r/TagPro • u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee • May 19 '20
Map Thread #101 Results 😢
Welcome to the official results thread for Map Thread #101! Following are the upcoming changes to the official TagPro Map Rotation.
Additions
Lime by Ball-erina and DragonBeast
Serengeti by PIZZAspartan and Fronj
Willow by Tumblewood and DragonBeast
Removals
Conniption by Fronj
Swan Song by DragonBeast, Aniball, and Sloppy
Ultralight by Dove
Throwback Rotation
- Volt
- Tehuitzingo
- Tombolo
- IRON
- EMERLAD
- Vardo
- Kite
- Ricochet
- Jardim
- Thinking with Portals
- GeoKoala
- Bombing Run
Changes to MTC Roster
Additions:
- Tumblewood
- NIGEL (Notes only)
Removals (happened a while ago but it hadn't been updated):
- Blazeth
- Destar
Notes
Notes on notes:
What we write is to be taken as constructive criticism. We sometimes test all the maps in one sitting; we can't break the news gently that each map isn't great if we want to maintain our sanity. Please understand some comments will occasionally sound frustrated.
The notes are anonymous and randomized so we don't get harassed.
Don't expect perfection or even consistency. If we all had the same opinions there would only need to be one of us.
Take no comment as an MTC member echoing other members.
no video again
Your votes on maps influence rotation. Please remember to vote after each game!
Below are comments about each addition/removal where MTC members may or may not give their personal opinions/feedback. Please give us yours.
Congratulations to all the mapmakers who have influenced the rotation! Keep mapmaking!
8
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee May 19 '20
Please welcome Tumblewood and NIGEL
5
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee May 19 '20
Please discuss the addition of Serengeti by PIZZAspartan and Fronj
3
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee May 19 '20
Please discuss the addition of Lime by Ball-erina and DragonBeast
16
u/musiciscool23 May 19 '20
Why are all the maps that were just added getting removed? Some of them were actually pretty good (Asido, Conniption).
13
u/[deleted] May 19 '20
This is a disaster when we just get unique and fun maps they get removed. WTF
13
u/Lovemesomediscgolf Big_Mike May 19 '20
Axel, Box Turtle, and Conniption should NOT be out of rotation already. They are really good maps.
35
u/PIZZAspartan442 naga///MTC May 19 '20
Five of the most interesting maps in rotation and axel were removed, with three fairly generic maps to replace them. I feel like almost all of the top maps could've played alright in rotation, yet people were quick to shoot down any small flaw without considering the merits of each map. Consider maps like Constriction, Market, and Hornswoggle. All of them have sizable areas that feel like garbage, yet the overall map makes up for them. A map like Nanobot shouldn't miss out just because mid feels a little awkward. Being this nitpicky for no good reason is how we end up with shit like Toe Tag. If the MTC cares this much about every little detail being perfect without worrying about the bigger picture, there's no way we're going to get maps that are interesting and unique to play on. What's worse, nobody seems to care.
In testing, there were actually people who laughed at the idea of adding unique maps, or "changing the meta." Apparently there's nothing wrong with current rotation, where with the new removals almost every new map looks the same. People blame inactive devs for killing the game, but part of the problem lies in the MTC. When every map looks the same, there won't be any reason to play the game any more. Maybe comp will have some value still but in pubs every match will play out the same way, which defeats the point of playing. How much fun can you have on Sugar Hill or its clones 5 games in a row?
And then there are the removals. Five of the most unique maps we've seen in years. All of them were removed after one or two threads. The only justification people had for this was their ratings? All the ratings have been dropping due to the nice little push we've been getting. If a map adds something to rotation it shouldn't be removed just because it's near 60. Yeah different maps are gonna be rated a little lower but there's still a clear majority of the playerbase that enjoys them. If we judge only based on our arbitrary criteria of 70% being public acceptance, what's the point of having a committee?
I know there are people like me, Fronj, Siz, and Dove that are pushing for a more diverse, eclectic rotation, but there are far too many people in the MTC that follow the ratings like sheep instead of actually stopping to think about how a map will work in rotation. If y'all want to ensure the longevity of this game, you need to expand what you consider to be an acceptable map for rotation. We can't keep up this trend of map convergence forever.
7
u/KewlestCat NIGEL May 19 '20
Being reinstated to the MTC for my third stint like: https://i.imgur.com/S0AZrQd.jpg
1
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee May 19 '20
Please discuss the changes to throwback rotation
3
u/myaltaccount333 May 19 '20 edited May 19 '20
When you say notes are randomized, does that mean that Feedback slot 1 is all different people, or are they the same person?
Because that person typed notes for 13 maps and only 5 of them had more than 10 words, one of which had 12 words. Person #4 only wrote something on 9 maps, and only TWO of them had more than 15 words. That's terrible feedback.Now, I don't know if any of the maps were from veteran makers dicking around, or if they were from first timers making a terrible map, but feedback has to be better. I know it must take a lot of time to type it out, but c'mon. If you're having trouble giving feedback can we do the field test where Anne invited randos to test a few maps, but have those randos write something up if need be?Look at inchman (row 82). The feedback given was "it's a sphere" and "unique shape and probably not broken". Cool, no one had anything bad to say about it, why isn't it added to rotation? Whereas Willow had 4 comments, all of them negative, including being called "Autistic", "Clunky", and "Less interesting than Aerodent" (a map that only had 2800 games on .eu). So why was this one added to rotation?
Edit: Wrong info crossed out
4
u/Tyler1986 Trapsin May 19 '20
Willow is a great map, and the other 2 additions look interesting. But none of the others deserved to be removed, imo.
0
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee May 19 '20
Please discuss the addition of Willow by Tumblewood and DragonBeast
1
u/uhhhhmmmm sexytiger / #merbs May 19 '20
i used to have a lot of thoughts/arguments about maps but its been a long time.
personally, i feel that different people like different things about maps, and the way the game is set up isn't particularly conducive to this. i love bigger maps with good boost lanes that are somewhat holdy/chasey but give you the freedom to move around and juke. for that reason i really hate market. other people despise holdy/chasey maps and would never want to play on them. theres no way for me to choose "i would like to play on only these maps". my only option is to leave any time a map i dont like comes up. if everyone did this, it would be difficult to get a 4v4 game going. It would also royally screw up my stats. so, it makes sense in some way that naturally it would progress towards a more or less agreeable sameness. not too holdy/chasey, not too small. not too crazy in one direction or another, there's not too much that i just outright want to quit.
i guess then it comes down to, would you rather have a rotation full of maps that people dont super hate or love, or one that has maps that people both really love and really hate?
1
u/Electric-Wood May 19 '20
I think during or after a maps first thread it should get a serious discussion to consider updates. A few games of 4v4 during testing won't always be enough to figure out the best polish. The MTC may consider this to be an official suggestion. Imbalances and frustrating sections get cleaned up, and maps get another look before being pitted againsy new maps in the next thread, better rotation.
-9
u/TPCaptographer The Map Test Committee May 19 '20
Please discuss the removal of six new maps
0
u/[deleted] May 19 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment