r/anime • • Oct 17 '20
Watch This! [WT!} Why Hai to Gensou no Grimgar is highly underrated and why you should watch it!
Rating Website
Grimgar’s MAL: https://myanimelist.net/anime/31859/Hai_to_Gensou_no_Grimgar
Grimgar’s Anilist: https://anilist.co/anime/21428/Hai-to-Gensou-no-Grimgar
Why People Don't Get Grimgar
The three main pillars of a story are: Plot, Character, Theme. Different stories revolve around different pillars, that's why you might have heard of terms like "plot-driven" and "character-driven" stories. Grimgar is not a plot-driven story, it does take the plot into a direction we rarely see in isekai but it doesn't make you go "Holy Shit! I can't believe that happened.". Instead, its narrative highly revolves around its themes and characters. So audience should experience and critique the story for what it's aiming for, instead of what you crave for.
Typical isekai-fans watching Grimgar, expecting another hype/harem story will completely overlook what Grimgar is about. Isekai-haters whose hatred are based on popular Youtube opinions will watch with the intend to hate the show, which ultimately leads to subjective criticisms. As a rule of thumb, I believe viewers should never generalize any genre and build their own opinion rationally on each story. Finally, for Isekai-haters who knows what separates good from bad writing and have seen so many trash isekais they doubt Grimgar is going to be any good, I'll give my best shot on convincing you that Grimgar is a gem among isekais.
Relatable and Practical Themes
As I said above, Grimgar are one of the rare animes in the whole medium that consciously aim to share a positive message for society. The story parallel its "another world" nature premise with young adults taking their first breath out in the uncertain world called adulthood. (I've never seen any isekai done this before)
The first episodes before any dramatic story beat happened illustrates how the characters struggle at work, financial stability and shortage of essential sheltering needs, something most people will probably relate to and experience once in their life. Later on in the second and third arc, more themes are explored. And to avoid any spoilers, I'll leave one essential theme out and only share that the story sets an example of how human can learn to be a leader through attempting and improving at thinking outside of one self, observation, empathy and communication. All of these are lessons essential to workers who have to work with other human in their career! Even if you're not working yet, I'm sure you've experience once or twice, maybe too much, of the pain known as "group project" in high school or college.
Also, this only work because the anime has a certain amount of realistic psychology for its characters so it's highly going to be applicable in real life. As an example of how this anime really can affect people, me myself has started and try work with other people at school even though I'm an introverted geek.
Humanizing Characters
First, when you think of characters, most people think of intriguing characters who either has an extreme backstory or is force to make a choice in a morally complex dilemma as "good character". But that isn't the only way to build characters!
In Grimgar, the narrative aims to increase character-audience relationship by showing as many "human" sides of the characters as possible for audience to relate to and bond with them. We get to see all of the characters social interactions ability (body language, open or closed posture, distance etc.), reaction tendencies to certain situations, hobbies, fears, desires and so on. Dialogs are written as realistic as possible while still maintain its comedic and emotional values. Sometimes characters say things vaguely, hinting at what they want to say between the lines instead of being fully aware of each and every single words their idea wanted to communicate. I'm sure this happen to you before, those time when you can't seem to deliver what you wanted to say when emotion is put into the equation. However, this reading between lines style of dialogs is different and easier to understand than Oregairu.
I addressed previously that this anime taken realistic psychology into account, from 1-10 with 1 being "cartoonish" and 10 being "realistic", I'd say Grimgar stays somewhere at 8.8. There are still characters traits that is slightly cartoonish like, "shy", "goofy", "energetically selfish", "soft", "average", "cold" and "caring" but you can also see this in real life so it's much more realistic than let's say "full blown chuunibyou", "cat girl" and "2D obsessed otaku" (not that any of these comedic traits are bad, these types of characters are meant for different story, like Steins;Gate likable over-the-top cast for example).
Realism and Fight Choreography
The fight sequence of this anime taken anatomy into account, of course when the magic power level increase and become more relevant to the story, this slowly fade away, but never vanish. For instance, when you swing a sword into the ribcage of a living being, you're not simply slashing the thing in half like cutting fruit. You have to cut through the skin, tendon, muscles, bone, organs of that organism so it's impossible to have those flashy and gory fights like in other "action" and "realistic" animes.
The show also taken adrenaline, multi-individual combat coordination, lack of neurological efficiency and experience into account when it comes to combat. Yes, you read correctly, exposition is not stated directly through dialogs but rather shown in combat, it's a big win! People who have never work with each other before cannot rush in and fight one enemy with their swords and not harm each other. People who have never fight their whole life with their body force to adapt to a new environment will take time to adjust, imagine yourself swinging a sword, how powerful is it without any training? Creatures who have live hunting and killing their whole life are more efficient at excreting adrenaline, making them have those moments of resistance to survive even when they're wounded multiple times. Adrenaline are also seen in human characters as they become unconscious of how tight they're gripping a certain weapon when the tension of the fight become high. The fight scene aren't flashy, but it tells the audience a lot about the characters, the settings or the enemy they're facing.
Gorgeous Art, Movie Level Cinematography and Animation, Fun and Creative Soundtrack
The artistic effort put in this show is unbelieveable, this unique art style make the shows stand out among other isekais. Just google "Grimgar art styte" and see for yourself, you'll not think that they'll keep this style consistent through out the show but they actually do.
The expositional arts aren’t just there to look pretty, each scene really tell us about the ecology, geography and society of Grimgar and how they interconnected with each other. What animal replaces horses in this geography? How do people design their houses based on the geography of their settlement? What gods do they worship and how does it affect their architectural design? Watch actively and you’ll find yourself more invested in the world of Grimgar
If you pay attention to the animation for communication, one of the central theme, they really pays great details to it. Characters do communicate with non-verbal language since they not only have their dialect, they also have their own body language while talking, open or closed posture, etc.
The soundtrack makes the experience even better! (K)noW_NAME really play around with all types of instrument and styles, making the audience engage to anticipate what music they're offering next. Different songs use different style: solo-acoustics guitar, solo-piano, energetic drums and keyboard, piano and violin, piano and saxophone, cello and violin, vocals and even beatbox with rapping. If you're looking for music to add to your spotify playlist, I'll highly recommend Grimgar Original Soundtrack.
16
u/Webfat Oct 17 '20
Grimgar was the first novel I read and I think you nailed. For me what makes me like in the begining was the combat, how the whole coreografy was not about "wow that guy kill the enemy with a finger" but more like coordination and intuition, everyone in the party have a vital role in the combat and that makes tense and exciting. People who likes MMORPGs like FF14 and WOW will like this anime for the combat alone.
Afte that was see the struggles of the MC in becoming a leader, I think everything his think about group coordination and his anxious about been a good leader is so relatable that sometimes I think Grimgar is a Isekai simulator.
10
u/Ry-O-Ken Oct 17 '20
I disagree with your opinion on the animation being “cinematic” because while it did start out pretty good (weighty and clumsy movements in the goblin fights to show how realistic humans with no combat experience would fight), it pretty much gets worse later on (an unfortunate consequence of the production pretty much falling apart later on).
That being said, I agree with pretty much everything else. I think it’s a very underrated anime and the people who call it slow and boring pretty much miss the whole point of the first season. The director’s intention was to have “death and grief over a loved one” and imo he mostly succeeded in doing so. People don’t just quickly get over the death of a friend, the healing process takes time, and the director made sure of this by writing the script for the whole show to have the first volume(well technically it adapts the first 2 iirc) be the main focus of the series. That aside, I feel like the author’s intention to have a realistic portrayal of humans in another world with no combat experience was also executed well enough. Another highlight for me was the background art, which IMO added to the fantastical but lived in feel of the setting. The OST was also great and the insert songs were among the many highlights in the show. Overall great show that unfortunately seems unlikely to get a second season. I’ll give the LN a read eventually.
4
u/[deleted] Oct 17 '20
I somewhat liked anime, it was indeed masterfully done adaptation, but after reading the novels my opinion of this series is pretty low. It's only gimmick is being a misery porn. The author has very little idea on how to engage the reader or where this story is going and the result is well... pretty bland. Being different is not enough, you need to be able to tell an interesting story. Not surprised people didn't get it since anime has some of the same issues only on smaller scale.
2
u/Segaco https://myanimelist.net/profile/Segaco Oct 18 '20
I think linking the MAL/Anilist page would help get more people
2
u/muratamurata Oct 28 '20
One of the reasons why i don't read Grimgar light novels is because it is a very depressing/tragic isekai.
If you like Angel beats, Anohana, Clannad, then you would definitely enjoy reading Grimgar.
Most fans love isekai animes/novels with upbeat happy tone or action pack story.
The story of Grimgar is not upbeat or action packed and as the story in the light novel series goes on, the story becomes more sadder and sadder.
39
u/Neville_Lynwood Oct 17 '20
Yeah, it's pretty good.
Definitely worth a watch. Grittier than your average isekai, more emotional, feels more real. Art style is interesting for sure.
20
u/joselrl Oct 17 '20
Yeah, definitely underrated. And for that reason I hate that I may never get a second season... It was different than other isekais, no one felt quite the same yet
3
u/SpaceMarine_CR Oct 17 '20 edited Oct 17 '20
The only thing I didnt like about the anime was the "dead time" in the episodes where nothing happened, not dialogue not exposition, I mean actually nothing
1
u/aTrustfulFriend Oct 18 '20
The animation is pretty average. The premise we've already seen a dozen or so times before. Characters are one-note. Backgrounds aren't very well done. I can't even remember what the music was like. I dropped it after 3 episodes.
3
u/Revolyze Oct 17 '20
There are some shows that are really good to watch before going to bed, like Mushishi, and this. They're still interesting shows, but they also help you wind down. Highly recommend. I've been using it to study Japanese as well, currently on the 9th book.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '20
I reeeally hated this one. I started it with my boyfriend, but deopped it and he ended up finishing it. I watched a few clips and scenes whenever he had it on, but I really didn't think the character dynamic worked at all. Felt so forced and fake?? The idea was good, the art was awesome, but the characters and plot were so lame
2
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '20
I liked it which it would beat a season 2
1
u/AutoModerator Oct 17 '20
Hi Mikeng_0106, it seems like you might be looking for anime recommendations! I have changed the flair on your post to indicate that, but if I'm wrong, feel free to change it back!
The users of this subreddit came up with an awesome recommendations flowchart. Maybe you can find something there that you'll like ^.^
You might also find our Recommendation Wiki or Weekly Recommendation Thread helpful.
The following may be of interest:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/multixrush Oct 18 '20
I loved this anime during its season, but its pacing was just too slow for me. artwork, animation, overall story was good.
It had potential, but they moved the story too slowly, otherwise it would be more memorable.
Too much setting up the background, till it forgot to give us the punchline.
0
u/[deleted] Oct 18 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment