I watched Katana Maidens a couple weeks ago, and gotta say, it was one of my fave anime I've seen. That's why I was so surprised when I hadn't heard many people ever mention the show, & also why the MAL rating seemed lower than what I would've guessed or rated myself. I thought maybe since I haven't been an anime fan for very long, that my taste was just different or more easy to please.
One thing I really appreciated about the show, was the ending. Many anime & just works in fiction in general, seem aren't able to execute a proper closing to a storyline these days. That's why many endings feel rushed, incomplete, or just abandoned or avoided altogether.
I felt Katana Maidens nailed the ending to the story it wanted to tell, and gave proper closure to the viewers who invested time getting to know the characters and world around them.
Another show I just recently finished, reminded very much of Katana Maidens, and that was Release the Spyce. Both shows featured girls somewhat coming of age, and using their skills in weapons & combat to battle a more formidable enemy than what was expected. I really enjoyed both shows despite a somewhat average MAL rating & apparent low fanfare.
One thing I really appreciated about the show, was the ending. Many anime & just works in fiction in general, seem aren't able to execute a proper closing to a storyline these days. That's why many endings feel rushed, incomplete, or just abandoned or avoided altogether.
I felt Katana Maidens nailed the ending to the story it wanted to tell, and gave proper closure to the viewers who invested time getting to know the characters and world around them.
I totally agree. I think part of that problem with other anime is due to the vast majority being adaptations of manga and light novels, meaning they usually leave the anime with an ambiguous ending point to get you to read the source material. Katana Maidens - Toji No Miko was an original anime with no source material, so we got a concrete ending to the story. The mobile game that came later is actually re-telling the anime's story, but it's also diverging in some places and basically becoming an alternate continuity, which is an interesting way to do it.
Another show I just recently finished, reminded very much of Katana Maidens, and that was Release the Spyce.
Hell yes, that one was great too. Between Katana Maidens, Revue Starlight, Release The Spyce, and The Girl In Twilight, 2018 was an amazing year for "cute girls doing action things" anime. but all of them were mostly overlooked by seasonal anime watchers.
Maaan! Girl in twilight was sooo good too!! I finished that yesterday. That, like the other two shows we talked about, is another show that I heard nothing about. I decided to check it out based off the description and thankful I had w/ no regrets.
I actually started Revue Starlight before all of these shows, but circumstances kept me from finishing the first episode, & I just haven't circled the wagon back around yet to continue. Tho your recommendation has motivated me to do so real soon, and I'm looking forward to it.
Also, if you hadn't already, i recommend Uma Musume: Pretty Derby. It's a lil different from the shows like Katana & Girl Twilight as far as combat & battle against enemies, but the tone is overall similar. It's something I have a feeling you'd enjoy.
I actually started Revue Starlight before all of these shows, but circumstances kept me from finishing the first episode, & I just haven't circled the wagon back around yet to continue. Tho your recommendation has motivated me to do so real soon, and I'm looking forward to it.
You definitely should. Almost everything good I have to say about Katana Maidens, I could say that Revue Starlight does just as good, maybe better.
Also, Revue Starlight's mobile game is actually out in English.
Both Toji no Miko and Release the Spyce were made by Studio Gokumi. If you liked these two I recommend Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru, third anime by them that shares main writer with Spyce. It's my favorite of the three.
Ughhhh... why'd you do this to me.... I just finished ep. 9 of Yuuki Yuuna.... Ya know, the episode I "can't talk again" about, because apparently I have emotions, according to my tear ducts, that are too sensitive to handle the type of sadness Ep. 9 had just now.
Sigh... Don't think the ol' allergies are acting up excuse I keep handy, will fly this time. Oh well...
But Seriously, ty again for the Yuuki rec. I've thoroughly enjoyed the 9eps I've seen so far. I both, look forward to the last few eps, & am also sad, because these are the last few eps.
This is the episode that cemented this series as one of my favourite. What an emotional ride! Fuu is my favourite character in whole series and this scene gave her justice.
I hope you'll have (already had?) fun with the rest of the series! There are also prequel (Wasshio Sumi no Shou) and sequel (Yuusha no Shou) if you're interested in watching more :)
Seems like so long ago now... earlier today, when I wrote you that post, I was still a naive but innocent, young boy filled w/ hope.
Sigh... I can still remember saying "there was only a few eps left," thinking -now that ep9 is over, the sadness will be behind me from now on.
Such a stupid fool....
I finally became aware of the two additional seasons or arcs that'd been made, and available now. One season tells Sonoka's story & the other season is a direct sequel to Yuna's story or the main plot line. I also discovered additional content made available in print form, the most notable being a story about the first Hero's.
Which as of now, the point I'm currently at in the Yuyuyu timeline. I finished the prequel about Sonoka & her group of friends....breath intensifies... tear... And I also finished the Yuna sequel and what appears to be the overarching plot. The image of Final Form Yuna is what the word "epic" was created for.
I've just started the manga about the first hero's, Nogi Wakaba. I've heard this story hunts for sensitive & tender emotions from its readers, all for the direct purpose of breaking them.
After what I consumed the past day or so, I'm not so sure there's emotions, or even a soul, left to break. That naive kid from way back yesterday, who thought there were only a few eps left-- is gone forever.
In his place... stands a dude, troubled by the frequency & relative ease, that it takes to trigger his crying face these days. I mean really, it doesn't take much it seems. So, when something like Yuuki series comes along, that can be fierce when the plot wants to establish emotional connections to its reader, I'm already ded.
If you do plan to watch (and I highly recommend you do) you should keep in mind that there's a certain recommended watch-order, I don't have it right now but you should find it easily online.
Toji no Miko and Yuuki Yuuna wa Yuusha de Aru are both made by Gokumi, Spyce was by Lay-Duce but one of the writers of Yuuki Yuuna worked on it. And the Yuusha de Aru series is my favorite as well. I love cute girls in action.
Oh yeah, speaking of Studio Gokumi shows, have you seen Endro~! from earlier this year? It's made by Gokumi and also has the same character designer as Yuru Yuri and Release The Spyce. It's much more lighthearted compared to Toji or Spyce, but it's a lot of fun.
The best way I have to describe it would be "Yuru Yuri meets Dragon Quest meets It's Always Sunny In Philadelphia" and it's hilarious.
Loved this show when I watched it, it was in my top 5 of new anime form 2018. The dub was fantastic by Funimation. Super under appreciated and underwatched. Loved almost every moment.
Studio Gokumi, who also did Yuki Yuna, another favorite of mine, are really good as the cute girls doing action things.
Another Toji no Miko fan! I loved the later fights between characters, especially since all the fights were choreographed in real life by a swordsmaster which some of the fights very fluid and realistic.
I deeply regret how unnoticed Toji no Miko was, since it was of of my favorite shows of 2018.
To add to the (correct) points you make about the beginning, I would also say that they took their time to slowly build the story, so that show was lacking a "wow" factor in its first episode (which, in fact, showed very underwhelmed discussions). However, they were able to speed up and keep the pace over the next few episodes, improving both the worldbuilding an the slowly setting by dropping important reveals in each episode. They took about 6 episodes (which, incidentally, would fit the "rule of three" times two because it was a two cours show) to really get into the meat of the main plot.
Good story, nice fight scenes, and great (main and side) characters made this extremely enjoyable.
I wonder if in these days of insane anime quanitity, unproven seasonal shows are more and more reliant on flashy opening episodes than they were in the past.
Multimedia tie in anime usually aren't very good but TnM I actually enjoyed a lot and went somewhere with its plot even after it seemed like it had nowhere to go.
Oh yeah, and some character deaths I haven't gotten over...
Having said that, I have a question: Do you happen to know if in the game they have done a popularity poll? if so, I would like to see how truly popular she is :)
I haven't heard of any popularity poll, nor can I find any evidence of one. But she was apparently well-liked enough to get her own prequel light novel spin-off despite having a smaller role in the anime, so yeah. She's very popular.
Alas, Ryukyu Tenpu Roku doesn't actually star Yume (though she does appear for a secondary role, as do Maki and Suzuka, and Kaoru/Ellen get an extended cameo).
The three anime that come to my head when I hear multimedia tie in are Love Live, Revue Starlight, and BanG Dream. I loved all of LL, the parts of RS I've seen till I put it on hold, and I hear Bandori's anime is pretty great too.
As OP mentioned there is a mobile game, TojiTomo which there is a small community for so if you're interested, feel free to drop me a message and I can link you to the Discord where we have more Toji content for people to delve into, namely the concept book, drama CDs and the recently released spin off prequel novel, Ryukyu Kenpuuroku in addition to the game itself where we'll soon get our 2nd Yuuki Yuuna collab - in fact in 2 days!
