r/anime • u/AmethystItalian :Jg::Jh::Ji::Jj::Jk:myanimelist.net/profile/AmethystItalian • Dec 29 '18
WT! [WT!] AmethystItalian's Top 10 Romance Anime of all time
Romance has always been my favourite genre so I decided to put together a list of my top 10 romances to show it some love. This isn't a list of romances that I think are a must watch or ones I'd recommend to everyone but just my top 10 shows where romance is the main focus or the reason I enjoy the show is primarily for the romance. This means a lot of romcoms that focus more on comedy (GSNK, Ouran Host Club and School Rumble) won't be included here, I've also chosen to omit movies/OVAs just to keep things simpler.
A little preface about me and my tastes, I'm a sucker for lighter romances with happy endings so you won't find too many serious or realistic romances on here!
Without further ado here are my top 10 romance anime starting with #1 :)
Amagami SS
I won't spend too much time on this one as I've said most of what needs to be said in this separate WT! thread. and have probably talked about this show to death to most people. This isn't a romance for everyone as it can be a bit weird at times but it really is a special show in the romance genre.
Watch This if you want to see ships sailing, no prolonged drama and every girl getting a chance to win. Or just to see why I never shut up about this show
Spice and Wolf
Chemistry. That's the best word to describe what I love about Spice and Wolf. The main characters are the biggest reason to watch this show, they would make watching paint dry entertaining! The plot, setting and OST all complement them on their journey and it all blends together so well. Holo and Lawrence are both capable leads that can hold their own by themselves but together they are a force in anime romances on how they play off each other.
Sadly it is a LN adaptation so it does have an unfinished ending but it is worth it to see Holo and Lawrence in action alone.
Watch This if you want some adventure with your romance and if you enjoy chemistry between romantic mains. Or simply if you want to see what a best girl looks like in Holo.
Tsurezure Children
Tsurezure Children's strongest attribute comes from its variety of characters. The anime showcases many different couples in different romantic scenarios and paths. It's cute, it's funny and it's everything you can ask for when it comes to lighter high school romances. Highly recommend watching but even more I highly recommend reading the manga for even more couples and progression!
Watch This if you want something short, easy to digest and you want to see some cute moments. You're bound to find at least 1 couple you like!
Sukitte Ii na yo
This is my favourite shoujo of all time but I have some nostalgia bias as it was one of my first romance. I have this on my list instead of other more popular shoujos such as Maid-sama or Kimi ni Todoke because of the drama and the progression. This is one of those rare romances where the couple gets together early and face relationship obstacles related to that. Too many romances end at the couple being formed or even before that so this romance is refreshing in that sense.
That being said this is a very shoujo shoujo, you won't find too many things that break the formula but it does the usual things quite well. If you're a fan of shoujo it's a must watch but if you don't care shoujos than this show won't change your mind on the genre demographic.
Watch This if you want a romance with a couple that is established early with some drama mixed in.
Akagami no Shirayuki-hime
This anime has the best shoujo MC to grace romance anime that I've seen. Shirayuki is just such a treat to watch as she is so determined, independent and just plain adorable at times. She's surrounded by a strong cast which includes a very nice sideship and a competent male counterpart. The romance has good progression, cute/uplifting moments and is just a pleasure to watch. It looks great, sounds great and has a good amount of memorable scenes. One of the safer romances to recommend and try!
Unlike the aforementioned Sukitte Ii na yo this is a shoujo that doesn't feel like the typical shoujo and should be tried by all romance fans.
Watch This if you want to see a strong willed female character or want a romance with a fairy tale like feel to it.
Nagi no Asu kara
Most of the shows listed here are devoid of love triangle drama as that's not something I'm not too fond of but this show is the big exception. NagiAsu follows multiple characters and multiple ships with a whole lot of crying and a whole lot of drama. The setting and visuals are reasons to watch alone but if you can get invested into the characters than this can end up being a really special show.
Honestly this show was not one I really cared for until the second half so be wary that it does get better if you're not feeling it at first!
Watch This if you enjoy pretty visuals and drama with your romances or if you enjoy love triangles polygons.
Honobono Log
If there was one show out of these 10 that I'd choose to best represent love it would be Honobono Log. It's a collection of romance shorts each showing different depictions and sides of love. You can finish this all in half an hour so there's no excuse not to watch this if you even remotely consider yourself a romance fan, you won't regret it!
Watch This if you have 30 minutes to spend, seriously that is the only excuse for not watching this! Go do it now!
Tsuki ga Kirei
This one is a lot of people's beloved romance anime and rightfully so since it's simply put a very solid romance anime. The characters are very relatable and the relationship is just sweet to watch while keeping the drama relatively low. This romance anime checks all the boxes when it comes to progression, satisfaction and romantic moments which makes it one of the safest romances to recommend.
Watch This if you want a simple romance that does all the "good" things in a romance well.
Kokoro Connect
One of my earliest romances that I watched and it still sticks with me to this day. Kokoro Connect brings a supernatural element to its romance which keeps things unique and fresh. Each arc feels different and tackles a different situation for the characters to overcome and grow. The cast is well balanced and the drama is at nice level where it doesn't feel over-dramatic but gets you wrapped up in what's happening.
Watch This if you're a fan of Miyuki Sawashiro or if you like your romances to have a different element to it instead of the normal HS romances.
Nijiiro Days
Don't judge this anime by its cover! I've seen many people avoid this one because the focus looks to be on the male characters which is abnormal for a romance anime but this honestly feels just like every other romance to me. The guys are the main focus yes but they each have their own love story being told with other girls, all at different stages too! Sadly this is another one where the juicy stuff lies in the manga :(
Watch This if you want something cute but easy to ingest as each episode is half-length. The variety of couples at different stages makes it fun as well.
I hope someone out there finds this useful in some way or another. If you feel like I'm missing out some romances feel free to let me know! I'm always looking for new shows that could end up earning a spot on this list :)
25
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18
+1 for Akagami! Shirayuki is a wonderful MC.
Neat list overall! Looks like I have a lot more stuff to add to my PTW lol.
16
u/Taiboss :Fj::Fl:x7https://anilist.co/user/Taiboss Dec 29 '18
I watched seven of those, dropped one, put one on-hold and never started one. Close enough I'd say. Nah, without jokes, that's a good list you've got there! The "Watch this if" is a great concept for such a list, and you didn't put in too much content either.
You actually convinced me on Nijiiro Days! Time to put it on my PTW and hopefully not forget about it!
76
u/VincentBlack96 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Vincent Dec 29 '18
Wait Amagami is your favorite romance!!??
sincewhen!?
9
u/TheRiyria myanimelist.net/profile/TheRiyria Dec 29 '18
I've watched (and loved) 5 of these, had 2 others on my PTW, and 1 more on a very long-hold (I really should consider restarting Kokoro Connect). I don't think I've heard of Nijiro Days or Sukitte Ii na yo, so I think I'll add those as well.
This was a great writeup! Thanks for the new suggestions on things to watch! Though I was kinda half expecting Toradora to be here with the rewatch for it ending tomorrow.
9
u/smokerun Dec 30 '18
no wotakoi?
4
u/JustAWellwisher Dec 29 '18
Fine! I'll watch Nagi no Asu Kara. I've tried it once before, watched an episode for a bit and just... decided to do other things that day and every day since. But I should go back to it.
Quality list of upbeat romances. Notable exceptions that seem to me to be around the same genre you're going for with somewhat upbeat romances I'd be interested in your thoughts about. Wotaku ni Koi wa Muzukashii, His or Her Circumstances, Nodame Cantabile, Ore Monogatari, Karakai Jouzu no Takagi-san?
4
u/Lilaith https://myanimelist.net/profile/lilaith Dec 29 '18
I came in excited for new shows, but rip, seen them all already. Glad to see you love them as much as I do tho!
3
u/SmurfRockRune https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smurf Dec 29 '18
I've seen 7 of these, with another on PTW. That's pretty good for someone that's mostly into action shows.
Good write ups here. Concise and to the point without falling into the trap of using the same adjectives for everything. Seriously, look how many times I use the word "fun" in my MAL tags.
3
u/kimbombo Dec 29 '18
Hey. You forgot to mention the best one, Konbini Kareshi. J/K
Have watched all of those and I agree, they are all great, specially "Say I love You"
Wished there were more romance shows with the same format as Nijiro Days with multiple couples, and it doesn't focus either just the boys or just the girls.
3
u/Mage_of_Shadows Dec 30 '18
I got to say, those are pretty good and diverse recommendations for romance. It's good to see another person rec Nijiiro Days, shame about the manga hiatus tho.
3
u/jaesuk97 https://myanimelist.net/profile/tebls Dec 30 '18
Here are some romance anime I enjoyed that you may like:
5
u/Gaporigo Blhttps://anilist.co/user/Gaporigo Dec 29 '18
Huh, I have watched 6 of this, have 1 On-Hold (TL is almost done!) and 1 in my PTW... way more than I thought, may also have to add Nijiiro Days to the PTW, had no idea it was a romance or had female characters x)
5
u/babydave371 :Ej:myanimelist.net/profile/babydave371 Dec 29 '18
Ooooo, great write up! Looking through your MAL I'm kind of surprised you haven't seen Touch yet. It may be 100 episodes long but it is one of the great shows of the 80s and probably the best sports romance anime had to offer. Oh, and the OP is wonderfully melodramatic.
2
u/Terranwaterbender https://myanimelist.net/profile/Teranwaterbender Dec 29 '18 edited Dec 29 '18
Given some of our similarities, I guess I shouldn't be surprised I've completed all but one of the shows (Sukitte Ii na yo being the odd one out as I dropped it 1 episode in).
Gonna throw in Tamako Love Story (watch Tamako Market first) and High Score Girl because more nice romance recs couldn't hurt for anyone passing by.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18
Great list! Despite having heard of all of these I've only seen half. I really need to watch Amagami SS at some point.
I'm just going to use this space to plug my favourite romance, Doukyuusei! It's so short but still manages to be the sweetest thing I've ever seen. They become a couple early on, there's plenty of development and it ends on a high note. Really something I wish more people would watch.
2
u/Elfaleon :AMQ: Dec 29 '18
Was on the fence about possibly picking up Nijiro Days since I hadn't seen a lot of support for it. Maybe I'll bump it up on my priority list.
2
u/J765 Dec 29 '18
Haven't watched a single one of those, but I do plan to. I really like romance anime, but every time I watch one it's around 100 episodes long and enough for a year or two. Next up on my list are H2 and Kimagure Orange Road(Tooru Furuya voices the protag!).
I just love old romance shows. The aesthetics are so good and they have the most comfiest OSTs. Sadly it's a bit hard to relate sometimes, since a lot of misunderstandings wouldn't happen anymore, due to cell phones.
2
u/Hagita https://myanimelist.net/profile/TheHagita Dec 30 '18
If I can add to Sukitte Ii na yo, I'd say to pick up the manga after the anime ends. It gives a much more complete picture of Mei and Yamato's relationship over a longer span of time than just high school.
2
u/ukainaoto :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ukainaoto Dec 30 '18
Nagi no Asukara is distinctively standing out for me because spoiler Nagi no Asukara
It is very sad that, to recommend this show you can't avoid mentioning spoiler.
2
u/EasternOtaku1422 Dec 30 '18
What can you say about Yona of the Dawn?
2
u/daftPun5 https://myanimelist.net/profile/daftPun5 Dec 30 '18
Nice list /u/AmethystItalian, I'll be sure to check them out.
I actually used your Amagami SS rewatch as a reference while watching the series.
2
u/messem10 https://myanimelist.net/profile/bookkid900 Dec 30 '18
You're missing two pretty good shows:
2
u/HasanAly :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/HasAly Dec 30 '18
thanks! ill give Tsurezure Children and Tsuki Ga Kirei a shot
2
u/hansantizor :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/hansantizor Dec 30 '18
Don't really have anything to say other than I love how concise this was. I can't tell you how much I hate that most recommendation posts are literal walls of text that would take me 10 minutes to read for one show. Planning on adding all of these to my PTW list (Somehow I haven't seen/finished any of them despite watching like 150 shows lol).
Hope to see more write ups like this in the future!
2
u/Metallic_Mango Dec 30 '18
Holy moly thank you for this list. I have watched most of them but will make sure to watch the rest thanks.
2
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Dec 30 '18
I still need to watch Sukitte Ii na yo and finish Shirayuki-hime, I don't think I even finished the first season. We do have a dead week so I'll probably use this to catch up on these two shows.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
Yeah alright, I think it's time to watch Amagami. I've been delaying for what, 3 years now?
2
u/Sgtvp https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sgtvp Dec 30 '18
I really needed a list like this as I'm always craving some romance, so thanks! I'm sure I will love all of these to death.
2
u/Takana_no_Hana https://anilist.co/user/v4v Dec 30 '18
I guess my top 10 are quite different from yours.
2
u/Yubisaki_Milk_Tea Dec 30 '18
u/AmethystItalian. Putting everything else aside, what are your thoughts on the romance in Eureka Seven? Personally, I consider it to be one of the greatest love stories told in the animated medium, without romance being the primary genre.
2
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
Ah, the apostle of Amagami has spoken again! I remember finally trying it on a whim last year (it must have been you who mentioned it in some thread previously) and boy did I love it. I usually don't watch 2 cour series, but I ended up watching SS, SS+ Plus, and all the OVAs. What did you think of Seiren?
2
u/Goldenfox299 Dec 31 '18
Only watched a bit of Spice and wolf season 1 and I enjoyed the bit I seen (like 5 episodes) so the rest are probably good too. I don't usually watch romance anime though, can't take all the drama.
2
u/Sellier123 Dec 31 '18
Thanks for tagging me! Interesting list, I am surprised though how different our top 10 would be. As I am also a fan of the romance genre I figured our lists would be a lot closer then this. The only show I have not seen on this list is Amagami SS and out of the other 9 only 2 or maybe 3 would make it on my list.
Nagi No Asu Kara and Tsurezure Children would definitely be on my list. Nagi no Asu Kara because its not only a good romance but a really good show in general and Tsurezure Children is just so fkn sweet it gave me cavities. Spice and wolf might make it but, while i did enjoy the anime, I feel the anime does not do the LN's justice. God i can re-read those every month xD.
2
u/Smashtime7 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/39Subrosia Dec 31 '18
This is a pretty unique WT! I really like the more concise format.
I've enjoyed all the shows I've seen from this list (Spice and Wolf, Tsurezure Children, Honobono Log, and the first season of Shirayuki-hime) quite a bit, so I might check out one of the others next time I want to watch a romance. I should probably also watch the second season of Shirayuki-hime soon...
2
u/JoshuaSonOfNun :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/JoshuaSonOfNun Jan 10 '19
I was looking through your anime list.
I enjoyed Re:Life but I think it's more complete as a romance when you watch ReLIFE: Kanketsu-hen the sequel as it ties things up. I'm surprised to see Kokoro Connect in your list.
I'll give Amagami SS and Sukitte Ii na yo a shot!
2
u/[deleted] Jan 17 '19
I'd never heard of Honobono Log before but just watched it -- delightful!!!
3
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18
If Toradora isn't on here...
No! It's not on here. That's disappointing. I really loved it. I rated it a 9/10, originally; couldn't stop thinking about it and even had a post-anime-depression where I didn't watch anime for three weeks after that, so I put it to a 10/10.
Note if you do watch it make sure that you watch the end credits to the finale some people miss it.
Akagami no Shirayuki-hime is on here: Neat! I really liked the first season, I still need to watch the second season though.
Honobono Log is on here too! Awesome, don't hear it talked about much; unfortunately.
I need to check out Amagami SS; watching Spice and Wolf, need to check out Tsurezure Children, and Sukitte Ii na yo
I'll check out Nijiiro Days. I watched Kokoro Connect; I tried watching Nagi and Tsuki but couldn't get into them; for whatever reason, maybe I'll try them again.
2
u/CakeBoss16 Dec 30 '18
Here is my top 10 in no particular order-
1
u/Combo33 :STAR::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/bcom33 Dec 29 '18
The only anime on this list that I'd really strongly disagree with, is Nijiro Days. There are some really uncomfortable interactions between Mari and Matsunaga, that result in a relationship dynamic that made absolutely no sense to me, and was borderline offensive in how much it seemed at odds with Mari's character's initial desires in the show. It really rubbed me the wrong way.
Otherwise, though, a very good list.
1
u/Iva-Biggun Dec 30 '18
I always disliked Say I love you, the dude is just too creepy.
1
u/ParkedLikeAHotCar34 Dec 30 '18
From Me to You is the goat for me
1
u/BreezyOG Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
Mad that Kimi ni Todoke isn't on his list
1
u/Arzete Dec 30 '18
Have you seen Clannad before?
If you haven't, it's a much watch for anyone into romance! The ending is soooo bittersweet. I highly recommend it, even for someone who enjoys happier endings...
1
u/Iroald :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/L_O_V_E_L_A_I_N Dec 30 '18
So I watched Honobono Log, which I was kind of planning to do anyway, but decided to go ahead with because of your post. It was pretty alright, but not really amazing either. I gave it a 6/10.
I'm curious about your thoughts on Sono Toki, Kanojo Wa. It's a bit similar to Honobono Log, but I liked that one a lot more.
1
u/Masaru6006 Dec 30 '18
Have you possibly watched just because! ? Imo one of the best cause it is very down to earth and actually relatable
1
u/homie_down :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/sodumblol Dec 30 '18
As much as I loved NagiAsu I wouldn’t put it in this type of top all time lists. There are plenty of romantic feelings but no romance itself really. And while I did enjoy seeing the characters’ feelings change over time, especially post TS, it was still essentially a lot of teenagers who have crushes on each other but not much more happening.
1
u/Witn https://anilist.co/user/Lawrenz Dec 30 '18
I want to eat your pancreas
3
u/tbayleyt :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/tbayleyt Dec 30 '18
Any list with Nijiro days and Tsuredure Children on is immediately a good list
1
u/vaclav_2012 Dec 29 '18
Thank you for this post. I like how information about each show is short and to the point. Although romance currently isn't my primary focus, I have added Amagami SS to my PTW. It sounds like fun. I also read your WT post for this show which is nicely written as well.
1
u/kappaderickz Dec 30 '18
No Toradora or Golden Time? Both of them are great in terms of romance and has decent endings too...
1
u/poohmaobear :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/poohmaobear Dec 30 '18
I've only seen about half of these. Thanks for recommendations!
2
u/dadnaya https://myanimelist.net/profile/dadnaya Dec 30 '18
7 out of 10 watched for me, I am pleased.
I'll take recs of Nagi and Nijiro days, hmm.
2
u/NuclearStudent Dec 30 '18
We tend to have wildly different tastes, but the lack of Clannad is something I approve of.
2
u/Disenculture Dec 30 '18
+1 for best girl Holo
1
u/juzamj Dec 30 '18
Hana yori dango and my love story are my top 2.
1
u/Galaxy__ :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Galaxy__ Dec 30 '18
thank god no overrated toradora or clannad.
1
u/Vengetsye Dec 31 '18
How is golden time not here? Can you also pm a list of similar anime to golden time. Charlotte was very good and plastic memories
-1
u/PainStorm14 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gekkostate14 Dec 30 '18 edited Dec 30 '18
I was almost about to downvote you when I saw that you put Amagami SS (AKA Cop-Out:The Anime) on the list but you bounced back epically with Tsuki ga Kirei, Kokoro Connect and Nijiiro Days
And good to see Akagami no Shirayuki-hime there, it's nice when romance anime depicts couple who are in romantic relationship instead of strictly platonic one
Also, where is White Album 2? Massive oversight if there ever was one...
0
u/[deleted] Dec 30 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
6
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '18
[removed] — view removed comment