r/anime • u/Suhkein :Gy::Gz::G1:x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/Neichus • Jul 20 '19
WT! [WT!] Hourou Musuko (Wandering Son)
Wandering Son is a slice of life series about figuring out who one is. For three childhood friends, Yoshino Takatsuki, Shuuichi Nitori, and Saori Chiba, life becomes increasingly complicated as they transition from the confines of their elementary class to the uncertain and formative years of middle school. Feelings and relationships which were once clear have become confusing, and as development takes its toll they must confront these inevitable changes.
Appreciating the series
In Wandering Son one finds a rare depth of sincerity and delicacy. From the first moments, with the characters sitting in seats talking to the camera, there is a sense that it wants us to understand who they are rather than just be entertained by them. Or perhaps I should say the people are the ones who so desperately want to be understood, enough to be interviewed by us strangers about what they feel most deeply.
Such intensity, however, is not taken as an invitation for hysterics. Wandering Son is a series of understated emotion, with tears and screaming replaced by awkward glances and unspoken words. Such absence has a presence all its own and by decluttering the stage it cuts deeper to the motivations which lie beneath. There is something here to listen to, quietly, like the unobtrusive music, and when the connection is made one feels it from within as well.
Furthermore, to truly grasp someone we must also know those around them, and in this Wandering Son does not disappoint. While the main characters and their problems take center stage, forming the thematic core of the series, it shows a rare compassion for the entire cast. These are people in their own right, poorly defined by whether they help or hinder the protagonists. Some of the best behavior is aided by selfishness, while some of the worst springs from confusion and fear rather than spite. Indeed, wounding lines can be spoken with good intent and even the main characters make choices which inadvertently hurt those around them. Everybody is affecting everybody else whether they know it or not.
So perhaps my first comparison to an interview was poor, for those are undertaken alone. It is more like a play, one which looks backward into the actors’ own past with the attitudes of a future maturity. In this way, then, Wandering Son is not an accurate recounting of what middle school life is like so much as what it can come to mean. Always couched in imagery which fades at the edges like memory, it is a series of recollections; a story composed of flashbulb vignettes that when stitched together have made these people who they are. And like actors who are permitted soliloquies which nobody would truly utter, so at times do the characters speak with a directness and clarity which belies their age. It is not what middle school students would do, but in exchanging some realism for incisiveness the series best accesses their essence.
Finally, there is taste. Some of the most impactful moments in life are truly painful, and those the series leaves unseen. Such times hurt too much for the characters to recall directly so we have no business viewing them either. There is only the long, quiet struggle afterward, and when at last tears make an appearance we can have no doubt that they are earned. This is the artistry through which Wandering Son is able to harness this emotional and turbulent period in life while transmuting the melodrama into genuine sentiment:
“Do you see now? This is what we really wanted.”
Should you watch it?
At the close of this post, one more detail about the series bears mentioning: several of the main characters are transgender. This would seem to be the first thing one ought to explain in a recommendation, but beginning that way sells it short.
The unfortunate truth is that targeted works are frequently shallow and predictable; the moral is known from the beginning so all that is required is to baldly enact it and count on agreement in the viewer to carry the rest. Even Wandering Son is not entirely free of this, at times becoming contrived for the sake of its message. In fact, I would go so far to say that for some parts the transgender emphasis was the lesser issue, and that I found Saori Chiba, a character who is not transgender, to be one of the series’ greatest assets.
What has been my hope, then, is to convince people in this small space that Wandering Son is better than just a niche piece. It is true that its core is gender identity, its scenes filled with the small-yet-poignant reminders to these children that the world (and body) they find themselves in is not one in which they naturally fit. But to introduce it as merely a good transgender story is a disservice; it is a good story, with no other qualifications required. Its focus will deepen the connection for those who have undergone similar trials, but anybody with the least bit of humanity can appreciate the piercing conflict between a heart’s desire and the forbidding struggle before it.
So should one watch it? Yes, and with the plea to watch it for the right reason. Don’t watch it because it’s a curiosity, a show with a rare premise and unusual conflicts. It’s too genuine for that. View it as another human story, accepting it for what it is, for that was the point all along.
Info
- Info: MAL, AniList
- Runtime: 11(12) episodes (see below)
- Year: 2011
- Streams: Crunchyroll (subs only)
When Wandering Son originally aired it had eleven episodes which are the ones listed on Crunchyroll. However, this was because they were forced to condense the intended twelve due to limited slots, with the original episodes 10 and 11 becoming a single installment. At a later date these were released separately, and if you acquire the series by “other” means it is possible to view them both.
My thanks to u/lilyvess for the information.
15
u/Jiggy90 Aug 10 '19
Oh. My. God.
So I used to be a frequent user here on /r/anime, back before this alt account became my main (because trans). I haven't properly watched an anime series start to finish for about two years now, but yesterday my Spotify on shuffle played Sparkle from Your Name, which reminded me of Mother's Basement's Your Name OP video, which brought me to his podcast with the Pedantic Romantic about the movie, which brought me to her channel, where her most recent video is a retrospective of this series and she talks about how the show partly inspired her to start hormones about a year ago (right about when I did...) and also which she talked about in a video from a year and a half prior, which I clicked on and watched (and literally started crying when she gendered Nitori and Takatsuki properly), which inspired me to watch the show. I started watching last night.
Sorry for the ramble, but anyways what I'm saying is that I'm on episode 3 right now and I absolutely love it. This show very well might be what brings me back into the /r/anime fold after a two year hiatus, and holy crap coincidence would have it that the first time I go back to the anime subreddit, the WT pinned in the top right corner is a show about trans people... that I literally just started.
Like, what? I'm so surprised and happy that this show is actually decently well known and liked! And for good reason, gosh the art direction is so soft and endearing, the cast is all unique and likable, it's awesome.
Dang I just can't get over the coincidence. Love it.
21
u/lilyvess :Df::Dh:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lilyvess Jul 20 '19
It was actually outside interference, they only had 11 slots to air on the channel, so this was how they were forced to air. the Blu Rays came out with the full 12 episodes.
It's really annoying (though somewhat understandable) that Crunchyroll has never updated it off the airing 11 even nearly a decade after it came out. I try to hunt down people watching the series to make sure people are aware of this. The 12 episodes is the way the studio always intended it to be seen
10
u/Roccobot https://anilist.co/user/Roccobot Aug 04 '19
I've finished watching Wandering Son just a week ago and this is the WT! thread I could have written if I were good enough.
24
u/prolapsingpotato :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/SHSLtrash1 Jul 20 '19
I’d recommend the manga instead. It’s a nice story but the anime really doesn’t do it justice & cuts it short.
6
u/RRotlung Aug 03 '19
I've not heard of this show before, but I really liked your write-up and took the plunge to start watching. I'm only done with the first episode so far, but I really like it so far. My impressions are that it's a very muted and subtle show, very different from what I'm usually used to. But it seems to deal with some very deep issues (like gender identity, as you helpfully mentioned), and I think it's going to be interesting how this show handles that.
Thanks for the recommendation!
7
u/jackalheart Aug 05 '19
This anime helped me better understand the experience of trans individuals, and helped me accept them more. I consider this show one of the best.
4
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19
/u/lilyvess Would probably like this, she likes when people talk about this series.
I was more... ignorant about the subject matter, I suppose you'd say, but this series does a (imo) a good job at explaining the different aspects of LGBT community. It handles sensitive topics pretty well or at least in realistic ways.
2
u/killingspeerx Sep 01 '19
Apparently the anime was on my "plan to watch" list but seems that the trans thing turns me off. It is short so I might give it a shot.
83
u/[deleted] Jul 20 '19
This show is one of the reasons I know I'm trans. It's very dear to my heart.
4
u/powerchicken Aug 15 '19
As someone who isn't particularly invested in trans issues, it was a pretty good, albeit predictable watch. Can recommend.
4
u/[deleted] Aug 22 '19
FUCK YEAH! WANDERING SON IS THE BEST! I was like 12 when I watched this show and I STILL love it. As a trans girl its special to my heart in so many ways.
1
u/kalirion :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/kalinime Aug 03 '19
I tried watching it on Crunchyroll, but it felt like I was starting a show from the second or third season. Killed my interest.
1
u/animar37 Aug 04 '19
This reminded me of how much impact that show had on me, really appreciate your write-up.
1
u/iBzOtaku Aug 14 '19
please put MAL, etc links at the top. I had to google and find it on my own and then realized you had them at the bottom.
5
u/didtrowie Jul 20 '19
Would've been cool if the did Bokura no Hentai as an anime as well. Fumi Fumiko is such an underrated author.
2
u/Dave55811 Aug 12 '19
Last year, curiosity got the better of me and I decided to check this anime out.
It was alright. This show would definitely be more appropriate for transfolk, though....but that too would be an interesting experiment; honestly, I can't picture many transfolk liking this anime, but I base that on various assumptions....which I admit I shouldn't do, since everybody's different. That being said, it looks like there are people here who are trans and are saying they liked this anime. More power to them.
I find myself frequently recalling the ED for each episode, personally. Something about it felt 80's and/or early 90's.
3
u/cpc2 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/cpc2 Aug 05 '19
I remember watching this last year when I was questioning (along with other LGBT related media that I had missed in my teenage years), it resonated with me. It's the only show I've watched that tackles directly that theme.
And now I'm already a few months into my transition 😊 Maybe I should rewatch this show later this year as a retrospective.