r/anime • u/TriggeredSnake • Mar 21 '19
WT! [WT!] School Days: Controversial, but unique. [Tagged Spoilers] Spoiler
School Days is an anime you don’t expect to see recommended very often, being known mostly for its memes and references rather than for its actual content. Hell, even I only learned about it due to its memes. Although I wasn’t on the internet in 2007, when I was on it a few years later I remember seeing some references to the “Nice Boat” meme, often in connection with School Days, although I didn’t really know what it was.
I wasn’t into anime at the time, and had no clue what anime even was, and didn’t look into School Days until a couple of years ago, when I saw a meme based off of School Days’ ending, a clip of Sekai brutally murdering Makoto, and later Konotoha brutally murdering Sekai, with the intro to A-ha’s Take on me in the background. Credit where credit is due, it was a great meme, and it encouraged me to finally look into School Days, where I then rediscovered the Nice Boat meme, and eventually added it to my MAL when I made one later.
I didn’t watch it however until a few hours before this is going to be posted, it was originally one hour but then reddit deleted the thousands of words I’d written over the course of 2 hours as the original version of this post before I spent another 2 hours rewriting the post you are reading. I was very surprised by this, I had expected the anime to be a flaming dumpster fire like it is normally considered to be, with a 5/10 rating on MAL.
I went in mostly blind, having deliberately done no research and knowing little more than the fact that Makoto was the scum of the universe, and the plot twist from the ending. I ended up enjoying the show far more than I expected, giving it an 8 on MAL. At first, it thought the show was okay, although I expect there would be some harem-stuff later.
Around episode 6, I was starting to think that the show wasn’t that bad, and I was exited for the prospect that the show might end up being good and some kind of lost hidden gem. But unfortunately, my hopes were rapidly dashed by episode 9, and I was thinking instead that the show was just absolutely awful harem-trash.
Makoto, as I had known, was literally the scum of the universe. A sex-obsessed bastard with less regard for people’s emotions then me, and I have a reputation for heartlessness due to my autism. He currently sits as my second least-favourite anime character of all time, right above Miki Sayaka from Madoka Magica.
Sekai was just confusing: why did she kill Makoto? I understand she was pissed off, but if people just killed their friends when they were angry I’d have a death toll in the hundreds by now. Why did she fake a pregnancy? It’s not like Makoto would care, he couldn’t care less about his girlfriend. Why did she help Makoto get with Kotonoha in the first place if she fancied him!? I don’t understand!
I hated the green-haired loli, Satsuma or whatever her name was, I can’t be arsed to learn it. If she fancied Makoto, why did she help Sekai get with him!? And in general, she was just a massive pillock, constantly getting involved in other people’s problems and causing more of her own! Trust me, I couldn’t wait for her to move to France.
Konotoha was my favourite. Her personality was close to what I desired, but she was a bit too submissive for my liking. This issue was obvious during the festival arc, where she let those 3 girls walk all over her, forcing her to do extra work and help them with their stupid plan to get arrested instead of being with her boyfriend, and just generally bullying her. Why didn’t she just tell them to fuck off like a normal person!? And why did she spend ages running the reception when the next shift-person didn’t turn up? Any normal person would just leave the minute their shift ended, whether the next worker was there or not!
My favourite thing about her wasn’t her personality though. Or her tits. It was the way the anime presented her descent into madness. Over the final few episodes, the anime would occasionally cut to Konotoha, and each time her mental state would’ve deteriorated. First, she stsrted repeatedly trying to sent emails despite being blocked, refusing to accept the reality of it. Then, she started talking to herself into the phone, acting like Makoto was really there, even though the phone kept saying he couldn’t be accessed. This was incredibly creepy to me, but the scene that really messed me up was in episode 11. Konotoha sat alone in the snow, trying to set up a meeting with Makoto when he wasn’t on the line. When she stopped talking, the view moved to show the phone screen; it was off. The phone’s battery had died. Konotoha had used the phone until it had run out, but she was so mentally broken that she didn’t even notice and continued to talk to herself as if her boyfriend truly was talking back. This properly scared me, a rare thing with anime or really anything at all. I don’t really understand why she let things build up until she hit the point of insanity, I know from experience that I would’ve snapped long before that and done something violent but not quite to the level of murder to solve my problems rather than ignoring them until it was too late.
Her eyes were also used amazingly. Starting off as these large, happy and bright purple designs with lots of detail, they slowly transitioned into dimmer and more empty eyes, with flat gradients instead of the detailed colours; washed out and subdued, exuding sadness and staring infinitely onwards in horror. The scene where this became truly scary was when Sekai ran into her on the bridge, and the camera froze on her empty face of loss and betrayal.
The animation for the series is alright at best. I like the style, being that it’s from the 2000’s, but the colours were too washed out early on and I don’t like the way some Male characters were drawn. Sometimes though, the animators excelled, such as with the eyes of Konotoha during the latter half of the story, or the sudden transformation in Sekai’s eyes during the final episode.
The music is forgettable, really. I remember none of it, except for the very good in my opinion intro, (Shame the outro wasn’t anywhere near as good.) and some of the scarier music tracks and effects from the final few episodes. Everything, literally everything else, I’ve forgotten.
The ending, and the final episode in general was very good. I originally wrote a 3-paragraph long description of it all, but I’m not rewriting that as it wasn’t that good and is pretty much unnecessary for a post like this. Some standout scenes included the outro, which unlike the normal outro lacked any pictures on the phone screen, and the final scene where a completely insane Konotoha killed Sekai, tearing open her body to see if she had faked her pregnancy, any tiny amount of mental integrity left intact torn to shreds by Sekai’s murder of Makoto, before cutting to her on a Nice Boat™, holding onto MAKOTO’S DECAPITATED HEAD AND WHISPHERING TO IT AS IF HE WAS STILL ALIVE.
The final scene was perfect, showing the school, and while switching between different views of the interior, Makoto described his initial encounter with Kotonoha, and how he fell in love with her, perfectly representing the regret he felt after his actions during 8 of the episodes, after episode 4.
In conclusion, School Days is definitely worth watching. As a result of me remembering things wrong, I was still surprised by the ending to an extent, but even to someone who’s seen the ending and remembers it perfectly I still think the anime deserves to be seen, both because of Konotoha’s mind’s gradual disintegration being very well done, but also because the sheer uniqueness of its ending. As far as I know, School Days is the only anime to have an ending like it, since no other production team would be mad/genius enough to adapt the BAD ending.
It’s no 10/10, but it’s no dumpster fire either. I give it a 6:8 on my dual-score technical:enjoyment score scale that I developed, meaning I enjoyed the show quite a lot despite numerous technical flaws.
13
u/pittman66 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Homura Mar 21 '19
Just saying...usually WT! are meant to convince people who haven't seen said anime to watch it. So having as many spoiler tags as you have, along with the overall style you're going with, I'd say to just make it a review post rather than a WT!. Spoilers really shouldn't be necessary in WT! posts as again, it's directed at people who haven't seen the show.
9
u/ExcellentBread Mar 21 '19
So you didn't go in blind at all if you spoiled the ending for yourself lol.
School Days is meant to be a deconstruction of the harem genre. It's supposed to demonstrate why sleeping around and stringing people along is a recipe for disaster. I loved the anime, and I loved hating Makoto. I have not watched any other anime where I hated a character as much as I did Makoto.
I recommend it to people frequently but everybody thinks it's only a meme-worthy show.
3
u/PureXNitrous1995 Mar 21 '19
Until I watched school days I had never been able to say “ I hate the anime.” Needless to say I can’t say that anymore
4
u/Mekazuaquaness Mar 21 '19
It’s not even a generic harem. A generic harem is something like asterisk wars. This is a show about someone who uses his harem and takes advantage of all the girls in them which is why people call school days trash. Because trash refers to wanting the mc to die. People say myne is trash but this guy is very high on the trash list