r/anime • • May 23 '18
[WT!] Rurouni Kenshin: Tsuioku-hen - A tragic tale of love and war
Anime: Rurouni Kenshin Tsuioku-hen/Samurai X: Trust and Betrayal
Type: OVA (4 Episodes)
Year: Feb 20, 1999 to Sep 22, 1999
Genre: Historical Drama, Action, Romance, Samurai
I’ve noticed here on the sub that while the series is on the Top 50 on MAL, it doesn’t tend to be mentioned so much. So I've decided to do the job of trying to get the series some attention with my first ever WT thread since I feel it’s quite underrated. Feel free to comment on the quality of it if you can.
When mankind's savagery surpasses his fear of death, there is little hope for those who wish to live honest lives. Beneath a full moon, a young boy witnesses the murder of the bandits who had enslaved him, and is then christened with a new name by the man who rescued him. This boy is Shinta, now known as Kenshin Himura, and he is destined to become a swordsman. The softness of his heart does not befit the occupation, but his desire to protect the innocent is absolute.
Rurouni Kenshin Tsuioku-hen (alternatively know as Samurai X: Trust & Betrayal) is a 4-episode OVA series adapted by Studio DEEN in 1999 based off the Trust & Betrayal arc in the original shounen manga by Nobuhiro Watsuki. Serving as a prequel to the original Rurouni Kenshin series, Trust & Betrayal takes place during the Bakumatsu (the final days of the Edo period in Japan, with the fall of the Tokugawa Shougunate) and chronicles the story of the series’ protagonist, Himura Kenshin’s bloody past as Battousai the Manslayer, revealing the experiences he goes through from how he gained his iconic scar, to his eventual renouncement to ever take a life ever again.
First off, to those who thinking that viewing the original series is required to view this OVA, I’d say that doesn’t have to be the case. While having knowledge of the original can allow others to catch references made to the original, the OVA can be viewed without prior knowledge and can be enjoyed as a standalone Samurai story all together.
Speaking of references, with Trust & Betrayal being a Historical drama, it has its fair share of historical references to the Bakamatsu revolution, along with the historical figures who took part of it, so keep an eye out for that ;).
Also, with the series being based off of a shounen with a comedic undertone to it, Trust & Betrayal is a major departure from that, so the OVA can be noticeably bleak. So if heavy gore and violence isn’t your cup of tea, tread with caution.
Now to the meat of the story. Trust & Betrayal focuses primarily on Kenshin Himura's efforts to upend the Tokugawa Shougunate, and make way for a new, peaceful era in Japan, while exploring his relationship with his first lover, the mysterious Yukishiro Tomoe. What makes Kenshin such a fantastic, and compelling character would be his inner conflict between how his selflessness and sense of justice demands action against the “evil” responsible for the atrocities he’s witnessed, and the severe actions he takes in order to commit to that action. He’s a kind, loving soul at heart, and is a pacifist at best, but can’t bear to see the violence brought forth due to his dislike of seeing the innocent being trampled on, and thus forces himself to do what he believes to be done, despite hating what he does. He kills those who must be killed, even if they aren’t considered “evil”, and Trust and Betrayal focuses heavily on that aspect of his development, from a cold-blooded killer to the kind hearted wanderer we know him as in the original series. While I can’t say much about Tomoe since that would be heavy spoiler territory, I can say that she's a well-developed character, and her relationship with Kenshin is fleshed out very well, and even feels real. Both of their overall characters complement each other perfectly, and adds more impact to the tragedy of the story.
One aspect to note about Trust & Betrayal the amount of detail put into it. The action scenes hold up very well despite it being made a decade ago, are well choreographed, with its movements feeling real and fluid, with a lot of weight put behind them. Despite being violent, nothing is exaggerated or over the top, keeping a realistic vibe to it without getting too out of hand. The sound effects make it feel more grounded, from the sound of swords clashing together in the fights, to the sound of fire burning away. Not to mention the visuals are breathtaking. The features to the characters give it realistic feel, opting for normal sized human eyes, instead of the more shounen-esque eyes the original went for.
The soundtrack, composed by Taku Iwasaki (Gurren Lagann, Soul Eater, Oban Star Racers, Katanagatari, Noragami, Jojo Part 2) is produced fantastically, with elements of traditional Japanese music that’s fitting for a Samurai story, and sets the tone to the overall series with the serene, and haunting feeling it emits.
Another noteworthy aspect about Trust & Betrayal are the themes and symbolism present. Trust and Betrayal obviously enough, are one of the main themes apparent in the series, with all our characters carrying certain beliefs or “truths” to themselves only to be bitten in the assess at the end of it all, or in this case “betrayed”. Then there’s how it presents war. Trust & Betrayal emphasizes how there isn’t any “good” or “evil” in a war, but simply two warring factions with their own ideologies and beliefs they’re willing to fight for, and delves into the philosophical question of whether bringing an end to bloodshed with force is a better solution to things, or just adds fuel to the already burning fire. The core theme to it all however, is how it portrays murder. It’s not something meant to be badass, or something that means victory for everyone, but it’s portrayed as tragic, and heavy. Trust & Betrayal does not lampshade the fact that no matter what reason the sword is being wielded for, it’s still murder. One of the characters points out that “Swordsmanship is a method for murder. You can decorate it with all sorts of pretty words, but that is what it is.” It’s expressed in the series that taking sides could turn anyone into a killer, no matter what the beliefs behind it are. It could be used for god knows what, and people that don’t even deserve end up doing so because of that. It’s a very interesting take on the portrayal of war which leads to interesting dialogue between the characters. Not to forget the symbolism put into its direction and visuals.
And despite being a prequel, the OVAs manage to tell the story in a way that doesn't seem too predictable, which allows it to play up the drama and tension perfectly.
In summary, Rurouni Kenshin Trust & Betrayal is a dark, tragic, and enthralling coming of age story of a boy out to discover what role he plays in the widespan of things, who’s experiences with war, bloodshed, loss, and love eventually shape him into the kind, and passionate man seeking repentance we would later know him as. With amazing actions scenes, beautiful visuals, outstanding direction and storytelling, a powerful soundtrack, and masterfully crafted characters, it’s a masterpiece that's must-watch for action fans.
The series unfortunately, isn't available for streaming, but it is available for Blu-Ray DVD on Amazon Prime.
I’d like to mention again that this is my first WT thread, so all comments relating to the quality are highly appreciated. Otherwise, thank you so much for reading it!
EDIT: On a side note of things, I highly recommend the Japanese sub. The English dub is awful, and barely captures any emotion on the story, so keep that in mind.
14
u/Nomar_95 :Ed:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nomar_95 May 23 '18
10/10 masterpiece.
The art, the cinematography, the OST, the Shakespearian tragedy.......everything is as close to perfect as one could get.
It's a work of art
1
u/aholibamahobama https://anilist.co/user/Person14 May 23 '18
I've been meaning to watch this OVA series for a while now, but the investment needed to get through the main series is quite daunting. As a general question, could Trust and Betrayal still be enjoyable as a standalone or does it lose some impact if not watched in conjunction with the main series?
3
u/dusjanbe May 23 '18
One of my first anime ever, i actually saw it through some AMVs with Linkin Park in the early 2000s and later downloaded to check it out.
The technical aspect was just stunning and still hold up today.
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '18
This is only time I couldn't decide between sub or dub because I didn't like either. The dub felt lifeless and Kenshin subbed sounded like a woman, otherwise it would've been fine. I ended up sticking with the dub but I think it affected my enjoyment. So my advice to everyone is to try both and see which one you prefer.
While it is standalone, if anyone loved the main series it's almost like required viewing. It's very important for the story, albeit with a complete tonal shift.
Some constructive criticism: it could definitely benefit from splitting the longer paragraphs into two and adding some section headings, it's just a lot easier to read that way. Also talk more about what your personally liked about it (I'm working on my own WT so I've been getting the same feedback).
Thanks for the WT!
1
u/TheRisingTide May 23 '18
Word of caution: If you'd like to ensure that your consumption of Rurouni Kenshin does not monetarily support magaka Nobuhiro Watsuki's legal funding for his child pornography charges, I recommend pirating this and all of his other work.
1
u/RuSyxx https://anilist.co/user/RuSyxx May 23 '18
As someone who grew up on this show and the manga, this franchise was a huge part of my life while growing up. Its unfortunate that Watsuki has been found to be a less than ideal person behind the work, the story is still very worth checking out. Its a huge part of the reason I came to really love anime, and japanese history as a whole as while not everything that happens is entirely accurate, you can definitely find some really cool stories that really happened, and its always a fun rabbit hole, at least for me.
So I definitely agree, the entire franchise is an eternal 10 to me, and I'd recommend it to almost anyone.
1
u/CoolFiverIsABabe May 23 '18
I've watched this countless times. Such a great series. It might be too slow paced for some people but I was fine with it.
1
u/[deleted] May 24 '18
I just started reading Rurouni Kenshin recently. It’s pretty fucking good, and I really appreciate how he transitions from a super sweet gentle dude to a straight up vicious murderer look. It’s quite a juxtaposition that really highlights how different his past ideals were compared to now.