well-rounded, flawed and human character. I just wish it hadn't taken so damn long.
7
u/IndyCotton Feb 11 '18 edited Feb 12 '18
Quite sharing most of the points you had here, aside from perhaps the cultural landmark point - I think SAO merely got quite lucky hitting into the anime market at the right time due various factors like flowing well on the rising of technology around the time compared to 2000s' Web Novel, while having decent production value put to it's presentation.
But indeed, I have had shared same thoughts and I have had managed to consume ton of good things before, so SAO felt bit like taking step back to more humbler times. Behold though, it kind of surprised me at times despite not being exactly "amazing".
Still, it kind of has me wonder why can't we allow these anime and their communities to co-exist together without necessarily demonizing and benchmarking on what is good anime - when if you just consume too much that good, it all becomes same over time. Sometimes you need to widen your perspectives or relax via exploring more experimental or even not-so-exceptional anime, if they happen to be popular too - and learn about various communities or people within them.
Most, importantly you learn more about yourself as well.
1
u/Wynter_Phoenyx Feb 12 '18
I read through (most of) your post, and I'm still not understanding why people dislike this show, especially on the art front. The only shows close to the style of SAO that you mentioned is Hyouka, and even then it feels like you're comparing apples to oranges since Hyouka looks like it's intended to be slice of life based on the muted palette whereas SAO uses a very saturated palette.
I get what you're going for, I just am not understanding the arguments against this show.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '18
I definitely feel that SAO suffered from airing when it did. If it aired now, it wouldn't catch that much (negative) attention, because nowadays seasons are filled with garbage wish-fulfillment isekai. Still, I wouldn't compare it to a recent isekai. It lacks some of the things in isekai that to me are very unappealing due to the original WN being written quite a while ago.
It shouldn't need to be said that you should watch shows yourself to form an opinion on them but I'm glad you did anyway.
8
u/GameRender Feb 12 '18 edited Feb 12 '18
SAO is not rabidly hated by the entire anime community. It used to be, but then a counterculture of "it's not that bad" appeared and took over /r/anime, and now everyone loves it. You'll notice that not being downvoted to hell like subs such as this seem to do with contratian opinions is a sign of this.
3
u/SchizoidSuperMutant Feb 11 '18
I appreciate the effort that you put in this post, but I think I'm going to pass on SAO. Just because I don't find the premise very interesting. I might try it in the future, though.
Having said that, I agree completely on the point you made of not letting other people's opinion influence how you spend your time. I often find myself reading reviews on MAL after finishing a manga or anime, trying to reconcile the experience I had with the ones of others'. Then I ask myself: "Why?". Yes, sometimes I gain some interesting insights on the work I've just finished, but other than that, I feel I'm just punishing myself for enjoying things.
So, yeah. People, just watch things that catch your eye. If you like them, you finish them. And eventually you develop a taste and a critical sense. It's kind of obvious, but it's something I'd have liked to know before.
9
u/screwyluie Feb 11 '18
Well screw it. I love SAO. It's a great show. I like the characters, the story, the art, all of it. What I really like the most is how it reminds me of what it felt like the first time I played an MMORPG (asheron's call for those wondering). That sense of adventure, the fear of the unknown, the thrill of PK'ing (player killing). The exploration, the loot... Finding that new and amazing thing.
Now that online gaming and MMOs are everywhere people are over exposed and they don't get the same level of awe, wonder, and excitement from something new. SAO let's me share that with others, what it was like when the first MMOs came around.
So haters can hate but as for me, I love SAO.
4
u/WeNTuS Feb 12 '18
My problem with people hating SAO is that like if show isn't greatest of all time, then it's bad. No, it doesn't work like that. SAO maybe isn't greatest show of all time, but it's good and solid. It's entertaining. Claiming that it's bad because it's not flawless is very immature in my opinion.
2
u/omnimater Feb 12 '18
SAO is one of my favorite shows despite/because of its flaws. It's one where I like the overall premise more than the execution, mainly in that even though the original premise is one in which a story should have a great amount of room and time to grow and develop, the entire process is incredibly rushed to get to the next arc, the next game (this is true for every arc of the story until the next one up for the show, going by the light novels). But there is something to be said for watching a scene and just saying like "wow, that's fucking cool." Even if the surrounding story or character cast is incredibly weak.
Idk I don't get the need by so many to trash on shows that many people like. I don't like Naruto, but I don't go around dogging on Naruto for being a shit show (whether it is or not isn't up to me).
2
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
It's not a perfect show by any means and follows some silly tropes. But my wife and I enjoyed it.
And I'll be the first to admit I cried like a little bitch at the end of the second season.
2
u/AndrewLobsti Feb 12 '18
I support it, SAO was the show that got me into anime in the first place. Sure, it has many flaws, but i still find it to be a very enjoyable show.
2
u/BonoboClone Feb 12 '18
The first season blew me away!
2
u/warlocx Feb 12 '18
I think that SAO is a prime example of missed potential. I enjoy the animation, i really like the concept, the start was great. Only the story got lost somewhere.
2
u/SirNanashi Feb 12 '18
I volunteer for crucifixion. SAO is my favorite anime. I will die with no regrets!
2
u/Damnmage Feb 12 '18
I love SAO, i don't care what people say it about it, i'm watching it for me not anyone else.
3
u/abh037 Feb 12 '18
I thought SAO was pretty good.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
Yeah SAO is pretty alright. I enjoyed all 14 episodes of it!
1
u/Julianus-Vatinius :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vatinius Feb 12 '18
I loved SAO but most people will agree with me that fairy arc was not a shining point of the series but it is required for the plait to progress. SAO gets a lot of unfair dislike.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
The thing is, the show isn't perfect. Like any other show it carries its flaws however most people have taken all its flaws and governed the entire show unwatchable. I for one enjoyed many parts of the show as well as disliked may parts of the show. So, yeah definitely watch not that bad of a show!
1
u/ObliviousJahin :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/It Feb 12 '18
Hey if you got nothing else, just watch the series for S3, gonna be good
1
u/Mojo_13659 Feb 12 '18
I think SAO is a decent show to be honest. But also in my honest opinion, i only recommended SAO because i recommend SAO Abridged first.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
I liked it when I watched it years ago, I liked it when I rewatched it a couple months ago to see if perhaps I'd missed something that the hate train hadn't. Sure it has it's flaws, and honestly I could do without the fairy world storyline altogether and another 13 episodes in Aincrad further developing the characters and world but I still find it enjoyable. It's not in my top 10 but I don't really see why it gets so much hate.
1
u/pm_your_pantsu Feb 12 '18
i just watched cardinal movie [it took me 6h to DL 22gb, dam son] it was so good, i felt what i felt when watching the half of the first season, the only sao.
1
u/Shinkopeshon Feb 12 '18
I just got SAO S1 on Blu-Ray, so I'll definitely rewatch it soon. I could rewatch the Aincrad arc and Ordinal Scale a million times. I never expected to enjoy this show as much as I did and the exaggerated hate it gets is absurd, so I appreciate that you made a WT! thread.
And sure, it has a bunch of problems and it should be criticised accordingly but overall, it's far from a trainwreck. I enjoyed it more than a lot of other shows I found technically better, (kinda like DBZ).
1
u/scorcher117 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/scorcher117 Feb 12 '18
Currently re-watching it with my mum after it being my first anime at the end of 2014 and I am still loving it 3+ years later, so this is a series you can still enjoy beyond just starting anime.
1
u/kingoftheswiss Feb 12 '18
SAO was my first anime that I watched. Having it on Netflix was probably the only reason I got wind of it and definitely got me into anime.
I agree it’s not the best, but it was a solid platform to get into anime.
1
u/TheRealBailey_ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheRealBailey_ Feb 12 '18
Mmm, yep this is fair and relevant to me since I’ve been watching anime a while but never got round to this, guess I’ll watch a little while after I finish Utawarerumono: Itsuwari no Kamen. Also, fun to switch to ‘controversial’ in these comments.
1
u/meimi132 Feb 12 '18
I really liked SAO. It may be that it's cos I really liked the .Hack// franchise, and needed to scratch that itch.
I know it's not perfect. But I still really enjoyed it and I still to this day don't get the hate XD. Spose this is how Naruto fans feel alot of the time XD
1
u/prophane33 Feb 12 '18
I've been watching anime longer than a lot of people reading this have been alive. I love SAO. It's like how some people love the Fast and Furious movies; is it a masterpiece? Hell, no. Is it big dumb fun? Very much so.
1
u/heycheerilee :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/braveshined Feb 12 '18
I think a lot of reason people like it - at least for me - is wish fulfillment. I was addicted to Maplestory at the time I watched it, so that didn't help. I still like SAO and I'm still going to follow it, but it definitely has some flaws. You could say I'm at the acceptance stage lol
1
u/[deleted] Feb 13 '18
I loved it. Sometimes we all need a bit of wish fulfillment.
1
u/liatris4405 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/liatris4405 Feb 14 '18
I'm doing otaku for over 20 years.
I saw a lot of animation and manga too.
You can also understand that SAO is defective.
But I can not understand why it is criticized so far.
I only see anime otaku being concerned about external reputation.
By appreciating SAO it appears to be afraid of being called sexist or narcissist.
1
u/JamesLucrative Feb 15 '18
You gotta do it ironically. Do you like characters literally draped in plot armor so they wear a Neo trenchcoat? What about incest or lolis that your thing?
You don't tell people SAO is a great anime. It's not. It's butter man. Pure butter you spread all over your face and other parts of your body and hate yourself afterwards.
I'm writing a fanfic of it if anyone is interested. My favorite animes to date are Eatman and Golgo13. Because I like my perfect characters to be hyper masculine and straight out of a nine inch nails album cover not green day. Fucking millennials
0
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '18
I'm sure you had more to say, but this pissed me off so much I stopped reading immediately. The concept that it's okay to recommend shows almost universally accepted as bad (as even OP admits, "The more experienced viewer will immediately notice the flaws in SAO"), with the justification of "the newcomer lacks the benchmark" is absurd. If the concept was "recommend this show because it's accessible to newcomers and gives their perspective room to grow" it would still be ridiculous, albeit to a lesser extent. But the subtext reads "since new watchers don't know shit, they won't know it's bad, and it's fairly entertaining!" sets up future regret. I certainly regret watching SAO, and I'm sure a lot of other people do as well. It's not okay to purposely recommend people shows that have a high likelyhood to be regretted.
1
u/link7yrslater Feb 12 '18
I like sao
1
u/ISevaI Feb 12 '18
i kinda wanna watch sao just to get the grip of garbage now
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
It was a great show at an initial glance. And it still is. The show did a fantastic job of exploring an imagined world where VR and AR devices have taken over in the not-too-distant future. It's been quite a while since I watched the show so I don't remember many details as I used to but the way the director used scenes to evoke some emotion in viewers was excellent as far as I remember. The ending scene on season 1 where Kirito gets up and walks out of his hospital bed, resting his weakened body on a stick as he walks his way to Asuna and music seeps out was definitely the appropriate culmination of what had been a large-scale and arduous adventure. Walking to glory, if you will.
The only issue I saw with SAO was with the illogical plotline that seems to justify the atrocities committed by Kayaba Akihiko. Regardless of his motives, the mass killings that were carried out at his hands are clearly evil by any reasonable and widely upheld beliefs of human ethical standards. It striked me as odd on watching the part where Kirito meets Kayaba and he seems to instantly empathise with the serial killer who unfazedly massacred thousands of lives, instead of throwing it out. Of course, all this sinked under the powerful emotion of the scene decorated with music and tears as per the intention of the director in that very moment.
Someone might say the plotline was necessary to propel the story forward. Kayaba has not finished his role in the scheme of things and he does provide some help to Kirito later on. However, considering the fact that so many lives were lost to satsify curiosity of a single person with a deranged mindset, there is something about Kirito's attitudes that make it difficult to understand his personalities and make it that more difficult to emphathise with the show as an audience.
It does leave something to be desired, I guess but overall, it is a great show.
As for its relationship to other anime, I have nothing to comment on but it wouldn't surpirse me if the show has influenced a lot of following ones.
TL ; DR : Excellent scene-making techniques shown by the director and production. Some little holes in the plotline which might be negligible, but are hard to decipher and empathise with. Overall, great show nonetheless and definitely an influencer.
1
u/Emperor-Valtorei Feb 12 '18
I loved SAO. I’m not ashamed, it’s my opinion, so y’all can shove it. I respect your opinion, even though it’s wrong, and I’ll even take downvotes... Gonna live my life the way I want to. ^
1
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
I did like SAO but I have to accept that it has bad writing and stuff
1
u/ToFat2Run :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/buzxig866 Feb 12 '18
I never really disliked SAO until that point where the second half started on the first season. That whole arc is just terrible beyond belief that I dropped the series without a second thought.
1
u/Biomang :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Biomang Feb 12 '18
See the reason I hate SAO is because the main character was so unbelievable. He was basically Jesus Christ encarnate. He had no flaws at all besides perhaps being a bit of a loner at the start but besides that he was completely unrelatable and the entire thing was ruined in how abruptly he attracted the female protaginist.
Show just had awful character development. Oh and the little fairy thing they adopted was just weird.
1
u/0xFFF1 Feb 12 '18
Go find the Light Novels for SAO: Progressive. Reki Kawahara went back to the original Aincrad arc and redid everything from scratch using the writing skills he had honed in the meantime. Some of the major differences are, imo:
1
u/AnimalSloth Feb 12 '18
Not reading and downvoting lmao
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
Log Horizon, DanMachi and Overlord exist. There isn't much point watching SAO when there are multitude of shows that are exactly the same except better in every way.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
are you seriously bringing up sao in 2018
0
u/ivnwng Feb 12 '18
Too long, didn’t read. But hey, if you really enjoy it, good for you. That’s all it mattered.
0
u/Knuffelig https://myanimelist.net/profile/Knuffelig Feb 12 '18
It is ok to like Sword Art Online, but it is hard to recommend SAO to somebody who rarely watches anime and is above a certain age group. Or doesnt share the fetishes. People would like to openly like and recommend it, because in general it is very good. If those flaws weren't that major. I wouldnt say people really hate SAO, they are just incredibly frustrated since it could be so much more with just a few minor tweaks here and there.
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
I'm kinda fresh to the Anime scene so I haven't watched much Anime yet - but I have to say that the statement "newbies should watch SAO because it's popular, everyone knows it and it's a good gateway Anime" isn't really the case, in my opinion.
Yes I watched SAO as one of my "gateway Animes" (along with things like AoT, FMAB and Death Note) and I liked it for the fact that it speeks to my favorite hobby - gaming - it helped me to get touched with MMORPGs along with the name "Kirosuno" (KIRitO, aSUna, siNOn) - so SAO gave me a lot of things for what I'm kinda thank full. But as I watched more shows like Angel Beats, Your lie in April and currently Steins;Gate I had to realize that SAO is something that I only liked because I'm intersted in the mmorpg genere.
But let's get to the point:
(TL:DR) So just watch SAO if you interested in things like gaming but don't expect to much of it (even if you like it there are a shit ton of better Anime out there) - if you're not into the genere of gaming or isekai just don't watch it if you don't really want to even if its popular and everyone talks about it, because most of the time people only talk about the relatively good first part but not of the offending second part (even I do).
PS: sorry if my grammer isn't that well
-2
u/LordKaelan :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/LordKaelan Feb 12 '18
If you honestly think SAO is a Bad/below advage anime you are a mindless sheep with a tainted opinion because of the internet.
-1
u/pikkuhukka Feb 12 '18
honey you dont have to defend your opinion that you like SAO with a wall of text, just like it and move on :3
i love it and i dont give a flying derp about if someone hates me cause i love sao :3
-3
u/kancolle_nigga Feb 12 '18
https://i.imgur.com/JncrRQr.jpg
AAA+ writing
0
u/eetsumkaus https://myanimelist.net/profile/kausdc Feb 12 '18
This one should not be underestimated. I was one of those SAO haters, but at one point, I started putting on SAO in the background as white noise while working and listening to it on (good) headphones.
Holy. Shit. If you want to know how an anime can immerse you with its sound production values, SAO is Exhibit A. One of the most fascinating things I got out of it was how captivating it could be despite all the things wrong with it. It's almost like the creators were crying out their vision of SAO through the shittiness of the script and the genericness of the art. All the seiyuus nail their performances, foley work is practically inseparable from the screen, OST is top notch and edited to perfection in each scene.
Just take a look at (SAO SPOILERS!!!) this scene with Kirito and Suguha and listen to it on either a good sound system or headphones. I think this is a great example because hearing it described makes it sound like the stupidest thing on Earth, but actually watching it, I feel things.
SAO started my obsession with sound production values in shows, because I feel like SAO could NOT be the same show without it.
0
u/fatherkimothy Feb 12 '18
Yeah, everyone just has a circle jerk for hating SAO no matter what.
Even considering the fact that it probably the best show for a young film/anime newcomer considering how easy it is to digest.
Sure, it's not a good show when compared to other highly regarded ones, but there's a charm about SAO that is responsible for being millions of people's first favorite anime, no matter how obvious the flaws are.
Obviously, if you are already into films/anime or are a bit older/mature, then SAO will probably never appeal to you.
To anyone looking for a starter show, I always have two specific ones that I usually recommend.
SAO and Erased.
Try SAO if you are young and have little to no experience in theater/writing/cinematography and want to enjoy an easy to digest Fantasy show.
If you are disappointed with SAO early on and drop it, or you have experience in films or are a bit older and looking for a drama/thriller/mystery that covers a more mature subject but is still easy to consume for the newer viewer of anime's wildly paced shows, then try Erased.
-4
u/Evilandlazy :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/evilandlazy Feb 12 '18
This is why SAO sucks.
"If you die in the game, you die IRL"
Nobody of any importance dies.
-2
u/Tazzure Feb 12 '18
no
-12
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
SAO is garbage.. simple.. straight to the point. Whoever like SAO must be retards anyway
0
u/[deleted] Feb 11 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment