r/anime • u/MyrnaMountWeazel x2 • Sep 16 '21
Watch This! [WT!] Yama no Susume – Simple in Premise, Brilliant in Execution
There are numerous esteemed stories that are herculean and colossal: Ulysses, Don Quixote, Legend of the Galactic Heroes, Infinite Jest. Sprawling hundreds of pages and hours, their tales monumental like the peaks of mountains. And yet Yama no Susume, boasting a very modest 3-minute runtime per episode in season 1 and 13-minutes per episode in seasons 2 and 3, achieves more than thousands of other works of art that claim double or even triple the length.
Cute Girls Doing Cute Things and the Unapparent Depth (CGDCTatUD)
Yama no Susume or Encouragement of Climb is a simple story of a group of girls doing a certain activity together. While that may be an accurate, albeit reductionist, description of the show, the execution of this idea is what gives this half-length show a surprising emotional depth. It’s about climbing mountains. It’s about scaling past your comfort zone. It’s about the push-and-pull of friendship. It’s about taking everything step-by-step, ippoippo, reflecting on the past footprints down below while marching forward up the proverbial Summit of Our Halcyon Days; the collective efforts all pooling together for the magnificent view atop the mountain.
Aoi: The sky is so huge. You can’t see the Milky Way from here either.
Kaede: It is a city, after all. But you can see it from the top of a mountain.
Aoi: I’m jealous.
Enter Aoi Yukimura: A 10th year high school girl of comfort and habit who has trouble socializing. Sewing, cooking, shopping. She lives for the indoor activities in her own sequestered little world. Her horizons are limited to what she has experienced so far, but it isn’t long until Hinata Kuraue knocks on life’s door. An external force that barges into Aoi’s idyllic days, past childhood friend Hinata pushes Aoi out of her comfort zone and into the adventurous hobby of mountain climbing. Joined along with their new friends, the story of a group of girls bonding over mountaineering begins. The timid Aoi, the spunky Hinata, the wise-but-not-intelligent Kaeda, and the sweet dependable Kokona fall into place and set the stage.
Mountain climbing is an award that grants breathtaking views at the peak along with providing a sense of self-worth for conquering the daunting uphill battle. The chance of seeing the fruits of your labor and accomplishing what you set out to do all add up to one of the most ultimate expressions of freedom. The fresh air that fills your lungs at the peak, the relief of completing the task at hand, the azure blue sky that encompasses the entire vista. Mountain climbing is illuminating, it’s satisfying, it’s…difficult.
Herein lies the surprising emotional gamut hidden under the genre title of CGDCT. Yama no Susume doesn’t shy away from the fact that mountain climbing isn’t all glamorous and easy. Its careful depiction of the subject matter creates an aura of authenticity that serves to remind the viewer that Aoi isn’t a natural at this hobby and she doesn’t have some latent talent that allows her to be better than any other individual taking on this tremendous activity. Aoi sweats, crumbles, and struggles as she tries her hand at climbing mountains and the valley of her lows are tactfully portrayed as she begins to see the hardships that come to those seeking such great heights.
Aoi: If we don’t leave now, we won’t make it to the summit to see the sunrise in time.
Kaede: Aoi-chan, calm down.
Aoi: We have to leave.
Kaede: Aoi-chan!
Aoi: I mean, after all, I’ve been putting everything into this!
It’s not so much that the outwardly cute appearance belies the fact that not everything will come easily; more so the reality that the series respects its characters enough to depict all the facets of mountain climbing. This is a series that wants us to see genuine growth in its characters as they fail and progress through their journeys of both their hobby and their relationships.
We feel distressed as Aoi struggles to stay on her own two feet on the steep trail, we feel relieved as she conquers the inward and outward battle of climbing, we feel resplendent joy as she is draped in the night sky blanket peering down at the specks of lights that flicker like stars in the city down below. Yama no Susume’s simple story is brimming with poignant moments that will trickle over and stick with you for years to come.
Where Would We Be Without Pushing Past Our Comfort Zone
Why do we climb mountains? The very existence of them rouses a sense of awe within us yet ascending them is an exhausting painstaking ordeal. Is it to fulfill some primal nature within us that yearns to defeat nature? Is it to prove to others and ourselves that we have the capabilities of scaling the impossible? Is it all for the sake of fun? Everyone has a different reason but for Aoi it’s to discover beyond her world.
Throughout the series she is anchored by her hesitancy, moored to the dwelling of Doubt and Shortfalls. These failures weigh heavily upon Aoi but steadily with one foot ahead of the other, a budding support group in her wings, and a slight shift in perspective, the shy Aoi climbs higher and higher past her isolating inertia and takes flight into the open blue yonder.
The source of this push is found in Aoi’s friend Hinata. The relationship between the two is as close as two best friends could ever be which is to say that they bicker, fight, and tease one another incessantly.
It’s a refreshing way to show their love for one another and as much as Hinata pushes Aoi’s buttons, she helps develop Aoi into a confident individual willing to be determined for a change. It’s this chemistry that reveals the show as a character-driven spectacle and the hobby as a vehicle to express this.
The pair are two sides of the same mountain, interchanging between the windward and leeward side as the wind unfurls the sails of their beings and propels them to grow as individuals as they support one another. The icy self-imposed walls of Aoi’s life slowly but surely melt away as she glissades down the slope and explores beyond her boundaries. As Aoi’s expedition continues to cascade like a landslide, you can’t help but feel the series’ optimism seep into your outlook as well.
Take it at your Own Pace
Kaede: However kind you may be, I bet you’re thinking “I want to go home.” Mountain climbing is like running a marathon; if you don’t pace yourself, you’ll simply lose. Take it at your own pace. If you’re tired, take a break. And eat something sweet!
One of the early lessons Aoi learns in mountain climbing is from her senpai Kaede who offers her this advice and it’s as if the show took it to heart as well. Its runtime is short and sweet with 3-minutes in season 1 and expanding to half of the length of a regular show in season 2 and 3. Sure, a longer runtime could have packed in additional scenes, but that threatens to dilute what is currently concentrated goodness.
The brevity and eloquence displayed in this show owes its existence not in spite of its short runtime but actually because of it. In an industry plagued by production troubles and a Jenga Tower-esque bottleneck outlet, a short runtime can circumvent these issues and succinctly tell their stories without being asphyxiated from lack of resource and time.
Shorts circumvent all the woes of managing a behemoth 2-cour season beset by crunch time and burnout and instead allow the animators to breathe and pursue a solid production schedule. Shorts also lend themselves to be a playground for both pro and new up-and-coming animators as they experiment, toy, and diversify with each episode and Yama no Susume is a prime example.
Veterans such as Norio Matsumoto, Ryouma Ebata, and Toshiyuki Sato come together with young splendors like China, the youngest animation director of all time, Eri Irei, and Taiki Konno to create a surprising sakuga powerhouse of a series.
The brief 13-minute avenues offer a creative freedom to this series that allows it to showcase a slew of ace animators from across the industry like Shaft's Ryo Imamura, Trigger's Kai Ikarashi, ex-KyoAni's Yusuke Matsuo’s character design, Bones' Katsuya Shigehara directing and many more. Episodes can casually feature solo key animated cuts from legendary animators and allow us to see the holistic individual styles expressed by animators as their creativity fuel the imaginative and intriguing cuts that populate the series.
From Akira Hamaguchi’s articulate expressive faces to Ryouma Ebata’s bouncy character movements to Norio Matsumoto’s inventive shorthand drawings and resourceful layouts, Yama no Susume is a hub of innovative industry forces showcasing their animation prowess.
Even with such an impressive tour de force of animators in its midst, it’s not like the animation itself is a bombastic firework. Understated is the word that perfectly describes this series both in tone and in its scenes since many of them are blink-and-you’ll-miss-it fascinating in detail. It frequently features wide and spacious layouts that mirror the feeling of distant cliffs looming above along with visually eye-catching layouts such as Hinata showing off the effects of altitude on a bag of potato chips.
From the low drawing count cut of Hinata anxiously tapping her foot to my personal favorite cut of Hinata’s loneliness juxtaposed against the jampacked crowd, these scenes help establish the genuine quiet moments that are subtlety portrayed in this series.
Animators with distinct styles interweaving moving pictures to create a cohesive tapestry of art is the mantra of anime and it’s brilliantly displayed in Yama no Susume. At the end of the day though, the beauty of all of this is that you don’t even need to be able to recognize a single animator behind-the-curtain to appreciate this series. Its intrinsic charm and visuals speak to everyone who gives this series a chance and you’ll find something magical betwixt and between even if you can’t quite place your finger on it.
I mean, after all it is CGDCT
Make no mistake though, even with all this talk of hardship and effort, this series is still immensely sweet and adorable to watch. They snack on treats, they’re silly, they get into all mess of trouble. Yama no Susume is at its core a heaping lump of sugary slice-of-life and the charming cast of characters and their interactions all build up for the eventual avalanche that will bury you in a heartwarming snug-as-a-warm-tent experience.
Conclusion: Execution Over Originality
It’s about quality not quantity, it’s about the execution and not originality that makes a story soar. Yama no Susume succeeds where plenty of others have failed due to its efficiency in squeezing out every minute it has to offer and turning them into a truly special emotional powerhouse of a show. The idea of four girls pursuing an outdoor activity may not blow the door off its hinges but the way the series skillfully utilizes its simple premise sure does. In a time where optimism might be in short supply and overbearing anxieties are in surplus, Yama no Susume is the gift that encourages us to believe we can climb over any mountain, literal or metaphorical, so long as we continue to take it step-by-step, ippoippo.
Watch Order:
Yama no Susume: Kabe tte Kowakunai no?: MAL | Anilist
Yama no Susume: Second Season: MAL | Anilist
Yama no Susume: Second Season Specials: MAL | Anilist
Yama no Susume: Omoide Present: MAL | Anilist
Yama no Susume: Third Season: MAL | Anilist
18
u/[deleted] Sep 16 '21
Season 3 has some really cool animation.
Here's a breakdown on the Sakugabooru blog
For those who have already seen S3, I'm sure you'll all find it very interesting.
13
u/jamie980 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Eternal_Jamie Sep 16 '21
This is a fantastic WT!, thanks for putting all this together. I love hiking and from what you've highlighted of Yama no Susume here it really seems to bring out so many of the great qualities and challenges of it. This has definitely given me a great nudge to watch it sometime, and actually mean it this time.
8
u/AshenOwn https://myanimelist.net/profile/Lazysunflower Sep 17 '21
A CGDCT show with 3 seasons? That's all you had to say. I've been missing one of these ever since i finished GochiUsa a few weeks ago. Thank you very much for the recommendation.
8
u/Fools_Requiem https://myanimelist.net/profile/FoolsRequiem Oct 01 '21
Shame Season 2 isn't legally available to watch. Makes no sense. CR has S1 and S3, but not S2, which is the true meat and potatoes of the series.
7
u/Kalhiki Sep 17 '21
Yama no Susume is my favorite anime, and you have perfectly expressed what I love about this show. Especially the fact that Aoi struggles so much, which is something often not seen in cgdct shows. But despite her struggles, she continues on, and I love that development for her. There’s so much more I could say, but you’ve said it well enough, there’s nothing more I can add. I just hope more people give this show a watch.
6
u/frnxt Oct 01 '21
I value Yama no Susume on almost equal footing to K-On and Nichijou, it's just that good. The animation has those tons of little details you'd also find and enjoy in the latter two shows, the soundtrack has a lot of uplifting pieces that make it work very well with the tone of the show, and all the background art is wallpaper material.
It has also a special nostalgia factor for me because just as the protagonists were overcoming the mountains I was learning Japanese, and it was the first show I managed to watch without subtitles.
Really tempted to rewatch it now!
5
u/BizkitMonstah Oct 17 '21 edited Oct 17 '21
Very late to the party here, but I just saw this thread. Thanks for writing such a great write-up for a truly excellent series. /u/three-arms organised a rewatch of this around the start of the pandemic, which was a great joy and comfort to me and many who participated during a scary time.
One thing I'd like to add to the write-up is how well-situated this series feels in its main setting, the city of Hanno, Saitama Prefecture. Despite the show's theme of climbing mountains, to its merit as a character-driven slice-of-life series, it does not neglect the characters' daily life as residents of Hanno. The characters commute in and out of Hanno to climb mountains or go shopping and spend a lot of time hanging out in the city. While many anime faithfully represent the town where it is based, few give you the feeling that the setting matters and the story would feel out of place in a different town. To me, Yama no Susume manages to do this with Hanno.
Also, I'll leave below a list of links I amassed when making posts for the rewatch last year, for fellow fans of the series.
4
u/MaskOfIce42 https://anilist.co/user/MaskOfIce Sep 17 '21
Love the timing for this, I'm literally watching the show right now and am halfway through season 2.
3
u/Gilokdc :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Louback Oct 28 '21
saw the banner and decided to give it a go, but season 2 is missing from crunchyroll, what's up with that?
3
u/SpaRkofFiRe https://anilist.co/user/SpaRkofFiRe Oct 30 '21 edited Oct 30 '21
What a great post!!! YnS is one of my favorites of all time, and while the show's production is well-covered on Sakuga Blog, I've never seen any posts about the character writing, especially not in this much detail! Literally every thought I've had about the show was delved into here, and written with a level of finesse I could only hope to reach with my writing 😭
The section on Aoi pushing past her comfort zone was particularly resonant to my own thoughts. The very point of staying inside of comfort zone is to avoid the pain of failure. It's that struggle that is particularly relatable to me, and is something that could apply to a variety of situations beyond even a hobby—any passion at all subsequently comes with the possibility of failure. And the more passionate we feel about it, the more painful failure feels as a result. For Aoi, mountain climbing isn't an obligation. If she wanted, she could've just continued her habits and regressed further into her shell, but she didn't. She chose this for herself, and that just makes it all the more frustrating and humiliating when she doesn't enjoy it as much as she thought she would.
I absolutely love that the show doesn't just stop at saying "Just go outside your comfort zone and you'll automatically enjoy it", because the sudden change from a long period of stagnation isn't something that comes naturally to us. It's a long and awkward process that takes time to adjust to, and not something that we can do alone. That's what makes Aoi's relationship with Hinata that much better, that even through their constant bickering, Hinata never fails to encourage Aoi whenever she's struggling through that stagnation.
[Season 3 spoilers] Speaking of stagnation, I love that Hinata wasn't free from her own sense of stagnation either, something that's explored further in season 3. Even though it was Hinata that pushed her to do it in the first place, the more strides Aoi took in stepping out of her shell and expanding her support group, the lonelier Hinata felt when Aoi was no longer relying as much on her. The relationship of encouraging Aoi to change, in and of itself became a point of stagnancy for Hinata. Despite their seemingly opposite personalities, their responses to change were strikingly similar. None of this was explicitly said in words, it was all conveyed through its storyboarding and layouts, akin to the visual language we see in K-On and other KyoAni shows (and that's especially apparent in China's #10, who had gone on to directly cite Naoko Yamada as his main inspiration).
Sorry for the long comment, this post was the perfect excuse to finally dump all my thoughts on this show somewhere
2
u/RootaBagel https://myanimelist.net/profile/Rootabagel Oct 14 '21
I always thought it would be cool for the series to continue and have the girls grow up and take on really difficult climbs, like the Nordwand, K2, Denali, etc.
2
u/Hamlock1998 :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Hamlock Oct 27 '21 edited Nov 05 '21
Nice coincidence that this series is on WT this month, I just started watching it last week. It's very good.
4
u/MiLiLeFa Sep 16 '21
I don't want to take away from your WT!, and perhaps it's just a case of different usage in different areas, but surely this show never deals with mountain climbing? They go on hikes up to various hills and mountains, but at no point travel beyond prepared paths or need to use safety equipment and tools to get to their destination.
The difference between hiking up a mountain and climbing a mountain is like the difference between swimming underwater with just goggles and going diving with scuba gear.
5
u/mekerpan Oct 03 '21
I think we need to recognize a category one might call "Cute Girls Do Adventurous Things" (CGDAT). Shows like this ARE cute -- but the focus is on effort (and failure sometimes) and (eventual) accomplishment. Shows that show young people going (some times a LONG way) out of their comfort zones really are different from shows mainly interested in cuteness for its own sake (though I do think a lot of CGDCT shows are ultimately not mostly about cuteness).
1
u/ReWelp Oct 22 '21
Pfft.., Gay.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Oct 01 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment