r/anime • u/gunscreeper https://myanimelist.net/profile/mywargame • Sep 07 '21
Watch This! Imouto Sae Ireba Ii is actually really good. It's not some trashy imouto ecchi bait
So the other day, I stumbled upon a clip in this subreddit. A group of friends hanging out somewhere and one of the girls starts casually spouting dirty sex words while the guy nonchalantly handles them humorously. That scene alone made me hooked.
However when I found out that the title of the anime is Imouto Sae Ireba Ii, I was a bit disappointed. The title is all too familiar to me. I remembered when it was announced. Ah yes, another imouto bait romantic comedy whose only appeal is the "It's not like we're related or anything..". Along the likes of Kiss X Sis, Oreimo, Eromanga Sensei among many others. So I stayed far away from it when it airs
Until when I saw that clip. So I did a little bit of research (research as in read comments in the said clip). I know it's a trashy anime but I don't know how trashy. It seems like this anime is quite famous for it's first 90 seconds of the first episode. So I decided to watch the 1st episode just to see that scene in context.
After finishing the 1st episode, it's not that bad. In fact it's quite interesting. There are so many reference to other famous light novel titles and it's very self referential. And they didn't shy away to actually say the name of the real life title or the characters which makes it more interesting to me.
It didn't have too many cliche tropes. No annoying tsundere little sister crap. In fact it kinda makes fun of it. I don't want to spoil too much, but if this anime is categorized in the "sister" genre then it would make a very unique take on it.
And, there are some episodes that I think is very well directed. Sometimes the POV is changed from character to character without us even realizing it. Sometimes we feel said or happy if some character succeed or fail. And my favorite part of it is the music and how it slowly fade in from the end of the episode.
I actually haven't finish it yet so I appreciate it if you guys don't spoil it if you already watch it. For those who at first are take aback from the title, I was like that at first and I gave it a try and so should you.
6
u/jward Sep 07 '21
If I ever recommend this show to anyone, I'm gunna recommend they skip the first 5 minutes of episode 1 and go back and watch it after they finish the series. Because holy shit... that intro is something else and a massive turn off if you expect it to set the tone of the rest of the show.
2
u/BlazerionX Sep 07 '21 edited Sep 07 '21
Watched it at first because I like the opening, but stayed for the vibes. The last episode is good, kinda makes you want to read the LN
9
u/Verzwei Sep 07 '21
The series is definitely one of my personal favorites. I really enjoy the novels too, and this is reminding me that I need to catch back up on them. I think I was caught up when the English release was at the... 6th book.
The thing that I think I like most about the series that, despite how eccentric and sometimes absurd the cast is, they genuinely feel like a group of friends. Their back-and-forth dialogue is solid with a natural air about it. They argue, disagree, and even get envious of each other at times, but even in those moments you can still tell that they care about each other. Those minor frictions are a very normal part of long and ongoing friendships and a lot of anime (or manga, or novels) will either ignore that entirely or handle it in a very ham-fisted way.
Fun tidbit: This is because the author for Sister is also the author of Haganai. Additionally, this author has a good professional relationship with the author of Oregairu. That's at least part of the reason why Sister manages to directly reference (and sometimes poke fun at) some of these works.
12
u/aniMayor :AY:AZ:x3x6 Sep 07 '21
Well, maybe not imouto ecchi bait, specifically, but it's totally still ecchi bait. There's a good half dozen or so gratuitous sexual scenes that have hardly any relevance to the narrative (insofar as there even is an overall main narrative... which isn't much) and are clearly there primarily there to titillate the audience and not much else.
Which isn't to say a blatant ecchi bait show can't still have good writing, good compositing, be well directed, etc... either in its ecchi scenes or its non-ecchi scenes (or both). But let's not pretend that Imouto Sae Ireba Ii is more than it is, either.
2
u/MyLittleRocketShip Sep 07 '21
its the best, friends hanging out the anime. whenever a sol deviates from the regular highschool setting, theres always a lot of potential and usually the shows end up pretty good.
another bait show i recommend is ryuuou no oshigoto. yea theres loli fanservice but overall the story is pretty enjoyable for a guy taking on a disciple and struggling to maintain his title with his relationships.
1
u/Thatsmaboi23 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Thatsmaboi23 Sep 07 '21
It’s a very fun show. I enjoyed it much more than Sakurasou (a similar kind of show, except younger characters).
1
u/AndongLogicPH Sep 07 '21
I had a great time watching this when it was airing. I also finished reading the LN which is fantastic as a whole.
1
u/GeoSol Sep 08 '21
Interesting. I saw that clip and had the same thought, but then was getting put off a bi in the beginning, but was thinking about giving it another try.
-2
u/thuddundun :K:https://kitsu.io/users/FooPower Sep 07 '21
I'm going to downvote you, but not because I disagree with you but because you're writing a WT! post and calling a show good when you haven't even finished it yet (might be okay for a longer show but this is just 12 ep)
0
u/[deleted] Sep 07 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment