r/anime • u/YaBoyUneven • Mar 19 '22
Watch This! 86 is at least 11/10, Fight me.
Some time ago I made a post about how much I loved 86 season 1. Today I'd like to do it again so let's get into it.
86 is the one series that has the potential to bring back mecha anime as it is the one series which took a different angle on the subject. That means from the start it had a lot of potential and in my opinion, it delivered.
The Story: is about a team of 86s which are people frowned upon as they are thought to be lesser beings, so they are sent to fight a war that is not their own. In all of this a wishful girl named Milize thought that she was the one to do something about it, which is a major plot point about her character which I'll talk about in a minute. As we watch out characters fight, die, and learn, we can see them caring for each other and feeling grief, which leads me to the next thing.
The Characters: are superb. I really love how the writer interpreted the characters. They are simple, yet have a lot of depth in certain cases. Nothing award winning, but more than enough for this series. The only one character I am kind off skeptical about is the little girl they take in their team, Frederica. I think the "mature child" play with her is very off putting, as it takes away the realism it had developed (I swear to god don't start talking about how realistic the series is). The other characters like Anzu, Kurena, Theo are well thought out and the same goes for the rest of the cast which used to be by their side. I must admit we didn't see some of the characters' personalities, but I think that's alright. The two characters I believe have the most depth to them are Milize and Shin, as they are the "Main" main characters. That's all I'll go into without major spoilers.
Now The Animation: which I don't really need to go that much into. Really what would anyone expect from A-1? I get it that my 11/10 may not seem convincing, but if you ask me, the animators did a solid job and a 9/10 is the least they deserve. The awesome work they did in season 1 carries on to season 2 where all of the fight budget of season 1 went to the fighting budget of season 2 AND they seem to have plenty to spare since the "beautiful" scenes were damn gorgeous.
The Music: is amazing, this time we didn't have any Sawano bangers but the new ed artist did a fine job in the ending sequence. The opening was also very pleasing since I didn't find myself skipping it ever. I am no expert in music but I also think the soundtrack was very good as it fit right in. The insert song on ep. 12 (season 2) was (and yes I googled the word) pulchritudinous. You really need to watch this scene.
My Thoughts on Episode 11: are straightforward. "Best episode of the series up to now" wouldn't be enough to explain how I felt about it. Yes, ep. 12 was also really good and even if it was the end of season 2 but 11 just has created a new space in my heart and filled it. I believe this episode is the one where you will make the decision to follow the anime till it eventually ends. It was astounding. I do not wish to make any spoilers, so please give 86 a watch so you can enjoy this episode.
My Final Thoughts: are that you MUST watch the series. I really don't care what you say about it, nor do I care about it's flaws and shortcomings. I really enjoyed the series. I will be muting this thread. I just want more people to find happiness in this anime. It is definitely in my top 10s. Last but not least, if you were watching the series but were put off by the flaws people mentioned, pick it up again. Personally I stopped watching for a bit after I was influenced by the community, which I regret. I forgot how much I loved this series, and now I understand.
To Conclude: It's worth a watch.
376
u/RandomBadPerson Mar 19 '22
Coward
193
u/FuttleScish Mar 19 '22
11/10 is less than 8/6 you fool
47
u/Mute_Spitter Mar 20 '22
Last two episodes have elevated it so much, Shin and Lena two of my favourite characters ever
62
u/smeowark Mar 19 '22
I feel like the show has a very heavy emphasis on emotions.
Like the overall package, directing/music/visuals/story/worldbuilding etc is probably solid enough for most people to give it a 7 or 8 out of 10, but for it to be elevated to the next level you just gotta be invested into the characters and what they're feeling.
All the scenes personally hit me pretty darn hard and Lena is gotta be one of my fav female characters of all time now, she's just such a badass and her development is incredible.
But I can easily see how some characters might annoy you or some of the deaths or other emotional scenes might come off as cheap or cheesy if you're not already into the story at that point.
Also Story wise I have the same feeling I had with Re:Zero S1 back in the days or early Attack on Titan. It feels like we just started to scratch the surface of this world and there is a lot of untapped potential for this to go in certain directions and judging from what source readers are saying I think 86's reception might just get better and better as more of the Story gets adapted, similarly to what where seeing with AoT now.
99
u/Hallowbrand Mar 19 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
Is it really that good, I watched about 5 episode and the show felt very surface level. Felt like I was reading a YA novel.