I played the mobile game myself for a bit, but the lack of an English release made me put less time into it, and I eventually dropped it. If it did ever get an English release, I would definitely give it another chance.
If an English release is what you need to play, I don’t think it’ll happen seeing the popularity of Toji itself in the west isn’t as much as say Love Live or Bandori.
Always happy to help out new people with figuring out game menus and mechanics though!
I don’t think it’ll happen seeing the popularity of Toji itself in the west isn’t as much as say Love Live or Bandori.
That doesn't really explain why Revue Starlight ReLIVE got an English release though. That show was just as overlooked in the west as Toji No Miko was.
I’d say Revue has its own sizeable fan base as well. Since it’s also a property of Bushiroad who have plenty of mobage experience with the aforementioned Love Live and Bandori - they were probably confident that it would succeed.
This is just my assumption though so take it with a grain of salt.
I really enjoyed Toji no Miko. The cast was fun and the fights (even though in CG) were well choreographed and and used a lot of genuine sword-fighting techniques, since the studio actually hired a sword instructor to help them and it shows. The plot was intriguing as well. I understand why a two-cour show with a female-only cast and CG monsters would fly under most people's radar, but I think it deserves more recognition.
What’s interesting, and this is the show that made me stop just referring to the MAL Score but also looking at the user reviews themselves of those who completed the show or went past the 3 episode rule.
Also, most of the user reviews on MAL have Toji no Miko as mostly 8s and 9s.
You're going to get downvoted by not liking the show in a recommendation thread but you're complaints are 100% valid. The CG was bad, the fights were short, any long fights were padded with instant transmission attacks, the story in general was too dull to justify two cours, the political filler was some of the dumbest nonsense writing I have seen, and the character's outside of Yume, Eren, and Kaoru made every scene a slog, Kanami is the worst MC with the dumbest motivations for the shit she pulls. She literally gets her best friend killed by trying to fight her while the girl is trying to fight off a possession and doesn't give a fuck about it while they all sit around a table laughing and eating snacks the next day. Awful waste of time and deserving of its low scores.
Short fights were actually one of the strengths of this series. I greatly prefer dynamic clashes over yelling at each other for 5 episodes, which was once standard in anime.
Kanami is the worst MC with the dumbest motivations for the shit she pulls. She literally gets her best friend killed by trying to fight her while the girl is trying to fight off a possession and doesn't give a fuck about it while they all sit around a table laughing and eating snacks the next day.
If you're referring to episode 21, then you clearly didn't understand the meaning of that scene. TnM Ep21 spoilers
Most of the other points you mentioned are subjective, and I can understand why some people would say those. That's why I'm not going to downvote you for simply having an opinion. But when one of your points is based on incorrect information, or is blatantly spreading incorrect information, then I feel like I have to correct that.
It did have to do with Kanami TnM Ep21. Yes, part of the reason behind it was , and that's part of her character too. but the main reason was to . She had no idea that or else she probably wouldn't have done that.
I did go back and re-watch episode 22, and you're right that I was incorrect about TnM Ep22 I was wrong about that part, and I apologize for my mistake there. But the fact that She also mentioned
I do sort of agree that there were some things, such as the Toji's powers, that aren't explained well-enough in the anime due to time constraints. There was actually a 4koma manga that was released before/during the anime that offered additional info that they couldn't fit into the anime. Notably, the comic explaining the Utsushi ability (AKA why they can fight full power with killing blows but not actually kill each other) was the most useful thing that it covered that wasn't really touched on that much in the anime. I found the 4koma around the time episode 3 aired, and it was really helpful.
4)
Yeah, I did notice that too. Some of the shorter and less elaborate fight scenes in the second cour were hand-drawn instead of using CG, and they weren't as good as the normal CG ones. The early part of each cour (1-3 and 13-15) are the only parts of the show that I'd say were noticeably weaker than the others, but part of that is how the show liked to use a "slow burn" storytelling method to build things up.
15
u/break80 Aug 30 '19
I watched Katana Maidens a couple weeks ago, and gotta say, it was one of my fave anime I've seen. That's why I was so surprised when I hadn't heard many people ever mention the show, & also why the MAL rating seemed lower than what I would've guessed or rated myself. I thought maybe since I haven't been an anime fan for very long, that my taste was just different or more easy to please.
One thing I really appreciated about the show, was the ending. Many anime & just works in fiction in general, seem aren't able to execute a proper closing to a storyline these days. That's why many endings feel rushed, incomplete, or just abandoned or avoided altogether.
I felt Katana Maidens nailed the ending to the story it wanted to tell, and gave proper closure to the viewers who invested time getting to know the characters and world around them.
Another show I just recently finished, reminded very much of Katana Maidens, and that was Release the Spyce. Both shows featured girls somewhat coming of age, and using their skills in weapons & combat to battle a more formidable enemy than what was expected. I really enjoyed both shows despite a somewhat average MAL rating & apparent low fanfare.
10
u/Inuyashafan42 Aug 30 '19
This show is under appreciated imo. It has good characters, a good plot, and good fights. It’s a very solid show.
8
u/LeonKevlar x2https://myanimelist.net/profile/LeonKevlar Aug 30 '19
Great write up! Toji no Miko is so underwatched and under appreciated. More people really needs to watch this show.
7
u/Orzislaw https://anilist.co/user/Orzi Aug 30 '19
Yup, it was very satisfying and, what's very rare nowadays, completed Anime. Middle part was a bit of a slog, but finale was worth every second of it!
7
u/blueteamk087 :KW::KX::KY: Aug 30 '19
Loved this show when I watched it, it was in my top 5 of new anime form 2018. The dub was fantastic by Funimation. Super under appreciated and underwatched. Loved almost every moment.
Studio Gokumi, who also did Yuki Yuna, another favorite of mine, are really good as the cute girls doing action things.
6
u/UCCMaster Aug 30 '19
Another Toji no Miko fan! I loved the later fights between characters, especially since all the fights were choreographed in real life by a swordsmaster which some of the fights very fluid and realistic.
Kanami best girl! Hiyori always flat!
6
u/Bainos :XMOD::MAL:https://myanimelist.net/profile/Bainos Aug 30 '19
I deeply regret how unnoticed Toji no Miko was, since it was of of my favorite shows of 2018.
To add to the (correct) points you make about the beginning, I would also say that they took their time to slowly build the story, so that show was lacking a "wow" factor in its first episode (which, in fact, showed very underwhelmed discussions). However, they were able to speed up and keep the pace over the next few episodes, improving both the worldbuilding an the slowly setting by dropping important reveals in each episode. They took about 6 episodes (which, incidentally, would fit the "rule of three" times two because it was a two cours show) to really get into the meat of the main plot.
Good story, nice fight scenes, and great (main and side) characters made this extremely enjoyable.
5
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '19
Multimedia tie in anime usually aren't very good but TnM I actually enjoyed a lot and went somewhere with its plot even after it seemed like it had nowhere to go.
Oh yeah, and some character deaths I haven't gotten over...
5
u/ShadowVortexx Aug 30 '19 edited Aug 30 '19
Nice write up!
As OP mentioned there is a mobile game, TojiTomo which there is a small community for so if you're interested, feel free to drop me a message and I can link you to the Discord where we have more Toji content for people to delve into, namely the concept book, drama CDs and the recently released spin off prequel novel, Ryukyu Kenpuuroku in addition to the game itself where we'll soon get our 2nd Yuuki Yuuna collab - in fact in 2 days!
5
u/NierMiss Aug 30 '19
I really enjoyed Toji no Miko. The cast was fun and the fights (even though in CG) were well choreographed and and used a lot of genuine sword-fighting techniques, since the studio actually hired a sword instructor to help them and it shows. The plot was intriguing as well. I understand why a two-cour show with a female-only cast and CG monsters would fly under most people's radar, but I think it deserves more recognition.
5
u/HarleyFox92 Aug 30 '19
One of the most under appreciated shows of 2018 for sure.
4
u/blueteamk087 :KW::KX::KY: Aug 30 '19
I also appreciate how the first cour took time to develop all the characters and the plot, which lead to a great pay off in episode 11/12.
4
u/blueteamk087 :KW::KX::KY: Aug 30 '19
What’s interesting, and this is the show that made me stop just referring to the MAL Score but also looking at the user reviews themselves of those who completed the show or went past the 3 episode rule.
Also, most of the user reviews on MAL have Toji no Miko as mostly 8s and 9s.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 31 '19
the opening burned off a lot of people sadly. I really loved the choreography of the sword fights.
2
u/LegendaryRQA Aug 30 '19
I dropped it around Episode 10 cuz I got bored with it, which really should’ve happened with a show with a premise like this...
Also the CG was awkward and bad
4
u/[deleted] Aug 30 '19
[removed] — view removed comment