r/anime • u/stetstet • Mar 12 '20
WT! [Comic Girls] Sorry I have to recommend this
Sorry about the title, but recommending this show to anyone I don't know marks my last day as a conscientious human being. But I will shortly gain a sub-human status("a Korean Male Soldier") anyways, so why not.
If you watched the final episode of Neon Genesis Evangelion TVAs, you will remember that particular scene in the last episode. With some planet in the background and a lot of people clapping.
My guess is that, to the director of Eva, the whole show was a tool to provide the grounds for comprehending the final episode, which exists to be resolved as shown in the scene.
One day, the staff of a Kirara slice-of-life anime decide to make their own version of that scene. They carefully place breadcrumbs everywhere, and utilize your average kirara-slice-of-life clichès to hide everything under the veil, pretend everything is bright and cute, while our protagonist slowly dies inside.
Moeta Kaoruko, our heroine, is a good-for nothing. She is also an manga artist, submitting storyboards under the pseudonym Kaos. The premise that "Kaos wants to be a manga artist" never shakes once. But...will she be able to stay as one?
Quite weird for an anime like this, right? Name one cute/moe slice-of-life anime where the protagonist is constantly on the verge of being rendered incapable of becoming what she wants to be.
Kaos is intended as an incarnation of the average viewer.
Don't be fooled by the cover. The settings are hardly cute. As the anime progresses our protagonist continues to die inside, constantly questioning her worth. Have you not seen this kind of setting somewhere? For example....in your life?
Not everyone can be as talented as Aoba(New game!). Not everyone can be enrolled in Keio U. and make a game with vanilla C++, like Nenecchi(New game!) does. Not everyone is a prodigy like Umaru. And you not being a prodigy is hardly your fault. You've tried hard in some point of your life. Trying, learning, doing things. But there are bound to be people who are able to run faster than you. And then you question your self-worth, or let go of it all.
Kaos constantly self-deprecates, whines, asks for help, and is quick to do a dogeza. But you can't help but cheer for her. The girl is a fighter; she constantly questions her self-worth, but she never actually quits. She grips and hangs from a cliff until she is finally cornered. You, at least in some timespan, looked so much like her. You can't help but sympathize.
Comic Girls does a fine job of consoling modern-day humans, we who strive but can never be prodigies.
Or...Alternatively, a viewer may come back to reality, only to find that Kaos is an extremely happy individual, because she actually has people around her, and you are beyond salvation. (Remember how I mentioned my conscience above. I am really sorry if this is the case.)
2
u/MapoTofuMan myanimelist.net/profile/mTmTBaronBrixius Mar 13 '20
Seconding the recommendation, Comic Girls ended up becoming my runner-up of the season back when it aired. It didn't do anything special at first, but somehow the characters grew on me much more than your average CGDCT and I was crying right with them in the last episode
Also good luck in the miltary, I hope you meet some fellow weebs to keep you sane!
2
u/EpicTroll27 :AMQ:https://anilist.co/user/EpicTroll4236 Mar 14 '20
Hey /u/stetstet! Thank you for writing this WT! thread. As an admin of the WT! project, I leave feedback on all WT! threads in order to commend writers for their hard work and provide constructive criticism to help them improve their writing skills for future threads.
I was very confused by this thread, mostly because I had a hard time reconciling the Comic Girls I watched to the one you're describing. It's a bizarre recommendation to say the least and some sentences feel really out of place. I do get the point you're making about Comic Girls but the wording and structure could really use some work. For example, the only point you make about the show is that it's true to life and that Kaos is an audience surrogate while there's plenty of other aspects of the show you could talk about as well. The point about Kaos being relatable could also be more fleshed out (how her being relatable makes the show good for instance) but a major problem with the essay is poor grammar/sentence structure. As with all such cases, I recommend getting a proofreader to look over your writing before you submit it. Overall...not a submission I'm positive on but that doesn't mean you should stop trying since there's plenty of room for improvement.
If you want feedback for any future threads you're writing or just help in general, feel free to send a PM my way!
16
u/Overwhealming Mar 12 '20
Comic Girls got into my personal hall of fame of modern CGDCT shows along with Slow Start due to it's poignant message about life failures and trying to cope with them
13
u/saido_chesto Mar 12 '20
abababababababa
Please buy Kaos' manga
1
u/SmoothButtocks Mar 13 '20
Sorry, but I dub thee an honourary Canadian.
-A Canadian
3
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '20
No idea what you said, but seeing as it involves Comic Girls, i will ask the same question for anyone who reads this comment when it aired:
Anybody know the name of the orchestra piece that plays when kaos go to tsubasa's home for christmas(ep10?)? Its the same one played in Chio-chan during the motorcycle episode(ep2/3?).
-6
u/AutoModerator Mar 12 '20
Hi stetstet, it seems like you might be looking for anime recommendations! I have changed the flair on your post to indicate that, but if I'm wrong, feel free to change it back!
The users of this subreddit came up with an awesome recommendations flowchart. Maybe you can find something there that you'll like ^.^
You might also find our Recommendation Wiki or Weekly Recommendation Thread helpful.
The following may be of interest:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.