r/anime • u/Cottonteeth • Feb 25 '19
WT! [WT!] For those who haven't seen it, I find it to be imperative that - whether you're into the series or not - The first 17-18 episodes of Railgun S is probably the greatest consecutive bing you'll thank yourself for watching. Here goes:
EDIT: Shit, I meant to put "binge" not "bing". Eh, fuck it.
First off, let me get this out the way - Railgun S 1-18 can be watched without any prior knowledge of the series. Yes, it raises questions that aren't all clear, but that - in and of itself - adds so much greater depth and mystic to the whole thing that you wouldn't get from the original series of Index.
The reason I say this, is because it follows the "Sister" arc. I won't provide any spoilers in this, as I think going in blind will speak for itself and leave you wanting more. And that, I think, is the power of J.C. Staff and it's movie-quality miniseries - to give you mysteries that you can't help to learn about yourself.
Attempting to bypass these heavy spoilers, I hope I do this justice, as what J.C. Staff has created in the Sisters arc in Railgun S is...well, let's go with hyperbole.
It's god-tier. It's a 12/10. I know, I know. This sounds like a fanboy rambling, but you have to believe me when I say that, when taken as a whole the entirety of the Sisters' arc is the equivalent of a full motion picture.
Let's try and take it step by step while avoiding spoilers: The main character(s) are Misaka Mikoto - a brash, tsundere, ridiculously overpowered from every angle. Kamijou Tomoua, your semi-generic male who finds out out what's going on and tried to help the main character (though not till much later), and Accelerator - a heartless, brutal, sadistic, yet crushingly heartbreaking character.
The way those characters play off each other is beyond phenomenal. You'd be hard pressed to find any trio so convoluted, yet make the entire thing flow seamlessly. It's seriously a masterclass in character motivation, development, and payoff. Honestly, just thinking about it I'm almost speechless, but when has that every stopped me from this before.
If you are a true fan of anime as an artform, and not just your new kick with whatever's coming up withing the current or next season, I implore you to check these episodes out.
The Sisters' Arc alone could easily be, if done right, the absolute best Hollywood adaptation (if that's your thing), because you don't have to know anything going into it.
The whole thing starts light and funny with a bit of SoL. But then within two episodes shit gets real. And I mean bloody, gory, sadistic, and batshit insane.
But between all of that craziness, there are these moments, especially when Touma pops up with episode Vending Machine where you really feel these characters aren't just tropes. These are about as real people dealing fantasy scenarios that I haven't seen since Rokugo. And that's damn high praise.
Whatever you think about Index III (and I have my reservations, though I see what the studio is trying to do by rushing in order to catch up to the ridiculous amount of material ahead of it), Railgun S, Sisters' Arc is not to be missed.
By missing it, you will have lost a cornerstone of anime and. I'm talking cornerstones such as the first 24 episodes of SAO. Or Jojo Part 3 and 4. That's how impeccable this miniseries is.
And, again, do not think you have to watch the Index version first. In fact, I implore you to not do so until afterwards as the emotionally heft and impact will not make any sense unless you see it through Misaka Mikoto's eyes.
Please, please give this miniseries a chance. Pretty much any To Aru fan will supplement my ranting and raving.
Just do yourself a favor and watch possibly the greatest sequence of anime ever produced. Period.
That's all I can ask and plead. And for the love of all that is, please just find it so you can experience the exquisite, mind-melting paramour that is the Railgun S Sisters' arc.
I don't care if you don't like like Raildex as a series. There are a lot of faults. But this has none of them. You can go in blind and know everything about everything character (minus some mysteries you wouldn't know and aren't important).
Just do yourself a favor and look past the last 5 years and see what J.C. Staff and the Railgun Project II have created. If I had the funding, and the producers as well as the correct actress for Misaka, I wish nothing more than to make this into a Netflix mini-series.
It's that important to the history of anime. And you need to watch it.
It's just that good. No mere words could describe the majesty of that series. Just stop watching after episode 18 and you'll be okay.
Give it a chance, and I promise that you will come away with a new found appreciation for anime as a medium and as a story telling device. The Sisters' Arc is quintessential as art.
5
u/iknowkungfubtw Feb 25 '19
https://i.imgur.com/smvRAab.gifv
5
u/moa_vision Feb 25 '19
Because it is. Maybe tell us why it's a "12/10".
In its current state. This isn't a WT.
4
u/bagglewaggle Feb 25 '19
So what you're saying is: people who are fans of the franchise will agree with someone who is praising an entry in the franchise?
I saw Index. It's fine, I guess, but leans really heavily into its tropes and doesn't do anything particularly noteworthy. I'll pass.
3
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Feb 25 '19
I second that the Sisters Arc is amazing, I watched it only a few months after getting into anime, have rewatched it since and it's still my favorite anime arc.
I wouldn't say it's a good idea to watch it without watching Railgun's first season though. The reason the Sisters arc hit me hard as it did is because S1 got me to like the cast of Railgun (especially Misaka of course) a lot. It would still be great even as a standalone watch, but the lack of attachment to the characters and Misaka in particular would definitely reduce the impact.
But yeah, this arc is the biggest reason I always tell people to watch Railgun before Index, as weird as it sounds with Railgun being a "spinoff". Index takes the 16-episode long Sisters arc (it's 16 by the way, not 18, 17+ is Febri's arc) and turns into a 5-episode thing from the point of view of someone who isn't the MC of the arc, while still letting you know the outcome and slightly rushing the important moments - so once you get to that arc in Railgun, it's not as impactful as going into it completely blind.
1
u/StrayThor Feb 26 '19
Do I need to watch Index before I start Railgun or can I watch Railgun and then start Index?
2
u/raydawnzen Feb 25 '19
It's probably the best part of all the Raildex anime but it's not that good mate. Also, the ending is a bit dumb, especially if you're not already into Index.
0
u/Cottonteeth Feb 26 '19
For chrissakes, with all this negativity, this isn't going anywhere.
This is absolutely a valid WT, but because there's so much cynicism, I can't say that I see any sort of bright future for debate or discussion anymore.
Anytime anyone brings up something in order to push a relatively old show, or episodes, all I see are belligerent attitudes decrying anything that doesn't fit the more modern mold of what people in this subreddit want.
And that makes me sad. I really wish more people would push for older, genuinely great shows, but anytime anyone mentions anything pre 2015 (aside from FMA:B or Steins;Gate or any number of "Hey I just watched TTGL! or Toradora!"
How about a WT! of Uchyuu Kyoudai? Haven't seen that...ever? What about Space Battleship Yamato? Super Martian Successor NADESCIO?
I may be older, but for all that is holy, at least try to accept pieces instead of deriding them as if they have no bearing.
Hell, I bet if I did do a NADESCIO or Bodacious Space Pirates WT! I'd get the same damn response.