r/anime • u/MAD_SCIENTIST_001 x2myanimelist.net/profile/MadScientist_001 • Jan 16 '19
WT! Missed Some of [WT!] Threads? Here is a Compilation for You! (September-December, 2018. Edition)
Important announcement regarding the future of WTs in the comments
Since the introduction of a new [WT!] (Watch This) tag, these posts get a lot of well-deserved praise. We get to know some new interesting anime, remember some sweet moments about titles we've already finished some time ago, suggest shows ourselves. However, not everyone's browsing /r/anime everyday, and since we all live in different time zones, some very well-written posts may fly under the radar. I decided to make a little compilation of the posts that were posted here throughout the past few months. I took anime topics from September-December'18.
| Num | [WT!] Thread | Genres | Author | Upvotes | Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Gunslinger Girl (MAL) | Action, Psychological, Military, Drama, Sci-Fi | /u/Suhkein | 77 | 02.09.18 |
| 2. | Princess Tutu (MAL) | Comedy, Drama, Fantasy, Magic, Mystery, Romance | /u/elleyonce | 138 | 15.09.18 |
| 3. | Nyanpire The Animation (MAL) | Comedy, Supernatural, Vampire | /u/GiftoftheGeek | 2 | 05.10.18 |
| 4. | Maquia: When the Promised Flower Blooms (MAL) | Drama, Fantasy | /u/Dandelionel06 | 111 | 03.11.18 |
| 5. | Maria-sama ga Miteru (MAL) | Drama, Romance, Shoujo, Shoujo Ai, Slice of Life | /u/SpareUmbrella | 51 | 10.11.18 |
| 6. | The Rose of Versailles (MAL) | Military, Historical, Drama, Romance, Shoujo | /u/another_wordsmith | 74 | 01.12.18 |
| 7. | Tsuki ga Kirei (MAL) | Romance, School | /u/aestheticintuition | 188 | 06.12.18 |
| 8. | Aikatsu Stars! (MAL) | Music, School, Shoujo, Slice of Life | /u/MetaThPr4h | 47 | 09.12.18 |
| 9. | Hakumei to Mikochi (MAL) | Slice of Life, Fantasy, Seinen | /u/DutchPeasant | 91 | 16.12.18 |
| 10. | Tokyo Godfathers (MAL) | Comedy, Drama | /u/LiveCry | 103 | 22.12.18 |
| 11. | Saiki Kusuo no Ψ-nan (MAL) | Comedy, Supernatural, School, Shounen | /u/FlamingSparrow | 318 | 29.12.18 |
| 12. | Top 10 Romance Anime | Focused on the Romance genre | /u/AmethystItalian | 265 | 29.12.18 |
| 13. | Magi: The Labyrinth of Magic (MAL) | Action, Adventure, Fantasy, Magic, Shounen | /u/FlamingSparrow | 37 | 31.12.18 |
| 14. | Citrus (MAL) | Drama, Romance, School, Shoujo Ai | /u/ATargetFinderScrub | 1 | 31.12.18 |
WIKIPAGE WITH ALL [WT!] THREADS
GUIDE TO WRITING [WT!] THREADS
As always, leave what you think about the post in comments, any feedback is appreciated. Thanks for reading!
15
u/RX-Nota-II :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotANota Jan 16 '19
Just some clarification in case you are curious as to where /u/kaverik went, but from now on, /u/Mad_Scientist_001 and I will be handling the WT project including these monthly compilation threads. Please stay tuned for a post tomorrow where we will be introducing a new and revived WT project that should not only further incentivize the creation of WTs but also add some fun collaboration with fans of the weekly anime discussion thread.
Back after a few months break, there have been a number of great [WT!]s in that time. Some pretty high karma entries in the triple digits, and a good variety of shows from recent and popular to eternal classics. Anybody who wants feedback for their specific entries lmk.
Here are my top 3 for this group.
Best WT! (Gold award) : Aikatsu Stars (MAL), /u/MetaThPr4h
A follow up to his [WT!] for the original season, Meta nails an easy/quick to read recommendation post with tons of added flair. I enjoyed the generous use of GIFs, screenshots, and clips throughout, each serving a different purpose to make the post feel immersive and comprehensive an a way I would have never expected from such a modest length. If anybody is struggling to make their own [WT!] a bit less dry and reviewlike, I definitely suggest taking a look at this one to see how effective picking and choosing just the important aspects can make for a compelling essay.
Runnerup WT! (Silver Award) : AmethystItalian's Top10 Romance Roundup /u/AmethystItalian
One of the most unique [WT!]s I've read in a while, Amethyst's roundup completely shatters the paradigm of the 'standard successful [WT!]' format yet captures the essence of the project just as well with a range of possible recs rather than focusing on a single show. With the constant stream of threads on /new of people asking for a range of recs given a certain genre or style, I definitely see an audience for more of these general compilation types of WTs to flourish and I would love to see more.
Honorable Mention WT! : Hakumei to Mikochi (MAL) /u/DutchPeasant
A very solid entry by from what I can tell a first time WT writer, with plenty of intriguing points to bolster a compelling recommendation essay. Especially of note are the explanations of colors balancing out the otherwise overwhelming levels of detail or thoughts on cinematic tricks like paneling. Something I hope to see more of if the author is to tackle different shows in the future.
7
u/ATargetFinderScrub https://anilist.co/user/ATargetFinderScrub Jan 16 '19
Oh boi when your Citrus WT! probably has the lowest up voted ratio in WT! history and you can't even make the list.
Hehe and my mother said I wouldn't amount to anything
2
u/Calwings x3https://anilist.co/user/Calwings Jan 17 '19
There were some good ones in this batch. I still plan on watching Princess Tutu and Gunslinger Girl, especially after reading their [WT!]'s mentioned here, but I've been held up by other shows lately... one of which I may end up writing a [WT!] of my own about very soon.
3
u/Suhkein :Gy::Gz::G1:x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neichus Jan 16 '19
I must admit to some consternation to discover that more than the [WT!] flair was required to be considered a WT! post, thereby being accidentally disqualified without my knowledge.