68
u/A-ReDDIT_account134 Mar 20 '22
A lot of problems people have with the show has been mentioned already. I’ll add my own that I don’t see mentioned often.
I think the world building is atrocious for a sci-fi. The society, military, technology, army of ghost robots, people with special powers, etc. All just seem like “random bullshit go” and the author didn’t put much thought behind anything.
And random bullshit go can be fine… if it was presented like Gurren Lagann. But this should be more like Attack On Titan or Shinsekai Yori
66
u/gsenjou Mar 19 '22
As a huge mecha fan, it’s solid, but the mechs just don’t do it for me. Spider bots are pretty lame tbh.
26
u/PickledPokute Mar 20 '22
Most of first season has the theme of "anyone can die in a war".
Then suddenly no one except the one person who was clearly introduced in order for him to die.
5
u/Audacious124 Mar 20 '22
I feel like the second half (prior to the break, these last two have been incredible) was a let down narratively compared to the first. Because things had to be condensed so much in the anime format it felt like we didn't get enough time with the new characters, like Eugene, to form the attachments we had with the original Spearhead squad. I'd still give the show a 7.5 or 8 out of 10 because of how strong the first half and last two episodes were, but the second half was a bit of a slog. Animation, sound, music, everything was solid to great throughout as far as I'm concerned.
Also first OP was a fucking banger and I felt like the second one fell flat in comparison.
27
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22
People seem to often ridicule the cartoonish racism and evil in relation to the main character's idealism. They're kinda missing the point. Not only because similar levels of evil exist today.
It's a little bit more clear in the novel, but a central theme of the story is how even a freedom loving liberal democracy can rot from within when it denies the truth of harsh reality. The author then shows how the correct path out of the situation is not pity towards self and others, but trust in the will and strength of the human being.
The pitying idealism of Vladilena Milizé is a cautionary tale that she grows out of while taking the perspective of the 86. The 86 in turn find their humanity in rejecting self pity and in certain aspects also against the Celena.
This is a story humanity needs in these dark days.
4
u/Keyakidude Mar 20 '22
Haven't watched this. Are there more LN material to adapt?
25
u/testthrowawayzz Mar 20 '22
This didn’t pass the 3 episode rule for me. The story didn’t pique my interest but I admit the animation was pretty well done for the first 3 episodes.
30
u/BueKojiro Mar 20 '22
You say the characters are “superb” then go on to immediately say that they’re “nothing award winning, but more than enough for this series.” I stopped reading after that point.
This is why I can’t take some of you people seriously. It’s like when people say Demon Slayer is a must watch and then go on to say “yeah the story doesn’t do anything new and the characters are pretty simple” and every time I hear that I stop listening to anything that comes after. What that means is that the only thing good about it is the art and music, which means it fails as a piece of storytelling if nothing about the writing is worthy of praise compared to anything else.
I see the same thing with 86, only it doesn’t have ufotable animation to fall back on. Story doesn’t do anything unique, characters aren’t award winning, animation is pretty good, music is great. Okay, that sounds like a pretty strong 6/10 for me, which is an instant drop. You really need to rethink how you define certain words. Don’t use the word “superb” to describe something that’s completely average.
3
u/cxxper01 https://myanimelist.net/profile/cxxper01 Mar 21 '22 edited Mar 21 '22
Yeah 86 is pretty damn good, it’s like solid 8/10
34
u/babydave371 :Ej:myanimelist.net/profile/babydave371 Mar 19 '22
Except mecha anime never went away and 86 is kind of just an amalgamation of Muv-Luv, Gundam IBO, and Cross Ange. There isn't an original bone in 86's body to be honest.
86 suffers from the same problem as Victory Gundam. Yes the characters could be interesting but they are introduced and then killed off too quickly for me to care. Over and over it does that awful thing of spending an episode properly introducing a character only to then kill them off at the end of the episode. Not only does it make the flow of the show predictable but I also just don't give a shit about any of the characters because of it. At least in Victory Gundam they went so far that it became outright funny.
Once again was Sawano being Sawano and I'm bored of it. He has talent and I'd wish he'd try something new, that he'd take a risk for once. At this point you could shuffle all his soundtracks up and put them back into shows without it making much of a difference.
7
u/vinibruh Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
It was pretty good so far, but i wouldn’t give it 10/10, but tbh it’s one of the few shows that followed the story of two different people and i actually cared about both sides equally, for that reason i give it a 86/100 😎
5
u/unneccry Mar 20 '22
the only reason i have stopped watching this for now is that it was depressing and i stopped watching anime overall for like a couple months. but once i finished a couple cutsey stories im going right back because i loved season 1
24
u/AashyLarry Mar 19 '22
Everyone in this thread so far is hating, but I agree with you. One of the best anime I’ve seen in a while.
17
u/crixx93 Mar 19 '22
8/10 for me. Season 1 was better IMO. S2 feels like it betrays the conclusion of S1. I would've preferred for Shin and the others to die outthere, as we instead focus on Lena and the new batch of 86, I thought that was the direction they were going for with the ending of S1.
30
u/BlackSCrow Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
The racism felt too comical. It just didn't feel right that visiblly there was only one person to fight it in the whole country. She's portrayed as the only one with the right moral code while almost everybody else was an a-hole.
The war felt too drawn-out, especially in the second cour. Faster pacing would make it better IMO. This is probably one of the case that it will be better to cut the source material.
You have brought this one up in your argument, but other than the MCs, the characters were too simple and IMO it's not enough to make the story interesting.
I dropped it in episode 21 IIRC. The slow pacing was the biggest factor for me to drop it. 7.5/10.
Edit:
I just noticed this, but did you seriously wrote fight me in the title but muted the thread? Like another user said, I just want to say
COWARD
One doesn't say "Fight me" if they don't want to fight in the first place
10
u/zairaner https://myanimelist.net/profile/zairaner Mar 19 '22
86 is really weird, while watching it I feel touched and in awe like with few other anime, and then afterwards I no longer understand why or can't explain it.
6
u/ProfessorSimp69 Mar 20 '22
Based on the lot of complaints in the thread we really need S2. I think most of the ppl here are not into the character emphasis of both Shin and Lena to the point they are downplaying it. S2 will be the solution if those ppl here actually want a plot-driven story.
5
u/THEP0LE Mar 20 '22
Everyone brings up aot as if it wasn't seen as generic when only one season had been released, aot definitely gets alot better. but if you want to use it as a comparison compare season 1 to 86 this doesn't mean I disagree with the criticism however.
9
u/AoSora71 Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
TL;DR: "Mediocre thing is the best thing I've ever seen"
Thanks for the daily reminder to browse reddit less.
13
u/DutchDread Mar 19 '22
I dropped it
2
u/ericmok100 Mar 20 '22
Some parts in the middle definitely didn't sit well with me. But I can say the beginning and ending are done very well. Definitely worth the watch.
2
u/botaansimp Mar 20 '22
love everything about it. well theres a spiritual aspect that i didnt like cause it feels out of place (shin's hearing & frederica eyes ability). tbh i prefer the story just about politics, drama, mech battle, tragedy. but yeah overall i gave a solid 8/10 for this show, hope they announce season 2.
7
u/martau98 Mar 19 '22
Yeah enjoyed it. It's a solid 7.
4
u/tw_wombat Mar 20 '22
The reason I loved 86 is it really shows how ppl can live a much fuller and caring life when there's no expectation for longevity or comfort. Similar to those clips and streams from Ukraine. A very big contrast to our media spending all energy on "meaningful" things all day.
8
u/Quiddity131 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Quiddity131 Mar 19 '22
86 seems really similar to Code Geass: Akito the Exiled to me. The 86 part of the storyline also gives a Gundam Iron Blooded Orphan vibe. Not that 86 isn't good, it was for me, in season 1 in particular, but originality is not the place to go with praise for it.
Overall thoughts on 86? A lot of potential, but I feel the quality dropped considerably in the second season/cour. Stakes seem to fall away. In season 1 you feel like anyone could die. In season 2 it was the opposite, it came off to me that no one of consequence could, and they'd simply throw in a few side characters to die instead. Frederica was a very annoying character and I didn't feel the overall conflict of the season was all that different from what we already got in season 1. I do love the core 86ers at least. Milize I really disliked early on as she came off as the type of person who virtue signals on Twitter and thinks they've actually accomplished something, but she got better as the story went on.
All that said... I have yet to see the final two episodes. So maybe I will feel much more positively about it once I watch them. Or they will complete my thoughts on how it was a disappointment.
3
u/Aeiexgjhyoun_III Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 29 '22
Okay, I'll bite, currently on episode 20. I'm loving it but the show has one major flaw. Shin, dude is the most boring protagonist of 2022, his stoicism was cool in cour 1 because of how well it played off of Lena, but without Lena in the picture, the flaws of Shin and how the show basically ignored everyone but him starts to show. The other characters really don't get any development nor enough screentime, every conversation they have revolves around Shin, they're less like his comrades and more like his fangirls. This would all be okay if he was a more interesting character but he's not.
86 would vastly improve if Raiden, Kurena, Theo and the other one got some more development because so far, they could all die and I wouldn't care.
I get how they're doing the whole, "killed his big brother and now has to be a big brother" thing and while I appreciate it in concept, Frederica is just annoying.
I dont dislike the show, its one of my favorites this season and one of very few mechas which actually have entertaining fight scenes, the handling of bigotry and discrimination is top notch, the directing is movie level, and the dialogue (which the exception of the part where they explain blondie's nichname) is head and shoulders above most anime as it doesnt feel the need to ram everything down your throat. Please give us more animes without cringe inducing dialogue.
So yeah, I'd give it an 8.6 out of 10 nothing more nothing less. Though the hype surrounding the recent episodes have been pretty high so maybe the score will go up when I'm all caught up.
3
u/laceuZ Mar 20 '22
I didnt read anything but the title and I can 100% agree with you.
5
u/SisterOfBattIe Mar 20 '22
I'm hard pressed to find something wrong with the show.
Perhaps the cliffhangers involving the non death of Spearhead are what I enjoyed the least. I had no doubt the eightysix would survive, the cliffhanger don't work anymore. Raiden survived a point blank hit from Morpho's railgun!
7
u/carenard Mar 20 '22
11/10?
boy this is a 18/10
4
u/tomtomm9 Mar 20 '22
I’m surprised post got upvoted, if you were to say this about any other series it just gets downvoted to oblivion.
5
u/BugBoy_109 Mar 20 '22
The awful characters caused me to drop it 3 episodes in.
7
u/teerre Mar 20 '22
The problem with 86 is that it doesn't make any sense. You need to literally not have a functional brain to enjoy it.
There are so many logical and structural problems that it's impossible for any emotional point to have any impact.
The very premise is that the white people forced everyone else to become soldiers against the magical robots that want to literally kill everybody. It's never explained how that was possible and it's never questioned by any of the protagonists.
The protagonists simply fight the robots ad infinitum for absolutely no reason. Well, there's allegedly a reason: the military forces them. So that would make you think the military is stronger than the 86, otherwise the 86 would just rebel.
Unfortunately no. The military is played is if completely incompetent. That's the whole drama of the first season: the military is just partying around while the 86 are doing the fight. Btw, allegedly all the civilians think the war is being fought by robots. But how can that be? How long did the purge happen? How could possibly everybody have forgotten about it? Never explained. It's completely straight, it's just the dumbest shit.
Well, actually, there's something dumber: the villains of the show. Yep, it's the worst type of villain: killer robots that have no personality, infinite numbers and no motive, they just want to kill everybody. Great.
The author, noticing that, employed the most baffling artifice to solve this problem. Here it is: the robots, despite being ultra advanced, have to steal people's brain to add to their numbers. ????. Why the fuck would a robot do that? They are already ultra intelligent. But wait. It gets worse.
The whole drama of both seasons is about one of the protagonists really trying to kill someone they knew that turned into a robot. Unfortunately, that makes no fucking sense whatsoever. If the person in the robot is still the same person you knew, then they wouldn't try to exterminate humanity. If they are not the same person, there's no reason for any emotional attachment, it's just a stupid robot with a voice changer.
That's not to talk about other very stupid plot points like the government being fighting literal infinite robots but not doing anything about it or how the geography of the place makes no fucking sense, all the cities apparently are self sustained, lol, or how the whole prejudice against the 86 is literally not how prejudice has ever worked.
Truly one of the stupidest shows out there.
3
u/caliban969 Mar 20 '22
Watch Zeta Gundam, then come back and talk to me
3
u/[deleted] Mar 20 '22
Way way better than AOT
2
u/honjustice Mar 20 '22
I know a lot of people on this thread wants to chime in and bring their dissenting opinion, but I feel like they didnt watch the show all the way through. Common complaints like the racism makes no sense is like asking why in AOT titans eat people. It's just a plot device, it's not the meat of the show. In order to fully appreciate the show, you need to watch the entire show because the entire season is a buildup for the final 2 episodes.
86 in my mind is a masterpiece. The show can be broken up into three parts, beginning, middle and end. Part 1 was the setup. Part 2 (episodes 12-21) was the buildup. The suspense and tension, and not knowing if Lena was dead... all of that was done brilliantly and the 3 month delay only built on that suspense to ultimately arrive at the climax (episode 22 [Shin]). Episode 22 was the climax, and in my mind, the real ending. Episode 21 was a nice cherry on top and serves as an epilogue.
Overall, the show uses a show don't tell formula and it's a cinematic masterpiece. I haven't seen anyone use music, directing and storytelling to such terrific use since Kimi no na Wa.
2
u/BongWaterGargler Mar 20 '22
If I didn't like season one would I like season two?
2
u/randomawarenessman Mar 20 '22
Imo it's a 7. The themed treated in the anime such as racism, post trauma and losts in war were really well portrayed, especially in Shin who suffers the most along the series and I love his character and how he gets development.
My problem is that the story feels very plain, predictable and with plot convenience. The trama could be summarized in, protagonists vs boss, that somehow is related with one of the characters. I confess that at first I was surprised that a character you get to empathize in the early chapters gets killed, but then I was, oh I see where this man is going to end up alone.
Then again suddenly somehow someway the main characters were related by something that happened in the past, I mean how convenient It has to be for Lena to have met Shin's brother. Also the fact that her friend's childhood friend was Shin, so she can manipulate her to help the Spearhead, even now I don't get the point of introducing Fredericka but to excuse that the second boss is also related to Shin.
I'm not hating the show at all, it's a good anime I really like the character development, but just that nothing new at least for me.
-1
u/Kaleidocrypto Mar 19 '22
S1 was interesting, S2 feels like a recycled anime I’ve seen in the past.
1
u/dersnonem Apr 06 '22
It should be 86/10 haha
1
u/Dare555 Apr 23 '22
12/10 !!!!
3
u/NineTnk Mar 20 '22
Feels like a budget AoT the entire time I watched it.
-2
u/CynicalCreepy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Borrasca Mar 20 '22
no
1
u/Blackwolfe47 Mar 20 '22
Fight? Why? I agree 100%
-1
u/geniue Mar 19 '22
The premise of 86 definitely has been done before, so the plot is nothing to really write home about. However, its characters are quite enduring and make up most of the enjoyment of the series. This is a solid 8/10 anime, but its def not genre-defining like what mushoku tensei is to isekai. Its just a solid mecha, a rarity nowadays tbh. Still, its a great show and did provide me with some much needed enjoyment.
-3
u/Beneficial-Ad2084 Mar 20 '22
1
u/redoband :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/redoband Mar 20 '22
Just a question. How many anime have you watch? For me 86 is a strong 8/10
1
u/hintofinsanity Mar 20 '22
most of season 2 was 8/10. ep 11 of season 2 though, was easily 12/10
-7
u/Tokens-Life-Matters Mar 20 '22
I thought season 1 was super boring, overhyped, and anti climactic. So I havent watched season 2.
-1
u/Creamysense Mar 20 '22
I dropped at episode 3. Does it get better?
0
u/Hankan-Destroyer Mar 20 '22
I fell asleep watching this show
-3
u/Arcanisia Mar 20 '22
86 put me to sleep. Had to drop around episode 6.
-7
u/penguintruth Mar 20 '22
Season 1 is excellent. I dropped it in Season 2 because it became much less compelling and risk-taking.
-2
u/toilodi https://anilist.co/user/Luca5 Mar 20 '22
I might be alone in this boat, but part 2 quality dropped off a lot and the reason for that was Lena, or I guess everyone else, for me It became very clear that she was carrying the show, yes the fight scenes were still amazing but whenever we got an episode without those and without Lena It got a little painfull to watch imo, again, maybe its just me but I felt like characters were just repeating the same dialogues both when they were talking about their feelings and stuff like that, and when they were talking about the war, the enemy and the world situation (btw I do like when anime focus on world development and political stuff, but for this series It just felt boring for me, on part 2 that is).
Tldr: part 2 made me realise how Lena along with the animation were hard carrying the series, so we endend up getting a few really good episodes (the fighting ones and the last 2) but also some ok/boring ones imo.
-9
u/CeaRhan Mar 20 '22 edited Mar 20 '22
I've yet to watch the last episode, but I think it had a lot of potential and barely used it. It kept going back to the same points that were already dealt with and the story didn't complement or add much to it so eh.
There's that one scene that builds upon the show really well at some point which was the highlight of the show tho
EDIT: goddamn the fans aren't happy