r/anime • u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin • Apr 15 '19
WT! I wish more people here would watch A Certain Scientific Railgun. Whether you love Steins;Gate or K-On, Attack on Titan or CLANNAD, there's everything to look for there. It's just THAT good.
There's one anime series that combines the best parts of Steins;Gate, K-On, Attack on Titan and CLANNAD.
It's called A Certain Scientific Railgun.
Railgun was in fact my very first seasonal anime that I completed, after being pulled into this world via Makoto Shinkai and I took a few weeks to choose which TV anime to watch first. Thanks to a certain Mikoto Misaka, I ended up watching this first last early December and has never looked back since.
It seems to have everything people praise other anime for. Let's see:
- Steins;Gate's plot overturn was praised by everyone who have watch it, myself included. In Railgun S2 there's also one and that could easily stand proud neck to neck with S;G's one, down to the point that these two anime are both excellent stories on the effects of scientific and technological breakthroughs on individual people's lives. The one in S1's first major arc is also pretty well executed.
- Thanks to the well written original novels of Railgun's parent series A Certain Magical Index, Railgun has an all rounded and detailed, precise world setting of the topmost class. The power system in there was well-defined, the social structure of the city this anime is in, the delicate relationships of various organizations - these are well taken care of and I would say it is on par with the one in Attack on Titan, of which world building is best known. (Of course, if you want the bigger picture, look for the Index anime, or even better the novels) Due to the much more screen time given in Railgun than in similar parts of Index, Railgun even explains certain concepts of the Raildex universe much better than in the 2 seasons of Index I have seen (e.g. S1/Index I spoilers).
- Characters. Oh how do I start - let's say that the MC Mikoto Misaka is probably one of the most charismatic characters the anime world has seen in at least the last decade or two. Where do you find a badass, very powerful in fights, self-confident, no-nonsense, courageous enough to fight solo, loose cannon type girl who's also friendly and caring to friends and almost everyone else (despite being an iconic figure in her city and also coming from a wealthy family), stands up to whatever evil power that she and her friends came across, does everything she could to protect her most important people in her life, and still keeps her childish behaviors? Her personal character is one of the best well-written one I have seen so far (in my personal opinion, perhaps even better than Kurisu Makise, or Mikasa Ackerman, or Yukino Yukinoshita, or Hermione Granger - that's very difficult to do), and it's not that hard to see how:
- she almost always came in first in readers and staff votes in best female character in Japan's most renowned yearly Light Novel guide book for the last 10 years (!), only beaten once by Yukino Yukinoshita. The likes of Asuna, Rem or Megumin had no chance.
- her nickname aspiring the current name of the world's largest anime streaming service (in China, a company that made it to the NASDAQ stock exchange!)
This video probably illustrates her character best:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=echT7Ymj3-g
And the other members of her gang are very well written too - several months later I finished K-ON and I found that Railgun's quartet are just as well written. From the serious yet quirky Kuroko Shirai (well there's one small problem that I will write about her later), to the shy yet determined Kazari Uiharu, to Ruiko Saten which can easily be your tabloid magazine-reading classmate next to you, they all get multi-faced personalities that many of the best anime might even miss. Even that boy who get a major role in S2 or the no. 1 boss in S2's major arc are given better personalities illustrations in their supporting roles than in the first two anime seasons of their main story in Index (that most likely don't apply to the original novels, but that's another matter)! Other characters are somewhat hit or miss, but the ones appearing in the 2 best arcs are generally well done.
If you like all-female main casts, or strong/independent female characters in prominent roles in anime, Railgun most likely will suit you.
- The slice-of-life sections are well done too, if K-ON is representative of first-rate slice-of-life comedies and interactions. There's always time to relax after exciting fights, and the main cast's interactions are natural yet entertaining (well, maybe not for one or two pranks, of which I will write later).
- The whole series have a full set of their own emotional scenes, one that includes friendship, Railgun S1 spoilers and - by far the best written one and one that I would not surprised to see people crying over (I personally believe it to be on par with some scenes in CL:AS) - Railgun S2 spoilers. And if you want romantic scenes, there's one in S2 that I personally love too Railgun S2 spoilers.
- Animations are generally well done and the futuristic city background is immersive. The fight scenes are very well done - certainly far from blowing away people's minds like AoT or Madoka Magica, but they still top many others including all others from famous JC Staff produced anime like Index or Shana.
- Music.....just listen to these two OPs. 'nuff said.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yvS0Sr-2RH0
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S3QZv_RxsMc
- Voice acting - dunno about the English dub, but you have an award-winning VA as Mikoto, a VA who once voiced 8 roles in the same anime as Kuroko, Yui Hirasawa's voice as Kazari and so on. There's nothing that I can complain of their performance turned in.
- Director - Tatsuyuki Nagai has lead the production of many of the best school-themed anime out there, including Toradora, Anohana, Honey and Clover S2, The Anthem of the Heart, and Gundam Iron Blood Orphans (well I heard he badly screwed up the ending of the last one's S2, but that's another story :ahem:).
IMHO, had the series been done slightly later than the actual starting date of October 2009, the animation adaption might have the chance to simply adopt the 2 best parts in each of the 2 seasons we got (roughly S1E-E12 and S2E2-E16 - that's what I would recommend people to watch if they don't want to get through all 48 or so episodes). It would have been even better than what we get and I would not be surprised to see it in legendary status on par with the likes of Steins;Gate or Attack on Titan.
After watching about a dozen series, it's still unmistakably standing out as on par as whatever I have watched, and I am surprised that it's not really well that known on r/anime or MAL. Well, there's a solid follower base to the Raildex universe, but I would have expected it to be at least as large as the S;G one, maybe even on par as Monogatari. Yet when I looked around on the dozens MAL lists that people listed here, it seems that less than 1/4 have watched it, never mind the portion that admire it. Also I know that Mikoto Misaka was Best Girl 3 years earlier, but it seems that she won as the complete underdog, which was highly surprising to me too.
Of course there are problems with the adaption too - the anime original arcs (outside of the 27 episodes I recommend) are not that well done as in the adapted parts. The one at the end of S1 is OK, but the antagonist isn't well written. The one at the end of S2 screws up previous world settings and also the original source (and the antagonist is poorly defined anyway). The filler episodes (e.g. the swimsuit episode in S1) struggles in entertainment with similar slice-of-life sections of anime I have seen.
These can easily be skipped without any problem of understanding later parts of the story. The only problem I have outside of those parts is the characterization of Kuroko's and Ruiko's prank moments (which apparently put many people off). These were apparently greatly magnified than in the original manga. Luckily Ruiko's acts aren't too annoying, and for Kuroko you can easily see her serious and responsible side once you turn off your brain during the prank moments. I don't think these would greatly affect your viewing enjoyment, though this varies from one to another.
So considering that A Certain Scientific Railgun was very popular in Japan (^), I really, really want to recommend it to every single anime watcher here. Whether you like fights and action scenes, sci-fi stories, personalities illustrations, slice-of-life, comedies, emotional stories or cute girls, there are everything that you can find in here of the highest quality.
Just try it (yes, I believe that the best option for most people is to finish the whole Railgun series before heading to the Index anime, unless you like complex world settings development and/or the idea of Science clashing with Magic, in which coming to Railgun after Index I isn't a bad idea either). I'm sure many, many people here would fell in love with it. :)
If you have watched it and think it's boring, problematic, badly written or just not interested in going on, I would also welcome your comment as to what it lacks too. The discussions would certainly help other people to make their decisions whether or not to watch it. :)
(^) Season 1, with DVD sales averaging ~25000 per volume, topped sales in the Fall 2009 season and was the 3rd best of 2009, a tremendous success considering the top 2 are Bakemonogatari and K-ON! It handily beats out strong contenders like FMA:B, Haruhi 2009, CL:AS, Spice and Wolf II, Toradora and even all seasons of Index itself. Season 2 sales (average ~17000) managed to hold off multiple challenges in a stacked Spring 2013 season (SNAFU S1, OreImo S2, Date A Live etc.) and would have topped it had there not been a certain giant in the room called Attack On Titan (pun intended).
95
u/MillenniumKing x2myanimelist.net/profile/MillenniumKing Apr 15 '19
Isnt Misaka like one of the most popular anime characters of all time?
Im pretty sure there isnt any lack of people who have seen it.
21
u/DutchPeasant https://myanimelist.net/profile/NotJames Apr 15 '19
That's an incredibly long title. The first and last sentence aren't even needed since that opinion is very much expected when you write a WT! about it. "A Certain Scientific Railgun combines great aspects from Steins;Gate, K-On, Attack on Titan or CLANNAD into a fantastic show." would be a better title, but even that feels a bit messy.
Bringing up how popular it is doesn't feel like a good argument, and going on how it should be more popular only distracts. If you want to go that route, you should tell how it has influenced other shows. Most people are aware anyhow that Railgun is a popular franchise.
Finally, it also seems a few spoiler tags aren't filled in.
9
u/Trabant777 Apr 15 '19
So I watched the first half of a certain magical index and was not really into it tbh is it still worth my time?
28
u/N7CombatWombat Apr 15 '19
I couldn't get past the thirsty lesbian, I keep trying though, hopefully one day I'll be able to look past that character, but she's just so aggressive she makes me uncomfortable.
27
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Apr 15 '19
TL; DR - Watch Railgun for the amazing story of a badass shorts-wearing frog-mascot-loving 13 year-old girl and her friends fighting fucked up sciency schemes (and oh boy do they get fucked up), you won't regret it
4
u/Seb-sama Apr 16 '19
Honestly speaking, this show is the kind of show that my 13 year old self would’ve liked.
2
u/filimaua13 Aug 24 '19
Railgun wouldn't be as popular or praised if it weren't for Index. If Railgun started out as it's own thing, and Index didn't exist then people would see it as a typical anime. An interesting premise but nothing special. Let's be honest Misaka in her own series carries the same traits as Touma except she has powers and people call him a boring protagonist and praise the hell out of Misaka. It's the Index anime's fault for not presenting Touma's character and inner turmoils properly.
Don't get me wrong, I like Misaka's character but I enjoy watching Touma more. What makes Index so loved is it's concept of a world with science and religion (magic) in conflict with each other. Academy City is just a genius idea and sounds like a cool place to live in. It's cool seeing how many events that take place in that city affect many arcs that come later down the line. Railgun's core appeal is watching cool events happening and seeing how many are happening at the same time as Index main events and hoping for some character cameos and connections to the bigger picture that Index presents.
12
u/bagglewaggle Apr 15 '19
This is where you lost me.
I skipped Railgun after finding Index to become equal parts convoluted and generic.
13
u/SomeOtherTroper Apr 16 '19
Mikoto Misaka in Railgun: "Mikoto Misaka is probably one of the most charismatic characters the anime world has seen in at least the last decade or two. Where do you find a badass, very powerful in fights, self-confident, no-nonsense, courageous enough to fight solo, loose cannon type girl who's also friendly and caring to friends and almost everyone else (despite being an iconic figure in her city and also coming from a wealthy family), stands up to whatever evil power that she and her friends came across, does everything she could to protect her most important people in her life, and still keeps her childish behaviors?"
Mikoto Misaka in Index: Blushing tsundere who has to use all her willpower to avoid melting into a puddle when within fifteen feet of Touma.
And somehow these are supposed to be the same character.
I know I'm exaggerating, but the difference in how she acts on her own and how she acts when Touma's in the picture after Sisters' arc is pretty ridiculous. At least she pulls it together more in NT.
17
u/Madular Apr 15 '19 edited Apr 15 '19
Tried to watch it. Could not for the life of me stand the crazy side character that is infatuated with the MC. That was painful to watch and made me drop it. What is worse is that the show treats it as a lighthearted joke, always shoving her in the show to make stupid jokes.
And I am pretty sure she tried to spike a drink to do who knows what to the MC. But the MC forgave her and gave her a present, or something. The fuck is happening in that show ?
5
u/Better_MixMaster Apr 15 '19
My problem with the series is mostly Index. I really enjoyed both Railguns but I quit halfway through Index S2. Maybe it's just because every arc revolves around a lot of talking about nothing and Touma resolves it by punching someone. Will probably watch Accelerator but might have to force down Index S2 for it.
5
u/Mr_Magika Apr 16 '19
S1 was good. But I'd argue only for people already invested in the franchise. The SoL parts of it were boring to me though, because I wasn't watching Raildex for SoL. S2 though, is one of the best pieces of work I've ever had the pleasure of watching, all 16 episodes of it.
2
u/King_Merlin Apr 15 '19
Hard to get into imo. Really don’t like the MC and his relationship with anyone. It all seems so corny and tropey
1
u/IzzyRezArt Apr 16 '19
Well, I recently started Index! I'll get to Rail Gun as soon as I can. Is it on any streaming platforms?
1
u/Atemu12 https://anilist.co/user/atemu12 Apr 16 '19
Didn't read your post since I'm planning to watch it already but since there just was a new season, I assume it's still ongoing as a series?
I don't like watching series that don't have a proper end yet, got burned too often.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Do you have to watch Index first, or is Railgun independent?
1
u/KK9521 https://anilist.co/user/K9521 Apr 16 '19
Do I have to watch index to watch this?
1
u/WizYT Apr 16 '19
yes but, is the tuturuu phrase included?
6
u/[deleted] Apr 15 '19
It has the best tomboy mc ever, watch it.
6
u/Truenight95 Apr 15 '19
Mikoto is the cutest.
Don't @ me
4
u/bobobobobiy Apr 15 '19
I dunno, the way you described the MC makes her sound sort of boring as a character.
2
u/TheBlackestIrelia Apr 15 '19
Railgun is not a bad show. I watched most of the first season i think? It just got boring with all the little kid shit they had to do like that festival or fair or whatever it was around 16-18 (Guessing). I stopped there.
2
u/Gameking902 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/TrueHero Apr 16 '19
Went through all of index thinking it was pretty meh. Went through the first season of railgun thinking the first lart was ok but the anime original later half pretty lackluster. But the sister arc of railgun s was great (almost made going through the rest of those seasons i thought were mediocre worth it). The second part of railgun s is also anime original and isn't really that good imo but the sisters arc more than makes up for it. Oh, and misaka is fantastic lol.
2
u/StallmanTheLeft Apr 16 '19
Railgun is a really good anime. Index however is so bad I've considered dropping it many times every season.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
I watched 2 seasons of Index. Story is so cliché, characters as well. I really dont see why this series got 2 more spin-offs, Railgun and the other guy. Animation is sh*t, story is boring. I dont see anything of value here.
5
u/KaiserNazrin https://myanimelist.net/profile/Kaiser-chan Apr 16 '19
I don't think it hold a candle to Attack on Titan and Steins Gate.
1
u/DarknessInferno7 https://myanimelist.net/profile/DarknessInferno Apr 16 '19
I'll add it to the list.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
Don't listen to all who are saying, it's famous everyone's seen it bla bla. I have like 5000+ hours but never seen this one. Appreciate the recommendation.
1
u/shewy92 Apr 16 '19
I wish more anime did after stories like Clannad...well, maybe not EXACTLY like Clannad.
1
u/NeverMaksym Apr 16 '19
In my opinion the first half of the series with the sisters arc is better than all of the index anime put together, but the second half is not that good, I mean not even a 5 for me. My biggest praise for the series is in fact that Thouma or whatever he's called appears sporadically and we don't have him on screen all the time with his boring power and character.
1
u/elentarii Jun 02 '19
So love the show. But what's that odd eerie tone/sound that plays alot in the show. I'd say it's in alot of anime to near be called that errie anime sound. Anyone?
1
u/Kajanda Apr 15 '19
Hands down one of the best animes I have seen (in my opinion) and I have seen like 200-300+ different series
1
u/chrisdmontealegre Apr 16 '19
it's soo good, i agree. i loved the way you described misaka. i still prefer index seasons 1 and 2, but biri biri definitely deserved her own series, and boy is it good. i hope s3 can live up.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 16 '19
I have been watching this show. Fucking. Amazing. Hands down one of the greatest shows I will ever watch.
1
u/soundlinked https://anilist.co/user/soundlinked Apr 16 '19
The Railgun anime is leaps and bounds above the Index anime. I can't wait for season 3 to come out. I agree with the music too. The two OPs are so badass, especially with the animation that comes with it.
-6
u/AutoModerator Apr 15 '19
Hi CosmicPenguin_OV103, it seems like you might be looking for anime recommendations! I have changed the flair on your post to indicate that, but if I'm wrong, feel free to change it back!
The users of this subreddit came up with an awesome recommendations flowchart. Maybe you can find something there that you'll like ^.^
You might also find our Recommendation Wiki or Weekly Recommendation Thread helpful.
The following may be of interest:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.