r/anime • • Mar 30 '20
WT! If you haven't seen "Planetes" give it a go. I will tell you why it is worth a shot without spoiling it.
Damn it.
Just give it a shot because this is one of the most amazing series that I have watched through my 10 years career of watching anime. I want to write this recommendation in the most objective sense that it is possible so, I will try not to include personal feelings or taste to this show. (if possible)
First of all, anime is an art form for me. The same as movies or theatre itself. There are good and bad shows and it doesn't matter if you like one or hate another, but the good show is the one who can portray the reality and make protagonists deal with an actual problem in the most sensible way that it is possible. It must be natural and real, not in the sense of reality itself, but in the sense of sensibility. Do not misunderstand me, any genre can portray what I talked about, it just the matter of how creator deals with the cards that he's been given.
Characters:
There are so many characters in this show, but every each one of them feels unique and polished. They have their own different goals, values, dreams that make them pretty much - distinctive, which is pretty rare to find in a lot of shows. I am sure that the other shows has it too, but they tend to forget about this distinctive quality. All of the characters have a natural progress and the way how they deal with their each own problem makes them connected in some sort of sense. Each character has a great development that we can see throughout 26 episodes. They fully progress to the point that it feels just satisfying watching the end of the show.
Plot/Ideas:
There will be no spoilers, but I have to tell you about this sensibility/reality that I talked before. The plot progressed naturally and characters responded to it sensibly as it should be. One of the important things that the ideas have not been lost in the middle of the show, but they were relevant in each episode till the very end. The second thing is that the people choices were "real" in the presence of given ideas and story itself. It makes the show interesting with unexpected out comings and feeling that maybe you would have chosen the same action. You start to relate with the events and people in the show so it makes it enjoyable and even beneficial. They stayed truthful to the existing ideas in this show.
I just love how David Lynch talks about ideas, "The ideas dictate everything, you have to be true to that or you're dead."
Pacing:
I like to think of it as a time given to the world building and characters. It was nearly perfect. It felt that there is no redudant episodes. It was the time given to explore each value of his own, the connection between the ideas and world building.
Problems:
I do not want to repeat myself and just use "reality" at any moment given, but the problems were actually relatable to our surroundings and it showed how human can perceive it and try to deal with it in the way that they were built. Even more important thing is that each problem had logical consequences which is a must to make us feel connected.
Animation:
I guess it is more of a personal taste, but it is fluid and portrays the emotions well. It is more than enough for me.Stealing a great sentence about designs: Designs are an important factor as well because they are chunky, drab and not aesthetically pleasing—which is exactly how real-life designs look.
Overall:
As I said, this is a good show. For me it means that this is beneficial for you. You can catch yourself at times when you make an attempt to perceive this show through your heart and mind. It is rare to find such gems, but here you are.
I rate it 4/5 I want to give it 5/5, but I do not think it holds the title of "masterpiece". I do not know if any show holds it.
P.S. "from space you don't see any lines separating countries, so why can't we all be together"
Important note by one fellow redditor:
It's from the same author as Vinland Saga, Makoto Yukimura.
48
u/CpnLag Mar 30 '20
I think the best endorsement for the show I can give is this:
17
u/gangrainette https://myanimelist.net/profile/bouletos Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20
To help sell this anime you can say that it's from the same author as Vinland Saga now that they both have an anime :
https://myanimelist.net/people/2034/Makoto_Yukimura
edit : I love the format of the french integral edition : https://imgur.com/a/YCaMS80
7
u/noka237 Mar 30 '20
Love Planetes really solidified my love for anime. Claire Rondo is actually one of my favourite characters ever because of how complex her character is.
6
u/Jhin-Row :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/wherewild Mar 30 '20
i really want an astronaut to do a review of planetes and see how well they got the science and social aspects right while in space.
5
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
I love this series. Just finished it yesterday.
4
u/Dark_Shit Mar 30 '20 edited Mar 30 '20
It was kinda hard to get through the episodic episodes. I usually watch 2-5 episodes pet sitting but with Planetes I was maybe watching 2 per week. I didn't drop it completely because I love space stuff and some of the early episodes were pretty good.
Once the show actually starts moving a bit, I was totally into it. I basically binged the entire second half over 2 days.
I was actually pretty conflicted with the ethics and motives of the terrorist group. I wanted to root for them but they were a bit too eager to gun down innocent bystanders. I wish they showed us more of the exploited 3rd world countries so we could see how badly they've been fucked.
Their struggle was such a radical contrast to the wacky, lighthearted antics from the earlier episodes. I think the drastic shift works well. And of course the relationship between Tanabe and Hachimaki is what really kept me invested.
Overall I was blown away by the 2nd half of the show and I would definitley recommend it
3
u/garthvater111 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Garthvater Mar 30 '20
The bot changed your flair to recommendation, i think this should be a wt thread tho
I dont have much on my ptw list that isn't fantasy, so this sounds like a spicy change of pace :)
3
u/carrotface40 Mar 30 '20
Can you send me your MAL if you have one? I really like your review and wanna see what else you rate highly!
3
u/FaceOfTheMtDan Mar 30 '20
Interestingly enough, I started watching it last week, after being on my PTW for years and it's a lot better than I thought.
4
u/banditta82 https://anidb.net/user/222784 Mar 30 '20
It is one of the few shows that I would say to watch the show and skip the Manga that it was based on. The show makes many changes and all of them for the better
2
u/skippityoo1 Mar 30 '20
while it's from the same author as vinland saga, it's important to note that the anime is different than the manga created by him
3
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
Where can I watch it?
3
u/PainStorm14 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Gekkostate14 Mar 31 '20
Planetes is without a doubt the best anime I have ever seen
I doubt anything will ever be able to match it
Sci-fi, slice of life, romance, comedy, drama, adventure, music, animation it has absolutely everything
Ending is one of most beautiful things I have ever experienced
2
u/EpicTroll27 :AMQ:https://anilist.co/user/EpicTroll4236 Apr 02 '20
Hey /u/Dozeris! Thank you for writing this WT! thread. As an admin of the WT! project, I leave feedback on all WT! threads in order to commend writers for their hard work and provide constructive criticism to help them improve their writing skills for future threads.
While it's a short and succint recommendation, it relies too much on the show's portrayal of reality. So much in fact that it's the singular aspect that you discuss throughout the write-up without many examples of what exactly makes it so real. I would advise picking multiple aspects of a show to tackle and expand upon and finding examples to support your argument. Even just elaborating upon those aspects can do wonders. I also advise getting someone to proofread your work since it has quite a few grammar issues/errors.
If you want feedback for any future threads you're writing or just help in general, feel free to send a PM my way!
1
u/SmayGB :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smay21 Apr 01 '20
When does it start? I've been wanting to give it a shot for some time now. And this is the perfect moment
1
u/AutoModerator Mar 30 '20
Hi Dozeris, it seems like you might be looking for anime recommendations! I have changed the flair on your post to indicate that, but if I'm wrong, feel free to change it back!
The users of this subreddit came up with an awesome recommendations flowchart. Maybe you can find something there that you'll like ^.^
You might also find our Recommendation Wiki or Weekly Recommendation Thread helpful.
The following may be of interest:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
-12
u/9hokagefanboi :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/nofanserviceplss Mar 30 '20
nah i hate scifi/space shit
0
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment
-1
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '20
[removed] — view removed comment