r/anime • u/kaverik :Ef::Eh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kaverik • Feb 25 '18
WT! [WT!] Ergo Proxy
"What has been divided, must become one."
They say when huge ambition meets perfect execution actual masterpieces are born. They also say there are no true 10/10 anime exist.
It's hard to describe Ergo Proxy, an anime created by Manglobe (still remember them?) in 2006, in few words. Commonly perceived as a big original work with seemingly endless ambition which borders on pretentiousness if not madness, with all the philosophical allegories, convoluted story and dark, edgy™ atmosphere, Ergo Proxy is deemed as an acquired taste and is rarely recommended to a mass viewer. It's true that the scope of the work reaches the skies, burning itself while approaching the sun - however, that sheer ambition allows Ergo Proxy to show unique traits which make it a standout work among all of other anime, even if it takes experience to notice. And hey, it's not like execution is all too bad either.
Anime: Ergo Proxy
Episodes: 23
Year: 2006
Genres: Sci-Fi, Mystery, Psychological
Available on: Crunchyroll, Funimation, Hulu
Those of you who are model citizens, let's throw things away. [...] Your life will become easier when you lessen the number of things in your life.
- an announcer, Episode 1
Faraway future. People live in the special domed cities, mostly oblivious to what's happening outside of their zone of comfort. Re-l lives a respectable and comfortable life of a regent's granddaughter in one of such cities named Romdeau. She also works at her leisure in Citizen Intelligence Bureau as an inspector, complaining that nothing ever happens in this utopia. On one day, however, her peaceful life comes to an end - she was attacked by a terrifying monster, who ravaged her house and almost killed her in process. Driven by curiosity, Re-l tries to uncover mysteries of the monster, launching an investigation which will uncover far more sinister secrets of the world. Wait, what this meek guy has to do with anything?
Ergo Proxy doesn't hold back its scope from the beginning: unsettling atmosphere of (anti)utopia, cryptic phrases, mysterious characters - all of that is here to capture attention of the viewer. It works really well - action mixed with mystery fills the screen, and when the viewer finally prepares themselves for a serious political thriller a la Stand Alone Complex the story shifts for the first time. Suddenly, the characters are on the road, traveling around the world and trying to find themselves amidst the endless wasteland. And when the viewer gets accustomed to a wacky, totally bizarre adventure the genre changes once again. This is how Ergo Proxy works - it feels like several highly talented, ambitious people tried to pull the anime in different directions, resulting in eccentric amalgamation of brilliant ideas (while in reality it's all created by mastermind of Dai Sato). Melancholy of being an android in human society? Sure, why not. Awkward romance? Let's put it in! Choose a famous song by an iconic western group for an ending? Great idea! Starting episodes in the middle of the trouble so viewer gets more confused? Sounds cool, let's do this. By the way, you know why Ergo Proxy has such an interesting title? Yes, because it "sounds cool". Nothing more, nothing less.
This is one of the reasons why Ergo Proxy is an honest anime despite all of its ambition. In its heart it's an experimental work with a strong craving for adventure, which bears similarities to Samurai Champloo and Wolf's Rain. That's why one of the episodes takes place entirely in one of the characters' head. During the other characters are "busy doing nothing", while a notorious quiz episode achieved a legendary status. Ergo Proxy isn't afraid of taking risks - it embraces its weirdness and creates memorable, unique experience, effortlessly juggling the genres and even the artstyle. Sick and tired of predictability in anime, when events of next episode are seen from miles away? Ergo Proxy knows how to surprise or, in other words, how to entertain a viewer.
"Look at the minimalist beauty of this world. All of us are manufactured cogwheels in this utopia. Our existence is allowed so we can fulfill this reason we've been given."
- Raul Creed, episode 10
Entertainment and experiments aside, the anime has a lot to say on its own. Essentially, Ergo Proxy is a story about identity and, pardon my French, raison d'être, which the series is not-so-subtle about. Existentialism runs deep in Ergo Proxy, and at some points of the plot all characters think about their own reasons to live and struggle against cruel fate, often conflicting with their own sanity and world perception. Fair word of warning: the story is twisted, hard to understand fully and requires immediate and full attention. Filled with cultural and historical references, Ergo Proxy is infamous for being "too deep" for the sake of it, borrowing a lot from philosophy "just to look smart". It's up to one's judgment how really pretentious Ergo Proxy is, but one thing is for sure - it tries to be something different, with varied success.
Arguably the main reason why the series gets its job done against all odds is its cast of characters. Unlike many other psychological and experimental anime with dark and twisted nature, Ergo Proxy feels very much humane - and it's by virtue of having incredible cast. It's not easy task to create very much alive characters in otherwise dead world, while not making them totally naive and breaking immersion. Re-l seems like a cool badass female character similar to Motoko Kusanagi from Ghost in the Shell, while in reality she is just an ice queen with superiority complex. Iggy, Re-l's devoted companion, is hardly a simple machine serving a human and has surprising depth which also speaks for Re-l herself. Vincent Law has his own story which is long enough to create a whole anime about him. Pino makes the whole company work and is just adorable without measure. All of them are deeply troubled, show variety of emotions and are devoted to their own goals. The strong cast can make or break the story, and the person who was working on a script of Cowboy Bebop and Eureka 7 knows it best.
A buzzword "atmospheric" is also often thrown while talking about Ergo Proxy, and it indeed describes the anime extremely well. That odd middle section with almost standalone episodes exists for a reason. Remember that extraordinary weird game show episode? It's actually a brilliant way to tell exposition and provide necessary worldbuilding. What about that "filler" episode where characters did absolutely nothing? It was crucial in establishing characters' relationship, developing their bond and making them more likeable to the viewer. Add to this excellent visual style with distinct choice of color (almost everything in the anime is brown, grey and just dark), amazing and often overlooked OST full of electric guitars and industrial tunes, deliberately slow pace which unwillingly unravels mysteries and drops vague hints - and you get an example of how to create an unforgettable, embracing world which is hard to put on hold. Atmosphere of Ergo Proxy is second to none, and even people who disliked the series can hardly argue about that.
"The world will come to and end soon. That's just fate."
Ergo Proxy is wild, uneven and ambitious, sometimes too ambitious for its own good, when the mind of viewers can't keep up with all the nuances of the complex story. That's why it's a difficult anime to recommend - yet still, it rewards patient and attentive anime lovers with rich plot, remarkable characters and unique, haunting experience. Anime as deep and daring as Ergo Proxy are hard to come by (especially these days full of LN adaptations), which makes them all the more precious after passing years.
Watch if you liked:
- Shinsekai yori;
- Ghost in the Shell;
- Serial Experiments Lain.
Watch if you look for:
- atmospheric adventure with ingenious worldbuilding and captivating mysteries;
- likeable cast of characters who try to defy fate;
- experimental anime which isn't afraid of taking risks.
Be wary of:
- the story which is hard to understand and ending close to ideals of Gainax;
- at times excessive references and allusions to history and philosophy.
6
u/Khalku Feb 25 '18
What does that mean?
5
u/Slay3d https://anilist.co/user/Arcane Feb 26 '18
Well, guess I’ll watch
4
u/Reejis99 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Reejis99 Feb 26 '18
What does"WT!" mean?
3
u/omegashadow :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/omegashadows Feb 26 '18 edited Feb 26 '18
I thought Ergo Proxy was pretty good but it was also one of the first shows I found to be pretentious.
That's not because it was not clever and intellectually stimulating, it was both of those things some of the time and had some amazing moments. But overall I feel like despite being pretty "deep" it presented itself as way deeper than it actually was. Spent a lot of time building that slow burn tone in service of a jumble of ideas with no thematic core.
spoilers
Other shows with that same slow burn pacing do it to challenge the audiences patience in service of some core themes or ideas. Texhonlyze managed to convey it's nihilism way more effectively. I am not even sure that ergo proxy had much to say about it's decaying world.
46
u/-DatRandomDude- :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DatRandomDude Feb 25 '18
Also has one of the best Opening song in anime.
34
u/JamCliche :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JamCliche Feb 25 '18
Even the plot is confusing at times, it gladly explains itself in full near the end of the series in that fantastic meta-as-fuck game show episode. After that it's basically a joyride straight to the climax.
22
u/VincentBlack96 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vincent Feb 25 '18
I didn't read it but I'll just trust you and add it to PTW! :hug:
16
u/yuffieXcore Feb 25 '18
Pino is arguably the best thing about EP
https://youtu.be/VJntEXVhqZs
9
u/Re-l-Mayer :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Unique_Username Feb 25 '18
You, I like you!
6
u/scarmask Feb 26 '18
One of my favourites, but then I like melancholic slow paced anime with mysterious plots and wanky, edgy themes, so really it's a perfect storm. It obviously isn't for everyone.
My only real gripe with it is how inconsistent the animation is, the pilot is gorgeous, but then the budget kinda falls off a cliff. Didn't distract me much but I've known people who were really frustrated by it.
Lastly, Pino is a good girl.
5
u/Sharkface Feb 26 '18
Ergo Proxy is one of my top ten anime and I’ll admit there’s a part of it that feels like a real slag to get through but it rewards you. I watched it like half way the first time I attempted it, and then restarted it a whiiiile later and fell in love.
Also, the dub isn’t bad at all. Very easy to relax with and really get into due to how casually you can listen compared to reading all those very emotional and deep conversations.
3
u/ukehi Feb 25 '18
It took me 10 years to watch ergo proxy. I downloaded the episodes when they were originally released by fansub groups. I started it but I felt it had a very slow pace, so I dropped it. I tried to watch it again through the years and dropped it every time. But last year, I decided that I had to stop dropping it and when I finished it I realized that I missed a good show all these years. Not my fav, but good enough.
3
u/cosmo321 Feb 26 '18
This was the first anime I watched in HD back in 2006. It looked so good visually compared to most other anime at the time.
One of my all time favorite animes.
9
u/LeviathanDivine https://anilist.co/user/leviathanSlayer Feb 25 '18
I was a bit disappointed by this show. It just felt slow and like nothing was actually happening half the time. Might re-watch it in the future and change my opinion like I did with a few other shows.
2
u/melvinlee88 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Ryan_Melvin15 Feb 26 '18
If you need anymore justification, DemolitionD gave it a prestigious positive review
Edit: I miss you demo
2
u/Mimsy_the_Borogove Oct 23 '21
Ergo Proxy was one of my first anime. 70-odd anime later, it still is. How often does any TV series require active engagement from a viewer to unravel the mystery fully? I have seen it a couple of dozen times, and I am not bored yet.
I wish someone would do a remake.
5
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '18
I feel sophisticated as fuck when I recommend this to my new to anime friends. Even more so when they struggle to understand what's going on. The confusion on their little faces when I explain all will become clear once they've seen the gameshow episode. Delightful.
This was one of the first shows I sought out after Dragonball Z introduced me to anime. At the time I remember it blowing my socks off when I realised that there was more to this medium than two men screaming at each other for 5 episodes. This and Noein are my two nostalgia shows.
Good write up. Take my upvote.
3
u/AdventurerForFun Feb 26 '18
This show has the best "exposition dump" like, ever. No contest. Only for that episode I'd say it's worth a watch. And the series as a whole is very good.
3
u/Funk-sama Feb 25 '18
The anime was interesting and entertaining enough. I thought the world building was excellent. But it dragged a shit ton towards the end of the middle. Idc if that was the point it's still a drag. It also seems to attract a lot of "I am very smart" people which is kinda annoying
2
u/Ayesuku Feb 26 '18
I appreciate your proper usage of "it's" vs "its".
1
u/[deleted] Feb 26 '18
It is a really good series overall, although there are too many filler episodes during the middle segment. The show spends a lot of time explaining certain concepts which could have been done in fewer episodes.
1
u/takebrasilia May 09 '18
I am on episode 17 right now and I gotta tell you. There are some unnecessary shounen tropes that completely kill the atmosphere. It doesn't add up at all to how pretensious the anime is, and I don't say this in a good way. You gotta have something good to give if you wanna call your episodes "Meditations".
But since I read and trust you guys, I'LL REFRAIN from saying I don't like it until I finish the last six episodes.
-3
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '18
Alternatively, you can see at as a mess of cluttered ideas jumbled together with expressed purpose of confusing a viewer into thinking it's a lot deeper than it is, which leaves no room for an actual coherent story.
If you enjoyed this show, that's fine, but for me it's one of few 1/10 shows i've seen, because i like arthouse/philosophical/makes-you-think works of fiction, which makes me hate ones that reinforce stereotype it's all just pretentious wankery.
-3
u/Abeneezer Feb 26 '18
Ergo Proxy feels deep and poetic on the surface but after watching it more closely it just feels like pretense. It definitely had some spectacular episodes that will stay with me for long but too many things went wrong, in the script, worldbuilding, characters, pacing and so on. Interesting to watch if you have watched a lot of casual anime but not something you can binge or easily digest.
-7
u/[deleted] Feb 25 '18
This is the most pretentious and bewildering show I have ever watched. Shame, because I really liked the setting of Ergo Proxy.
-4
u/GhostfaceKilla21 Feb 25 '18
Their are plenty of anime that are 10/10 lol