r/anime • u/Agreeable-Weather-89 • Mar 12 '22
Watch This! Kotaro Lives Alone (Kotarou wa Hitorigurashi) is an excellent show killed by Netflix's release strategy
Kotaro has undoubtedly stiff competition with countless other great anime like Attack on Titan, Dress Up Darling, Demon Slayer and yet against all odds this show with it's charm stands up as not only a anime of the season contender but also anime of the year. While that phrase and praise is thrown around to such an extent I wouldn't be surprised to see someone unironically do the same towards ex-arm it is with sincerity that I say Kotaro is one such show which deserve it.
Synopsis: The "apartment comedy with laughs and tears" centers on a four-year-old boy named Kotarou Satоou, who moves next door to Shin Karino, an unsuccessful manga artist. Kotarou has no parents and lives alone. Not only does he seem to earn a living, he actually seems more put together than his own strange neighbors.
What makes Kotaro so great isn't the culmination of several didn't excellent aspects, in many ways from sound to animation Kotaro is nothing special, not bad or incompetent, just not the levels one might expect when describing a AOTY contender. Kotaro is the embodiment of a show that is greater than the sum of it's parts, a hamburger if you will, nothing about a hamburger is that special; bread, lettuce, cheese, meat, etc eaten individually it's fine but together it's a symphony of flavour with each element complementing the overall. Kotaro is no different it does not have any one element overshadow the overall. So what is the 'overall'? It's the balance between joy and sadness which is hard to do in any medium. Too much sadness and the moments of happiness feel out of place, too much comedy and the emotional scenes feel like a misplaced punchline to a cut joke. You never quite know what the next scene will bring, tears or a smile, but you do know you want to keep watching.
AND YOU DO NEED TO WATCH KOTARO LIVES ALONE
I could not put it down, and loved every moment of it. A 10/10.
That brings me to my final point, Netflix release strategy, Netflix often just dumps shows out all 8-12 episode in a single go this is because most shows are stretched and dull movies which don't really entice people back after a week but are good enough for a continue to next episode. The problem is with many anime, including this one, is that unless you're in the manga scene you've never heard of them there's no hype or franchise for too many great anime. Instead what turns hidden gems into mainstream successes is weekly charts and rankings. You'll see a show get a plenty of upvotes and a great score week after week and check it out, from there is snowballs. That simply can't happen with Netflix's release strategy unless it catches it'll miss, there's no second chances. Unfortunately in this case it was miss after miss.
There's no English manga
The trailers didn't sell the show too well
The art in promotional photos is off putting to some
The discussion megathread arrived late and never caught a critical mass
The episode sub-threads have been removed
tl;dr If you do nothing with your evening after Mirin' Marin and enjoying 86 do yourself a favour and check out Kotaro Lives Alone. You won't regret it.
22
u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh Mar 12 '22
Maybe I'm wrong on this, but I don't think that weekly charts and rankings do much for mainstream success. Those are largely shared within specific groups and don't really break into any sort of mainstream spotlight. Actually getting mainstream traction is difficult for most things to do, and usually relies on some combination of broad appeal, heavy advertising, using an established brand, and extreme word of mouth. While Netflix's model might be unpopular with a lot of anime fans, they do it because it's what the bulk of the Netflix customer base likes and is used to. They're only just starting to do "simulcasts" that are usually a bit behind the official release in Japan, and seemingly only for things that air on Japanese television. Maybe at some point they'll specifically target the hardcore anime fans that are watching everything weekly, but for now they seem to be much more focused on casual fans.
51
u/pw_arrow Mar 13 '22
I don't doubt that the show is good, but I don't think the show's lack of audience is... Netflix's fault? I for one don't think there's anything wrong with the batch release schedule in the first place - plenty of shows get off the ground just fine with this approach. Kotaro just seems to radiate niche energy, if you would.
17
u/KokoaKuroba :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/KokoaKuroba Mar 12 '22
Netflix makes live action shows a weekly release, it's weird that they don't do the same for anime
8
u/aranstone Mar 18 '22
One of the best anime I have watched in my life time
14
u/SalvadorZombie Mar 14 '22
I think a bigger problem is that there was zero promotional work that I saw done by Netflix. Nothing. It's a bad issue not just for this show, but for plenty of them. I only found out about Ranking of Kings about two months late because I totally forgot about the trailer I saw on a vtuber's stream. It's my show of the year so far.
Kotaro Lives Alone is very very good but the biggest problem is that only 2-3 shows have gotten a ton of attention this season, and even the other shows that have gotten notice have gotten a small amount. This show just happened to get none. If anyone, that's the fault of the company in charge of releasing it. Maybe if it gets more positive reviews (and I think it will as more people find out about it), it'll get those manga releases and further season releases.
3
u/RealMatchesMalonee Mar 15 '22
Tbh, I wasn't invested in Kotaro Lives Alone until I reached the 3rd or 4th episode. I don't think I would have had the same strong reaction towards the show if the episodes were released weekly.
3
u/Zipsterella Mar 16 '22
I really hope it keeps coming out. It makes me feel some type of way and Kotaro is absolutely loveable. I wish there were more shows like this, and I'm so happy that I found something about how good it is. I never watched it until recently because I didn't really get it and had never heard of it but I picked it up. I cannot put it back down and I don't want to. LET'S GO, TONOSAMAN!
edit:: spelling
3
u/osyrus11 Mar 16 '22
Is I possible there was never an intention to make follow up seasons? I agree this is a 10/10 show. Is it niche? I don't know seems like a no brainer, straight to the heart affair. I'd put it in a category of sentimental dramas that walk the line between feel good and heartbreak, but are wholesome in their intent, like midnight diner.
2
u/EconomistWhich Apr 11 '22
It's too bad that the translations are pretty much absolutely dog shit. Netflix needs to get it together and fix the damn sub translations. It's too inaccurate...
2
u/tryingtodothebest Apr 18 '22
I wonder if Mami Tsumara had a rough childhood, also is Karino a stand in for Tsumara? Karino complains a lot about Tonosaman being awful and wondering how something like that got any attention while struggling to keep the lights on in his mangaka endavours...
3
u/Kokonutsu Mar 13 '22
I've been watching this show and I love it. The trailer was odd and so was the premise but I'm glad I give it a try. It certainly is heartwarming and hilarious at times. But seriously where is this boys family, relatives or caretakers???
1
u/WildTunTuni Mar 15 '22
Haha, I was just about to make a post about kotaro lives alone and I saw this. It's honestly so emotional
1
u/apatt :JO::JP: Mar 15 '22
The live action version of Kotaro is also on Netflix. I watched it after bingeing the anime. It's not bad, and predates the anime.
2
u/HTC864 Mar 20 '22
After the first episode, I wouldn't have come back the second week. I saw it on Netflix, but I wasn't interested into a friend told me she liked it. It really is a weird little show.
1
u/Xason445 Mar 26 '22
Its funny and sad at the same time. i loved it so much. Waiting for season 2
1
u/Megsterrz Apr 11 '22
I agree with you with regards to a lack of organization for release. A basic rule of thumb is to invest in having an official website, social media channels, manga (Japanese and English), and a little bit of official merchandise available. There are a lot of search queries regarding these things, and unfortunately, they are almost nonexistent for the most part, which hinders fan involvement and word-of-mouth marketing.
Also, I agree with you with regards to the trailer and even some of the clips that Netflix Anime has posted. I feel like it doesn't show the true charm of this show, which is easily my favorite anime of 2022, and honestly speaking, of all time.
1
u/Certain-Reception176 May 04 '22
i will say that the eng dub is way better than japanese version, more specifically with kotaro. kotaro's eng voice acting is perfect, japanese doesn't capture the regalness as much. also, karino's eng voice was decent.
i was hoping there was a twist with his mother for a happy ending.
-1
u/hentaiyaoilovingnigg Mar 15 '22
Anyone got mizuki hentai from kotaro lives alone