r/anime • u/MauledCharcoal • Sep 16 '19
WT! RANK GRANBELM YOU COWARDS
I'm doing the TL;DR Upfront for you lazies. It's a series helmed by a great writer and director. It's completely underwatched and under appreciated.
Seriously though, in terms of reception Granbelm has likely underperformed worse than just about any other show in recent memory. Few shows that are this well done and worked on so passionately end up being ignored like it has. It's not Precure or Symphogear. It doesn't have a massive Japanese fanbase to appreciate it when the series is largely ignored in the west. As of right now it has less than 11k followers on Twitter. The English account has less than 400. Hardly any fan art exists which is a rough way to gauge how popular shows are. Ok let's look at MAL, it has less than 30k members and we're near the end of the season. It has a score of 6.37
"Now why do MAL scores matter?"
Well maybe not so much for this community but there are a decent amount of people who'll pick up seasonals by whatever has high scores or a large audience on MAL. Granbelm has neither. It also lacked the source material fans that it needed during the first EPISODES to hype it up and encourage others to stick with it.
"Well what is Granbelm, and why are you acting as if it deserves better"
Good question reader. Granbelm is a passion project.
It's written by Hanada Jukki. As in the writer for Love, Chunibyo & Other Delusions, Sora Yori, Hibike Euphonium, Nichijou, NGNL, Bloom into You, as well as uhhh STEINS; GATE. As well as writing the Screenplay for K-ON. Basically the guy is a heavy weight with a stacked portfolio. Not everything he touches is gold but he's definitely a strong writer and it definitely shows in Granbelm.
The director is Watanabe Masaharu. He hasn't directed much aside from some episodes in Naruto and some in the Rock Lee spin off as well as a Wakaba Girl where he worked with Hanada Jukki. Oh he also directed this little series called RE:ZERO. You may also recognize him as the animator for Haruhis first ED yes those cute dancing anime girls that were the Kaguya of the 2000s.
"So why's this relevant?"
If you've watched Steins;Gate you know just how well Hanada Jukki can write. More importantly if you've seen ReZero, think about episode 15 to have a glimpse of the talent Watanabe has. Ok good got your attention. My point is that this show has MASSIVE talent at the helm. Is Granbelm going to be at Steins; Gate or ReZero or Sora Yori levels? Yeah probably not but it's nonetheless a very solid series.
"Well if it's such talented staff why is it flying under the radar?"
Well despite the heavy weights I've just mentioned it's probably cause of the lack of recognizable talent. Yeah I know how that sounds. But after spending some months on this forum I've found it very rare to see any mention of either Hanada or Watanabe. Hell Watanabe doesn't even have a picture on MAL. They don't have the star power of Ikuhara or Shinichirou Watanabe or Tatsuki. Just go compare their MAL favorites count I dare you. So they lack recognizable staff. Alright that's one thing but a lot of shows are like that, but not only do they lack the star talent but they also lack the name brand of a studio. If this show had the label of Trigger, A-1, Ufotable it would be doing so much better. Don't believe me? Look at Fairy Gone by P.A. Works over 100k members on MAL.
"Well ok, but if the show was good it would gain attention on it's own merits wouldn't it?"
THAT'S THE THING. The SHOW IS GOOD. It's imo a top 5 contender this season and for the viewers on it's episode threads it seems to be a common sentiment. A lot of people may have dropped it because it was confusing. But trust me it'll make sense later on. Like Steins;Gate it's a series where you have to trudge on through the confusing first episodes to get to the meat of the story. It starts off slow and starts one upping itself every episode.
"Well maybe the show just looks bad?"
ITS GORGEOUS. ok let me rephrase that. Not only does this show have animation that rivals Fireforce and Demon Slayer. In fact this is bold, but I'd say it may even surpass them both in terms of sheer amount of action. There are moments when Fireforce and Demon Slayer both easily look better than Granbelm, but Granbelm hardly has any down time, I think half the episodes are completely jam packed with action. If I'm wrong then well the show does a great job at making it feel like that. It's such a fluid production with amazing visual effects. It's a Mecha show done in all 2D. The battles look gorgeous the characters look amazing. Just beautiful.
"You're circle jerking this show so much why?
Let's assume the story sucked and this was just a pretty looking show for a second. The animation is still worth checking out. In fact doubly so cause get this, the whole thing is being done by like 7 key animators. u/linearstargazer can give you more info about this than I can. Such a small staff means one thing. It has a phenomenal schedule. This is such a rarity in today's climate. It's a 2D Mecha show. A rarity in today's climate. Basically a show like this may never ever come again and the STAFF KNOWS it. Some shows go through 10 episode directors in a single episode notably Attack on Titan and One Punch Man S2. This shows has less key animators than that.
"Ok you've convinced me but why are you so passionate about this show?"
Because the people working on it are passionate about it. It's so god damn sad seeing how their work is being ignored both in the west and in Japan. Hell the producer Takayuki Nagatani has gone on record to say "Animation skills in Japan are changing and creators’ anxieties are rising. I truly hope that fans overseas can help us in protecting Japanese anime." They know they're show isn't being well received in Japan and they're asking for help. They're not going to get it. This show has no source material that it can rely on. No boost in manga or light novels that'll help make it a commercial success. It's an original and is only going to survive off Blu-Rays and merch. They're not expecting to ship thousands of Blu-Rays. For everyone concerned about proper schedules and 2D animation. This is how it dies. In silence a show filled to the brim with such amazing talent and charm is rotting away just below our noses and we're ignoring it. Good luck having another original 2D Mecha show ever be greenlit again because if I was on a committee I'd stay far away.
"I'm on board what can I do to help make sure this show is a success"
NOTHING :) Yeah at this point there's nothing at all that we can do. Unless a 1/500 of this whole subreddit got together and bought merch and Blu-rays. But considering this show hasn't even been able to rank on the Weekly Karma ranking that won't happen. So I wouldn't say to watch this show to support it or it's creators. I'd say watch it for yourself. Sit down and witness a show done by masters of their craft. Cause you'll probably never get another chance to see a show like this air again.
"So you've talked a lot about people and the situation around it but what's it about?"
Well it's a drama first and foremost. It uses mechas in a battle royale to sell the action. There's a lot of mystery that's fun to hypothesize over and creates an intrigue even 11 episodes in. Every girl is battling in order to become a Princess Mage and be able to fulfill their desires however it seems like they may just be pawns in a larger game.
Oh btw check out this interview for other gems such as "Some non-Japanese anime fans may believe that all anime made in Japan is great, however that’s not true."
Also go check out the actual masterpiece on YouTube. Or just go watch it on Crunchyroll.
Oh and thanks u/linearstargazer for speaking about the key animators on a bunch of weekly threads.
This is my first actual post on Reddit so I'm sorry if it's formatted badly or if I went on tangents.
76
u/AxtheCool Sep 16 '19
OP you did convince me to check the series out but I still dont think its something I would enjoy. I feel the same way about this show just like I felt about Revenue Starlight was hailed to be incredible and in the end was meh. So now I am wary of most of these kinds of shows.
And just because the creator wrote screenplays for Steins Gate, Chu2koi, NGNL and etc is not enough for me to watch the show. After all those are adaptations of already popular works.
But I give you props and an upvote for such a long post anyways. Good job.
321
u/bagglewaggle Sep 16 '19
This is a strange Watch This!, because it avoids actually explaining what the series is, who it would appeal to, and why.
There's less information about the story of the series here than in the MAL synopsis, and that is two sentences long.
8
u/Teath123 https://anilist.co/user/MahoHiyajo Sep 17 '19
You bring up a writer with pedigree, but like, how do you even compare a work that's just adapted from a visual novel, or a light novel to an original work? You can't. Like the script of Steins;Gate is practically word for word taken from the game, it's not the same thing as having to write something yourself.
12
u/phiraeth :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/phiraeth Sep 16 '19
A CFB and Granbelm fan? Can we be friends???
6
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '19
Something we can probably all agree on is that the OP song is actual fire:
https://youtu.be/wfvlGmY8z10
11
u/Emi_Ibarazakiii Sep 17 '19
I'm not even sure why I didn't try this show... I thought I tried most new seasonals (1 episode at least) but apparently I missed that one.
That being said, a few things:
Animation is the thing I consider most overrated in anime. To me, if a show is a 3/10, but it has great animation... It's still a 3/10.
I know some would say a show that look so great is at least a 5 or 6/10 just for the animation alone, but for me it doesn't even matter.
I can sometimes dock points for atrocious animations. But I don't add point for especially great animation.
The entertainment/enjoyment I get from a show is pretty much the same whether it has "OK" animation or "Excellent" animation.
I'm MUCH more likely to add points to an anime's score due to a good OST, than to good animation.
As for the rest... Well I haven't seen it so I can't give my personal opinion, but judging from the comments, I think your opinion differs from the general opinion... Lots of people talking about bland characters, a bad/boring/uninteresting story, etc. And yes I've seen people argue against this as well in the comments, but my question would be... Why would you think that is (meaning, that the opinions differ so much)?
Again I can't speak for this show, but I've seen similar thing happens in shows that I followed (some people saying a part of the show was shit, and others defending it ) and usually, when this happens, it's one of two things;
To give an example from another show this season: Fire Force.
Now, I do watch the show still, and enjoy it (at least a little, I mean I haven't dropped it yet) but goddamn, some parts of the story are awful, especially when it comes to character development/motivation. I have 2 specific characters in mind when I say this, and while 1 might be a bit controversial, I think the other one is super obvious starts with hib and ends in ana
Her story is ridiculously dumb from start to finish. Yes, the show at least attempts to explain why she's like that and all, but it falls so flat, it's as if they didn't even do it. There are so many comments from people everywhere (here, on youtube, etc) who say she makes no goddamn sense and all that.
Yet, there are people who defend it. Oh yeah it totally makes sense, because she has PTSD! Oh yeah it totally makes sense because Shinra offered a new world to her where Hero exists or some shit!
None of these comments made any sense to me. And this is from a show I watch. So I know how people can justify complete nonsense with arguments that (to the person who haven't seen what they're talking about) can sound right.
So... While it's obviously not a 100% accurate method, when I see such harsh criticism from so many people about an aspect of the story, I tend to give them a lot of credit... Perhaps more than I would give to the die-hard fans of the show. Because often, fans of a show are so biased that they'll say anything to make it look good. Sometimes they might not even do it on purpose. They justify it like they justify it to themselves.
11
u/CosmicPenguin_OV103 https://anilist.co/user/CosmicPenguin Sep 16 '19
Jukki Hanada is probably the best - and most importantly most reliable - contemporary anime scriptwriter active right now. The only works under his hands that were criticized in recent years that I can think of are Kancolle and LLSS - both of which are probably not due to his fault.
He's actually fairly well known in anime communities of other languages, just not in here.
P.S. I have to chuckle at the mentioning of Ikuhara, Shinichirou Watanabe & Tatsuki - none of their shows this year really made much noise here on r/anime. Kemurikusa in particular was at the exact same place as Granbelm during the Winter season here....when back in Japan it sold out volumes after volumes.
I still hold out a slight glimmer of hope that it would pull a Madoka during the final dash towards the end....it's slight, but the chance is still there.
6
u/Totalenlo https://anilist.co/user/Lenlo Sep 17 '19
What if I checked it out, decided I didn't like it/it wasn't my thing, then moved on? The staff is talented sure. It means they have a lot of good people working on it. But that doesn't automatically mean it will be good. Maybe people checked it out, and just didn't find it all that engaging, like me.
For instance, off the top of my head from what I remember a few months ago, I wasn't a fan of the chibi mecha designs nor the characters. Glad you like it, but may there's a reason its rated the way it is?
3
u/mcchickenngget Sep 16 '19
You know what sure I'll check it out. What kind of show is it anyway?
3
u/noxnoctum :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nox0s Sep 17 '19
I watched 4 episodes but couldn't get into it. Does it really improve later?
9
u/Sidearms4raisins https://anilist.co/user/Ch0ke Sep 16 '19
I mean, I watched the first episode with relatively high hopes when it aired because of the staff involved and didn't like it at all. I can still rate it if you want haha.
14
u/alwayslonesome :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/ImmacuIate Sep 16 '19
Even though ambitious originals are pretty much the only thing I still watch anime for, it's not that surprising to me for original series are consistently marginalized in the West. We don't get to take in any of the domestic marketing and advertisement, and there aren't any fanboys of the source material to inflate the ratings and shill the anime to other people.
What is downright surprising to me though, is how many people there seem to be that dropped the show, or are asking whether it's worth it to continue watching. It's incredibly apparent from just the first episode that if nothing else, the craft elements of the show are spectacular. I'd have thought that the talent on display there, along with the pedigree of the staff credits would be more than enough to convince people to keep watching. To be sure, the show takes its time to develop its narrative and characterization, but are people's attention spans really so short? It seems to be more of a recent trend as well - It'd be a really unfortunate direction for this medium's storytelling if every new show has to lay all its cards on the table from episode one so that impatient viewers get their instant gratification.
Either way, please just check out this show, it really does have something for everyone. It's ostensibly a mecha action spectacle with phenomenal animation, but the thematic and character work the show does is really impressive too. Easily a top contender for anime of the season and probably the year alongside Araburu.
6
u/Nikwal Sep 16 '19
I ordered some merch today. Found out about Granbelm when Eir Aoi posted she's singing the OP and have been watching since Episode 1, it's a fantastic anime. I can see why so many fans (myself included) are passionate about it.
6
u/Pentao Sep 16 '19
I gave the series like 3 episodes or so, but it failed to grab my attention. Cute girls, subtext, Yuuki Aoi, good art and animation... all things I like but the pull just wasn't there.
Especially could not sympathize with the mc's motivations.
2
u/Terminator1134 Sep 16 '19
I didn’t read all that info but I saw it’s made by the guy who made steins gate and chunibyo so I’m interested. Could you tell in a vague way what the shows about?
33
u/Yggdrazzil https://myanimelist.net/profile/Yggdrazzil Sep 16 '19
I've never checked out the staff for a show beforehand to decide whether to watch it or not, simply because I cannot remember (japanese) names of staff for the life of me.
Based on your description of the staff however, I felt obligated to check it, given how much of the shows you mentioned I enjoyed.
So I watched it and I am looking forward to ep 12.
It looks fine, it sounds fine, but the story sadly didn't do much for me. I expected something grander from the people behind all the shows you mentioned. There were some scenes that were well executed that would've tugged at my heartstrings a couple of years ago. Anna's VA blew me away with her intensity. Mangetsu's VA was cute.
All in all, it was an enjoyable experience, but it didn't excite me as much as it did you. Still, thanks for the recommendation!
22
u/Mystic8ball Sep 16 '19
You're leaning hard into this shows staff to sell us on it but I'm honestly not convinced. Steins;Gate for example was an adaption of a Visual Novel that was already critically acclaimed, the reason why we all love the S;G anime so much is because the source material was so strong... of course this means that he didn't cock up the adaption (S;G0's anime really fell apart towards the end which is a shame because the VN is very good), but it says very little about his own ideas as a writer.
A lot of shows are well written, a lot of shows are gorgeous, but nobody's going to be sold on anything with these vague statements. You need to really get into what makes the show itself so great. Talk about the writing in detail, the characterization, the themes it explores.
It's cool that you're so passionate about it but aside from the shows staff maybe having good credentials, you haven't really explained why it's worth watching this show at all.
11
u/AuburnTheWolf Sep 16 '19
This one is on my list, but I'm more of a binge watcher than a weekly watcher. I was going to watch when the season was complete
66
u/coding94 https://anilist.co/user/Halcyon13 Sep 16 '19
I'm completely up to date on it and completely unimpressed.
9
u/stella_snyper :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/stella_snyper Sep 17 '19
> It's a Mecha show done in all 2D.
Ok I'm sold OP.
29
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Sep 16 '19
I've been sticking with Granbelm all season and am enjoying it quite a bit. Especially with it being an original series - it's amazing how much better that makes the episode discussion threads, particularly since Granbelm has had a few cliffhanger episodes. Personally, I think this unrelenting fervour for complaining about the series being underwatched is getting rather annoying, but oh well.
Do I think it's a masterpiece? Not at all.
I think the chibi-mecha designs, while an interesting idea, are harder to visually distinguish their parts while in motion, which makes the action less distinct and harder to follow than it ought to be. The old-school solution to this would perhaps be to use contrasting colours on the parts of the mecha, but they didn't do that and we end up with black mecha limbs moving around a black body against a dark brown or dark purple background. (This isn't a new problem - Votoms had the same issue decades ago with its squat power armour painted in similar shades of brown-green against brown and green backgrounds.) Add to all of that the constant use of enormous glowing effects that add more visual confusion and distraction making it even harder to follow the mecha behind them.
The dialogue and narrative also dips too much into Ellipsis Syndrome for me - you know, where instead of speaking what's on their mind or saying anything really they just stare at each other and say "[Other character's name]...". Given that the plot of the series is supposedly spread over months, these characters sure do seem to be able to spend days or even weeks at a time ignoring the enormous interpersonal conflicts they are having. Likewise, there's some pretty obvious future plot points that you would think the characters would have plenty of time to anticipate and plan for during all those days of downtime/moping.
These aren't massive problems by any stretch, and like I said I'm still enjoying the show a lot. I'm still eager to see what will happen next after each episode and distraught over having to wait a week, so obviously it's doing plenty of things right. But I can understand those for whom the above factors are too much for them to enjoy it.
This is misleading, as you seem to be trying to lead the reader to conclude that Granbelm is a passion project of Hanada and/or Watanabe. But based on the recent interviews the project was conceived and planned by Takayuki with the in-house Nexus staff, while Hanada and Watanabe were both only brought on board after it was shopped out, approved, and pre-planning was already underway. Not that I think Hanada or Watanabe are dispassionate about Granbelm, but what evidence do you have that they are putting any more passion into it than any of their other past projects?
7
u/Hazeringx https://myanimelist.net/profile/akariaku Sep 16 '19
Though I haven't watched Granbelm yet (I do plan on watching it though, I believe that it's an anime that I will like a lot), I somewhat can understand Granbelm fans. I felt something similar with Toji no Miko last year. For me, it was the best anime of the year with Yuru Camp, but unfortunately it was relatively underwatched (I don't know if it was watched more or less than Granbelm though).
29
u/DimmuHS https://myanimelist.net/profile/DimmuOli Sep 16 '19
I have come here to know about the show, but I got nothing from it.
Although it's a good point to mention the directors, writers and reference shows, that alone isn't enough to make someone watch it if they don't like or know the genre or the plot.
People tend to bash MAL, but even so I think it's pretty accurate overall from the shows I watched (of course we have exceptions), the only thing I question myself is when looking at the ratings of the reviews which pretty much don't match the chosed score at all and thank god we generally have a variety of visions and approaches in reviews.
That said, MAL synopsis isn't interesting enough to pushed me to watch it and it has mecha with isekai and fantasy (like wtf), and from what I read it has a battle royale of sorts, I mean it could had all crazy directors and animators, if I don't care about the plot and you just don't show me anything about the characters it just not going to work, and honestly your post didn't touched the most important aspect: The show itself.
3
u/matigno Sep 16 '19
I dropped it during the first episode since the mecha looked horrible, but I'll give it another try after the season is over.
(seriously, they look like someone sat on them)
84
u/8andahalfby11 myanimelist.net/profile/thereIwasnt Sep 16 '19 edited Sep 16 '19
I've said it before and I'll say it again and I don't care how many times I get downvoted for it, Granbelm deserves exactly the amount of attention it's getting. It's a visually spectacular show that largely falls on its face because the characters are caricatures rather than people with relatable or compelling motivations, and it largely fails to present them as people beyond their problems. Instead we get a lot of targeted exposition, and some odd targeted responses that feel out of place for what bits of the characters we've been given.
This was an especially nasty gut-punch to me, given how much I enjoyed both A Place Further than the Universe and Steins;Gate 0, two recent prior works by Hannada, and as such this was my most highly anticipated anime of the season. I am still watching it, hoping that there's something in the end that really makes it stand out, but that lack of strong characterization to back up the action continues to drag down even its most powerful moments--and Episode 11 put in a really good effort!
I'm not entirely certain where to lay the blame, but if I had to point anywhere, I have a hunch that it's the Director. Re;Zero also had lots of great action, but it shared some of Granbelm's cases where scenes that could have been more powerful were dragged down by too much wordiness for their own good.
12
u/TanyaTheEvill Sep 16 '19
I absolutely love this show. Every week i look forward to the next episode. This week is episode 12 and I am looking forward to this. Also I do not put any stock in MAL. I don't like it as a forum or as any kind of reviews. It is by far to most hostile entity there is in regards to anime, manga and ect.
6
u/NurseOctopus Sep 16 '19
I started it on a whim weeks ago and have been enjoying.
11
u/tuuturu :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/tuuturu Sep 16 '19
Granbelm is my Anime of the season. I picked this show up after seeing the amazing cover the show had. The color design captivated me so much. MAL ended up changing the cover poster for the show later on which was disappointing.
The biggest reason I love this show is Mangetsu. The show explores her motivations and psyche brilliantly. (Warning:mild spoilers for episodes 1 & 2) At first she makes lunches for a lot of her classmates and volunteers for things just so she can feel wanted. She feels like she has no purpose - that is, until she is introduced to the Granbelm. She finally found a purpose for existing.
“I’ve finally found something, that only I can do.” —Mangetsu
This show has some absolutely amazing moments at times, and always leaves me thinking for hours about where the show is headed next. The quality of art in this show is gorgeous, especially the colors they use.
Theres just so many things I love about this show. It’s not without it’s flaws, as many users have mentioned in the comments, but for me the amazing things about this show heavily overwrite the flaws. I hope I’ve sold you to give Granbelm a look, and if you do, I hope you can join us on the discussion threads! We’re a nice group that loves the show. ^ Many thanks for reading.
5
u/lunarstarslayer Sep 17 '19
the show is literally like the first Wixoss series did the fusion dance with SD gundam and failed.
2
u/WhyYouMadBroo Sep 16 '19
What's the show about? Is it about magical girls? I have pretty much zero interest in the genre, so it won't matter how well the writing or directing is.
4
u/zeroryoko1974 https://anime-planet.com/users/wwwzeroryoko1974 Sep 16 '19 edited Sep 16 '19
It's ok. It wants to be Madoka Magica but with mechs. I am several episodes behind (last episode i saw was fight against resting bitch face). I would say it's somewhere between. 6 and 7
4
u/Sharebear42019 :FC::FD: Sep 17 '19
No ty
13
u/Human971224 Sep 16 '19
I hope this series explode into fame as the season ends. It's wonderfully crafted.
20
u/dragonmaster127 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/dargonsUnited Sep 16 '19
Watch Granbelm, its a gorgeous battle royale show with some fun narrative twists and turns.
While it may not be incredible, it is way better than half the shit that actually is popular this season.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '19
Im watching it only because the animation doesnt suck. The story is quite boring. IMO, they should rank MIX!!
9
u/PM_ME_YOUR_SPUDS https://anilist.co/user/voodoochile Sep 16 '19
They don't, and you shouldn't care about the people who decide what to watch based on them anyways.
11
u/the_swizzler https://myanimelist.net/profile/Swiftarm Sep 16 '19
I've been watching it since airing, but I don't rank shows until I finish them.
Even so, unless the last two episodes retroactively change my feelings on the entire show, I can't see myself giving it better than a 7.
It's got some interesting ideas and good animation, but I don't really feel much from the characters or the story. I don't remember any clear moments of going "holy crap", and every week I forget what happened last until the new episode starts up. It's interesting enough that I don't want to drop it, and I would recommend someone watch it if it sounds interesting to them, but apart from that, I just don't feel the same excitement I've seen a lot of fans get from it. I know what it's like though to see a series you desperately love to go unloved like this by the general populace. I was lucky that a mobile game was able to save the franchise for my anime though.
13
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
It's quite sad, because in the interview with the producer he literally said he hoped people would watch the entire thing before judging it, and most of r/anime is dropping it on the first episode for reasons like "I dont like the chibi mechs".
3
u/venpasa Sep 16 '19
The only reason I don't watch the show is that the mechs just look really stupid they are like tiny Nendoroid figurines. And any scene with them instantly takes me out of the show.
Everything else I saw was great. But I'm pretty sure the mech designs killed the show in one episode for a lot of people. If the mechs didn't look like a prop from a 90s episode of the power rangers I think the show would be rated a lot higher.
3
u/venpasa Sep 16 '19
The only reason I don't watch the show is that the mechs just look really stupid they are like tiny Nendoroid figurines. And any scene with them instantly takes me out of the show.
Everything else I saw was great. But I'm pretty sure the mech designs killed the show in one episode for a lot of people. If the mechs didn't look like a prop from a 90s episode of the power rangers I think the show would be rated a lot higher.
3
u/CakeBoss16 Sep 17 '19
Well I think passion has convince me to give it the ol college try.
3
u/xyander64 Sep 17 '19
I read most of your ramble, i think one of the main reasons the show isn't doing well its the mech designs are really unappealing.
I watched the first 2 episodes when they aired, as i was looking forward to the show do to it having people from Re:zero and Stines;Gate working on it. The 2 i wached weren't even bad, but every time i think about going back i see those chibi-fied mechs and i watch something else. I know it's stupid but the giant robots looking cool is a big draw for mecha shows.
Ps. Every time i typed mech my phone auto corrected to Mecha-Eli Chan im telling you this so it will keep doing it
12
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19 edited Sep 16 '19
I have been watching it and all I can say is the use of foreshadowing is awful. They pull multiple huge twists throughout it and they give us no real reason to think that we arent already at status quo.
Take Madoka Magica for example, they specifically let us know that there were things happening in the show that dont make sense given the rules we are told about how the world work, namely everything to do with Homura. This creates a mystery, one we hope to solve and eventually do. Granbelm on the other hand doesn't create a mystery and just says 'death game because' they even go put of their way to put our questions to rest. So good show but certainly not a great show
Edit; as I said it is a good show. But that's all it is, it will never be great unless it can make a mystery that can actually be solved by the viewer before the answer is handed to us.
9
u/touss231 https://anilist.co/user/touss Sep 17 '19 edited Sep 17 '19
I really like this show and I'm looking forward to see more of it each Friday, but holy shit those Granbelm fanboys are getting annoying recently and they can't even sell people on this anime. First there was this random Suishou clip that didn't make any sense out of context and now this WT that rather then give some info about the show itself, it's telling people to watch it because some famous people are behind it or that 2D mecha animation is dying. Are there seriously no better reasons to watch it? Also, making this kind of thread when there are still two episodes to go, one of them being climax of the series, is kinda strange.
7
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
I'm gonna be honest, I have watched the first 3 episodes, and I just didnt like it, now you may say that it gets better, but when I remember mc, I just see someone careless, dumb, and definitelly not interesting or smart what so ever, so whatever happens later, will be less interesting for me if characters in the story aren't interesting and intriguing, that's it for my review of first 3 episode, have a good day.
7
u/basuga_BFE https://myanimelist.net/profile/KPF Sep 16 '19 edited Sep 16 '19
Thanks to OP for saying it loud!
OP said about artists and their passion to make good anime, though said nothing about what is good.
So let me say about emotional side.
7
u/AsuraTheDestructor Sep 17 '19
Way to come across as an eltist Dick, dude. Not everyone will listen to your soapbox, and in someways, you make it even worse for some people by making them get turned off by the series even more.
5
u/BoyTitan Sep 17 '19 edited Sep 17 '19
As a major mecha fan just now hearing of this, along with other mecha fan friends not posting about it on fb. I can says its probably flopping due to design. If the story is super solid and the actions good its failing for 1 reason. Design. Its way to fucking cutesy. Even the mechs are to cutesy looking and have to many rounded angles, are to diminutive, and chibi looking. Muv luv alternative which I can barely remember anything about had a mediocre story but it got its target audiences with design if you are going to mix moe and mecha. Keep the mecha designs super sharp and angular to appeal to mecha fans. I gave the series a like 6/10. But man did I love the mecha designs. Actually even the character designs are to blobby no one uses that style anymore for anything thats not slice of life.
18
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
Im sorry the moeblob character designs make it totally unpealing to me....
But Im getting pretty tired of being called a coward.
6
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19 edited Sep 16 '19
Granbelm is a fascinating experiment to me, in that it’s an ambitious passion project that’s not quite working as intended.
It's clear they had a plan for what they wanted to do, but the way the show tells its story feels super clumsy. The early episodes were overloaded with characters we hadn’t been introduced to properly. The most interesting thing in any battle royal type show are the characters themselves, and most of the time they're all infodumping about Granbelm (Made worse by the fact the stuff they’re infodumping about isn’t actually important to the larger story). Between the hard to follow animation and the “Super robot logic” the show uses to resolve its fights, the mecha portions themselves vary between serviceable and borderline incomprehensible.
As far as why nobody is giving it a shot goes, I don’t think it can be understated how bad that first episode is. I legitimately fell asleep watching it the first time and had to watch it a second time to make sure I’d taken it all in, and I still mostly had no idea what was going on.
Also the weekly Granbelm threads have become increasingly hostile towards anyone with any sort of criticism of the show, no matter how minor. More power to you if you like the show, but maybe it’s ok if other people feel otherwise?
Edit: One more thing - without spoiling anything, I hate the direction they went with Mangetsu's character.
11
u/Buddy_Waters Sep 16 '19
I can get not liking the show once you check it out. Tastes vary.
But I can't understand how people could see this staff on it and not give it a shot at all.
11
u/AsuraTheDestructor Sep 16 '19
Stop being selfish. You can soapbox all you want, but not everyone will agree with you in the end.
4
u/S-dono Sep 16 '19
Gonna go watch it just cuz u spent the time to write all that out 🏃♂️
4
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '19
This WT annoyed me so much that it killed every interest in watching Granbelm. Congrats OP, you made me never ever watch this show.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
I like the idea of a magical girl battle royale but dropped it bc watching way too many seasonal rn, gonna have to return to it later
2
u/Mortem001 Sep 16 '19
I watched the first 3 episodes and it didn’t hook me, but I suppose I could give it another try.
2
u/FullRage Sep 16 '19
Got turned off by the first ep. The animation was ok till they started fighting in the mech looking things. It just looked low quality and generic designed. Idk, maybe I was on the brink of falling asleep and try watching again.
2
u/frankyb89 Sep 17 '19
Honestly, I just started this series for cutesy robot girly shit and got hit by a wall of feelings instead. It's been an unexpectedly great show this season for me.
2
u/AsuraTheDestructor Sep 17 '19
I think the reason its not doing well is the Chbi mech design is a throwback to the horror that is the SD gundam anime....
7
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
Maybe it just aint that good tho
4
u/rotvyrn Sep 17 '19
I watched like an episode and a half, I guess, and I don't have any interest in continuing. So, my impressions so far, which are worthless as an appraisal of the series, but explain why I don't have any interest in moving forward with it:
The animation/choreography don't sell me. It didn't feel particularly cool; it was pretty arbitrary. I don't think it needs to explain its power system in episode one, or anything, but it lacked impact. When someone did something unexpected, it just didn't come across as cool for me. People did whatever with their magic in rapid succession. It wasn't overwhelming, but without establishing a baseline or being visually stunning, I had no reason to be impressed with what they were doing. Unlike other mecha anime, they don't have visible weapons to clue you in on their capabilities. Unlike other fantasy shows, there's no human movement to give you a sense of scale.
The mech designs are cluttered and I'm not liking the chibi style. Distinct limbs do wonders for conveying agility and posing, and I had too much trouble making those out. This is also coming from someone who played and enjoyed SDGO and SRW. So I'm used to SD proportions, and I think they can be executed well. I just wasn't following the action in episode 1's fight, however.
So far, there's not that much personality in the show. And I don't mean complexity or loudness. But I just...don't get any distinct impression. Unlike other magical girl shows, there's not a lot of energy or quirkiness or slice-of-life happiness. It's quiet and dull. It lacks energy. Most of the dialogue so far is explaining things that aren't super interesting and there's not a great sense of what the protagonist wants or thinks about any of it. And frankly, I don't feel like the right information is coming out. I loved Re:Creators, which is the poster child for longwinded explanations. But I enjoyed them a lot. I...felt like all the dialogue so far in Granbelm has been drawn out and boring.
And if it's a show like Madoka, well, I'm not super into the darker magical girl stuff anyway. It was a great work, but not one I can stomach a second time, and none of the dark magical girl shows since have held my attention as well as Madoka did.
5
u/darpblog Sep 16 '19
So, read your post, went ahead and tried. 5 minutes in I have to double check that I'm actually watching the same show you recommend. Halfways into the episode, sorry, I'm dropping. I'm just bored. This feels nothing like those other great shows you mention.
3
u/DqrkExodus https://myanimelist.net/profile/MeariSa Sep 16 '19
How many cour is it?
From what I understand people got turned off by the early episodes but the show gets alot better later on? For the benefit of the anime if its 2 cour at least, more people who rated it low and dropped it in its first 4 or so episodes will have their scores removed
Also I think Steins;Gate had a score of like 7 or a low 8 when it was airing its first half, so there's hope for Granbelm if its picks up
3
u/Pixelsaber https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pixelsaber Sep 16 '19
Granbelm is most definitely a show I would be watching as it aired where it not for the fact that it interferes with my ongoing mecha watching venture.
3
u/Audrey_spino Sep 17 '19
Watched it. Gets a solid 7.5/10 from me. I do think 6.37 is a bit of an injustice.
5
u/Christopho https://myanimelist.net/profile/furrytoes Sep 17 '19
So glad to see most of the top comments saying it's not that great because it's true.
I've been watching it since day one. I was amazed at the level of care in the animation then and even now. However, that's the only thing that has kept me watching (even then, while the level of animation has been top notch especially considering they're mechs, the direction has been terrible imo). There are obviously some really nice moments but it's really not that amazing.
I won't even attempt to list the reasons as people have already stated them more eloquently than I ever will both here and in the weekly discussions. However, what I will say is I dislike the fact that this post even exists when we literally don't know how it will end.
It could easily end up as a dumpster fire or it could even be so amazing that I end up rating this show a 10; point being, no one knows.
3
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
Maybe it just aint that good tho
4
u/Sn0wHunterWing :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Sn0wHunterWing Sep 16 '19
I tried it, gave it 4 or 5 episodes and found it incredibly mediocre. There was nothing I hated, nothing I particularly liked. For me, a score around 6/6.5 is more than fair.
3
u/dioburhando Sep 16 '19
I already knew about the staff and i admire their works especially the guy that handle re:zero, but i don't like an anime with a cast full of girls :(
2
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
Ok OP I trust you. I'll be giving it 3 episodes.
2
u/YoshiYogurt :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/YoshiYogurt Sep 17 '19
Granblem was a show I was really looking forward to, but it really disappointed.
2
u/manaworkin Sep 16 '19
Yeah, got my fill of magical girl mechas this season with symphogear. Plus there's trashy isekai to watch.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '19
I think we can all agree this is most polarizing anime of the season. The people who hate it absolutely fucking hate it, and the people who love it absolutely fucking love it.
2
u/lamentmyname Sep 16 '19
no its shit im not watching it, deserves that 6 on mal. complete garbage show
2
u/DC_Anime Sep 16 '19
I rated it "Dropped" after a messy first episode with nothing in the way of a hook. Does that count?
1
u/ProudLiterature Sep 17 '19
Happy cake day!
1
u/kaije7 https://anilist.co/user/kaije Sep 18 '19
I have answered the call. I watched ep 1 today going in without even knowing what it was about. I wish it wasn't mecha... anything but mecha... I will attempt to watch more since you said it's a drama first, but mecha is my least favorite sub genre so far.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
I mean, Re:Zero is way overrated. That show is like, at 7 at best.
1
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '19
If it deserved it, it would have the ranking. If week after week it doesn't even make the ratings, then clearly either enough people aren't watching it, or the show is clearly not as amazing as you think it is.
0
u/TheRedSlasH Sep 16 '19
I have granbelm on my radar ever since the season started. Hopefully it doesn‘t disappoint me like KnY or Fireforce did.
Only bugging thing here is you lumping Re:Zero together with greats like S;G and Sora Yori lol.
1
u/mrhades113 https://anilist.co/user/mrhades113 Sep 17 '19
THANK YOU!!!! PEOPLE NEED TO SPEAK UP!! I will not accept this anime being só underrated.
1
u/HestiaXDarkness Sep 16 '19
It was not interesting.
1
u/Kevinlafriday Sep 17 '19
I watched this every week, but unfortunately this series with pink-and-black-haired-girls trope is just not my cup of tea.
I want to like this too, but every week i felt the same way: this show forces too many things to its characters.
1
u/FistedMate Sep 17 '19
lolicon mad
1
u/jonnovision1 Sep 20 '19
Everyone out here ragging on the mecha designs but I just see them as perfect Super Robot Wars fodder since that series already kinda chibifies the mecha represented in it anyways