r/anime • u/Pixelsaber https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pixelsaber • Mar 06 '20
WT! [WT!] Koi Kaze - Entirely Spoiler Free Recomendation
NOTE: This WT! post is tailored for people with absolutely no prior knowledge of the series, and so makes no mention of a plot detail revealed very early on in the series which informs the premise and the rest of the narrative. I would ask those of you familiar with the series and its premise not to mention or discuss it in the comments below unless properly hidden by a spoiler tag.
I had the fortunate experience of experiencing this show absolutely blind, having sought it out solely due to an acquaintance’s high praise for it and not piecing that critical detail together from the few hints appearing in the show. It changes one’s perception of the show before that point, and that’s an experience that I wouldn’t want to rob anyone off, regardless as to how few unspoilt but nonetheless interested viewers there are and the fact there's a significant chance of people realizing it ahead of time. However, I have never been able to find something which I could easily point to as a recommendation without also spoiling the show, and so have resolved to make one myself here, to serve as an extensive recommendation for those in the same position that I was. As a result of these aims I have also chosen not to link to any of the show’s entries in various databases.
For those of you blind readers, do be wary while navigating the comments. I hope that you, in particular, find this post useful.
”It’s like the sun has suddenly tossed into my saddened heart.”
What is Koi Kaze?
Koi Kaze is a romantic drama and character study focused on broaching several topics closely tied to the experiences it's main characters undergo throughout the narrative, the intimate and neutral presentation of which is punctuated with a strong sense of transient beauty. The series was adapted from a seinen manga by Motoi Yoshida (Natsu no Zenjitsu, Mushishi Gaitanshuu), produced at A.C.G.T. Inc. (Kino no Tabi: The Beautiful World, A Certain Scientific Accelerator), directed by Takahiro Ōmori (Samurai Flamenco, Natsume's Book of Friends, Durarara!!) written by Noboru Takagi (Legend of the Galactic Heroes: Die Neue These, Baccano!, Kuroko no Basket) and was broadcast on April 1st 2004 on TV Asahi. The series’ nuanced, realistic, and intimate look at the circumstances and emotions of its main characters, and the relatively impartial perspective the show takes in observing and analyzing these, entirely set it apart from shows of its ilk.
The series also remains the premier example for the handling of certain sordid subject matters in anime, posing a genuinely mature representation of the topic —far removed from the clichéd and idealized manner it is usually broached in anime— and with a strong regard for its connection to the characters’ unique perspectives. The straightforward, direct, and grounded handling of these topics are bound to immediately push some people away from the series, and other viewers might not be able to set aside their distaste and effectively have the experience soured for them. However, the series poses such an excellent showing that it is well worth taking that risk to figure out whether the series suits or not. There’s few anime quite like it, and likely none to go where it has. Koi Kaze is truly a one-of-a-kind experience that remains unrivaled.
Narrative, Writing, and Characterization
Koi Kaze is a slow and contemplative character drama with a keen focus on on its two main characters, Kōshirō Saeki and Nanoka Kohinata, and their respective struggles with interpersonal relationships, affection, repressed desires, self-loathing, and acceptance. Kōshirō is a sensitive, emotional, and awkward man with a tendency to distance himself from others and act abrasively in the face of his insecurities and frustrations, who also grapples with the fact that he has never experienced genuine romantic affection for another. Nanoka, on the other hand, is assertive, slightly naive, and a personable character whose outlook on the matter of love differs. These two main characters are at markedly differing stages of their lives whose personalities and outlooks offer differing perspectives as to the related personal issues they both deal with throughout the series, and the show gives us a very close look at their lives, with specific attention paid to their emotions in the face of new developments and conclusions to extensive pondering alike, laying them bare for us to comprehend and scrutinize. The show very effectively communicates the emotions of its main characters through both contentment and tribulations, deftly making us understand and empathize with these characters while never asserting that they are right or wrong. The characters are also written to convincingly grapple with and act upon the emotions they possess but don’t fully understand, just as a person is likely to, such as fearfully lashing out to others in denial of one’s own feelings, creating distance in order to avoid facing pertinent issues, or desperately clinging unto newfound sensations. By the end of the series one knows Kōshirō and Nanoka like one would know a very close friend; friends whose happiness we are terribly concerned with, but whose desires and actions we might be unwilling to support.
The show possesses a light, comforting atmosphere which easily accommodates itself to different tones and moods as the narrative develops, making for a very pleasant watch. The series will occasionally overstate things using its first-person narration, such as when it has a character tell us of their restlessness when we see him tossing and turning before demonstrating his frustration, or when a character states what can be easily inferred —in the process cutting into the atmosphere and pace of an otherwise perfect scene. These instances are thankfully few, but they are nonetheless annoying to some viewers.
The show isn’t exhaustive in its exploration of its few chief topics, but rather it is thorough in elaborating upon how it affects and relates to the characters in particular, and as such doesn’t take the time to address seemingly obvious topics which might be of interest to the viewer. This approach might be disappointing for some, but given where the series’ strengths and focus lie, it is undeniably the best course for the series to have taken. The presentation of these interesting and complex topics is nonetheless an intricate and compelling exploration which puts the characters under the scope and urges us to come to our own conclusions on the matter —just as the characters settle on theirs. Although the show is very forthright in showcasing the joyful exuberance of the character’s positive experiences, it does not falter in —nor diminish— its emotional depictions of less pleasant topics either. It does not seek to cause discomfort or inciting feelings of distaste in the viewer by exploring these unappealing aspects that are of relevance to the narrative, but is nonetheless unafraid of doing so as it dives into some of its stigmatic narrative developments.
While the characterization for our main characters is nothing short of amazing, the side cast is nowhere near as fleshed out. This is not really an issue, since their screen time and narrative relevance is largely proportional to the depth of their characterization, and they all accomplish an important and necessary purpose of the narrative. These side characters range from mere caricatures like Kōshirō’s oft-humorous father and his perverted coworker which meant to reinforce aspects of his emotional turmoil and character arc; background fixtures such as Nanoka’s friends, who exist to bounce off her thoughts with; and a couple well-rounded characters that prove intriguing on their own merit while serving as significant influences on the main characters as well as mouthpieces for opposing thoughts.
Audiovisuals
The visuals in Koi Kaze accomplish their goal of heightening the narrative impact, complementing the series’ mood and succinctly communicating to us some subtler elements as to the characters, narrative, and themes. Art director Tsutomu Nishikura (The Heroic Legend of Arslan OAV, Gunslinger Girl: Il Teatrino) evidently understood the narrative’s texture and sought to accurately recreate it with the visuals. The subdued colors palette and understated watercolor backgrounds are an excellent fit for the tone of the narrative and steeps everything in a sense of everyday mundanity that is very befitting of the plodding and grounded nature of the series. The series has a few idiosyncrasies in its visuals —such as the decision to display the inside of character’s mouths as blank— which might rove distracting at first, but they’re things which one becomes accustomed easily enough. The characters designs by Takahiro Kishida (Serial Experiments Lain, Haikyu!!, Puella Magi Madoka Magica) are fairly faithful to those in the manga, and appear appropriately understated, soft, and capable of great expressiveness.
The animation quality is adequate, as the character animation pulls its weight in convincingly bringing the characters to life, but it does not excel with it, as there is plenty of space for more intricate depictions of body language and smoother movements. There are even instances of shots that appear as if they are unfinished, as well as some repeated shots, but both of these are rare enough to be of little to no adverse impact, and the latter are all used cleverly in appropriate places. The voice acting for dialogue was pre-recorded, which makes animation during dialogue appreciably more natural, though this also has the side-effect of making the scenes where id doesn’t line up perfectly stand out harshly. The area where the visuals impress the most is likely to be in its overall scene compositions, which use a rather gentle touch to help communicate feelings such as awe, fear, and pain wordlessly —though oftentimes accompanied by dialogue regardless— resulting in softly evocative images as well as choice moments of striking beauty.
Dialogue is also handled exceedingly well, not only sounding fairly natural but also paced expertly, unafraid to let moments of contemplation or pregnant pauses do all the necessary speaking. Along those lines, the series’ sound direction is also exemplary, with the big exception being that the soundtrack composed by Masanori Takumi (Genshiken, Claymore) and Makoto Yoshimori (Durarara!!, Princess Jellyfish, Natsume's Book of Friends), while being a perfect fit for the series, sees several of its tracks repeated to a distracting extent throughout the series’ modest thirteen episode length.
Koi Kaze is a show without equal, specifically in that no show has tackled the same subjects with such care, respect, and scrutiny in equal measure. It’s uniqueness poses a strong point of appeal, but is far from the only asset to its name, as its character-driven narrative is incredibly compelling, entertaining, and entirely engrossing. It is an unforgettable experience, not suited for everybody, but likely to stick forever with those who it does suit.
”My heart hesitates and hits the brakes on this feeling, but I feel pain and can’t breathe. ”
Information
Episode Count: 13
Genre Tags: Drama, Romance, Seinen,
Aired from: April 2nd, 2004 to June 18th, 2004
Studio: A.C.G.T.
Source: Manga by Motoi Yoshida
Availability
The show is sadly unavailable for online streaming. There was a physical release by Geneon Entertainment in 2005, however it has been out of print for a while, and so might be difficult to get ahold of.
35
u/bagglewaggle Mar 06 '20
When you mentioned you had a WT! in the works, I expected some 80s dark horse, likely a mecha.
I did not expect one of my top-tier shows, and I certainly didn't expect a recommendation that avoids a major spoiler for the work.
Unless you've seen Koi Kaze and know what Pixel is avoiding saying, it is very difficult to understand just how well-written this WT! is, and how daunting a project it was from the get-go.
The passion for the blind experience is clear, as is the time and effort that went into writing and editing, but even above all that, the choice to write a WT! from something outside of your comfort zone, and write it with a constricting stipulation, makes me respect and appreciate Pixel's writing even more.
18
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
I actually find people being disgusted by Koi Kaze's main theme funny.
It's in a lot of Western media and no one seems to care. It's in anime, then a lot of people are calling it pretentious, disgusting, immoral etc.
Where is the line? It's al fictional in any case. I thought it was a pretty decent romance, despite the themes. The manga is also a bit different, so if you found the anime interesting, you should read the manga.
8
u/mattamj Apr 02 '20
You've got me. Time to sail the high seas then.
[edit] also going 100% blind - so i'll be back to this discussion later as I don't want to risk ANYTHING coming up in the comments.
7
u/alfaindomart Mar 07 '20
I watched it because it's directed by one of my favorite director and his teams. It's been so long since i watch a rather old anime but this one totally caught me off guard. I didn't expect a rather unknown series with a controversial theme to be handled with such care. They really deliver each scenes, from slow and relaxing to anger. I really hope for similar anime in the future, but with how censorship is on the rise, I'm pessimistic.
I don't find the soundtrack to be repetitive, but it might be that I'm already used to how the director use the soundtrack (particularly from Yoshimori Makoto) in many of anime he directed.
I read the manga after watching it. There are some contents that are cut from the anime but they're not that essential so the anime still nail the overall result imo.
7
u/PocketCharacter Apr 03 '20
This show is one of few that aims to really ask you to question your prejudices and beliefs and for that I have nothing but love for this show.
Thanks for bringing this show some much needed attention!
5
u/ArCSelkie37 Mar 07 '20 edited Mar 07 '20
I managed to get a limited edition Koi Kaze pretty cheap on Ebay thankfully. God it was worth.
I certainly agree it is super hard to recommend this show without either partially spoiling it or putting people off because of the themes. But it is super good.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 07 '20
Great writeup. That sounds straight up my alley, will definitely check it out!
5
u/JimJamTheNinJin Apr 01 '20
You've convinced me, I'm downloading it.
4
u/fauceeet Apr 02 '20
Well written and thought out. I applaud your work!
4
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '20
This is one of my favorite series. It's such a roller coaster. Well done on the WT!
3
u/NecDW4 Apr 04 '20
God, I remember finding an unopened LE box of the first volume randomly in an FYE almost 10 years ago, and i THINK volume 2 as well. Had a hell of a time finding a new copy of 3, took almost a month combing Amazon and Ebay. Totally glad i did it tho, the anime and manga were great.
5
u/EpicTroll27 :AMQ:https://anilist.co/user/EpicTroll4236 Mar 07 '20
Hey /u/Pixelsaber! Thank you for writing this WT! thread. As an admin of the WT! project, I leave feedback on all WT! threads in order to commend writers for their hard work and provide constructive criticism to help them improve their writing skills for future threads.
I can see how different your approach to selling Koi Kaze is compared to the various robot anime you write threads for. Many of them tend to feel same-y, often having the same structure and similar flaws mentioned. Specifically, when you write about flawed anime, there needs to be something that sets them apart from others of their ilk and this thread conveys that about Koi Kaze very well. There's a good balance between being concise and thorough. It's just a really well thought-out description of all the show's various strengths while also keeping in mind its status as somewhat of an acquired taste. The audiovisuals section is a welcome addition to the essay as it draws parallels between the staff's previous works quite well. As others have mentioned, the opening note is rather distracting and smaller headers would have gotten the point across just as well. Highlighting the 'critical detail' that you must absolutely avoid learning about also leads to more morbid curiosity than anything so I question the fixation on it in the opening section. Regardless, it's very difficult to not spoil critical details about the show especially when those details may often make up a significant part of its appeal. I can't know what this essay would look like had you discussed that part of the show but I do know that the write-up we have now is a particularly good one.
If you want feedback for any future threads you're writing or just help in general, feel free to send a PM my way!
2
u/[deleted] Apr 05 '20 edited Feb 07 '25
upbeat chubby flag squeeze one disarm versed tan whistle bells
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
2
u/[deleted] Apr 09 '20
Wow, the one word you could've used to describe the entire series and you just don't. Genius.
2
u/obnoxious_comments Apr 15 '20
WT! inspired me to rewatch. Man, this show does so many things well. As someone who normally feels pretty emotionally devoid/uninvested in a lot of shows that I watch, this one is a huge change of pace. Big nostalgia feelings. 100% would recommend.
2
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '20
What is a WT?
6
u/demoran https://anilist.co/user/demoran23 Mar 06 '20
I rec Koi Kaze frequently. One of my 10s.
After reflection, I've come to view Saeki Koushirou as a heroic figure.
5
u/Durinthal https://anilist.co/user/Durinthal Mar 06 '20
The only show with its theme that I respect for how it approaches the topic, and likely worth a revisit some day when I'm in the mood for it.
5
u/Btw_kek https://myanimelist.net/profile/kek_btw Mar 07 '20
I have to give a shoutout to the OST for being legitimately one of my favorites. It's true there's a lot of repetition but I don't see it as a problem at all, especially when the biggest "offender" is exceptionally gorgeous in all of its simplicity. Every dissonance is laid bare, which is what makes it sound so fragile and intimate. There is perhaps no better way to musically set the atmosphere for the romance in show.
4
u/youkai94 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/youkai94 Apr 07 '20
Watched it a while ago, it was definitely worth it. The visuals are dated but still pretty decent. It did a really good at showing how dangerous social stigma can be and actually made me think a lot how they really didn't want any of that, it just happened.
Koshiro may feel a little hateful at times but it's understandable considering the situation. Definitely watch it if you have spare time, it's worth it.
That said, there is one thing that really triggered me a lot Koi Kaze minor spoilers.
3
u/sickvisionz Apr 10 '20 edited Apr 11 '20
Crunchyroll or Right Stuf was doing a grab bag of anime DVDs and vol 1 of this came in mine. I was super into romance anime at the time and this looked like a romance anime so I checked out it. And ended up grabbing the rest of it. The content is what it is, but I thought they did it really well and handled it maturely. Detractors would probably try to spin it like it's some fanservicey ecchi take on the content but it's really nothing like that at all. Koi Kaze is to its subject matter as Aoi Hana is to yuri or Wandering Sun is to BL and all the other things it encompasses imo. If you're looking for an ecchi take on it, you'll be thoroughly disappointed in it what's presented to you.
I think what sets it apart is that it takes place in a world where the main character feels bad about it and when people find out about it, they're appalled as well. There's like zero titillation or hell yeah, fanservice time in it all, which goes a long way to making it palatable for those willing to give it a shot imo.
I think it's a really great show but it can be kinda tough to recommend outside of the more accepting parts of the anime world. I'd probably never bring it up to someone unless I knew they were really deep down the anime rabbit hole. Especially for me because in real life my Dad waited until I was 14 to have another kid so advocating for the series could draw questionable looks.
1
u/Varrick2016 Apr 27 '20
I remember seeing Koi Kaze in the early 2000's. I remember crying because of how beautifully and delicately it was done given the subject matter. That final shot of the heart on the tree broke me down completely. Was there ever a bluray release?
2
u/aleaallee Apr 15 '20
This anime didn't gross me out, in fact, I liked it a lot, I also liked Aki Sora, Yosuga no Sora and Kiss x Sis.
1
u/aleaallee Apr 29 '20
I loved this anime, even though I find incest taboo irl, watching in anime and eroges is ok and even turns me on because it's "forbidden".
0
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 06 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment