r/anime • u/Alemismun :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Alemismun • Jun 19 '22
Watch This! Why I recommend "Skeleton Knight in Another World" in spite of poor critic reviews [WT!]
Although "Skeleton Knight in Another World" has a fairly high score (~7.5 atm), if you check out the reviews themselves you will find that they are all giving it pretty low scores. I believe the reason for this is because the reviewers came in with the expectation that it would be some sort of epic saga that takes itself midly seriouly like how Overlord does, but that simply is not what this show is.
This show is goofy, as in, a skeleton smoking a cuban cigar while their theme music plays with a guitar solo and a cloud with their face watches over them goofy.

And this is what this show is about, it's about goofy, entertaining and light hearted fun. If you come in with no expectation other than the hope to be entertained by the duration of the episode, it will be a very enjoyable and relaxing experience. I am a little bit tired of big epic tales with serious intrigue that will get me hooked only for there to never be a next season and the author having died by getting hit by a car or something, I just want something that will make my day a little bit more enjoyable for the few hours of free time I get after a long day at the shit factory.

It has a delightfuly charming MC, which has an easy going attitude (to be honest, I don't get why so many reviews mention how strange it is that the MC accepts so quickly that he is in a new world and does not seem to want to go back. If you were in his position, would you be desperate to return to your shitty office job after being transported to a fantasy world?), a wonderful evil laugh (always a plus, specially considering that the character is a skellyboi) and some honestly great facial animations for what should otherwise be a pretty mild show.
Additionally, the CGI (what little there is) is really well done for what seems to be a smaller studio. There is a lot of attention to detail in the places you least expect it. While the animation is certainly not top of the line, it is clear a lot of love was put into it and I can appriciate that.
Story wise, it follows a pretty standard plot, but it does actually have some nice nuances here and there, especially when it comes to the history of the world, which I thought was quite fun.
So yeah, if you are looking for good, simple, cheerful fun. Then this is something you should watch. The first few episodes are not particularly strong (as u/EldritchCarver mentioned, episode one gives off goblin slayer vibes because of a rather intense scene, but the rest of the show is nothing like that!), but once it gets going, you really warm up to it.

87
u/EldritchCarver :MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pilomotor Jun 19 '22
I feel like if you're going to recommend the series for being goofy, entertaining, cheerful, and light-hearted fun, you should at least include a disclaimer about some of its darker moments. The first episode's cold open was particularly shocking and grim, and I'm sure a significant chunk of first-time viewers dropped it immediately because it gave them the wrong expectations.
34
u/TimeForHugs Jun 19 '22
Not every single anime has to be groundbreaking and amazingly well thought out. Sometimes a silly, fun, show is nice. It's something I can turn my brain off to and enjoy. This is why I welcome all these isekai shows. Most are just ridiculous and fun. It's simple to enjoy it.
Of course, there will always be haters. People trying to compare everything to the likes of Overlord and AOT. More power to them if they don't like it, but some people are way too hard on shows. Not everything needs to be on the level of Death Note and such. Just try to enjoy the dumb fun. That's what I do.
8
u/Thraggrotusk https://myanimelist.net/profile/Thraggrotusk Jun 19 '22
OP, not sure why you are trying to justify this super average isekai (I heard the LNs are much better), when you are going to forget about it in 6 months.
And you can't seriously claim it be "goofy, entertaining and light-hearted fun" when the whole story is about rescuing slaves and/or sexual abuse victims (while sexualizing them in the process as shown by the first five minutes of the show).
2
u/Patros15 https://myanimelist.net/profile/Patros15 Jun 19 '22
I like Skeleton Knight in Another World, but I feel it is underrated by community because I enjoyed every episode for now and I think it could be in top 10 of spring season.
2
u/throwaway__rnd Jun 19 '22
Just so you know, it’s “entertain”, not “entretain”. Only correcting because you said it twice, so I’m assuming it’s not a typo
2
u/Sharkyboy292 Jun 19 '22
The biggest reason I picked it up was because the MC has Veldoras VA from slime and his laugh is addictive
94
u/InsomniaEmperor Jun 19 '22
It's really fun to watch cause I like the characters and their antics. I'd really like a Ponta doll. The food porn in the show is also gorgeous. My only real gripe with the show is they introduce that political drama which looks compelling but it doesn't exactly go anywhere.
138
u/AllelujahTv Jun 19 '22
I find it to be a quite enjoyable romp, it knows what it is and it leans into it, a fun anime, hope it gets another season!
35
u/supafuz Jun 19 '22
It’s just a stupid, fun anime to watch. It wouldn’t make a recommendation list to binge watch but, as a Thursday seasonal to plop down and chill for 20 minutes to, it’s been enjoyable.
4
u/TexturelessIdea https://myanimelist.net/profile/TexturelessIdea Jun 19 '22
This show is like the failed abortion of Overlord and Goblin Slayer that for some crazy reason thought it could improve its ideas with a light hearted tone, and it can't even pull that off well. It is a tonally incoherent and completely unoriginal shitshow. I useually don't judge people for their taste, but if this review isn't some sick joke (i.e. "wouldn't it be funny if I tricked people into watching trash") you need to learn more about anime or media in general. Your opinion is bad and you should feel bad!
19
u/Rhoru Jun 19 '22
When I saw Arc being good with kids, he was immediately one of the most likeable Isekai MCs
45
u/hnlPL Jun 19 '22
little?
It's pretty CGI heavy once you notice it, Arc, Arianne and Ponta are just CGI in some shots. About as much CGI as Arifureta had on the main characters, which might not bother most people.
56
u/MejaBersihBanget Jun 19 '22
The most intriguing thing about this show for me is what our hero spends the entire season battling. He's not fighting some ancient awakened sealed evil, invading army, or Demon Lord bent on world conquest. It's an evil much more uncomfortably closer to home: a sex trafficking international criminal enterprise that is on Jeffrey Epstein-levels of organization and influence. The funniest thing is that most of the time, he's just bumbling around and unintentionally comes across their wicked activities, so he's slowly dismantling this organization by accident.
The other interesting thing is that this is a rare isekai without a harem. Ariane is really the only girl in the plot. Chiyome pops in from time to time but vanishes just as quickly, she acts more like a guest party member in a JRPG lol.
13
u/NoSolace_NoPeace Jun 19 '22
It’s fun and entertaining, but I can’t help but get that “budget” feeling when watching it. Lots of cutaway action scenes and static feeling fights. And the plot just doesn’t seem to be progressing enough. But yes, it’s fun and the characters are what drives it for me.
11
u/Figerally https://myanimelist.net/profile/Pixelante Jun 19 '22
I thought it was just going to be comedy and I was really shocked by the opening scene. But this really set the tone of the show. Yeah it's pretty goofy, but underneath that it's a pretty serious story about political intrigue and ripping the heart out of the slave trade.
26
u/n0oo7 Jun 19 '22
They keep using attempted rape as a plot device. I believe in at least 3 of the the first 5 episodes (really think 4) someone was about to rape something and MC steps in and goes "HO HO EVIL DOER" and saves the day.
11
u/Soronir Jun 19 '22
The anime has a bunch of cut content and fan service. The LN goes into more depth, has more intrigue, and takes itself slightly more seriously. Would recommend the LNs.
19
u/animepig https://myanimelist.net/profile/ChickenDan Jun 19 '22
I thought it would use the skeleton gimmick a bit more but it’s basically an afterthought in the show. And it’s mostly just a basic isekai
11
u/odraencoded Jun 19 '22
Nah, I don't think so. The show is getting low scores in reviews because it's sending mixed signals all the time, as do poorly written series.
You have this super serious plot: racism, an enslaved race, rape almost every episode like they have a rape quota or something, children crying, women being eaten alive, abandoned corpses of sick slaves left to rot in a dungeon cell, etc.
But it's like it's not happening. The characters keep goofing around as if they were in a generic middle school slice of life and not committing mass homicide to save victims of abuse.
Tsukimichi is much better despite having similar goofiness because the protagonist has emotions that last longer than 20 seconds. Shinchou Yuusha takes a more pragmatic approach and the goofiness comes from how ridiculous the situations get, not from the characters lazying around while the world is in danger and they have the power to save people.
This series is just: the protag acts like a generic gaming streamer and the heroine like a big tiddy elf heroine, and the story just goes exactly the same aimless "defeat bad guys with un-earned OP-ness" way you'd expect, and everything that doesn't go like this feels like a half-assed attempt by the author to convince the audience and perhaps himself that the story isn't generic like the other stories, no sir, because the MC is... a skeleton, or because he [Skeleton Knight] couldn't beat a sword master in a sword duel once.
4
u/drripdrrop Jun 19 '22
It has a lot of things going for it but got a bit boring for me
4
u/LeJumpshot Jun 19 '22
Your opinion about it being like OPM is exactly how I took it. It's isekai Saitama who is having fun instead of bored.
4
u/HajimeFromArifureta Jun 19 '22
I think the interactions Arc has are what make the show. Times like when the elf climbs through the window then he just teleports. Or his buff ninja buddy that instantly became a bro. Even his meeting of the furry eared ninja.
He has this wild excitement of a child, which I think is one of the most accurate portrayal of a character who’s been isekaid.
I’m always confused why people want to go back to a world where they’re nothing. A good example is Arifureta. Hajime can become a God. All he wants is to go back to his shitty world.
4
u/figool Jun 20 '22
A show that's about light hearted fun really should not have as much rape with as little care for the topic as it does. It makes the tone feel like it's all over the place for no reason. There's a good bit to enjoy about the show, but also some moments where I was just like, what the actual fuck
4
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '22
I dont really care for a grand story. Im up for an overpowered character being goofy and shit. Im even ok if it had a bit of bad animation as long as it's fun like Tatoeba last dunegon BUT skeleton knight almost failed in every way possible.
People are comparing this to overlord but it's more like how not to summon a demon lord but more mediocre. Almost every fucking struggle in the show has fucking sexual harrasment involve lmao. Im starting to think the author had a fetish for that shit. Skeleton knight's character is the most uninspired and confused character Ive encountered for a while now. First few episodes, he's a bootleg version of momon but he completely scratched that idea almost immediately and sticked to a bootleg version of Brook. Side characters are bland as fuck and so predictable. They dont even react appropriately to whatever bs skeleton knight is doing. There was nothing fun about this in my opinion. I had no expectations when I started this and was bored almost immediately.
4
u/MadDany94 Jun 20 '22
Its generic. That's what it truly is. There is nothing depressingly bad about it nor applause worthy about it either.
It fits in the criteria of a good time waster.
As long as you don't have any expectations going into it you can enjoy it as it is. I won't really recommend it as a show worth watching, but recommend it as a boredom repellant instead
38
u/zdesert Jun 19 '22
slavery and sex trafficking is a huge part of almost every single episode. it takes every opportunity to show every attractive slave, chained up in a suggestive pose, or blushing cutely. half the time those slaves are about to be... used poorly.
and it is all played as a kinky fun joke.... even when they find a bile of slave bodies the tension gets released by getting a characters butt stuck in a window or some other tasteless joke.
i like that every episode is a simple low stakes adventure in a fantasy world, there should be more isakai, or just anime that do that.
But making a 'low stakes' adventure focus on slavery, racism and sex trafficking, is really tasteless, because slavery and sex trafficking and racism.... are not low stakes. Making those things into kinky scenes and into jokes is kinda gross and that is all the main plot is.
Skeleton knight wants to say: hey its kinda hot to chain up and mind control these elf girls! but then excuses itself from the bad look of that by having the main character save them in a weird rescue fantasy.
3
u/CoolestBikeInReddit Jun 20 '22
Respectfully decline
3
u/Cryten0 Jun 20 '22
If the near rape and other horrible things denziens of the world do wasnt so gleefully shown to us then I imagine I could really like the show. I wish there was a nicer version for me but there isnt.
Even all the previews for the show make it their number 1 thing to show you so I never got past the first 2 seconds in investigating the show. So I made do reading the ANN weekly reviews.
5
u/firefaiz6 Jun 19 '22
While it's been one of my favorites that I look forward to watching every week, I can also kind of understand why not many people watch it.
There is a lot of sexualization, whether it be the cold open the first few minutes, every villain to Ariane, all the slavers, or when they murdered the princess. It's a little alienating since people who expect a fun fantasy romp may assume it's *those* types of anime from the first few minutes while people who are expecting *those* types of anime may be disappointed by the fun fantasy romp segments. In turn, it feels the target audience is for people who for some reason want both, which is a smaller subsection of the viewerbase. Case in point, the only reason I started watching was seeing clips on Youtube of Arc being a dork after the fact, but I'm sure I would have been offput if I just dived straight into episode 1. I do my best to look away from those segments, but I feel like they are unnecessary to include in the first place.
Also for people who care about visuals, the switch between 3D CG and traditional 2D art is really noticeable. It doesn't hurt my enjoyment of the show, but even as someone who doesn't usually notice these things, it's reaaaaallly obvious at points.
Lastly, while I would have liked more of Arc just enjoying his fantasy adventures, I also see the need to introduce a driving force for the plot forward by trying to dismantly the slavery ring. Compared to something like Leadale, while I enjoyed both, the latter felt a bit more meandering at times because of the lack of immediacy in its conflict. Again, I just wish there was less sexualization, since it's already clear to see in other ways how evil the villains are.
Overall, to me I see it as an issue of subjective vs objective metrics, with the latter being what I assume is more impactful to scoring to most. And based off the visual and the flipflops in tone, it's rather understandable. As said before though, it's one of my favorites this season despite everything, and I think it's perfectly okay as such, since not every work needs to be a masterpiece to be enjoyable.
2
u/Niyari Jun 19 '22
I recommend just not watching or reading reviews about ANYTHING unless it's about a series possibly being suggested to you.
If a synopsis or key visual interests you, give the series a try. If you think you'll enjoy it, keep watching. If you aren't, drop it. Simple as that. No need to get some kind of worthless gratification from a stranger whos brain is completely different from yours.
The faster you do this, the more media you'll enjoy.
2
u/sequential_doom Jun 19 '22
Also PelleK
2
u/iwipiksi Jun 19 '22
I recommend this anime simply because the OP soundtrack singer is Pellek and the way they draw boobs is godly.
2
u/kurono-yajirushi Jun 19 '22
When is see the last image I can't get that laugh out of my head haha or mwahahahahahaha
2
u/[deleted] Jun 19 '22
I watched this show, just because i saw the cover and thought i looked cool. This and Spy x Family and probably the only two anime's I've TRULY enjoyed this season. It's definitely worth a watch. I look forward to it every week now.
2
u/Berserker-1982 Jun 20 '22
Watch the OP....if that doesn't get you it's probably not for you.
2
u/Koyori_QED Jun 20 '22
I watched two episodes and the first one was decent but the second was painfully generic. I like the op because PelleK sings it but uhhhh I dunno about continuing the show.
2
u/Krait972 Jun 20 '22
It's a fun show
2
u/SimpinOnGinandJuice Jun 20 '22
It’s very fun to watch and the intro song/animation pumps me up so much. if I ever start working out again that song will be first on my playlist.
2
u/OmnidalTTV Jun 20 '22
Ains on vacation has a good charm to him that is funny and wholesome at the same time.
2
u/Nova_187 Jun 20 '22
Agree 100%
2
u/Trabant777 Jun 24 '22
This show was as vanilla and boring as it gets tbh.
2
u/deffinitely_lacking Jun 19 '22
Where do I watch this?
2
u/LoxodonSniper Jun 19 '22
Fuck them critics, it’s so good
1
u/placeres Jun 19 '22
A recurring criticism that I do not understand. The protagonist is not the main actor in the story. This anime is the Ariane's story, the MC just accompanies her
Personally I like it, it is a simple and fun anime, but it still suffers from the lack of direction of the author when he wrote the web-novel. He was just throwing in ideas as he came up with them and it shows..
1
u/Hockeyspaz-62 Jun 19 '22
I enjoy every episode. I don’t go by pro reviewers, I check them out myself, and read recommendations from regular anime fans.
1
u/JOINTHEREVOLUTI0N Jun 19 '22
overlord season 4 🤮
1
u/Mindofthequill Jun 19 '22
I loved the opening so much I ended up picking it up as a read as well
1
u/Rhsinbad Jun 19 '22
I like it. I actually find it more enjoyable than Overlord which gets pretty boring and repetitive after season 1.
1
u/ExO_o Jun 20 '22
i like arc but all the other chars and the plot suck ass. also too much fucked up shit going on there, but that's expected of LNs i guess
1
u/Merkyorz Jun 20 '22
Great performance as usual by Tomoaki Maeno (the lucky guy who married Mikako Komatsu).
1
u/ACriticalGeek Jun 20 '22
It’s because this anime got made and Skeleton Couldn’t Protect the Dungeon did not.
1
u/theprofessor1985 Jun 20 '22
I was reading the manga and I thought it was great
1
u/TexanInAlaska Jun 20 '22
I love it so far, doubt that’ll change. I do think the first episodes darker aspects were a strange addition seeing the rest of the show but somehow I just wasn’t worried by it before I saw the rest. Wasn’t like Goblin Slayer, thankfully, never did finish that show. Which is extremely rare for me because I finish almost any anime I start regardless how much I like it and especially anything in fantasy/action/adventure genre, but for several reasons I didn’t, a particularly strong one is my distaste for grape scenes.
1
u/Graciaus Jun 20 '22
For anyone who tries it but isn't feeling it it picks up when the female main character shows up. I was going to drop it at first but I look forward to it each week now.
1
u/UberDueler Jun 20 '22
Imagine how much they saved on the animation budget by having Arc's mouth covered by the helmet 90% of the time.
1
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '22
I've never seen this anime or Manga so my first thought of it was
"Oh shit! Papyrus was issekaid and became a badass knight!"
1
u/QuiteChilly Jun 20 '22
I read the manga for this, I like it a lot. I was really sad about the poor critic reviews because I actually think it was decent.
1
u/seandkiller Jun 20 '22
I might check it out. After bingeing Arifureta I've been looking for something that would be as fun to me.
My main concern after hearing that it was a lighthearted show was that the MC would be somewhat of a bland goody two shoes, which... You know, that's not necessarily a bad thing, but I tend to prefer characters that aren't wholly good.
1
u/jinxtir Jun 20 '22
I don't like overlord and didn't expect to find it here either.Its just boring as fuck.The only good episode was the tenth and it gone back to being shit again.
1
u/kokonotsuu Jun 19 '22
For me its the best isekai of the season.
1
u/heartsrmended Jun 19 '22
Hands down my favorite updating anime right now.
1
u/Sweetcorncakes Jun 19 '22
Yes its a guilty pleasure kind of show
1
u/Dante-lux Jun 20 '22
Show fucking slaps
0
u/[deleted] Jun 20 '22
Manga was pretty decent never checked out the anime but overlord fandom was mighty salty once it came out it's prob pretty decent like the manga but people are judging it by the cover and letting their opinion be clouded by prejudice while watching.
-39
u/uncultured_guy https://myanimelist.net/profile/httpsmyanimelist Jun 19 '22
Who asked for ur opinion?