r/anime • u/chaosof99 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/chaosof99 • Feb 20 '21
Watch This! Hyouka - KyoAni's reluctant detective show
I've just finished watching Hyouka, the 2012 series by Kyoto Animation. While I knew about the series when it aired, I only really knew two things about it: The studio and that it had a cute girl in it. That alone didn't appeal to me so I left it by the wayside at the time, getting around to it eventually. However, the more of KyoAni I watch, the more they impress me and this is certainly a high quality show as well.
Based on a novel from 2001, the show's central character is actually the rather lazy, grumpy, and disinterested Houtarou Oreki, a first-year high school student in a rather big school with more than a thousand students and over fourty clubs. He is asked by his sister to join the forgotten "Classics Club" so it won't be disbanded due to a lack of members. There he meets the energetic if a little bit ditzy Eru Chitanda, the above mentioned cute girl, who joins the club due to her uncle having been a member some fourty-odd years ago. Her enthusiastic persona taking interest in various small mysteries is the impetus that manages to get Houtarou to also engage in them, unwillingly so. The Club is further rounded out by Houtarou's best friend, Satoshi Fukube, and their female friend from middle school Mayaka Ibara, who has a romantic interest in Fukube but doesn't like Houtarou very much.
The primary focus of the series are the mysteries. They are not of a supernatural nature, and they are very well set up and paid off, often with several additional layers to them that take their time in unfolding, but are better for doing so. I particularly found the second major arc in which the Classics Club is asked to review suggestions for the ending of an amateur horror film made by a class a grade above them very interesting, especially the twist presented to the scenario itself that only shows itself later in the story but makes perfect sense looking back.
Secondarily the show lives off of the character dynamics, which are quite entertaining, if initially a bit cliched as it does heavily borrow from the manic-pixie-dream-girl archetype, but Eru's distinct disregard for personal space is also very funny. At times it did feel a bit same-y to have Houtarou be ultimately the guy to find the solution to the mysteries when there is a supporting cast whose contributions to the resolution are often a bit overshadowed. However, unlike shows with a similar setup, this part is actually also adressed from a viewpoint of some of the other characters inside the show, and the rest of the cast also gets some good spots that deal with their personal interests, opinions and characteristics as well.
From a technical standpoint it is of course high quality, as is to be expected from KyoAni. The colors are crisp, particularly for specific scenes which are drenched in specific aesthetics to convey certain emotional states. The character animation is also well done, though it does have the rather familiar KyoAni-design for the characters they employ when there is no pre-existing template to work off of. It is also present in shows like Hibike! Euphonium or Tamako Market, and while it is well suited, it also isn't a mark of distinction. There aren't any big action scenes or complex mechanical things to animate, but I very much liked the more esoteric animation segments used for flashbacks, theorycrafting and explanations. Unfortunately these segments are absent for a large chunk of the middle of the series.
The show is als a bit oddly structured. The bulk of the twenty-two episodes consists of three major arcs that span several episodes, while the rest are smaller, self-contained stories that take only a single episode. However, due to the dates at which they are set, and the show following a chronological order, the last couple of episodes are these smaller stories instead of a major arc, which I found to be a strange choice. It isn't anything that devalues the series, but it does feel like the show ends with more of a hodgepodge of things than a grand finale. There is also an additional OVA episode set in the middle of the series for a total of twenty-three episodes.
The only real negative I can say about this show is that the first Ending credits sequence, featuring Eru and Mayaka in nightwear lazing on a big bed, feels rather gratuitous and really doesn't fit with the presentation of the rest of the show. It does skip endings and openings quite often though, and the second Ending is much more entertaining.
If you are in for a good mystery series, or even if you aren't, this is definitely something you should pick up if you haven't seen it yet.
6
u/zptc Feb 20 '21
Wrong. There are two cute girls in it.
I would also debate the idea that mysteries are the focus and character dynamics are secondary. I feel the characters, their development, and the evolution of their relationships is at least as important as the mysteries. Hyokua is about mysteries the way K-On is about playing music.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
I'm glad you enjoyed it, though I disagree with a lot of your statements.
First and foremost, I would definitely not say Hyouka's primarily focus are the mysteries. In fact, the mysteries are more plot devices than anything. The show has a lot of mysteries to keep it going, but it's not a mystery show.
The main focus of Hyouka, from the very start, has always been the characters. It focuses on Oreki's growth as a person, and everyone else around him as well, using the mysteries just as a way to kick off the interactions and development. Hyouka is 100% a character based show first and foremost.
Second, I also disagree with the ending being a hodgepodge of thing and not a grand finale. Granted, it's not a big arc or anything. The last two episodes are easily some of the best of the show, at least in my opinion, and the ending itself is absolutely genius and perfectly fitting for the show. While it is one of my favorites and I would love a season 2, I feel like getting a sequel would almost devalue the ending in a sense. Makes me quite conflicted. Anyway, about why the ending itself is so amazing, someone else has already taken the time to make an excellent writeup on it. Definitely recommend you give it a read.
57
u/introspectrive Feb 20 '21
It’s really one of KyoAni‘s best works imo, and I say that as someone who loves basically everything they’ve made. It gets the balance between mystery solving and SOL/romance stuff just right.
24
u/gratifiedlonging Feb 20 '21
Sucks that we most likely won't ever get a second season. RIP Hyouka director.
8
u/yurabe https://myanimelist.net/profile/yurabe Feb 20 '21
I'm planning to rewatch this.
7
u/BossandKings Feb 20 '21
Thank you, i'll watch it
7
u/Parth-_- Feb 20 '21
idc what anyone says this is a god tier show
7
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
Hyouka is a 10/10 to me.
12
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
I actually just finished this a couple days ago lol.
Regarding openings and endings, I honestly didn't like either the first OP or the first ED. I felt the second of both fit the series much better, and I found myself being a big fan of the second ED by the end.
I honestly really wish I'd seen this in high school, because I would've totally related to Hotaro. Not so much the super intelligent detective part, obviously, but having my life suddenly change from being very subtle and low-key to vibrant and nearly nonstop thanks to a girl dragging me around and me being unable to say no to her. Even now I can relate to that, although not in the same high school sort of way. It's a dynamic that appears every once in a while in anime, but I don't think any anime I've seen hit that sweet spot of characters remaining themselves within the dynamic. The way Chitanda opens up Hotaro's world was just very reminiscent of my own high school days.
There's also one episode in particular that I absolutely loved, and is the reason I ended up giving Hyouka an 8/10. "Is the Mountain Range Sunny?" where Hotaro does his first investigation completely on his own, just off a hunch that he could be misrepresenting someone in a negative way. For one thing, I feel like this is a subject that is rarely, if ever, brought up in fiction. It's such a niche, personal trait that I would've never thought an anime of all things would address it. Second, it just really resonated with me. I vividly remember doing almost the same sort of thing(more of asking around than deduction from newspapers though) a few times in my teen years, because I would stress out about or worry whether I was misremembering someone's feelings when relaying a story about them. I just felt very seen in this episode in particular I guess lol.
But yeah, Hyouka was awesome, wish I watched it much sooner.
2
u/Deepak_prajapati Feb 20 '21
Can somebody recommend some shows like this. I have already watched & really liked it
5
u/Jazzlike_Razzmatazz Feb 20 '21
My favorite mystery show.
4
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
I read an offhand comment that said the main reason behind that questionable ED1 is because the director thought it needs a tad of fanservice, not sure if it's true though
4
u/mosaicalmess Feb 20 '21
Ah yes, Hyouka! My all time favourite anime! One of the rate gems that has re-watch value. In fact, the amount of details I pick up each time I watch is astounding!
Genuinely loved the direction, cinematography, animation and the overall vibe of the show. The characters, especially the main cast, are so down-to-earth and bounce off each other extremely well.
3
u/JasmineDragonLover Feb 20 '21
I love this series! It was the very first anime that I watched and now I'm currently rereading the novels.
1
u/AutoModerator Feb 20 '21
Hi chaosof99, it seems like you might be looking for anime recommendations! I have changed the flair on your post to indicate that, but if I'm wrong, feel free to change it back!
The users of this subreddit came up with an awesome recommendations flowchart. Maybe you can find something there that you'll like ^.^
You might also find our Recommendation Wiki or Weekly Recommendation Thread helpful.
The following may be of interest:
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
Yes. Watch it! Planning to rewatch it for the third time.
1
u/81Ranger Feb 20 '21
Does anyone know were this is streaming in the US? I’ve looked for it a few times, can’t seem to find it.
1
u/Fa1l3r Feb 20 '21
Hyouka is one of my favorites not because of the mystery/suspense/SOL/romance but because of how they use the elements of those genres to tell their perspective on the story of life.
Real life is boring, and depending on who you are, life kind of sucks. But what you make out of the mundanity of life can make life wonderful. What you can do for and with those around you can make life worth doing something. A boring life can be a good life.
I also enjoyed the smaller themes explored in the story especially with the exploration on talent. Sometimes people just are better at things that you love even if they hate it. I have been on both sides of it. I have been talented at something that I did not care for, and I felt bad for people who really wanted to be good at it. And I've also tried my hardest to be good at a particular skill, yet others can pick up that skill with ease. Life can be unfair.
1
u/paukshop x2https://anilist.co/user/paukshop Feb 20 '21
Hyouka is easily one of my favorite shows and the school festival arc is probably my favorite arc in all of anime. Such a complex and well planned arc.
1
u/linkinstreet Feb 21 '21
Fun fact, Full Metal Panic's author Gatou Shoji was the one tasked with helping Takemoto adapting the novel into a more anime adaptable structure.
While it has been years since it was released, it's still ranked as one of my favourite series of all time. To see Oreki evolved from cold, grey person to a one that is looking forward to his future is quite satisfying, like seeing Holmes slowly changes his character into Poirot.
1
u/LegendaryRQA Feb 21 '21
Hyouka is KyouAni's best looking show. Yes i am including VEg in that.
1
u/needhelpASAPTHANKYOU Feb 21 '21
Just rewatched this last week after watching it for the first time 3-4 years ago, and it still holds up so well, one of the best series and one of my favourites for sure. I actually agree with you with the structure for the most part, even in this rewatch I forgot I was watching the final episode until a little over halfway through.
1
u/VengarTheRedditor Apr 02 '21
Another thing I don’t see pointed out enough is how similar Houtaro (and the rest of the cast in general)’s experiences in high school are to mine (and many others I’m sure). The impact the it left on me is all the more hard hitting once i related so much more to the characters and what they go through. It’s truly a wonderful show whose nuances and depth is once in a lifetime to find
-16
u/[deleted] Feb 20 '21
chitanda eru worst girl