r/ •
[WT!] Medaka Box - an abnormally fun high school shounen that takes tropes so far it almost becomes satire.
[deleted] β view deleted post
0
Upvotes
r/ •
[deleted] β view deleted post
26
u/daniel_22sss Aug 09 '19
The anime stopped right before the best arc. If we got Kumagawa Misogi's arc - Medaka Box would get way more love. That character is amazing.
10
u/trollocity Aug 09 '19
I screwed myself leaving out a specific joke on this post, thinking about it.
6
u/OtherwiseNinja :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/MambaNuggets Aug 09 '19
I was sceptical, but knowing this was written by Nisioisin has convinced me I'll check it out tonight.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '19
The best parts of the manga aren't on the anime, like the Minus Arc, so I would say just go for the manga in the first place, then if like, watch the anime.
2
u/DirtBug Aug 09 '19
The manga is super fun. It really answers the question "What if Nisio writes a shounen" very well. The result is incredibly meta, unnecessarily convoluted series set in the most tried and true setting of highschool battle series. I advocate for the series everytime anyone ask about shounen recommendation.
1
u/Enmerker Aug 09 '19
I had a blast with the manga back in the day. I had kind of forgotten about it before seeing this post, but might need to give the anime a go then, cheers!
1
u/Illidan1943 Aug 09 '19
As someone that likes Symphogear this feels like the kind of show I'd like but I remember trying a couple episodes and not really liking it, maybe I'll give it another try
1
u/S1k-Stayn :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sikweeb Aug 09 '19
Romance?
1
u/BLACKOUT-MK2 https://myanimelist.net/profile/DelayedLaserBoom Aug 09 '19
Maybe it's because I watched it when I was relatively new to anime but I remember genuinely enjoying Medaka Box and being surprised when I saw how much criticism it's received later down the line. However, I will talk about it OP, that cliffhanger was a dick move!
1
u/JKlovelessNHK Aug 09 '19
I'm the kind of pissant that enjoys SAO and recognizes it as flawed all the same, I'm just sad it's so hard to find translations of the LNs that are further than what I've read. Progressive is great, imo. Kinda retcons some stuff a little bit, but it makes it better.
I'll have to check this out, at least the manga if not also the anime.
1
u/Djinnfor :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/DjinnFor Aug 10 '19
I tried but I couldn't find a halfway decent translation of it anywhere. I really liked Medaka Box but I seriously had to give up a couple chapters into the manga.
0
u/Eterna1Ice :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Eterna1Ice Aug 09 '19
Honestly I only watched this series as I already had continuing to the manga in mind. It seems counter-intuitive, as I hate the outcome of the question "Would you recommend watching this show?" on this subreddit being "No, they did this/that wrong, go read the fucking manga/LN/VN". Like fuck off, dumbass, I'm not here to fucking read, I want you to tell me if the anime itself is good, you idiot. I'm not involving myself with the other part of the media I don't particularly enjoy whether the ending is inconclusive or original, if it is, just tell me so. Fuck your source reader privilege. This is probably my personal issue, innit...
Well that aside, the show is alright. First season has a couple of good stories, and the Abnormal arc is cool stuff for fans of genre. But it's true that the best parts are after the show ends.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 09 '19
[removed] β view removed comment