The anime is only scratching the surface in this love triangle. The visual novel detailing the five years after is still killing me.
When people ask for sad / tear inducing animes on this subreddit I never recommend WA2, because it doesn't bring you tears, just some healthy dose of PTSD.
Closing Chapter should be pretty much done (may have untranslated bits but generally playable), there are youtube video playthroughs, in overall, because Coda Chapter is exceedingly long, the game is only half translated at the moment.
While I can't give specific links, 4/5 routes are complete in the closing chapter. While the 5th route is about 1/3 complete (but its been like that for a while.) As far as the code chapter, which is the final, it has a longggggg way to go.
Not sure if I can link the site/name the group, but the people translating closing chapter say that they’re 48% through the script on their website. When they first announced they were going to pick up closing chapter, they expected it to be done in 2018. In my personal opinion, they’re probably going to take longer than that.
You should join the Amagami SS waiting room. They started in 2012, and were only done with translations at the end of last year. By the time editing is done, my grandchildren might get to check it out.
I'm lucky that I can read Chinese and they have everything translated. I played through all of the routes. It's the only serious VN I ever played and it was incredible.
I have to say, besides the amazing story, there were so many good songs! Time to prepare some painkillers and go through the playlist again...
I think the Closing Chapter is almost full translated into English and you can probably search "WA2 Closing Chapter" in youtube. The last part - Coda is still yet to be translated but you could find some online summary - doesn't do its justice though because you would miss the excellent inner monologues, voice acting, music, sex scenes etc
As a whole I liked WA2. It was a good story and well done, but in the end the things that happened at the end hurt my enjoyment of it. I really don’t like Haruki cause of the things he did at the end, he’s probably the only MC I’ve ever hated.
I feel like that makes him more relatable. He's not the super perfect hero guy who always does what's in the best interest of those around him, he's a teenager who's kind of a jerk sometimes and mostly looks out for number one unless the situation calls for it. He makes mistakes and the story is not afraid to make him look like a jackass, it's what makes him more interesting and human as a character. At least for me.
He's also actually relevant beyond the romantic triangle.
Sounds stupid, but it doesn't happen nearly enough as it should in romance, anime or not. Too many times you'll see romantic relationships being part of the setting or develop out of boring traits like "oh he's so kind" or some shit, without ever really knowing why they're supposed to like each other. I personally find it vastly more interesting to see relationships actually flourish naturally (even more so in love polygons).
Sure, a lot of us weren't fans of that kind of personality in high school, but it gives plenty of context to all the relationships (including friends and acquaintances) he's formed and continues to form. He's clearly driven by things that make him who he is regardless of other characters, and it's a lot easier to imagine that being attractive to some people.
This is how I felt too. While he made a lot of mistakes, there are scenes where you see him crying because he doesn't know how to deal with them properly. This made him much more relatable to me.
I can agree with that, and I have no problem with selfish/jackass characters cause like you said yourself it makes them relatable, my issue was his actions themselves.
To be honest, we can despise Haruhi all we want, but if we put in his situation,
I don't really blame Haruhi's mistakes in high school as the girls share some responsibilities for being immature as well, although I do have tons of issues with his life choices in adulthood 5 years later, but that's a separate matter.
You can fuck up a triangle in many many ways. You can take the WA 2 appraoch by trying to line up 2 matchsticks to form one, or you can take the School Days approach and use the matches to light yourself on fire instead.
White Album 2 is one of my absolute favourites. I think the reason why the love triangle works so well here is because all three of them genuinely like and care about each other, and they didn't stop liking each other even after all that happens, it's the reason why White Album 2. The ending was also perfect, leaving enough for a sequel but still having an 'end'.
Also, for those that don't know, Kazusa stomped other Aquaplus characters in a character poll a year and a half ago; for winning, we ended up getting a character song CD of Kazusa singing many of the vocal tracks from WA2.
I've rarely been interested in romance shows (with a few exceptions like Clannad and Nagi no Asukara), especially when the focus is on something as messy as love triangles. Maybe this was due to too many soap operas that I've watched when I was younger. I have to admit that your write-up has gotten me rather curious though...
Despite the name, apparently it's not critical to watch its predecessor?
No, White Album is different than White Album 2, which is also why I think this anime isn't as popular as it should be. Please give this one a shot, it might rekindle your love for romance!
The anime is only the introductory chapter of the Visual Novel! there is a closing chapter and an extra after story called "CODA". This shit goes pretty deep yo. This VN is a goldmine for some real ass love triangle depression shit and i love it.
Just finished this anime a couple days ago and I really liked it, does anyone think we'll be getting a second season for this? Or is there no plan to continue in the future?
You got voted down but I like WA1 a lot more than WA2 as well. I don't think WA2 is bad but I don't think it's like pinnacle of the genre like the OP does. If I had to say any WA was that, I'd definitely lean more towards WA1. WA2 is like a normal show that leans harder than most into the I don't think this is a positive relationship for everyone type of show that stuff like WA1, School Days, Scum's Wish, and NTR (less porn though) live in.
My favorite comment from that watch thread is around the mid point of the show someone going "Alright guys the show's about to start" then like 12 episodes of pure sadness occurs.
51
u/dene323 Apr 26 '18
The anime is only scratching the surface in this love triangle. The visual novel detailing the five years after is still killing me.
When people ask for sad / tear inducing animes on this subreddit I never recommend WA2, because it doesn't bring you tears, just some healthy dose of PTSD.
10
u/ktomp21 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ktomp41 Apr 26 '18
As a whole I liked WA2. It was a good story and well done, but in the end the things that happened at the end hurt my enjoyment of it. I really don’t like Haruki cause of the things he did at the end, he’s probably the only MC I’ve ever hated.
17
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '18
I'm pretty sure the whole purpose of WA2 is that its love triangles done wrong...
12
u/HamazuraXTakitsubo Apr 26 '18 edited Apr 27 '18
White Album 2 is one of my absolute favourites. I think the reason why the love triangle works so well here is because all three of them genuinely like and care about each other, and they didn't stop liking each other even after all that happens, it's the reason why White Album 2. The ending was also perfect, leaving enough for a sequel but still having an 'end'.
10
u/RunningChemistry :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Delphic-Runner Apr 27 '18
WA2 is so well-received that it even got re-released last Valentine's Day.
Also, for those that don't know, Kazusa stomped other Aquaplus characters in a character poll a year and a half ago; for winning, we ended up getting a character song CD of Kazusa singing many of the vocal tracks from WA2.
7
u/Justice_Chip Apr 26 '18
The dialogue and the music of this show. The themes, the characters, the depiction. All of it is wonderfully done. Please watch this show.
3
u/PokeMikey1234 Apr 27 '18
White Album 2 got me to continue watching romance anime that I haven't already seen. The ed is still in my playlist xD
2
u/RRotlung Apr 27 '18 edited Apr 27 '18
I've rarely been interested in romance shows (with a few exceptions like Clannad and Nagi no Asukara), especially when the focus is on something as messy as love triangles. Maybe this was due to too many soap operas that I've watched when I was younger. I have to admit that your write-up has gotten me rather curious though...
Despite the name, apparently it's not critical to watch its predecessor?
2
u/adamantitian Apr 27 '18
I STILL have that song stuck in my head from however long ago I watched it
0
u/axel360 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/axel360 Apr 27 '18
I think it was done well until . Downvote me if you want, but that's just how I felt watching it.
I mean, their feelings are fine, but them acting on them was really shitty and sort of out of character for both.
Then the person went way out of her way to basically be a martyr to the point she actually apologized to him.
I get she wanted the group to stay together but come on, really?
1
u/khawaja07 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/khawaja07 Jun 19 '18
The anime is only the introductory chapter of the Visual Novel! there is a closing chapter and an extra after story called "CODA". This shit goes pretty deep yo. This VN is a goldmine for some real ass love triangle depression shit and i love it.
1
u/GreenKokiri45 Jul 06 '18
Just finished this anime a couple days ago and I really liked it, does anyone think we'll be getting a second season for this? Or is there no plan to continue in the future?
-8
u/[deleted] Apr 26 '18
i just recently got into watching a bunch of anime and my hot take is that white album is a goat show and white album 2 is just a meh variation of it
0
u/[deleted] Apr 28 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment